Lilly v Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Lilly v Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Limited [2004] NSW WCC PD 62

APPELLANT:  Eric Norman Lilly

RESPONDENT:  Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Limited

INSURER:QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd

FILE NUMBER:  WCC10880-03

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          16 March 2004

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  2 September 2004

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Appeal Against an award of expenses under Section 60 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. Leave Threshold in section 352 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. Error of law.

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Dr Gabriel Fleming

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:  Bale Boshev Lawyers

Respondent:  Moray &Agnew Solicitors

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  The decision of the Arbitrator is confirmed.

CONTENTS

THE APPEAL  PARAGRAPHS 1 – 5
ISSUES IN DISPUTE  PARAGRAPHS 6 - 8
LEAVE  PARAGRAPHS 9 - 17
EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS  PARAGRAPHS 18 - 33
DISCUSSION AND FINDINGS  PARAGRAPHS 34 - 53
DECISION  PARAGRAPH 54

THE APPEAL

  1. On 13 April 2004 Eric Lilly (‘the Appellant/Mr Lilly’) sought leave to bring an ‘Appeal Against Decision of Arbitrator’ in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) against a decision, dated 16 March 2004.

  1. The Respondent to the Appeal is Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Limited (‘the Respondent Employer’).

  1. The appeal concerns a claim by Mr Lilly for medical expenses associated with an injury to his right knee. The Arbitrator made an award in favour of the Respondent in respect of Mr Lilly’s claim for medical and related expenses under section 60 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (‘the 1987 Act’).

  1. The appeal was referred to me for review on 10 August 2004.

  1. I am satisfied that I have sufficient information to proceed ‘on the papers’, pursuant to Section 354(6) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (‘the 1998 Act’) without holding any conference or formal hearing, and that this is the appropriate course in the circumstances.

ISSUES IN DISPUTE

  1. The first issue in dispute is whether or not the Appellant can meet the threshold test for leave to appeal. 

  1. The second issue is whether or not the Arbitrator erred in the application of section 9A of the 1987 Act and in finding that Mr Lilly’s employment was not a ‘substantial contributing factor’ to his injury. 

  1. The Respondent argues that leave should be refused and that the Arbitrator’s decision should be confirmed.

LEAVE

  1. Before proceeding to hear the appeal the Commission must determine whether the application meets the requirements of section 352 of the 1998 Act, which provides as follows:

    “352Appeal against decision of Commission constituted by Arbitrator

    (1)     A party to a dispute in connection with a claim for compensation may, with leave of the Commission constituted by a Presidential member, appeal to the Commission as so constituted against a decision in respect of the dispute by the Commission constituted by an Arbitrator.

    (2)     The Commission is not to grant leave to appeal unless the amount of compensation at issue on the appeal is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lilly v Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWWCCPD 62
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lilly filed an appeal against Tomago Aluminium Company Pty Limited regarding a compensation claim. The dispute centred on the eligibility of the appeal under section 352 of the 1998 Act, specifically whether the claim met the threshold requirements for compensation and the timeline for the appeal. The Commission had to decide whether the appeal was within the 28-day limit as per subsection 352(4) and whether the compensation amount met the threshold criteria under subsection 352(2).

The central legal issues revolved around the interpretation of section 352(2)(a) and (b) of the 1998 Act. The Appellant argued that the potential cost of future surgery would meet the $5,000 threshold, despite the absence of a definitive figure at the time of the appeal. Conversely, the Respondent contended that without evidence of the cost of future surgery, the claim remained at $280, which was insufficient to meet the statutory threshold. The Court also had to consider whether the appeal was lodged within the stipulated 28-day period.

The Court determined that the appeal was indeed lodged within the 28-day limit, complying with subsection 352(4). However, as no compensation was awarded in the decision appealed against, section 352(2)(b) was not applicable. Regarding section 352(2)(a), the Court found that there was no evidence of the cost of future surgery at the time of the appeal. Consequently, the claim remained at $280, which did not meet the $5,000 threshold. The Court concluded that leave to appeal should be refused due to the insufficient evidence of the future surgery costs and the inadequate compensation amount.

The Court ordered that leave to appeal be refused, and the reasons for the refusal were to be stated in writing to the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Before proceeding to hear the appeal the Commission must determine whether the application meets the requirements of section 352 of the 1998 Act, which provides as follows:“352Appeal against decision of Commission constituted by Arbitrator(1) A party to a dispute in connection with a claim for compensation may, with leave of the Commission constituted by a Presidential member, appeal to the Commission as so constituted against a decision in respect of the dispute by the Commission constituted by an Arbitrator.(2) The Commission is not to grant leave to appeal unless the amount of compensation at issue on the appeal is both:(a)at least $5,000 (or such other amount as may be prescribed by the regulations), and(b)at least 20% of the amount awarded in the decision appealed against.(3) If the Commission refuses to grant leave to appeal, the Commission must state reasons for the refusal in writing to the parties.(4) An appeal can only be made within 28 days after the making of the decision appealed against.(5) An appeal under this section is to be by way of review of the decision appealed against.(6) Evidence that is fresh evidence or evidence in addition to or in substitution for the evidence received in relation to the decision appealed against may not be given on an appeal to the Commission except with the leave of the Commission.(7) On appeal, the decision may be confirmed or may be revoked and a new decision made in its place.Alternatively, the matter may be remitted back to the Arbitrator concerned, or to another Arbitrator, for determination in accordance with any decision or directions of the Commission.(8) In this section, decision includes an award, interim award, order, determination, ruling and direction.” The Appeal was lodged within 28 days of the Arbitrator’s decision in compliance with subsection 352(4) of the 1998 Act. No amount was awarded in the decision appealed against and therefore section 352(2)(b) of the 1998 Act has no application (Mawson v Fletchers International Exports Pty Limited [2002] NSW WCC PD 5). The claim that was made to the Employer, and was before the Arbitrator, was for “$280.00 to date and continuing”. The Appellant submits that the threshold of $5,000, in section 352(2)(a) is met because:“A specific or general order in relation to proposed surgery was sought. The particulars as to that expense are outstanding. A letter of 24 October 2003 requesting report from Dr Berton was admitted into evidence pursuant to Directions made at teleconference on 15 December 2003. Dr Berton has not provided an opinion as to the cost of the Total Knee Replacement.It is submitted the cost of the Total Knee Replacement would be at least $5,000 including surgeon, anaesthetic, prosthetic, hospital and ancillary expenses.” The Respondent submits leave to appeal should be refused because there was no evidence before the Arbitrator of the cost of future surgery, nor any commitment to surgery actually being undertaken. This leaves the amount of the claim at $280, considerably less than the $5,000 threshold required by section 352(2)(a) of the 1998 Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established