Lin and Han

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

LIN & HAN [2015] FCCA 2395
Catchwords:
FAMILY LAW – Practice and procedure – where the substantive proceedings relate to an application to set aside a Binding Financial Agreement – adequacy of legal advice provided to the applicant – conduct of legal practitioner – referral to Legal Services Commissioner.

Legislation:

Family Law Act 1975, ss.90G, 90K
Succession Act 2006
Supreme Court Rules 1970
Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001
Australian Solicitors Conduct Rules 2011
New South Wales Professional Conduct and Practice Rules 2013 (Solicitor’s Rules)
Evidence Act 1995, ss.38, 118, 192

Incorporated Law Institute of New South Wales -v- R D Meagher (1909) 9 CLR 655
Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465
New South Wales Bar Association -v- Thomas (No.2) (1989) 18 NSWLR 193
Rondel -v- Worsley [1969] 1 AC 191; [1967] All ER 993
Tyrrell -v- Bank of London (1862) 10 HLC 26

Other Articles Cited:
Virginia Shirvington, the Senior Ethics Solicitor of the Law Society of New South Wales, “Avoiding A Breach Of The Professional Conduct and Practice Rules”, 2001.

Applicant: MR LIN
Respondent: MS HAN
File Number: PAC 290 of 2014
Judgment of: Judge Harman
Hearing dates: 3, 4, 23 June 2015
Date of Last Submission: 24 July 2015
Delivered at: Parramatta
Delivered on: 4 September 2015

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Greenaway
Solicitors for the Applicant: Watts McCray Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr Sansom
Solicitors for the Respondent: Ren Zhou Lawyers
Counsel for Mr Zhang: Ms Traill

ORDERS

  1. I request that the Registrar of the Court forward to the Legal Services Commissioner of New South Wales a copy of each of the following:

    (a)These reasons;

    (b)Transcript of the evidence of Mr Zhang, solicitor, 3 and 4 June 2015;

    (c)Copy of the submissions filed on behalf of Mr Zhang, 24 July 2015;

    (d)Copy of the relevant documents as contained within Exhibit A2 and comprising:

    (i)The checklist for advice regarding the Financial Agreement;

    (ii)The Financial Agreement;

    (iii)Correspondence between the attorneys for the parties (or either of them) and Mr Zhang;

    (iv)The draft Affidavit of Mr Zhang (noting that the Affidavit has not been sworn, Mr Zhang contests that it accurately reflects the evidence that he would have given, Mr Zhang denies that he has provided any information or instruction leading to the preparation of the Affidavit or its contents but noting the annexures thereto);

    (v)Copy of the file cover (both outside and in).

IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment under the pseudonym Lin & Han is approved pursuant to s.121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT PARRAMATTA

PAC 290 of 2014

MR LIN

Applicant

And

MS HAN

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. These reasons are delivered with respect to a discrete issue within the proceedings and which does not directly bear upon the substantive issue for determination.

  2. The substantive proceedings are between an Applicant, Mr Lin, and Respondent, Ms Han. Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lin and Han and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCCA 2395
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Judge Harman concerning a dispute involving Mr Lin and Mr Han. The proceedings involved an examination of the conduct and advice provided by a solicitor, Mr Zhang, in relation to a financial agreement. The court was required to consider whether to refer Mr Zhang's conduct to the Legal Services Commissioner of New South Wales.

The central legal issues before the court were whether Mr Zhang's evidence was reliable, whether he had acted competently and ethically in providing advice regarding the financial agreement, and whether his conduct warranted notification to the Legal Services Commissioner. Specifically, the court considered arguments raised by Mr Zhang against such notification, including claims that an adverse view was formed prematurely, that he was not afforded counsel, that he did not require an interpreter, that parties did not formally cross-examine him, that a Lawcover notification request was made prematurely, that he was unwell, and that his actions were out of character.

Judge Harman found Mr Zhang's evidence to be internally inconsistent, implausible, and difficult to follow, leading the court to be unable to accept it as reliable. The court rejected Mr Zhang's submissions against notification to the Legal Services Commissioner, finding that a "notifiable event" arose when the proceedings commenced and that Mr Zhang should have notified Lawcover much earlier. The court expressed concerns not about Mr Zhang's ethics, but about his competence and fitness to provide advice in family law matters, based on his evidence regarding his practices, failure to keep file notes, issue receipts, and his comprehension of confidentiality duties.

Consequently, Judge Harman ordered that the Registrar of the Court forward to the Legal Services Commissioner of New South Wales copies of the reasons for judgment, the transcript of Mr Zhang's evidence, his submissions, and relevant documents from Exhibit A2, including the financial agreement checklist, the financial agreement itself, correspondence, and a draft affidavit.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

I request that the Registrar of the Court forward to the Legal Services Commissioner of New South Wales a copy of each of the following:

(a) These reasons;

(b) Transcript of the evidence of Mr Zhang, solicitor, 3 and 4 June 2015;

(c) Copy of the submissions filed on behalf of Mr Zhang, 24 July 2015;

(d) Copy of the relevant documents as contained within Exhibit A2 and comprising:

(i) The checklist for advice regarding the Financial Agreement;

(ii) The Financial Agreement;

(iii) Correspondence between the attorneys for the parties (or either of them) and Mr Zhang;

(iv) The draft Affidavit of Mr Zhang (noting that the Affidavit has not been sworn, Mr Zhang contests that it accurately reflects the evidence that he would have given, Mr Zhang denies that he has provided any information or instruction leading to the preparation of the Affidavit or its contents but noting the annexures thereto);

(v) Copy of the file cover (both outside and in).

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Lin and Han revolves around a dispute concerning the conduct and practices of Mr Zhang, a legal practitioner. Mr Zhang was involved in the drafting and advice surrounding a Binding Financial Agreement (BFA) between Mr Lin and Ms Han. Mr Zhang's conduct and the reliability of his evidence became central issues in the proceedings. Mr Zhang failed to produce subpoenaed material and provided internally inconsistent and implausible evidence. Despite being given ample opportunity, he did not seek to be represented by counsel and did not request an interpreter, even though he is a practising legal practitioner. Although not formally applied for, Mr Zhang was effectively called as a hostile witness by the Court, which deemed his evidence unreliable and a catalyst for the contested proceedings. Mr Zhang also did not notify his insurer of the proceedings despite the potential for a claim in negligence arising from the BFA. Various reasons were posited for why notification to the Legal Services Commissioner should not occur, including Mr Zhang's prior adverse view, lack of counsel, absence of an interpreter, and failure to formally apply to cross-examine him. The Court concluded that notification should have been made by Mr Zhang upon being served with a subpoena. Despite claims that Mr Zhang was feeling unwell or that his actions were out of character, the Court found no evidence to support these claims, focusing instead on his competence and fitness to provide family law advice.

