Li Shan and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

[2014] AATA  278

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Numbers

2012/4298; 2012/5484;2013/1185;2013/2813;2013/2814

Re

 Li Shan

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member 
Dr M Couch, Member

Date 8 May 2014
Place

Sydney

Decision:         The Tribunal affirms each decision under review.

Costs may not be awarded.

..........................[sgd]......................................

Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member

Catchwords

Compensation – Applicant claims incident with heavy tray of mail at work in August 2010 caused right shoulder cuff tear - Compensated for right shoulder cuff tear – Applicant at the Tribunal for liability to be accepted for left shoulder cuff tear – Applicant’s evidence that she used the left arm more at home and at work because of pain on the right - At hearing results of an ultrasound taken in July 2010 approximately three weeks before the alleged incident at work shows the right shoulder cuff tear – further applications for compensation in relation to work hours  – decisions under review affirmed.

Legislation

Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 5A, 5B, 6, 14, 19

Cases

Telstra Corporation v Hannaford [2006] FCAFC 87
Comcare v Lofts [2013] FCA 1197

REASONS FOR DECISION

8 May 2014

SUMMARY

  1. Ms Li is fifty years old, and after completing school in China and undertaking clerical work there, she came to Australia in 1987. Ms Li joined Australia Post (the Respondent in these proceedings), as a mail officer in 1999. Her main duties were as a video coder and working at the Bar Code Sorting (BCS) machine.

  2. Ms Li says that on 9 August 2010, while working at the BCS machine, she pulled down a heavy upper tray from the mail rack, and felt a sharp pain in her right shoulder and arm. Australia Post accepted liability for a right shoulder cuff tear. Ms Li has undergone surgery for her right shoulder, and had time off for that. Liability was also accepted for further surgery as Ms Li developed adhesive capsulitis following the first operation.

  3. Ms Li has not worked at the BCS machine since 9 August 2010. She has had a graduated return to work commencing in September 2010, and has been on light duties since. At the time of the hearing, she had been working fulltime performing the designated light duties since May 2013.

  4. The matter before us concerns a claim for a left shoulder cuff tear which Ms Li says occurred because she used her left arm more after experiencing the tear, and subsequent pain in her right shoulder.

  5. We found problems with Ms Li’s credit. We are mindful that she told various versions of how her left shoulder, which has been found to have a similar tear to the right shoulder, occurred. To some doctors, she stated that she felt pain in her left shoulder from approximately 2011 because she was using the left shoulder more at home and at work due to the pain in her right shoulder. To others, Ms Li alleged that in May 2012,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Li Shan and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 278
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Li Shan brought an action against the Australian Postal Corporation in the Federal Circuit Court, alleging that she suffered a left shoulder tear and other injuries while working as a mail officer. The case involved five applications, primarily concerning the alleged left shoulder tear and the hours spent on return to work plans. The legal issues before the court involved the credibility of Ms Li's claims, the nature and origin of her injuries, and the impact of her injuries on her ability to work. The court was required to determine whether Ms Li's alleged left shoulder tear occurred as a result of her employment, and whether her claims regarding the severity and impact of her injuries were substantiated.

The court found that there were significant credibility issues with Ms Li's evidence. The court accepted that she had suffered a right shoulder supraspinatus tear approximately three weeks before reporting an injury on 9 August 2010. Ms Li had not disclosed this prior injury to her treating doctors or in her statements to the Tribunal. The court also found that Ms Li had relied on untruths and inconsistencies in her evidence, and that her oral evidence was unconvincing. The court noted that four of the specialists who examined Ms Li for medico-legal purposes concluded that the underlying pathology of her shoulder injuries was primarily of a constitutional nature, and associated with degenerative changes. The court accepted that Ms Li may have suffered pain in her left shoulder as a result of using it more because of the pain in her right shoulder.

The court affirmed the five decisions under review, finding that there was no evidence to support Ms Li's claims of a left shoulder tear or of significant work-related injuries. The court concluded that it was unlikely that Ms Li suffered structural damage to her left shoulder at work at any time. The court found that Ms Li had benefited from substantial compensation payments and had been on light duties since her reported injury, with no duties requiring her to reach above shoulder height or to lift weights above five kilograms. The court also noted that Ms Li had not disclosed prior shoulder problems to any doctors and had instead told doctors she had muscle pain. The court found that none of the doctors had recorded said muscle pain.

