Lieschke and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

Lieschke and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) [2018] AATA 3787 (11 October 2018)

Division: GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/1856; 2016/2119

Re: Christopher Lieschke  

APPLICANT

And Telstra Corporation Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member A Ward

Member M O’Loughlin

Member D Ben-Tovim

Date:11 October 2018

Place:Adelaide

The decisions under review are set aside and in substitution it is decided that:

a)    The Applicant continues to suffer from the compensable injuries of ‘subarachnoid haemorrhage due to a ruptured left middle cerebral aneurysm’ and ‘anxiety and depression with mild cognitive changes’ which arose out of the course of his employment;

b)    In relation to application 2016/1856:

i.the Applicant is entitled to be reimbursed by the Respondent for the costs of pharmacy related expenses and occupational therapy services expenses incurred by him as a consequence of his injury pursuant to s 16 of the SRC Act;

c)    In relation to application 2016/2119:

i.the Applicant is entitled to be paid compensation by the Respondent for weekly incapacity payments, including arrears, from 23 December 2015 to the date of this order pursuant to s 19 of the SRC Act;

ii.Insofar as it does not lead to duplication of the orders made in relation to application 2016/1856, the Applicant is entitled to be reimbursed by the Respondent for the costs of medical treatment arising from the injury pursuant to s 16 of the SRC Act;

d)    The Respondent is to pay the Applicant’s legal costs and disbursements under s 67 of the SRC Act;

e)    The Tribunal requests further written submissions from the parties as to whether interest is payable on the unpaid income arrears as requested by the Applicant from 23 December 2015 to the date of this order, to be provided within 14 days of this order.

.........................[Sgnd].......................................

Member A Ward

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – Whether person requires ongoing treatment for compensable injury – Incapacity for work – Compensation for medical expenses – Intervening act – Psychological sequelae – Determinations under review set aside.

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998 (Cth)

CASES

Nicolas v Comcare [2007] AATA 1858
Koker v Comcare [2017] AATA 1432

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member A J Ward
Member M O'Loughlin
Member D Ben-Tovim

11 October 2018

  1. This is an application by Mr Christopher Lieschke seeking review of two determinations made by the Respondent: the first dated 4 December 2015 relating to the payment of diverse expenses; and the second dated 23 December 2015 relating to ongoing entitlements to receive compensation by way of weekly payments from 23 December 2015 onwards, and compensation for medical expenses. 

    History of Events

  2. Mr Lieschke suffered a subarachnoid haemorrhage whilst at work on 15 October 2009. He required emergency treatment and then rehabilitation as he recovered from the acute effects of the aneurysm and the surgery.

  3. He submitted a claim for compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998 (“the SRC Act”) and on 13 January 2010,[1] a representative of the Respondent (a “determining authority” for the purposes of s 60 of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lieschke and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 3787
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Christopher Lieschke against determinations made by Telstra Corporation Limited regarding his entitlement to compensation. The dispute centred on whether Mr Lieschke continued to suffer from the effects of a compensable injury, specifically a subarachnoid brain haemorrhage he sustained at work on 15 October 2009, and consequently, whether Telstra remained liable for ongoing compensation payments. The decision was made by Member A Ward.

The court was required to determine whether Mr Lieschke continued to suffer from the effects of his compensable injury at the time the previous determinations were made and up to the present. This involved assessing whether his incapacity for work and need for ongoing medical treatment were a direct consequence of the aneurysm, or if any intervening factors had broken the chain of causation. The court also had to consider Telstra's ongoing liability to pay compensation for medical expenses, excluding gym expenses, in light of these findings.