This case, Lin and Han, originated as a family law matter concerning a Binding Financial Agreement. The initial proceedings were heard in the Family Court of Australia, where Mr Zhang, a solicitor, was subpoenaed to provide evidence regarding the creation and contents of the agreement. The proceedings then moved to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on appeal, where Mr Zhang's conduct and competency in handling the case came under scrutiny. Notably, Mr Zhang's failure to produce subpoenaed material and the inconsistencies in his testimony raised significant concerns. The matter was subsequently referred to the Legal Services Commissioner of New South Wales for a potential disciplinary action. Prior to this referral, Mr Zhang had the opportunity to notify his insurer, Lawcover, of the proceedings, but he did not do so, despite multiple chances to rectify this oversight. The Federal Circuit Court found Mr Zhang's conduct to be problematic and made an order for relevant documents and reasons to be forwarded to the Legal Services Commissioner for further investigation.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At paragraph 91 of the submissions filed on behalf of Mr Zhang, the following reasons are advanced for why notification or referral to the Legal Services Commissioner should not occur. I will address each individually:a)An adverse view of Mr Zhang was formed prior to his giving evidence and prior to either party being cross-examinedAn adverse view of Mr Zhang arose from his inability to produce material to the Court in response to a subpoena and, at the conclusion of his evidence, as a consequence of the internally inconsistent, implausible, and difficult to follow evidence given by him.b)Mr Zhang was not afforded counselAs indicated above, Mr Zhang had ample opportunity to instruct Counsel. Mr Zhang never sought to be represented even when this was raised.If Mr Zhang had followed even the most rudimentary requirement of his insurance cover notification would have been made by him when he first became aware of these proceedings and that alleged within the proceedings as to a suggested lack of or inadequate advice. That is when the “notifiable circumstance” first arose. If that had occurred, Counsel may have been provided for Mr Zhang by his insurer.c)Mr Zhang did not have the benefit of an interpreterAs a practising legal practitioner, I would not expect that Mr Zhang would require an interpreter. No Application was made by Mr Zhang at any time for an interpreter to be provided, nor did he seek to make arrangements to bring an interpreter with him, it being his expense and obligation in the circumstances.d)There was no application by the parties to cross-examine Mr ZhangAs indicated above, the evidence of Mr Zhang is fundamental to these proceedings. After Mr Zhang’s evidence I was unable to accept his evidence as reliable. The non-acceptance of Mr Zhang’s evidence, without the need for any challenge to the evidence of either of the parties themselves, has been sufficient to now engage these parties in contested Part VIII proceedings. I am not concerned that an Application was not expressly made by Counsel for either party to cross-examine Mr Zhang. Mr Zhang had been subpoenaed by each. Mr Zhang was, in effect, called as the Court’s witness and his compulsion to testify by his former client, the husband, clearly made him a witness adverse to the husband’s case and “hostile”.e)A request for Lawcover notification was made prior to Mr Zhang giving evidenceI do not understand the basis upon which this is suggested to be a reason why notification should not be made. Clearly a “notifiable event” arose when and as a consequence of these proceedings being commenced in April 2014. It is at that time and upon material being forwarded to Mr Zhang (which occurred no later than 22 April 2014), that a notification should have been made by Mr Zhang. The occurrence of a “notifiable event” does not determine a claim (nor does the identification of the need for that notification to be made). It simply acknowledges the existence of circumstances which may be argued to constitute a basis for relief.In the event that either of these parties wishes to pursue a claim in negligence for loss that they allege that they have suffered as a consequence of the Binding Financial Agreement, the integrity of which has been called into question, a notification to Lawcover is something of a prerequisite. It is extraordinary that Mr Zhang would not have made such a notification at least 14 months prior to his giving evidence. The notification should have been made, at the latest, when Mr Zhang was served with a subpoena to give evidence in the proceedings.f)Mr Zhang expressed he was feeling unwellI note that the submission purports to place before the Court certain things that were “quite possible”. There is no evidence that Mr Zhang was at all hypoglycaemic or confused at the time of his giving evidence. He certainly did not deal with or address cross-examination well and, for whatever reason. I do not accept there is any evidence to suggest the reason was medical.g)It is out of character for Mr Zhang to do anything unethicalThe Court does not suggest that Mr Zhang has been “unethical”. The concerns raised by the Court are as to Mr Zhang’s competence and fitness to provide advice in family law matters. That concern arises from Mr Zhang’s evidence as to the practices adopted by him in this case. That is compounded by Mr Zhang’s failure to keep file notes (if they were made), issue appropriate receipts or comprehend or understand his duty of confidentiality to Mr Lin.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether an adverse view of Mr Zhang was appropriately formed prior to his giving evidence and before either party was cross-examined.
2. Whether Mr Zhang was adequately afforded counsel in the proceedings.
3. Whether Mr Zhang had the benefit of an interpreter, and if not, whether this omission is significant.
4. Whether the absence of an application to cross-examine Mr Zhang by the parties should preclude notification to the Legal Services Commissioner.
5. Whether a request for Lawcover notification should have been made prior to Mr Zhang giving evidence.
6. Whether there is sufficient evidence to suggest Mr Zhang was feeling unwell during his testimony, and if so, whether this impacted the reliability of his evidence.
7. Whether it is out of character for Mr Zhang to act unethically, and if so, how this relates to his competence and fitness to provide advice in family law matters.

