LM and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

[2013] AATA 408 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/3057

Re

LM

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms A F Cunningham (Senior Member)

Date  19 June 2013
Place Hobart

The decision under review is set aside and the matter remitted to the Minister for reconsideration of LM’s application to become an Australian citizen under section 17(1) of the Australian Citizen Act 2007.

[Sgd Ms A F Cunningham]

Ms A F Cunningham (Senior Member)

CATCHWORDS

IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP – citizen by descent – whether applicant had a parent who was an Australian citizen at time of her birth – weight of evidence supports finding that SM, an Australian citizen is LM’s biological father – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007, ss 16(2)(a), 17

CASES

H v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2010) FCAFC 119

NWH v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) AATA 833
McMullan v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) AATA 638

Kumar v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) AATA 124

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms A F Cunningham (Senior Member)

  1. The applicant, LM, a citizen of Papua New Guinea, seeks the review of a decision which refused her application for Australian citizenship by descent on the ground that she did not have a parent who was an Australian citizen at the time of her birth.

    Background

  2. LM was born in Port Moresby Papua New Guinea on 20 April 1996. The Certificate of Birth Entry records LB as her mother and SM as her father. The Registration Certificate issued by the Registrar-General's Office, Papua New Guinea, states that LM's birth was registered on 7 August 1996 and that both parents, SM (father) and LB (mother) consented to the registration.

  3. LM is a citizen of Papua New Guinea as is LB. SM is an Australian citizen and was so at the time of LM's birth.

  4. On 5 May 2011 LM made an application for Australian citizenship by descent. The application was based on her claim that SM, an Australian citizen, was her father at the time of her birth. LM was 14 years of age at the time of her application and SM was nominated as her responsible parent and representative.

  5. On 30 June 2012, a Delegate of the Minister refused LM's application for citizenship on the basis of not being satisfied that SM was her father at the time of her birth.

  6. On 18 July 2012 SM, on behalf of LM, filed an application for a review of the Delegate’s decision and lodged further documentary material in support.

  7. Both parties to the appeal requested that the Tribunal determine the matter on the basis of the documentary material submitted which included the T Documents lodged pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the respondent’s Statement of Facts and Contentions with annexures, an affidavit of GM sworn 1 April 1988, Order of the District Court at Port Moresby dated 17 July 1998, Order of the National Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LM and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 408
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In LM and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, the applicant, LM, a citizen of Papua New Guinea, sought the review of a decision that refused her application for Australian citizenship by descent on the basis that she did not have a parent who was an Australian citizen at the time of her birth. LM was born in Port Moresby, Papua New Guinea, on 20 April 1996, and her birth was registered on 7 August 1996. LM's application for citizenship was based on her claim that her father, SM, an Australian citizen, was her father at the time of her birth. The Delegate of the Minister refused LM's application, and on appeal, the Tribunal was required to determine whether LM satisfied the eligibility criteria for Australian citizenship by descent under section 16(2)(A) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007.

The issue before the Tribunal was whether LM satisfied the eligibility criteria for Australian citizenship by descent. Specifically, the Tribunal needed to determine whether SM was LM's parent at the time of her birth, either as a biological parent or by virtue of a parent-like relationship. The Minister argued that there was no evidence to support a finding that SM was LM's parent at the time of her birth, whereas SM contended that the evidence overwhelmingly supported a finding that he was LM's biological father. The Tribunal considered the documentary evidence submitted by both parties and SM's written responses to the Departmental Delegate's conclusions.

The Tribunal accepted the Delegate's findings regarding the identity and date of birth of LM and that SM was an Australian citizen at the time of LM's birth. However, the principal issue was whether SM was LM's parent within the meaning of the Act. The Tribunal considered the Full Court's decision in H v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2010) FCAFC 119, which concluded that the term "parent" in section 16(2) of the Act has the meaning it bears in ordinary contemporary English usage. The Tribunal found that the ordinary meaning of the word "parent" is a question of fact and that the Tribunal is bound to determine whether, at the time of the applicant's birth, they had a citizen parent. The Tribunal considered the evidence before it, including evidence as to SM's conduct before and at the time of LM's birth and evidence as to the conduct of any other person who may have had some relevant knowledge. The Tribunal found that there was no evidence to support a finding that SM was LM's parent at the time of her birth, either as a biological parent or by virtue of a parent-like relationship.