The court accepted Mr Lieschke's evidence as truthful and consistent, corroborated by his wife's testimony regarding his deterioration following the aneurysm. Relying on the histories provided to medical professionals over time, the court found that Mr Lieschke had continued to suffer from the effects of the compensable injury at the time of the previous determinations and continued to do so. Consequently, the court determined that Telstra's liability to pay compensation, with the exception of gym expenses, continued from the time of those determinations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, our Decision is that at the time those two determinations were made and to the present, the Applicant has continued to suffer from the effects of the compensable injury. In accordance with the various sections of the SRC Act, the Respondent’s liability to pay compensation, with the exception of gym expenses, continued from the time of those determinations.BACKGROUND FACTS AND KEY FINDINGS The Applicant suffered an aneurysm whilst at work on 15 October 2009. He provided a statement to augment his evidence,[9] and gave sworn evidence at the hearing.[9] Exhibit 13. As an overview we accept Mr Lieschke’s evidence as truthful. His report of symptoms and events has been consistent. He has been reported by doctors as being co-operative in medico legal referrals. There was no attack on his credibility. In any event his evidence was corroborated by his wife, Ms Narelle Leischke who gave evidence as well. It is noted they have now separated. Her evidence was very impressive as she set out her observations of his deterioration following the aneurysm. Thus we rely upon his histories given to the doctors over the course of these events as being accurate. Mr Lieschke was born on 14 October 1977 and had a difficult childhood. His mother died of a stroke. His father had significant difficulties with alcohol, and Mr Lieschke’s oral evidence was that his childhood was difficult and the household chaotic. These observations are supported by his wife. He met his wife at the age of 14, when they first became friends. He would spend a considerable amount of time at his wife’s house with her family. In contrast to his own family life, his wife’s family was described as relatively normal and stable. Mr Lieschke had a variety of jobs, having completed Year 11 at school. His father worked in various small businesses. The Applicant undertook training and worked as a cook for a period of time. He operated a taxi with his father from 1998 for some years. He then engaged in sales work with home loans and superannuation. He studied a Diploma of Financial Services. He worked for two years as a real estate salesman. He undertook work installing garage doors and erecting fencing. He employed other contractors in this work and then sold that business in 2006. As he progressed through the various employments, he would often be in the roles of marketing, sales and management and thus dealing with people. He also had other supervisory work with Ion Automotive. He commenced work with Telstra in October 2006. Shortly prior to that, he was selling wine. At Telstra, he took on the role of Acting Team Leader in May 2007 and then was promoted to permanent Team Leader in October 2009. Mr Lieschke found the role of Team Leader stressful, but also enjoyable. He managed 15 to 18 staff, which was a role he found challenging. It was while performing that role that he suffered a subarachnoid brain haemorrhage on 15 October 2009 and received emergency treatment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The following witnesses gave evidence during the hearing of the matter:1.1.The Applicant, Mr Christopher Lieschke;1.2.The Applicant’s wife, Ms Narelle Lieschke;1.3.Dr Ninda Sandhu, Consultant Radiologist;1.4.Dr Leslie Koopowitz, Neuropsychiatrist;1.5.Dr Emma Fitzgerald (nee Scamps), Neuropsychologist;1.6.Dr Bruce Rounsefell, Pain Medicine Specialist;1.7.Dr Tony Davis, Psychiatrist;1.8.Dr Richard Burns, Consultant Neurologist;1.9.Professor Richard Mattick, Psychologist; and1.10.Professor Brian Brophy, Neurosurgeon.THE DECISION For the reasons set out below, our Decision is that at the time those two determinations were made and to the present, the Applicant has continued to suffer from the effects of the compensable injury. In accordance with the various sections of the SRC Act, the Respondent’s liability to pay compensation, with the exception of gym expenses, continued from the time of those determinations.BACKGROUND FACTS AND KEY FINDINGS The Applicant suffered an aneurysm whilst at work on 15 October 2009. He provided a statement to augment his evidence,[9] and gave sworn evidence at the hearing.[9] Exhibit 13. As an overview we accept Mr Lieschke’s evidence as truthful. His report of symptoms and events has been consistent. He has been reported by doctors as being co-operative in medico legal referrals. There was no attack on his credibility. In any event his evidence was corroborated by his wife, Ms Narelle Leischke who gave evidence as well. It is noted they have now separated. Her evidence was very impressive as she set out her observations of his deterioration following the aneurysm. Thus we rely upon his histories given to the doctors over the course of these events as being accurate. Mr Lieschke was born on 14 October 1977 and had a difficult childhood. His mother died of a stroke. His father had significant difficulties with alcohol, and Mr Lieschke’s oral evidence was that his childhood was difficult and the household chaotic. These observations are supported by his wife. He met his wife at the age of 14, when they first became friends. He would spend a considerable amount of time at his wife’s house with her family. In contrast to his own family life, his wife’s family was described as relatively normal and stable. Mr Lieschke had a variety of jobs, having completed Year 11 at school. His father worked in various small businesses. The Applicant undertook training and worked as a cook for a period of time. He operated a taxi with his father from 1998 for some years. He then engaged in sales work with home loans and superannuation. He studied a Diploma of Financial Services. He worked for two years as a real estate salesman. He undertook work installing garage doors and erecting fencing. He employed other contractors in this work and then sold that business in 2006. As he progressed through the various employments, he would often be in the roles of marketing, sales and management and thus dealing with people. He also had other supervisory work with Ion Automotive. He commenced work with Telstra in October 2006. Shortly prior to that, he was selling wine. At Telstra, he took on the role of Acting Team Leader in May 2007 and then was promoted to permanent Team Leader in October 2009.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.