Little and Others v Oriole Resources Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Little and Others on behalf of the Badimia People v Oriole Resources Pty Ltd
[2005] FCAFC 243

NATIVE TITLE – future acts – act attracting the expedited procedure – grant of Miscellaneous Licence – whether an act ‘likely to involve major disturbance to any land or waters concerned’ – whether likely to ‘create rights whose exercise is likely to involve major disturbance to any land or waters …’ – predictive assessment of likely major disturbance required – Tribunal proceeding on assumption that rights granted under Miscellaneous Licence could be exercised to full – construction unduly favourable to appellants – Tribunal finding no likelihood of major disturbance – erroneous finding – evaluative judgment – court in position to make substituted judgment – on predictive assessment no major disturbance likely – appeal dismissed

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) 24AA, s 237
Mining Act 1978 (WA) s 91

Mining Regulations 1981 s 42B

Little v Oriole Resources Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 506 cited
Smith v Western Australia (2001) 108 FCR 442 cited
Little v State of Western Australia [2001] FCA 1706 cited
Ward v State of Western Australia (1996) 69 FCR 208 cited
State of Western Australia v Ward (1996) 70 FCR 265 cited
Dann v Western Australia (1997) 74 FCR 391 cited

ALBERT LITTLE AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE BADIMIA PEOPLE v ORIOLE RESOURCES PTY LTD and THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
WAD 110 OF 2005

FRENCH, STONE & SIOPIS JJ
5 DECEMBER 2005
PERTH

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 110 OF 2005

On Appeal from a Single Judge of the Federal Court of Australia

BETWEEN:

ALBERT LITTLE AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE BADIMIA PEOPLE
APPELLANTS

AND:

ORIOLE RESOURCES PTY LTD
FIRST RESPONDENT

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

FRENCH, STONE AND SIOPIS JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

5 DECEMBER 2005

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The appeal is dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 110 OF 2005

On Appeal from a Single Judge of the Federal Court of Australia

BETWEEN:

ALBERT LITTLE AND OTHERS ON BEHALF OF THE BADIMIA PEOPLE
APPELLANTS

AND:

ORIOLE RESOURCES PTY LTD
FIRST RESPONDENT

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGES:

FRENCH, STONE AND SIOPIS JJ

DATE:

5 DECEMBER 2005

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:
Introduction

  1. On 21 May 2003 the State of Western Australia (the State) published a notice under s 29 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (NTA) advertising the proposed grant of a Miscellaneous Licence under the Mining Act 1978 (WA). The proposed Licence covered an area of 120 hectares, about 70 kilometres north east of Dalwallinu at the Mt Gibson Gold Mine. The purpose of the Licence was mining camp infrastructure and associated facilities.

  2. The Licence was to be granted to Oriole Resources Pty Ltd (Oriole).  Oriole’s stated intention was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Little and Others v Oriole Resources Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCAFC 243
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Little and Others v Oriole Resources Pty Ltd, the appellants, representing the Badimia People, challenged the grant of a Miscellaneous Licence by Oriole Resources Pty Ltd, a subsidiary of PacMin Mining Corporation Limited. The licence, covering 120 hectares near the Mt Gibson Gold Mine, was contested on the grounds that it would likely involve major disturbance to the land and waters, contravening the Native Title Act 1993 (NTA). The Tribunal, however, dismissed the objection, finding no major disturbance was likely due to the limited extent of the licence's exercise as stated by PacMin.

The primary legal issues revolved around the interpretation of Section 237(c) of the NTA and the definition of "major disturbance" in the context of the grant of the Miscellaneous Licence. The appellants argued that the Tribunal misconstrued Section 237(c) and failed to undertake a proper predictive assessment of the potential disturbance. The respondents contended that the Tribunal correctly assessed the likelihood of major disturbance based on the evidence provided.

The court found that the Tribunal did not err in its interpretation of Section 237(c), as supported by precedents such as Smith v Western Australia and Little v State of Western Australia. The court also determined that the Tribunal correctly assessed the likelihood of major disturbance by considering the evidence, including the limited scope of the licence's exercise as stated by PacMin. The court held that the Tribunal's assessment was not based on a false assumption but on the actual intention to limit the exercise of the licence rights.

Accordingly, the appeal was dismissed, affirming the Tribunal's decision that the grant of the Miscellaneous Licence would not likely involve major disturbance to the land or waters. The court upheld the Tribunal's approach to the assessment, ensuring it was aligned with the statutory requirements and evidence presented.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

While the Tribunal erred in assessing that there would be no ‘major disturbance’, that assessment was done on a false assumption. On a proper evaluation based upon the unchallenged stated intention of the grantee to exercise the rights conferred by the Miscellaneous Licence to only a limited extent, there could be no major disturbance to the land or waters. For that reason the appeal should be dismissed.Factual and Procedural Background Oriole is a company related to PacMin Mining Corporation Limited (PacMin) which was, until 2002, the owner of the Mt Gibson Gold Mine. The Mt Gibson Gold Mine is located about 280 kilometres north east of Perth and about 12 kilometres east of the Great Northern Highway. It has been operating since 1986. It was put on a care and maintenance basis in 1999. On 12 January 2000 Oriole lodged an application for a Miscellaneous Licence 59/53 in respect of an area of 120 hectares near the gold mine for the purpose of mine site accommodation and associated facilities pursuant to reg 43B(n) of the Mining Regulations 1981. The application was incidental to plans to recommence mining operations. The application included the area of a pre-existing Miscellaneous Licence 59/12 which had been granted on 26 August 1986 and which covered 8.75 hectares of land. The purpose of that Licence was also expressed as ‘mine site accommodation and associated facilities’. An existing mining camp and accommodation for some 106 personnel lies within the 8.75 hectares. In a statement filed by PacMin on 4 February 2000 with the Mining Registrar at Mt Magnet pursuant to reg 37(3) of the Mining Regulations and made in support of the Licence application, PacMin stated that: ‘(a)The licence once granted will be for the sole purpose of the mining camp infrastructure associated with the Mount Gibson Gold Mine; (b)This campsite consists of transportable unit accommodation structures, transportable house structures and associated facilities; (c)These facilities have been in place for a number of years and associated with the Mount Gibson Gold Mine operations.’ On 21 May 2003 the State published a notice of the proposed grant of the Miscellaneous Licence. The notice was published pursuant to s 29 of the NTA. The Licence was described as covering an area of 119.96 hectares, located 74 kilometres north-east of Dalwallinu. The notice contained a statement that the State considered the grant to be an act attracting the expedited procedure under the NTA. That is the Licence could be granted unless, within the period of four months after the notification day, a native title party lodged an objection with the Tribunal against the application of the expedited procedure. On 27 May 2003 an objection to the application of the expedited procedure was lodged at the Tribunal by the registered claimants in a native title determination application brought on behalf of the Badimia People. The claimants are the appellants in these proceedings. The claim area covered by their application includes the 120 hectares the subject of the proposed Miscellaneous Licence. The formal statement of objection was by way of an objection to the inclusion in the State’s s 29 notice of the statement that the proposed grant of the Miscellaneous Licence attracted the expedited procedure. In their objection, the claimants stated their belief that the grant of the Miscellaneous Licence would create rights the exercise of which would involve major disturbance to the land over which it was to be granted.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Mining Regulations 1981 set out prescribed purposes for the grant of Miscellaneous Licences thus: ‘42B. For the purposes of section 91(1), a miscellaneous licence may be granted for the use of land for one or more of the following purposes: (a) a road; …(e) a power line; …(n)any other purpose directly connected with mining operations approved by the Director General of Mines.’ The Evidence before the Tribunal The only evidence brought on behalf of the claimants before the Tribunal was that of Cedric Stileman Davies, a geologist, who was employed by the Yamatji Land and Sea Council, which is the native title representative body for the area. Mr Davies deposed that in the course of his work as a geologist in Western Australia he had resided at various mine site accommodation facilities associated with mining operations and commonly known as mining camps. All of the mining camps at which he resided had included the following facilities: (a) accommodation units in the form of portable or semi-permanent dongas;(b) ablution facilities; (c) laundry facilities; (d) a large central hard standing area with buildings including: (i)a restaurant/cafeteria with associated kitchens, food storage and delivery facilities;(ii)a wet mess/bar area and small shop; (iii)a television/video room; (iv)an administration office; (v)public telephones; (vi)ice machines, potable water facilities etc.(e)dedicated parking areas and associated roads; (f)concrete pathways between buildings; (g)a sewerage system; (h)a rubbish dump; (i)reticulated landscaping; (j)some form of recreational facility or combination of facilities.Mr Davies exhibited photographs of mining camps to his affidavit. Oriole provided an affidavit sworn by Mr Timothy Carter, an Executive Director of Oroya Mining Ltd who has had more than 20 years experience in senior management positions with Australian exploration, open-cut and underground mining companies. He had reviewed the operation of the Mt Gibson gold project in 1991 and had been actively involved in feasibility studies for its recommissioning. Mr Carter exhibited to his affidavit a letter dated 19 December 2003 from an Environmental Officer at the Department of Industry and Resources stating her intention to recommend to the State Mining Engineer that the project be approved subject to conditions on an attached schedule. The conditions on the proposed Miscellaneous Licence were included in a schedule which drew the attention of the licensee to the provisions of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) and the Environmental Protection Act 1986 (WA). The conditions required, inter alia, that the development and operations under the Licence were to be carried out in such a manner as to create the minimum practicable disturbance to existing vegetation and natural land forms. On completion of the life of the mining operations the holder of the Licence would be required to remove all installations constructed under it, cover all wells and holes in the ground to such degree of safety as should be determined by the Inspector and on areas cleared of natural growth, to plant trees and/or shrubs and/or any other plant as shall conform to the general pattern and type of growth in the area. The rehabilitation conditions were subject to the Warden or Minister for Mines otherwise ordering or consenting.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In their notice of appeal dated 9 June 2004, as amended on 9 February 2005, in the original jurisdiction of this Court, the claimants alleged that the Tribunal had misconstrued s 237(c) of the NTA (grounds 1 to 4). It had also erred in law in its approach to the assessment of whether the grant of the Licence was likely to involve major disturbance to the land or waters concerned or to create rights whose exercise was likely to involve such disturbance. The Reasons for Judgment of the Primary Judge The claimants contended before the learned primary judge that the likelihood to be assessed in the second limb of s 237(c) related to the creation of rights by virtue of the grant of the Licence. The predictive exercise did not extend to whether the rights so created would or would not be exercised. The Licence would create the right to build a mining camp. The exercise of such right, if it was found likely to exist (a certainty on the claimants’ construction) should have been found by the Tribunal to be likely to involve major disturbance. That is to say the question of the likelihood of major disturbance in par 237(c) was to be assessed by reference to the scope of the rights created pursuant to the grant of the Licence rather than by a predictive assessment whether the rights created under the Licence were likely to be so exercised as to involve major disturbance to the land affected by them. The State contended before his Honour that under the correct approach to s 237(c) a predictive assessment must be undertaken under either limb having regard to the rights which are created at the time of the grant. The difficulty with this aspect of the debate before his Honour is that, as noted earlier, the Tribunal assessed whether there was likely to be a major disturbance by reference to what could be done under the Licence. It did not acknowledge any requirement for a predictive assessment of the things likely to be done under the Licence. Nor did it cite the authorities relevant to the construction of s 237(c) in its amended form. The learned primary judge referred to those authorities namely Smith v Western Australia (2001) 108 FCR 442 and Little v State of Western Australia [2001] FCA 1706 and concluded (at [27]): ‘Accordingly, I do not consider the approach to interpretation of the second limb of s 237(c) contended for by the applicants can be accepted. There is nothing in the applicants’ submissions or in the statutory language in issue to answer the issues raised and reasoning followed by the Tribunal in Smith 169 FLR 1. The statements in Smith 108 FCR 442 and Little support the correctness of it. Applying the second limb in the manner contended for by the State still leaves that limb with a function.’His Honour did not consider that the ground of appeal based upon the construction of the second limb of s 237(c) was made out. The second argument before his Honour went to the construction of the word ‘major disturbance’. After referring to authorities he said (at [37]): ‘Turning then to ground nine in that context, it cannot be the case that the fact that the Licence may authorise a construction of a mining camp necessarily entails that it is likely to involve a major disturbance. The predictive assessment must be made of that fact in the context of all the evidence before the Tribunal. The decisions make apparent that the Tribunal is not operating in a vacuum isolated from the evidence before it. The Tribunal would have fallen into error of law if, having reached the view that the Licence authorised the construction of a mining camp, it did not make a predictive assessment as to whether it was likely to involve major disturbance. That necessarily required it to go to the evidence and not simply to the dictionary definition of ‘mining camp’ or, indeed, to the evidence alone of the nature of the existing mining camp.’

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.