| [2020] FWC 4782 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Lisa Peel
v
Aster Home Nursing Service Pty Ltd
(U2020/3569)
COMMISSIONER SIMPSON | BRISBANE, 8 SEPTEMBER 2020 |
Application for unfair dismissal – Jurisdictional objection – Whether applicant was employee or contractor.
[1] Ms Lisa Peel has made an application to the Fair Work Commission (the Commission) under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) for an unfair dismissal remedy against Aster Home Nursing Service Pty Ltd (Aster).
[2] In the Form F3 – Employer Response to unfair dismissal application, Aster objected to the application on the basis Ms Peel was not an employee, but rather an independent contractor under the Act.
[3] The matter did not settle at conciliation and was allocated to me. I issued directions for the filing of material, and the matter was listed for Hearing of the jurisdictional objection by telephone on 23 June 2020. Evidence in the matter was heard on both 23 and 24 June 2020. Ms Peel represented herself with the assistance of her support person Mr Michael Brown and Mr Mark Curran of DWF (Australia) was granted leave to represent Aster.
[4] Ms Peel filed submissions and a witness statement dated 19 June 2020. The Respondent also filed submissions and two witness statements of Mr Andrew Ning (Director).
[5] On Thursday 18 June, Aster sought to file a further witness statement of Mr Mark William Molesworth in response to the material filed by Ms Peel. Ms Peel objected to the late admission of the statement on the basis the document was some 50 pages in length and would prejudice her case. I ultimately decided to allow the statement of Mr Molesworth into evidence 1.
[6] Section 382 of the Fair Work Act outlines the requirements for a person to be protected from unfair dismissal:
“382 When a person is protected from unfair dismissal
A person is protected from unfair dismissal at a time if, at that time:
(a) the person is an employee who has completed a period of employment with his or her employer of at least the minimum employment period; and
(b) one or more of the following apply:
(i) a modern award covers the person;
(ii) an enterprise agreement applies to the person in relation to the employment;
(iii) the sum of the person’s annual rate of earnings, and such other amounts (if any) worked out in relation to the person in accordance with the regulations, is less than the high income threshold.”
[7] The Full Bench decision in Kimber v Western Auger Drilling Pty Ltd 2 provides the factors/indicia this Commission needs to consider in assessing whether an Applicant was an employee or an independent contractor during the relevant period of employment. The Full Bench endorsed the general approach to distinguishing employees and independent contractors provided in Jiang Shen Cai T/A French Accent v Michael Anthony Do Rozario which follows:
“(1) In determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lisa Peel v Aster Home Nursing Service Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FWC 4782
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Commission were the correct characterisation of Ms Peel's employment status and the applicability of the unfair dismissal provisions. The Commission needed to examine the nature of the relationship between the parties, focusing on factors such as control, economic dependence, and integration into the business. The arguments centred on the interpretation of various contractual terms and the conduct of the parties throughout their engagement.
The Commission examined the terms of the agreement between the parties and the conduct during the relationship. It found that despite the label of "independent contractor" in the agreement, the nature of the relationship exhibited characteristics of an employment relationship. The level of control exerted by Aster over Ms Peel's work, her economic dependence on the company, and the integration of her services into the company's business operations supported the conclusion that she was an employee. Consequently, the Commission ruled that Ms Peel was an employee, and the unfair dismissal provisions applied to her case.
The Commission ordered that the application for unfair dismissal be reinstated and proceeded to the merits. Aster Home Nursing Service Pty Ltd was directed to show cause why the dismissal should not be deemed unfair. The Commission also ordered that Ms Peel's entitlements be reinstated, pending the outcome of the unfair dismissal application.