In conclusion, the court dismissed Ms Li's claims and affirmed the decisions under review. The court found that there were serious credibility issues with Ms Li's evidence and that her claims of a left shoulder tear and significant work-related injuries were not substantiated. The court accepted that Ms Li may have suffered pain in her left shoulder as a result of using it more because of the pain in her right shoulder, but found that there was no evidence to support her claims of structural damage to her left shoulder at work. The court did not award costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There were five applications before the Tribunal, one dealing with the alleged left shoulder tear, (2012/4298), and the others in connection with hours spent on return to work plans.THE APPLICANT’S EVIDENCE Ms Li gave evidence before the Tribunal. She is reasonably fluent in English, but she says she has some difficulties with the language, particularly with medical terms. Ms Li told us that she has worked as a mail officer with Australia Post since 1999, and was, prior to 9 August 2010, doing mainly video coding five days a week, working seven hours and 21 minutes a day. She described the work as sitting in front of a computer screen, reading documents, and using her right hand to enter a postcode. She is right handed, and she uses a mouse. Ms Li also worked the BCS machine. She told us that the duties at the BCS machine involved lifting and moving heavy trays with envelopes containing mail. Those trays generally weighed no more than eight kilograms, but if larger and thicker letters were involved, they weighed up to 12 kilograms. She told us that the highest tray was above her head, the second at approximately shoulder height, and that the lowest was at about hip height. However, Ms Li’s evidence was inconsistent. In her written statement dated 11 March 2013, (Exhibit A2), Ms Li stated that prior to her injuries, she did video coding for an average of half her regular hours, and did the BCS machine work for the rest of the time. In her oral evidence, Ms Li told us that prior to 9 August 2010 and acceptance of liability for the supraspinatus tear to her right shoulder, if there was no video coding work, she would work the BCS machine, sorting magazine bundles or opening large Express Post bags. This required her having to lift the bundles and bags. She said that she performed the latter duties for a short time on each occasion. In her oral evidence, Ms Li sought to correct the history Dr McGill had recorded of her work at the BCS machine. Dr McGill had recorded on 2 July 2012, the day he examined and interviewed Ms Li, that she worked the BCS machine for relatively small amounts of time. Ms Li said that she told Dr McGill she worked the BCS machine for a couple of hours every day. Ms Li recounted how on 9 August 2010, when on the BCS machine, she pulled a heavy upper tray from the rack, using her right shoulder and arm, and felt pain in her shoulder. She stated that she informed a colleague that she had hurt her right shoulder, and that the fingers of her right hand were swollen. She was directed to the first aid room where an ice pack was applied. Ms Li said that she was referred to see the Australia Post doctor, Dr D Saad on that day. Also on 9 August 2010, Ms Li filled out a form recording the incident (Exhibit R1/T3). Ms Li said that she consulted Dr Saad again after a few days, and was referred for further investigations, including to Dr J Trantalis, an orthopaedic surgeon. It is not in dispute that Australia Post accepted liability for the events of 9 August 2010, and that Ms Li underwent a right rotator cuff repair carried out by Dr Trantalis on 26 October 2010. She had three months off work, had physiotherapy, and was directed to do exercises at home. Ms Li told us that because of the pain in her right shoulder, she had to do a lot of things at home, and at work with her left arm. She said that Dr Saad told her she had developed post-surgery frozen shoulder (adhesive capsulitis).

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the sake of completeness we note that in recent times Ms Li has suffered pain down her arms, and pins and needles in her legs, and has undergone major neck surgery, being C3 – C7 laminectomy with a lateral mass fusion. She does not claim that her problems with her neck, knee and back are work related.DECISION The Tribunal affirms each of the five decisions under review. Costs may not be awarded.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

We conclude from the evidence of both doctors that it was unlikely Ms Li suffered structural damage to her left shoulder at work at any time. However we accept that she may have suffered pain in her left shoulder as a result of using it more because of the pain to her right shoulder.THE TRIBUNAL’S DELIBERATIONS We are satisfied that there are serious issues of credit in regard to the Applicant. These commence with the reporting of an incident in which Ms Li claims she injured her right shoulder at work at Australia Post on 9 August 2010, when in fact she had been diagnosed with a right shoulder supraspinatus tear approximately three weeks beforehand. We were also concerned about the subsequent reliance on untruths, both by Ms Li and her legal team. Ms Li reported that on 9 August 2010 the trays for the BCS machine were heavier than usual, that she pulled out a tray from the top level which was above her head height, and that she accordingly injured her right shoulder. Liability for the right shoulder cuff tear was accepted by the Respondent on the basis that Ms Li described. As noted above, Ms Li then underwent surgery for the right supraspinatus tear on 26 October 2010, followed by further surgery to deal with adhesive capsulitis on 8 March 2012. Due to the acceptance of liability by Australia Post, Ms Li has benefited from substantial compensation payments, and has been on light duties, with no duties requiring her to reach above shoulder height since 9 August 2010, or to lift weights above five kgs. We noted that Ms Li did not disclose to her treating surgeon, Dr Trantalis, or to Dr Mastroianni that she had consulted Dr Ng in 2009 for a painful right shoulder, and that she had been diagnosed by ultrasound on 20 July 2010, only approximately three weeks before the incident on 9 August 2010, with a 20mm full thickness right shoulder supraspinatus tear. Further, Ms Li did not disclose the tear diagnosed on 20 July 2010 in her statements to the Tribunal. Her oral evidence, in reply to questions from Mr Jones was unconvincing, and included attempts to rely on problems with English to explain she did not understand what a tear was. Mr Jones submitted that Ms Li had not disclosed prior shoulder problems to any doctors, and stated in her oral evidence by way of explanation that she had instead told doctors she had muscle pain. He noted that none of the doctors had recorded said muscle pain. We have noted above that four of the many specialists who examined Ms Li for medico-legal purposes gave evidence at the Tribunal. A summary of the reports of Drs McGill, Bodel, Gray and Pillemer appears in the paragraphs above. Each of the reports was prepared without the knowledge that the diagnosis of the right shoulder tear predated the alleged work injury. When the doctors gave evidence at the Tribunal, and were informed of the results of the ultrasound of 20 July 2010, their opinions inevitably, changed. All the doctors who gave evidence at the Tribunal were satisfied that the underlying pathology was primarily of a constitutional nature, and associated degenerative changes. Drs Bodel and McGill were of the opinion that the incident on 9 August 2010 may have caused a minor aggravation which would have taken a few days to heal.