LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: Loader v Department of Natural Resources and Mines [2008] QLC 0150 PARTIES: Robin L, Kathy L, Brian E and Lynette M Loader
(applicants)v. Chief Executive, Department of Natural Resources and Mines
(respondent)FILE NO: RV2005/1584 DIVISION: Land Court of Queensland PROCEEDING: Appeal against rental valuation under Valuation of Land Act 1944 – General Division DELIVERED ON: 22 July 2008 DELIVERED AT: Brisbane HEARD AT: Emerald MEMBER: Mrs CAC MacDonald ORDER: 1. The appeal is allowed.
2. The unimproved value of Lot 10 on CP DSN 805047 GHPL 37/3316 in the County of Denison, Parish of Osmondthorpe is determined at $1,085,000 as at 1 October 2004.
CATCHWORDS: Evidence – expert witness - valuer acting as witness and advocate – evidence admissible but may affect weight.
Valuation – principles of valuation – Spencer test – whether long term owner had more detailed knowledge of property than hypothetical prudent purchaser – owners classification accepted.
Valuation – analysis of sales – sale applied at less than half analysed figure – sale rejected as being too high to apply in absence of explanation.APPEARANCES: Mr RL Loader for the appellants
Mr WA Isdale, Crown Law, for the respondent
This is an appeal under the provisions of the Valuation of Land Act 1944 (the Act) against a determination by the Chief Executive, Department of Natural Resources and Mines (the respondent) of the unimproved value of certain land at $1,400,000 as at 1 October 2004. The property, Wongabell, is held by the appellants, Robin L, Kathy L, Brian E and Lynette M Loader under a Grazing Homestead Perpetual Lease and is used principally for cattle breeding purposes.
Mr PD Schefe, a registered valuer employed by the respondent, compiled a written report and gave evidence at the hearing. The appellants' case was conducted by Mr RL Loader and both Mr Loader and Mr PJO Turner, a registered valuer of Turner Valuers, gave evidence.
Mr Schefe described Wongabell as an irregular shaped holding of 6,188 ha located about 7 kms from Springsure. All weather access to the property from Springsure is available via the Dawson Developmental Road which severs the southern portion of the property. Mr Schefe considered the highest and best use of the land to be grazing purposes. His valuation of $1,400,000 (6,188 ha at $226/ha) was reached by direct comparison with two sales.
Mr Loader said that Wongabell comprised large areas of steep tableland dropping down to steep rocky ridges which run all the way through the property. The ridges surround the black soil areas and cause severe erosion making them unsuitable for cultivation. The soil is also very shallow so that no dams can be constructed on the property and water is supplied from bores, which is very expensive. The subject also adjoins Minerva National Park and the spread of feral animals and weed into the property from the park adversely affects carrying capacity.
Mr Turner said in his report that he had assessed the unimproved value of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Loader v Department of Natural Resources and Mines and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] QLC 150
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to address several legal issues, primarily centred on the principles of valuation and the admissibility of evidence from an expert witness. The key issue was whether the Spencer test, which considers the knowledge of a long-term owner versus a hypothetical prudent purchaser, was correctly applied. The court also needed to determine whether a sale that was significantly lower than the analysed value could be disregarded without further explanation. Furthermore, the court had to assess the impact of the expert witness acting in a dual role on the admissibility and weight of their evidence.
In reaching its decision, the court found that while the expert witness's evidence was admissible, it was necessary to consider its potential bias due to their dual role. The court accepted the owners' classification of the property based on their more detailed knowledge, applying the Spencer test appropriately. However, a sale of the property that was significantly lower than the analysed figure was rejected as being too high without adequate explanation. Consequently, the court concluded that the unimproved value of the property should be set at $1,085,000 as of 1 October 2004. The appeal was allowed, and the court's determination was made accordingly.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal is allowed.
2. The unimproved value of Lot 10 on CP DSN 805047 GHPL 37/3316 in the County of Denison, Parish of Osmondthorpe is determined at $1,085,000 as at 1 October 2004.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi