Lleneva Pty Ltd v Elders Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[2008] QSC 296

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CIVIL JURISDICTION

DAUBNEY J

Mackay No 72 of 2003

LLENEVA PTY LTD Applicant

and

ELDERS INSURANCE LIMITED Respondent

BRISBANE

..DATE 03/11/2008

ORDER

HIS HONOUR:  The immediate issue for resolution on this application is whether notice given by the applicant on the 26th of March 2008 pursuant to UCPR rule 389(1) of its intention to proceed remains efficacious.  The respondent submits that the applicant has taken no step in the proceeding since giving that notice and that, as more than two years have elapsed since the applicant last took a step in the proceeding, the applicant requires leave to proceed under rule 389(2).

The applicant has sought such leave in the alternative in its application but contends that such leave is not required because two years have not yet elapsed since a step was taken in the proceeding.

On the 10th of February 2006 Dutney J made certain orders in these proceedings.  Some debate erupted between the parties as to whether the terms of the order as taken out properly reflected the orders pronounced by his Honour.  That debate see-sawed between the lawyers for the parties over most of 2006. 

At the same time there was animated correspondence between the solicitors in relation to disclosure, with the respondent's solicitors contending that further disclosure was required from the applicant.  On the 29th of May 2006 the applicant had served a fourth list of documents on the respondent and provided copies of the documents on that list in a sporadic way over the ensuing months.

On the 30th of November 2006 the applicant's solicitors wrote to the respondent's solicitors stating, inter alia: 
"In relation to 'paper' documents our client has instructed us that the only further documents it has in its possession are various receipts in relation to its business (such as for the purchase of fuel and other business expenses).  Our client further instructs us that the amounts of those receipts would be summarised in the BAS statements which have been disclosed.  If your clients intend to assert that such receipts should be disclosed then please inform us of the basis of that assertion with reference to the proceedings.

Apart from the receipts our client has located 'electronic' documents which we are instructed are located on an old computer.  A disc of those documents is attached to the original of this letter.  Because of the fact that the documents use 'outdated software' our client has instructed us that it has not been able to print out these documents.

Our client will allow your clients a further three week period in which to complete any steps that they may wish to take with respect to disclosure.  After that time our client will proceed with the matter to trial."

There was obviously a disc enclosed with the original of that letter because on 5 December 2006 the respondent's solicitors wrote to the applicant's solicitors saying: 
"We refer to your letter dated 30 November 2006.

The disc supplied…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lleneva Pty Ltd v Elders Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QSC 296
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lleneva Pty Ltd sought a ruling on whether their notice of intention to proceed, given in March 2008, remained valid. Elders Insurance Ltd argued that more than two years had passed since the last step was taken in the proceeding, necessitating leave to proceed under UCPR rule 389(2). The applicant contested this, asserting that two years had not yet elapsed since the last step in the proceeding. The dispute arose from a series of events in 2006 and 2007 involving the disclosure of documents and the delivery of discs containing electronic documents. Elders Insurance Ltd contended that the applicant had not made the documents accessible, despite multiple opportunities.

The legal issues before the court were whether the applicant's actions constituted steps in the proceeding, and if so, whether the two-year period under rule 389(2) had elapsed. The court needed to determine the meaning of "disclosure" under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, and whether the production of discs and the offer to deliver a computer to view those discs constituted steps in the proceeding. The court also considered relevant case law, such as Citicorp Australia Limited v. Metropolitan Public Abattoir Board, which distinguished between the production and inspection of documents.

The court concluded that the applicant's actions did constitute steps in the proceeding, as the term "disclosure" under the UCPR encompassed the delivery or production of documents in accordance with rules 214, 216, and 217. The court found that rule 217(3)(a) required the party producing the documents to provide facilities, including computerised facilities, for inspection and copying. Therefore, the applicant was required to make the computer available to enable the inspection of the electronic documents. As the two-year period under rule 389(2) had not yet elapsed, the applicant could proceed with their notice of intention to proceed.

The court ordered that the notice given by the plaintiff in March 2008 was effective, the plaintiff be granted leave to file their reply to the amended defence, and costs be awarded in the cause.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established