Litz v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

COURT OF APPEAL [1999] QCA 401

PINCUS JA
THOMAS JA

CULLINANE J

Appeal No 10762 of 1998

HORST WILHELM LITZ Appellant
and
STATE OF QUEENSLAND Respondent
BRISBANE
..DATE 20/09/99
200999 D.1 T10/LE9 M/T COA231/99

PINCUS JA: This is an appeal from the judgment of Ambrose J given in an application made by

the respondent, the State of Queensland, for leave under O.90 r.9 to deliver a defence and

counterclaim in an action and on an application made by the appellant, Mr Litz, to strike out

Queensland's defence and counterclaim. The Judge granted Queensland's application and gave

Litz leave nunc pro tunc to make an application to strike out Queensland's defence and

counterclaim. His Honour made no order on the application to strike out.

There was a previous action related to the subject matter with which we are presently

concerned, but the writ in this action was issued in October 1994 by Mr Litz. It sought among

other relief a declaration that certain land is not within any national park and specific performance

of an agreement made in 1977 to extend a certain special lease in respect of the land just

mentioned for 30 years from

31 October 1988 - that is, to extend it to 31 October 2018. It also sought other relief. The

statement of claim was delivered on 3 April 1995. However, due to dilatoriness on the part of

the State of Queensland, no defence and counterclaim were delivered until more than three years

later, that is, on 28 April 1998. It is the fact that that pleading came in a little more than three

years later which has been the cause of the proceeding before Mr Justice Ambrose.

The appellant's case as set out in the statement of claim appears to have been primarily that he

was induced to take

a transfer of the land in question from the second defendants in the action (who have not been

served) upon an undertaking that on the expiry of the then current lease there would be a

renewal of the lease or a grant of a new lease for 30 years. The lease expired in 1988 and

thereafter the appellant held over without paying any rental. He is, it appears, still in possession.

The primary Judge thought there had been an inordinate delay on both sides and that both parties

200999 D.1 T10/LE9 M/T COA231/99

needed leave to proceed under Order 90 rule 9. His Honour was of the opinion that there was

no statutory limitation which would prevent either side from commencing fresh proceedings and

that the matters in question should be resolved quickly. He made the orders which I have

mentioned.

The appellant's outline says in effect that, since the Judge below gave Mr Litz leave to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Litz v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] QCA 401
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves an appeal by Horst Wilhelm Litz against the State of Queensland, brought before the Court of Appeal. The central issue revolves around an application by the State of Queensland for leave under Order 90 rule 9 to deliver a defence and counterclaim in an action initiated by Litz, as well as Litz's application to strike out Queensland's defence and counterclaim. The primary judge had granted Queensland's application and allowed Litz leave to apply to strike out the defence and counterclaim, though no order was made on the application to strike out. The case stems from a previous action concerning the ownership and lease of certain land, where Litz sought a declaration that the land was not within any national park and the specific performance of an agreement to extend a special lease for 30 years.

The legal issues before the court pertained to whether the significant delay in delivering the defence and counterclaim warranted granting leave under Order 90 rule 9, and whether the application to strike out should succeed. The Court of Appeal had to determine if the delay was justifiable and if the action should proceed despite the late delivery of the defence and counterclaim. The court also needed to consider whether the relief sought by Litz, including specific performance and a declaration, was appropriate given the circumstances. The appeal questioned whether the primary judge's decision to grant leave and allow the action to proceed was correct.

The Court of Appeal found that the appeal lacked merit. The judges noted that the delay in delivering the defence and counterclaim was significant, but justified due to the short period beyond the three-year limit and the fact that Litz remained in possession without paying any rental. The court concluded that allowing the appeal and restarting the proceedings would be undesirable and would only prolong the resolution of the matter. The judges emphasised that the need to resolve the issue of Litz's right to possession was urgent and justified the granting of leave. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Horst Wilhelm Litz initiated legal proceedings against the State of Queensland in October 1994. The primary claim sought a declaration that certain land was not within any national park and specific performance of an agreement made in 1977 to extend a special lease in respect of the land for 30 years from 31 October 1988. The lease in question had expired in 1988, and Mr Litz had been in possession of the land without paying any rental. Due to delays on the part of the State of Queensland, a defence and counterclaim were not delivered until more than three years later, on 28 April 1998. This significant delay prompted Mr Litz to apply to strike out the defence and counterclaim. The primary judge, Ambrose J, granted Queensland's application for leave to deliver a defence and counterclaim and allowed Mr Litz to make a nunc pro tunc application to strike out the defence and counterclaim, making no order on the application to strike out.

The case originated from an application made by the State of Queensland for leave to deliver a defence and counterclaim in response to Mr Litz's action. This application was granted by Ambrose J. Subsequently, Mr Litz applied to strike out the defence and counterclaim, which was allowed nunc pro tunc by the same judge, although no order was made on the application. This decision is now being appealed by Mr Litz. The appeal was heard by Pincus JA, Thomas JA, and Cullinane J.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appeal against the primary judge's decision granting leave to the State of Queensland to deliver a defence and counterclaim should be allowed.
2. Whether the Court should make a judgment in default of pleading for Mr Litz based on the specific relief sought in the statement of claim.

Held
1. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal against the primary judge's decision granting leave to the State of Queensland to deliver a defence and counterclaim.
2. The Court declined to make a judgment in default of pleading for Mr Litz based on the specific relief sought in the statement of claim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal held that the appeal was devoid of substance and dismissed it with costs. The Court examined the extensive delay in the proceedings and found that the appellant's allegation of an assurance given by the State of Queensland regarding the lease renewal was the only factor preventing the State from being entitled to possession. The Court agreed with the primary judge's decision to grant leave to the State of Queensland to deliver a defence and counterclaim due to the significant delay caused by both parties, the shortness of the time involved, and the necessity of resolving the question of Mr Litz's right to possession. The Court held that allowing the appeal would only extend the proceedings further and was not in the interest of justice. The Court also declined to make a judgment in default of pleading for Mr Litz, as specific performance and declarations sought in the statement of claim would require a trial to determine the facts. The Court found that the primary judge's decision to grant leave to the State of Queensland was the only proper result that could be reached.