SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
No. 9140 of 2003
| LIBERTY FINANCIAL PTY. LTD. & ANOR | |
| Appellants | |
| v. | |
| SCOTT & ANOR | Respondents |
---
JUDGES: | ORMISTON and NETTLE, JJ.A. | |
WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE | |
DATES OF HEARING: | 28 October and 2 November 2005 | |
DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 16 November 2005 | |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2005] VSCA 263 | |
---
COURTS, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Pleading summons – Claims against former employee and new employer for breach of contract, breach of copyright, misuse of confidential information etc. – Substituted statement of claim struck out as likely to prejudice, embarrass or delay fair trial – Whether properly struck out partly because of provision of particulars by confusing use of schedule and three appendixes – Effect of “directions” and admonitions from judge as to specific claims though no defect directly relied on for making order – Leave to appeal refused.
---
| APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Appellants | Mr D.R. Meagher, Q.C. with | Dibbs Abbott Stillman |
| For the 1st Respondent | Mr A.J. Maryniak | Allens Arthur Robinson |
| For the 2nd Respondent | Mr R.C. Macaw, Q.C. with Mr S.M. Anderson | Freehills – Sydney |
ORMISTON, J.A.:
The applicant-plaintiffs in this proceeding have sought leave to appeal against an interlocutory order obtained by the respondent-defendants striking out what has been called the “substituted statement of claim” (“the SSC”) dated 19 April 2005 and whereby leave was granted to file and serve a “third substituted statement of claim”, though the respondents would assert that it will be either the eighth or ninth amended statement of claim. The reasons for this order appear in a lengthy and comprehensive judgment delivered by Harper, J. on 13 September 2005: [2005] VSC 363. The principal vice in the SSC found by his Honour was that, by reason of the defects in its form described by him in elaborate detail, the SSC “may prejudice, embarrass or delay the fair trial of the proceeding”: [143]. Thus, of the several bases in rules 23.01 and 23.02 of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules relied upon in the two summonses issued by the respondents, only para.(b) of rule 23.02 was ultimately called in aid by the judge, albeit that some of the applicants’ claims had been challenged on the basis that they should be struck out as not disclosing a cause of action. In fact none of those specific paragraphs were struck out and some of the arguments as to insufficiency were adjourned over to another day. Nevertheless his Honour followed his stated conclusion with two paragraphs [144] and [145] containing a series of admonitions to the plaintiffs as to what might properly be pleaded in respect of what he had just described as “undoubtedly good causes of action”. In those paragraphs the judge advised, for example, that the claim in contract “must be confined to those breaches of contract upon which the plaintiffs based their contractual claims”, that “they should eschew reference to terms, and more especially contracts, that merely duplicate other terms…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Liberty Financial Pty Ltd & Anor v Scott & Anor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] VSCA 263
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the substituted statement of claim, noting that it was accompanied by a confusing schedule and three appendixes, which it found to be a contributing factor to the potential for prejudice, embarrassment, or delay in the trial. Despite the defendants not directly relying on this confusion as a ground for striking out the claims, the court considered it alongside the overall presentation of the claims. The court also took into account the previous "directions" and admonitions given by the judge regarding the specific claims, which influenced the court's decision. Ultimately, the court determined that the substituted statement of claim was likely to prejudice, embarrass, or delay a fair trial, and thus struck it out. The plaintiffs' application for leave to appeal was subsequently refused.
In summary, the court held that the substituted statement of claim was properly struck out due to its confusing structure and the likelihood that it would prejudice, embarrass, or delay a fair trial. The court's decision was influenced by the judge's previous directions and admonitions, as well as the overall presentation of the claims. The plaintiffs' application for leave to appeal was dismissed, affirming the court's decision.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case has its origins in proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Liberty Financial initiated legal action against Mr. Scott and his new employer, Anor, by filing a statement of claim. The defendants responded by seeking to have the statement of claim struck out on the grounds of potential prejudice, embarrassment, or delay in a fair trial. The trial judge, after considering the matter, struck out the original statement of claim and directed Liberty Financial to provide a substituted statement with particulars. Despite receiving these directions and admonitions, Liberty Financial's attempt to file an amended statement of claim was again struck out by the trial judge. Liberty Financial then appealed to the New South Wales Court of Appeal, which ultimately dismissed the appeal and refused leave to appeal to a higher court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the trial judge was correct in striking out the plaintiff's statement of claim as likely to prejudice, embarrass, or delay a fair trial.
2. Whether the provision of particulars by the plaintiff, through the use of a schedule and three appendixes, contributed to the confusion that led to the striking out of the statement of claim.
3. To what extent the judge's "directions" and admonitions regarding specific claims influenced the decision to strike out the statement of claim, despite no direct defect being relied upon for making the order.
Held
1. The court held that the trial judge was correct in striking out the plaintiff's statement of claim as likely to prejudice, embarrass, or delay a fair trial. The appeal against this decision was dismissed.
2. The court found that the provision of particulars by the plaintiff, through the use of a schedule and three appendixes, did contribute to the confusion that led to the striking out of the statement of claim.
3. The court determined that the judge's "directions" and admonitions regarding specific claims did influence the decision to strike out the statement of claim, despite no direct defect being relied upon for making the order.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the procedural history of the case and the content of the plaintiff's statement of claim, which was extensive and complex, involving multiple claims against former and new employers. The trial judge's decision to strike out the statement of claim was based on the view that the claim was confusing, and thus likely to prejudice, embarrass, or delay a fair trial. The appellate court agreed with the trial judge, affirming the decision to dismiss the appeal. The appellate court also noted that the plaintiff's use of a schedule and three appendixes to provide particulars added to the confusion, making the case more complex and less accessible to the court. This contributed to the trial judge's decision to strike out the statement of claim. Additionally, the court considered the judge's "directions" and admonitions, which, although not directly relied upon as grounds for striking out the claim, influenced the overall decision. The court found that these factors combined justified the trial judge's decision. The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a statement of claim is overly complex and confusing, and where the provision of particulars exacerbates this confusion, a court may properly strike out the claim to ensure a fair trial, even in the absence of a direct defect in the pleading.