The Tribunal dismissed LM's application for the review of the Delegate's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, LM, a citizen of Papua New Guinea, seeks the review of a decision which refused her application for Australian citizenship by descent on the ground that she did not have a parent who was an Australian citizen at the time of her birth.Background LM was born in Port Moresby Papua New Guinea on 20 April 1996. The Certificate of Birth Entry records LB as her mother and SM as her father. The Registration Certificate issued by the Registrar-General's Office, Papua New Guinea, states that LM's birth was registered on 7 August 1996 and that both parents, SM (father) and LB (mother) consented to the registration. LM is a citizen of Papua New Guinea as is LB. SM is an Australian citizen and was so at the time of LM's birth. On 5 May 2011 LM made an application for Australian citizenship by descent. The application was based on her claim that SM, an Australian citizen, was her father at the time of her birth. LM was 14 years of age at the time of her application and SM was nominated as her responsible parent and representative. On 30 June 2012, a Delegate of the Minister refused LM's application for citizenship on the basis of not being satisfied that SM was her father at the time of her birth. On 18 July 2012 SM, on behalf of LM, filed an application for a review of the Delegate’s decision and lodged further documentary material in support. Both parties to the appeal requested that the Tribunal determine the matter on the basis of the documentary material submitted which included the T Documents lodged pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the respondent’s Statement of Facts and Contentions with annexures, an affidavit of GM sworn 1 April 1988, Order of the District Court at Port Moresby dated 17 July 1998, Order of the National Court at Waigani, Papua New Guinea dated 14 December 2011, Certificate of Birth Entry of LM dated 7 August 1996, Certificate of Birth Entry of LM dated 10 March 2011, letter of authority to travel dated 24 November 2011, Birth Registration Certificate dated 28 November 2012, Statutory Declaration of Senior Constable English dated 23 November 2012 and Statutory Declaration of JM dated 30 November 2012.Issue The issue for the Tribunal to determine is whether LM satisfies the eligibility criteria for Australian citizenship by descent pursuant to section 16(2)(A) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (the Act). That is whether either:(i) SM is the biological father of LM; or(ii) SM had a parent like relationship with LM at the time of her birth.Contentions It is contended by the Minister that there is no evidence to support a finding that SM was LM's parent at the time of her birth, either as a biological parent or by virtue of a parent like relationship. SM contends that the evidence overwhelmingly supports a finding that he is the biological father of LM. SM relies on the documentary evidence submitted by him as outlined above and his written responses to the conclusions of the Departmental Delegate who determined LM's application.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Minister‘s power to either approve or refuse to approve a person becoming an Australian citizen is derived from section 17 of the Act which provides:“(1)If a person makes an application under section 16, the Minister must,by writing, approve or refuse to approve the person becoming an Australian citizen.(1A)The Minister must not approve the person becoming an Australian citizen unless the person is eligible to become an Australian citizen under subsection 16(2) or (3).(2)Subject to this section, the Minister must approve the person becoming an Australian citizen if the person is eligible to become an Australian citizen under subsection 16(2) or (3).Identity(3)The Minister must not approve the person becoming an Australian citizen unless the Minister is satisfied of the identity of the person...”.Consideration I accept the Delegate’s findings regarding the identity and date of birth of the applicant and that SM was an Australian citizen at the time of the applicant's birth. What remains in contention is whether SM was LM's parent within the meaning of the Act. The Act does not define the term "parent" but it has been considered on a number of occasions by the Tribunal and most relevantly by the Full Court of the Federal Court in its decision H v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2010) FCAFC 119. The principal issue in that case was whether the term "parent of a person" in section 16(2) of the Act means only a natural or biological parent of the person. Following a detailed consideration of the submissions of the parties, previous authorities including the Tribunal's decisions in NWH v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) AATA 833, McMullan v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) AATA 638 and Kumar v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) AATA 124, and other relevant case law, the Full Court concluded at paragraph 127:"There is nothing in the legislative object, the legislative text, or the legislative structure of the Citizenship Act that requires the Court to conclude that, in the specific context of s16(2), the word "parent" can only mean biological parent. Indeed, these considerations indicate that the better view is that the word "parent" in s16(2) has the meaning it bears in ordinary contemporary English usage. Indeed, legislative history confirms that this approach is most in keeping with the development of citizenship legislation over time and with the spirit and intent of the current Citizenship Act. No sound reason has been advanced to warrant a more limited reading of the word." And further at paragraph 130”"The ordinary meaning of the word "parent" is, however, clearly a question of fact, as is the question whether a particular person qualifies as a parent within that ordinary meaning. Applying s16 (2) (a), the Tribunal is bound to determine whether or not, at the time of the applicant’s birth, he or she had a citizen parent. In deciding whether a person can be properly described as the applicant's parent, the Tribunal is obliged to consider the evidence before it, including evidence as to the supposed parent’s conduct before and at the time of birth and evidence as to the conduct of any other person who may be supposed to have had some relevant knowledge. Evidence as to conduct after the birth may be relevant in confirming that parentage at the time of birth. For example, evidence that a person acknowledged the applicant as his own before and at the time of birth and, thereafter, treated the applicant as his own, may justify a finding that that person was a parent of the applicant within the ordinary meaning of the word "parent" at the time of the birth …".