Liney v Police No. Scciv-03-446

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

LINEY v POLICE
[2003] SASC 211

Magistrates Appeal

Gray J

  1. This is an appeal against conviction.

  2. The appellant Paul Graham Liney was charged on complaint with driving under the influence and failing to indicate a change of direction[1]. He was convicted of both offences following a trial before a magistrate at Roxby Downs.  Mr Liney has appealed against his conviction for driving under the influence. He was represented on the hearing of the appeal.

    [1] On the 23rd day of February, 2002 at Roxby Downs in the said State being the driver of a vehicle namely a motor vehicle on a road namely Burgoyne Street, who changed direction to the right by turning right into Burgoyne Street, you did not before changing direction, give a chance of direction signal in accordance with rule 49 of the Australian Road Rules for long enough to give sufficient warning to other drivers and pedestrians
  3. The appeal raises issues arising from the malfunction of a breath analysis instrument. It was said that notwithstanding the malfunction Mr Liney had a statutory right to request a blood kit and have a blood test taken. As this right had not been respected it was contended that the trial should have been stayed. Alternatively it was said that evidence of police observations should have been excluded as a matter of discretion. It was also contended that the conviction was unsafe.

    Proceedings before the Magistrate’s Court

  4. Mr Liney was unrepresented at trial. The magistrate discussed the issue of representation but Mr Liney informed him that he wanted to represent himself. The transcript reveals that the magistrate assisted Mr Liney appropriately during the hearing. When Mr Liney was encountering difficulty in putting his case the magistrate assisted. No application was made by Mr Liney to have any police evidence excluded as a matter of discretion.  No application for a stay of the proceedings was made.  Mr Liney did not seek an adjournment to obtain legal advice.

  5. The Crown called two police witnesses who recounted their observations of Mr Liney’s driving at Roxby Downs on 23 February 2002. The police officers formed the opinion that Mr Liney had driven in contravention of the Australian Road Rules and had been driving under the influence of alcohol. Mr Liney accompanied the officers to the Roxby Down police station and agreed to undertake a breath analysis test. The breath analysis instrument malfunctioned on a number of occasions.

  6. Mr Liney gave evidence and called a witness. Steven Robert Cox.  Mr Liney recounted that he had spent some time at a Roxby Downs hotel but had only consumed three stubbies of beer. Mr Cox gave an account which suggested Mr Liney may have drunk more than three stubbies of beer at the hotel.

  7. The magistrate accepted the evidence of the police officers and rejected that of Mr Liney where the evidence conflicted:

    The prosecution called two police officers as witnesses, they being Constable Cheers and Senior Constable Griffin. Their evidence is substantially consistent with each…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Liney v Police No. Scciv-03-446 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 211
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the court involved Mr Liney, who was challenging his conviction for driving under the influence and failing to signal before changing direction. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The primary issues in the appeal were whether the evidence gathered by the police should have been excluded, whether the magistrate had erred in his assessment of the evidence, and whether any procedural unfairness warranted a stay of proceedings or exclusion of evidence.

The court found that there were no grounds for a stay of the proceedings or for excluding evidence based on police observations. The magistrate had exercised his discretion properly and there was no unfairness in the process that would require the exclusion of evidence. The court also rejected the application to introduce further evidence, as it did not demonstrate any injustice or advance the issues on appeal. The proposed evidence regarding Mr Liney's attempts to obtain legal representation and his understanding of the breath analysis instrument did not support a finding of unfairness or an unsafe conviction.

The court concluded that the magistrate had made factual findings beyond reasonable doubt and had correctly assessed the credibility of the witnesses. There was no error in the magistrate's approach or in his acceptance of the police officers' evidence. The court found no basis to overturn the conviction, as the magistrate's findings of fact were supported by the evidence. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed, and the conviction was upheld.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 23 February 2002, Mr Liney was driving a vehicle on Burgoyne Street in Roxby Downs, South Australia. He turned right into Burgoyne Street without providing a sufficient warning to other drivers and pedestrians by not giving a direction signal as required by rule 49 of the Australian Road Rules. This constituted a summary offence under rule 48(2) of the Australian Road Rules. During the same incident, it was alleged that Mr Liney was so much under the influence of intoxicating liquor that he was incapable of exercising effective control of the vehicle, which constituted another summary offence under section 47 of the Road Traffic Act, 1961.

Following his arrest, Mr Liney appeared before a magistrate and was unrepresented. He had attempted to obtain legal representation but faced difficulties due to the unavailability of solicitors and the associated costs. Despite receiving some legal advice, Mr Liney chose to proceed unrepresented. During the proceedings, the magistrate found that the breath analysis instrument used to test Mr Liney's blood alcohol level had malfunctioned. The magistrate assessed the credibility and reliability of the witnesses, including the police officers, and found their evidence to be acceptable. Based on this evidence, the magistrate concluded that Mr Liney was affected by alcohol while driving, leading to the conviction.

On appeal, Mr Liney's counsel sought to introduce further evidence regarding the circumstances of his unrepresentation at the trial and his understanding of the breath analysis instrument malfunction. However, the court determined that this proposed evidence did not advance the issues on appeal or demonstrate any injustice. The court also rejected the application to receive further evidence, finding no basis for overturning the conviction.

The case of Liney v Police No. Scciv-03-446 came before this court on appeal from a decision made by a lower court. The matter originated in a trial court where Mr Liney was convicted of driving a motor vehicle while under the influence of intoxicating liquor and for failing to give a direction signal before changing direction. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Mr Liney lodged an appeal against his conviction and sentence. The appeal was heard by the court which reviewed the procedural history and the grounds upon which Mr Liney sought to challenge his conviction. During the hearing, Mr Liney’s counsel attempted to introduce further evidence concerning the circumstances that led to Mr Liney being unrepresented at the trial and his understanding of a breath analysis instrument malfunction. However, the court found that this evidence did not pertain to the issues on appeal and did not demonstrate any injustice, ultimately rejecting the application to admit the further evidence. The court proceeded to examine the substantive grounds of the appeal, including whether the magistrate's factual findings were beyond reasonable doubt and whether any error occurred in the assessment of evidence. The appeal was ultimately dismissed as the court found no basis to overturn the conviction.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For these reasons no unfairness arose in the circumstances of the present case. No grounds for a stay existed. No grounds for the exercise of the discretion to exclude evidence of police observations had been established. There was no need for an adjournment to allow legal advice to be taken. Further Evidence On the hearing of the appeal counsel for Mr Liney sought to introduce further evidence. The proposed evidence addressed the circumstances giving rise to him being unrepresented at the trial and his understanding of the breath analysis instrument malfunction. The proposed evidence established that Mr Liney had attempted to obtain legal representation. However he encountered difficulty because of the unavailability of solicitors and the costs involved. He received some legal advice but then made a decision to proceed unrepresented. The proposed evidence does not advance the issues on appeal and does not demonstrate that any injustice arose. To the contrary as earlier observed the transcript reveals that considerable care was taken by the magistrate to assist Mr Liney as an unrepresented litigant. Counsel for Mr Liney disclaimed any challenge to the magistrate’s finding that the breath analysis instrument malfunctioned. The proposed evidence about the breath analysis instrument process was said to establish Mr Liney’s state of mind at the time. It was said that Mr Liney had understood that the breath analysis instrument had produced a negative result and that the investigating officers had suggested that they would not transport him to the nearest hospital for the purposes of a blood test. Mr Liney’s state of mind is not relevant to issues raised in this appeal. The material does not support the suggestion that any unfairness arose. This court has a discretion to receive further evidence in the interests of justice[3]. No injustice has been demonstrated. The application to receive further evidence is rejected.[3] CDJ v VAJ (1998-1999) 197 CLR 172, Van Den Heuvel v Tucker [2003] SASC 110 at [11-14] and [121-124].Unsafe to Convict As earlier observed the magistrate made a number of factual findings beyond reasonable doubt. He prefaced these findings by assessing the credibility and reliability of the witnesses. It was open to the magistrate to accept and act on the evidence of the police officers. No error in his approach has been identified. It has not been suggested that the magistrate overlooked any relevant consideration or had regard to any irrelevant material[4]. The magistrate was entitled to conclude on the evidence before him that Mr Liney was affected by alcohol when driving. [4] House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499 No error has been demonstrated. There is no basis on which to disturb his acceptance of witnesses and his findings of fact. No basis for overturning the conviction has been identified.Conclusion For these reasons the appeal is dismissed.JUDGMENT CITATIONS LISTED IN ORDER OF APEARANCE IN JUDGMENT1 On the 23rd day of February, 2002 at Roxby Downs in the said State being the driver of a vehicle namely a motor vehicle on a road namely Burgoyne Street, who changed direction to the right by turning right into Burgoyne Street, you did not before changing direction, give a chance of direction signal in accordance with rule 49 of the Australian Road Rules for long enough to give sufficient warning to other drivers and pedestriansRule 48(2) of the Australian Road Rules.This is a summary offence.On the 23rd day of February, 2002 at Roxby Downs in the said State drove a vehicle namely a motor vehicle on a road namely Burgoyne Street whilst he was so much under the influence of intoxicating liquor as to be incapable of exercising effective control of the said vehicle.Section 47 of the Road Traffic Act, 1961.This is a summary offence.2 Police v Warren [2000] SASC 285 at [16-17]3CDJ v VAJ (1998-1999) 197 CLR 172, Van Den Heuvel v Tucker [2003] SASC 110 at [11-14] and [121-124].4 House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons the appeal is dismissed.JUDGMENT CITATIONS LISTED IN ORDER OF APEARANCE IN JUDGMENT1 On the 23rd day of February, 2002 at Roxby Downs in the said State being the driver of a vehicle namely a motor vehicle on a road namely Burgoyne Street, who changed direction to the right by turning right into Burgoyne Street, you did not before changing direction, give a chance of direction signal in accordance with rule 49 of the Australian Road Rules for long enough to give sufficient warning to other drivers and pedestriansRule 48(2) of the Australian Road Rules.This is a summary offence.On the 23rd day of February, 2002 at Roxby Downs in the said State drove a vehicle namely a motor vehicle on a road namely Burgoyne Street whilst he was so much under the influence of intoxicating liquor as to be incapable of exercising effective control of the said vehicle.Section 47 of the Road Traffic Act, 1961.This is a summary offence.2 Police v Warren [2000] SASC 285 at [16-17]3CDJ v VAJ (1998-1999) 197 CLR 172, Van Den Heuvel v Tucker [2003] SASC 110 at [11-14] and [121-124].4 House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's decision in the appeal by Mr. Liney commenced with the consideration of the exercise of discretion to exclude evidence of police observations. The court held that no unfairness arose from the circumstances of the case, and no grounds for a stay existed. The court found that Mr. Liney had not established any grounds for the exercise of the discretion to exclude evidence of police observations. The court was satisfied that there was no need for an adjournment to allow legal advice to be taken. This reasoning demonstrates that the court considered the necessity of fairness in the trial process, but found that the circumstances did not warrant the exclusion of police observations or an adjournment for legal advice.

