FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Lo Pilato (Liquidator) v Barclays Workshop Pty Ltd (In Liq); In the Matter of Barclays Workshop Pty Ltd (In Liq) [2013] FCA 729
Citation: Lo Pilato (Liquidator) v Barclays Workshop Pty Ltd (In Liq); In the Matter of Barclays Workshop Pty Ltd (In Liq) [2013] FCA 729 Parties: IN THE MATTER OF BARCLAYS WORKSHOP PTY LTD (ACN 105 332 090) (IN LIQUIDATION); FRANK LO PILATO AS LIQUIDATOR OF BARCLAYS WORKSHOP PTY LTD (ACN 105 332 090) (IN LIQUIDATION) and BARCLAYS WORKSHOP PTY LTD (ACN 105 332 090) (IN LIQUIDATION) v KELLAM BUSLINES PTY LTD (ACN 003 708 405) File number: ACD 63 of 2012 Judge: FOSTER J Date of judgment: 22 July 2013 Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether the defendant should be granted leave pursuant to r 22.06 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 to withdraw admissions deemed to have been made by it as a result of failing to respond to or answer a Notice to Admit Facts served upon it pursuant to r 22.01 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 in circumstances where the failure to respond was inadvertent and there was no real relevant prejudice to the plaintiffs Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 588FB, 588FC, 588FE, 588FF
Federal Court Rules 2011, rr 22.01, 22.04, 22.06Cases cited: Chyb v Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation [2012] FCA 872 cited
Cox v Cox [2013] VSC 318 cited
Deangrove Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2003] FCA 268 cited
Drabsch v Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd (unreported, Supreme Court, NSW, 16 October 1996) followed
Permanent Trustee Company Ltd v Gulf Import and Export Company [2006] VSC 110 cited
Rigato Farms Pty Ltd v Ridolfi (2001) 2 Qd R 455 cited
Turner and Townsend Pty Ltd v Berry [2012] FCA 111 citedDate of hearing: 22 July 2013 Place: Sydney Division: GENERAL DIVISION Category: Catchwords Number of paragraphs: 31 Counsel for the Plaintiffs: Mr J Kohn Solicitor for the Plaintiffs: Herman Davis Lawyers Counsel for the Defendant: Mr J Lazarus Solicitor for the Defendant: Brock Partners
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
ACD 63 of 2012
IN THE MATTER OF BARCLAYS WORKSHOP PTY LTD (ACN 105 332 090 (IN LIQUIDATION)
BETWEEN: FRANK LO PILATO AS LIQUIDATOR OF BARCLAYS WORKSHOP PTY LTD (ACN 105 332 090) (IN LIQUIDATION)
First PlaintiffBARCLAYS WORKSHOP PTY LTD (ACN 105 332 090) (IN LIQUIDATION)
Second PlaintiffAND: KELLAM BUSLINES PTY LTD (ACN 003 708 405)
Defendant
JUDGE:
FOSTER J
DATE OF ORDER:
22 JULY 2013
WHERE MADE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.Leave be granted to the defendant to file in Court and to read the affidavit of Anthony Charles Griffiths sworn on 22 July 2013.
2.By 5 August 2013, the defendant file an affidavit sworn or affirmed by its Managing Director that specifies:
(a)Whether any of the goods identified in paragraph 9 of the Statement of Claim filed herein ever came into the possession, custody or control of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lo Pilato (Liquidator) v Barclays Workshop Pty Ltd (In Liq) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] FCA 729
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court reviewed the principles established in Drabsch v Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd, which provide that an application to withdraw admissions should not be freely granted if the party seeking to withdraw the admissions does not provide a compelling reason for the court to disturb the previously accepted admissions. Additionally, the court considered whether the inadvertent nature of the failure to respond and the lack of prejudice to the plaintiffs warranted leave to withdraw the admissions. Ultimately, the court found that the inadvertent nature of the failure to respond and the absence of significant prejudice to the plaintiffs justified granting leave to withdraw the admissions. The court emphasised that the value of the goods at the heart of the plaintiffs' case must be proven to secure any monetary relief.
The court granted the defendant leave to withdraw the admissions made due to its failure to respond to the Notice to Admit, noting the inadvertent nature of the failure and the lack of significant prejudice to the plaintiffs. The court also ordered that the defendant provide detailed information regarding the goods in question and extended the deadline for filing a Notice of Dispute. Additionally, the plaintiffs were directed to file their reply and evidence by specified dates. The costs of the interlocutory application were to be borne by the plaintiffs. The proceedings were subsequently stood over for a hearing on the merits.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Leave be granted to the defendant to file in Court and to read the affidavit of Anthony Charles Griffiths sworn on 22 July 2013.
2. By 5 August 2013, the defendant file an affidavit sworn or affirmed by its Managing Director that specifies:
(a) Whether any of the goods identified in paragraph 9 of the Statement of Claim filed herein ever came into the possession, custody or control of the defendant and, if so, precisely which of those goods came into the possession, custody or control of the defendant and when in the case of each item that occurred.
(b) Insofar as any goods came into the possession, custody or control of the defendant, whether any of those goods subsequently left the possession, custody or control of the defendant and, if so, when in the case of each item that occurred and the circumstances in which that occurred.
(c) Insofar as goods came into the possession, custody or control of the defendant which remain in the possession, custody or control of the defendant, which of those goods are still in the possession, custody or control of the defendant and what is the location of them.
(d) Insofar as the defendant asserts that payment was made for any of the goods specified in paragraph 9 of the Statement of Claim, when was payment made, by whom, to whom and by what means.