Held
1. Whether an adverse view of Mr Zhang was appropriately formed prior to his giving evidence and before either party was cross-examined: The court concluded that an adverse view of Mr Zhang was appropriately formed based on his inability to produce subpoenaed material and his internally inconsistent, implausible, and difficult to follow evidence.
2. Whether Mr Zhang was adequately afforded counsel: The court concluded that Mr Zhang was not adequately afforded counsel as he had ample opportunity to instruct counsel but never sought to be represented.
3. Whether Mr Zhang had the benefit of an interpreter, and if not, whether this omission is significant: The court concluded that it was not expected that Mr Zhang required an interpreter and there was no application made by Mr Zhang for an interpreter.
4. Whether the absence of an application to cross-examine Mr Zhang by the parties should preclude notification to the Legal Services Commissioner: The court concluded that the absence of an application to cross-examine Mr Zhang should not preclude notification to the Legal Services Commissioner as Mr Zhang was, in effect, called as the Court’s witness.
5. Whether a request for Lawcover notification should have been made prior to Mr Zhang giving evidence: The court concluded that a request for Lawcover notification should have been made by Mr Zhang prior to his giving evidence.
6. Whether there is sufficient evidence to suggest Mr Zhang was feeling unwell during his testimony, and if so, whether this impacted the reliability of his evidence: The court concluded that there is no evidence to suggest that Mr Zhang was feeling unwell during his testimony and therefore it did not impact the reliability of his evidence.
7. Whether it is out of character for Mr Zhang to act unethically, and if so, how this relates to his competence and fitness to provide advice in family law matters: The court concluded that while it is out of character for Mr Zhang to act unethically, concerns remain about his competence and fitness to provide advice in family law matters.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court’s reasoning in Lin and Han centred on the need to evaluate whether Mr Zhang’s conduct warranted a referral to the Legal Services Commissioner. The decision involved a multifaceted analysis of several issues, each addressing a distinct aspect of Mr Zhang's professional conduct and the implications for the legal proceedings. Firstly, the court examined whether an adverse view of Mr Zhang was appropriately formed prior to his giving evidence. This assessment was based on Mr Zhang’s inability to produce subpoenaed material and the subsequent internally inconsistent and implausible testimony he provided. The court found that Mr Zhang's failure to produce documents and his unreliable testimony justified the adverse view. This conclusion was grounded in the principle that the court must consider the credibility and reliability of a witness's evidence, which in this case was significantly undermined by Mr Zhang’s actions and statements.

Secondly, the court deliberated on whether Mr Zhang was adequately afforded counsel. The court noted that Mr Zhang had multiple opportunities to instruct counsel but chose not to do so, even when the matter was explicitly raised. This decision to proceed without counsel, despite the potential for insurance coverage, was scrutinized against the backdrop of the necessity for legal representation in complex proceedings. The court reasoned that Mr Zhang’s decision to act pro se did not negate the necessity for adherence to legal protocols, such as timely notification to his insurer.

Thirdly, the court addressed the issue of whether Mr Zhang had the benefit of an interpreter. Given Mr Zhang’s status as a practising legal practitioner, the court did not expect him to require an interpreter. Additionally, no application for an interpreter was made by Mr Zhang, either through the court or on his own initiative. The court concluded that the absence of an interpreter was not a significant omission, as Mr Zhang was expected to understand and communicate effectively in the language of the court.

The court then considered whether the absence of an application to cross-examine Mr Zhang by the parties should preclude notification to the Legal Services Commissioner. The court found that Mr Zhang was effectively a hostile witness due to his subpoena by his former client, and the court’s inability to accept his evidence as reliable obviated the need for formal cross-examination. The court emphasized that the integrity of the proceedings was not compromised by the lack of an application to cross-examine Mr Zhang, as his evidence alone was sufficient to warrant a referral.

Further, the court examined whether a request for Lawcover notification should have been made prior to Mr Zhang giving evidence. The court concluded that a notification should have been made by Mr Zhang when he became aware of the proceedings and the alleged lack of adequate advice. The failure to notify Lawcover at the appropriate time was viewed as a critical oversight, impacting the potential for timely legal representation and insurance coverage.

The court also evaluated whether there was sufficient evidence to suggest Mr Zhang was feeling unwell during his testimony, and if so, whether this impacted the reliability of his evidence. The court found no evidence to support the claim that Mr Zhang was hypoglycaemic or confused, and it rejected the notion that any medical condition affected his ability to provide reliable testimony.

Finally, the court considered whether it is out of character for Mr Zhang to act unethically, and how this relates to his competence and fitness to provide advice in family law matters. The court did not find that Mr Zhang had acted unethically but raised concerns about his competence and fitness, based on his evidence and the failure to maintain proper file notes, issue appropriate receipts, and understand his duty of confidentiality. The court’s decision to refer Mr Zhang’s conduct to the Legal Services Commissioner was premised on these concerns, highlighting the importance of maintaining professional standards in family law practice.