Further, the court examined the proposed further evidence that Mr. Liney sought to introduce. This evidence addressed the circumstances surrounding his unavailability of legal representation and his understanding of the breath analysis instrument malfunction. The court found that this proposed evidence did not advance the issues on appeal and did not demonstrate any injustice. The court noted that the magistrate had taken considerable care to assist Mr. Liney as an unrepresented litigant. Additionally, the court observed that the proposed evidence about the breath analysis instrument did not establish any unfairness, as Mr. Liney's state of mind was not relevant to the issues raised in the appeal. This demonstrates that the court was cautious in considering the proposed further evidence and found no merit in admitting it.

The court also considered whether there was any miscarriage of justice or unfairness in the conviction due to the unavailability of legal representation and the breath analysis instrument malfunction. The court found that the magistrate had assessed the credibility and reliability of the witnesses and was entitled to conclude on the evidence before him that Mr. Liney was affected by alcohol when driving. The court found no error in the magistrate's approach and concluded that there was no basis for overturning the conviction. This reasoning reflects the court's consideration of potential miscarriages of justice but ultimately found no grounds to disturb the conviction.

Additionally, the court assessed the sufficiency of evidence to support the magistrate's findings of fact and the conviction. The court found that the magistrate had made factual findings beyond reasonable doubt and that there was no error in his assessment of the credibility and reliability of the witnesses. The court found no basis on which to disturb the magistrate's findings of fact or the conviction. This demonstrates that the court carefully reviewed the evidence and found it sufficient to support the conviction.

Finally, the court addressed whether there was any error in the magistrate's assessment of the credibility and reliability of the witnesses and whether the magistrate overlooked any relevant consideration. The court found no error in the magistrate's approach and concluded that the magistrate was entitled to conclude that Mr. Liney was affected by alcohol when driving. This reasoning reflects the court's careful review of the magistrate's assessment of the evidence and the witnesses.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the court found no grounds to exclude evidence of police observations, no miscarriage of justice or unfairness in the conviction, no merit in admitting further evidence, and no error in the magistrate's assessment of the credibility and reliability of the witnesses. The court found the evidence sufficient to support the conviction and dismissed the appeal. The court applied the principles of fairness in the trial process, the sufficiency of evidence, and the assessment of credibility and reliability of witnesses, and found no grounds to overturn the conviction.