3. Pursuant to r 22.06 of the Federal Court Rules 2011, the defendant have leave to withdraw the admissions made by it as a result of its failure to dispute the Notice to Admit served upon it on 28 February 2013 (the Notice to Admit).
4. The time by which the defendant is to file any Notice of Dispute in respect of the Notice to Admit be extended up to and including 29 July 2013.
5. The plaintiffs file and serve their Reply (if any) by 6 August 2013.
6. By 6 August 2013, the plaintiffs file and serve all evidence upon which they intend to rely at the final hearing.
7. The costs of and incidental to the Interlocutory Application filed by the defendant on 20 May 2013 be the plaintiffs’ costs in the proceeding.
8. The proceeding stand over to 9.15 am on 7 August 2013 before the A.C.T. List Judge.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
The key facts revolve around the goods which the liquidator claims were taken from the company and the defendant's failure to respond to the Notice to Admit. The defendant argues that its failure to respond was a genuine oversight and did not result in any significant prejudice to the plaintiffs. The case hinges on whether the defendant should be allowed to withdraw its inadvertent admissions and, if so, under what conditions.
The defendant contends that it did not have any opportunity to review the Notice to Admit properly and that its failure to respond was not due to any neglect or deliberate action. It further argues that there was no substantial prejudice to the plaintiffs because the central issue of the value of the goods remains unresolved and needs to be proven in any event.
The matter came before the court as an interlocutory application under r 22.06 of the Federal Court Rules 2011, where the defendant sought leave to withdraw admissions made by its failure to respond to a Notice to Admit Facts. The defendant's application followed the presumption of admissions under r 22.04 FCR after it failed to respond to the notice within the stipulated 14-day period. Prior to this application, the defendant was served with the Notice to Admit Facts on 28 February 2013 and was required to respond by 14 March 2013. The plaintiffs subsequently filed their Statement of Claim on 15 March 2013, further detailing the allegations against the defendant.
The defendant filed its Interlocutory Application on 20 May 2013, seeking leave to withdraw the admissions it was deemed to have made. The court heard submissions from both parties and considered the principles relevant to such applications as outlined in previous cases such as Drabsch v Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd and others. The court's decision involved assessing the defendant's reasons for its failure to respond and whether there was any real prejudice to the plaintiffs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the defendant should be granted leave pursuant to r 22.06 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 to withdraw admissions made as a result of its failure to respond to a Notice to Admit Facts.
2. If leave is granted, under what conditions should the defendant be allowed to withdraw its admissions.
3. Whether the failure to respond to the Notice to Admit Facts caused any real prejudice to the plaintiffs.
4. What measures should be taken to ensure the proper conduct of the proceedings moving forward, including timelines for filing affidavits, evidence, and the next hearing date.
Held
1. The court granted the defendant leave pursuant to r 22.06 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 to withdraw admissions made as a result of its failure to respond to a Notice to Admit Facts.
2. The defendant was allowed to withdraw its admissions under specific conditions, including filing an affidavit with certain details about the goods in question.
3. The court found that the failure to respond to the Notice to Admit Facts did not cause any real prejudice to the plaintiffs.
4. The court ordered specific timelines for filing affidavits, evidence, and set the next hearing date, along with other procedural measures to ensure the proper conduct of the proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
It is therefore obvious that the question of value of the goods which the plaintiffs allege were taken from the company is at the heart of the plaintiffs’ case and must be proven to the satisfaction of the Court in order for the plaintiffs to obtain any monetary relief. CONSIDERATION Pursuant to r 22.06 FCR, the defendant has applied for leave to withdraw the admissions which have been attributed to it by its failure to respond to the Notice to Admit. It is required to take that step because, once a Notice to Admit has been validly served, r 22.04 FCR provides that, at the expiration of 14 days after service, the served party is taken to admit the facts set out in the Notice. The defendant submitted that the relevant principles were explained by Santow J in Drabsch v Switzerland General Insurance Co Ltd (unreported, Supreme Court, NSW, 16 October 1996) and that those principles have subsequently been adopted and applied on numerous occasions in this Court (as to which see Deangrove Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2003] FCA 268 at [28]–[35]; Turner and Townsend Pty Ltd v Berry [2012] FCA 111 at 14; and Chyb v Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation [2012] FCA 872 at [17]). In Drabsch, Santow J said: 1.Where a party under no apparent disability makes a clear and distinct admission which is accepted by its opponent and acted upon, for reasons of policy and the due conduct of the business of the court, an application to withdraw the admission, especially at appeal, should not be freely granted…2.The question is one for the reviewing judge to consider in the context of each particular appeal, with the general guideline being that the person seeking on a review to withdraw a concession made should provide some good reason why the judge should disturb what was previously common ground or conceded…3.Where a court is satisfied that admissions have been made after consideration and advice such as from the parties’ expert and after full opportunity to consider its case and whether the admission should be made, admissions so made with deliberateness and formality would ordinarily not be permitted to be withdrawn…4.It will usually be appropriate to grant leave to withdraw an admission where it is shown that the admission is contrary to the actual facts. Leave may also be appropriate where circumstances show that the admission was made inadvertently or without due consideration of material matters. Irrespective of whether the admission has or has not been formally made, leave may be refused if the other party has changed its position in reliance upon the admission…5.Following Cohen v McWilliam & Anor (1995) 38 NSWLR 476, a court is not obliged to give decisive weight to court efficiency, such that a party who wishes to defend its claim is entitled to a hearing on the merits, with costs orders being available as a means of compensating the other party for any costs thereby unnecessarily incurred or not fairly visited on the other party.