SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
LIFEPLAN AUSTRALIA FRIENDLY SOCIETY LTD & ANOR v FORESTERS FRIENDLY SOCIETY LTD
[2012] SASC 173
Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court
25 September 2012
PROCEDURE
Rule 32 – pre-action disclosure – order by consent – alleged inadequate disclosure made – application under r 32(3) to cross-examine deponent to affidavits of disclosure – held cross-examination under sub-r (3) only to be ordered in furtherance of obtaining disclosure permitted by sub-r (1) and not merely because order not fully complied with – plaintiffs had not shown that documents not disclosed might provide information to satisfy sub-paragraphs (1)(a), (b), and (c) – application refused.
LIFEPLAN AUSTRALIA FRIENDLY SOCIETY LTD & ANOR v FORESTERS FRIENDLY SOCIETY LTD
[2012] SASC 173JUDGE LUNN:
Reasons on plaintiffs’ application to cross-examine on the defendant’s affidavits of documents
The plaintiffs have brought this action under r 32 for pre-action disclosure of documents against the defendant. On 10 August 2012 I made an order by consent (“the Order”) that the defendant disclose documents in various categories. Kerry Hughes, the Chief Executive of the defendant, has filed three affidavits (FDN5, FDN11 and FDN13) in purported compliance with the Order. There has been considerable correspondence from the plaintiffs’ solicitors to the defendant’s solicitors complaining that the defendant’s disclosure under the Order has been inadequate and incomplete.
By paragraph 4 of an application taken out on 26 July 2012 the plaintiffs sought an order under r 32(3) that Kerry Hughes be cross-examined on his affidavits[1]. The defendant opposes this application.
[1] Because the disclosure order was made by consent, FDN5 and FDN7 were filed before the consent order was made.
As far as I am aware no order has ever been made for cross-examination under r 32(3) and there is no authority on when such cross-examination will be ordered. Counsel for the plaintiffs and the defendant respectively advocated very different approaches on whether such an order should be made. The plaintiffs contended, in effect, that, if they showed that there had been significant non‑compliance with the Order, and/or the defendant had not had proper regard to its obligations to make disclosure under the Order, the Court should order the cross-examination as sought. The defendant’s counsel contended that the plaintiffs had to show more, and, in particular, that such cross‑examination was necessary to fulfil the purposes of r 32(1). For the reasons which follow I accept these contentions of the defendant. This is sufficient to dispose of the present application. It is not necessary for me to canvass the extensive arguments of the plaintiffs’ counsel about the many respects in which the plaintiffs allege that the defendant’s disclosure did not fully comply with the Order.
The relevant parts of r 32 provide:
32—Investigation
(1)If the Court is satisfied, on application by a person (the plaintiff) that the plaintiff may have a good cause of action and requires further information—
(a)to determine whether a cause of action exists; or
(b)to formulate the claim…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lifeplan Australia Friendly Society Ltd v Foresters Friendly... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] SASC 173
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiffs had demonstrated that the non-disclosed documents might contain information that would satisfy the criteria set out in sub-paragraphs (1)(a), (b), and (c) of Rule 32. This sub-rule permits the court to order cross-examination of the deponent to affidavits of disclosure only if it is necessary to obtain disclosure as permitted by sub-rule (1). The court had to determine whether the plaintiffs' application was justified based on the potential information contained in the non-disclosed documents.
The court held that cross-examination under Rule 32(3) could only be ordered if it would assist in obtaining the disclosure permitted by sub-rule (1). The plaintiffs had not provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the non-disclosed documents might contain the necessary information. Consequently, the court found that the plaintiffs had not met the threshold required for such an order. As a result, the application was refused. The court's decision underscored the importance of meeting the specific criteria outlined in the rules before seeking such an order.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi