Lestari & Hidayat (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 1)

Lestari & Hidayat (No 4) [2023] FedCFamC1F 850

File number(s): SYC 585 of 2016
Judgment of: ALDRIDGE J
Date of judgment: 9 October 2023
Catchwords: FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY – Final property proceedings between the husband and wife – Where the wife’s mother was joined to the proceedings – Where there is one property which is the major asset of the pool – Where the parties agreed that the property should be sold –
Where there is a lack of evidence due to the circumstances of the case – Orders for the property to be sold and net proceeds divided 60 per cent to the wife and 40 per cent to the husband.    
Legislation: Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 75(2)
Cases cited:

Kowaliw and Kowaliw (1981) FLC 91-092

Lestari & Hidayat (No 2) [2022] FedCFamC1F 320

Lestari & Hidayat (No 3) [2022] FedCFamC1F 445

Division: Division 1 First Instance
Number of paragraphs: 124
Date of hearing: 10 July 2023
Place: Sydney
Solicitor for the Applicant: QV Law
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms Reid
Solicitor for the Respondents: Savage Solicitors

ORDERS

SYC 585 of 2016

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 1)

BETWEEN:

MR LESTARI

Applicant

AND:

MS HIDAYAT

First Respondent

MS LIPARI

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

ALDRIDGE J

DATE OF ORDER:

9 OCTOBER 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Within sixty (60) days from the date of these orders, the parties are to do all acts and things and sign all documents necessary to forthwith place the property situated at F Street, Suburb G (“the Suburb G property”) (Folio Identifier: …) for sale and sold by public auction on the following terms:

(a)A real estate agent is to be appointed by the agreement of the parties to market the property and failing such agreement the real estate agent shall be as nominated by the President of the Real Estate Institute of New South Wales or the President’s nominee at the shared expense of the parties;

(b)The reserve sale price of the property shall be as agreed between the parties and failing such agreement, the sale price shall be nominated by the President of the New South Wales Division of the Australian Property Institute or the President’s nominee at the shared expense of the parties;

(c)A solicitor is to be appointed to act on the sale of the property by the agreement of the parties and failing such agreement by a solicitor nominated by the President of the Law Society of NSW at the shared expense of the parties;

(d)The parties shall co-operate with all reasonable requests by the real estate agent in relation to the sale including to facilitate inspections of the property by prospective purchasers; and

(e)Until such time as the Suburb G property is sold, the wife is to do all acts and things necessary to ensure that she maintains the Suburb G property in good order and pays all outgoings in respect of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lestari & Hidayat (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC1F 850
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lestari & Hidayat (No 4) was a property dispute between the husband, Mr Lestari, and the wife, Ms Hidayat, which was heard in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. The parties had been unable to reach an agreement regarding the division of their assets, including a property at Suburb G, which was the major asset of the pool. The wife's mother, Ms Lipari, was also joined to the proceedings. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate division of the parties' assets and the sale of the Suburb G property.

The legal issues the court needed to decide included the respective contributions of the parties to the acquisition and maintenance of the Suburb G property, the division of the net proceeds from the sale of the property, and the appropriate division of the parties' other assets. The court had to consider the evidence presented by both parties, which was limited due to the circumstances of the case, and the wife's mental health condition, which affected her capacity to provide further evidence.

The court found that the wife made the greater financial contribution to the acquisition of the Suburb G property, and that the parties' respective contributions favoured the wife at 55 per cent and the husband at 45 per cent. The court also considered the wife's lack of earning capacity and the husband's greater working capacity, and made an adjustment of five per cent to account for this difference. The court ordered that the Suburb G property be sold, with the proceeds to be divided 60 per cent to the wife and 40 per cent to the husband after payment of the mortgage, credit card debts, and other expenses.

The court's decision was based on the evidence presented, the parties' respective contributions, and the wife's lack of earning capacity. The court considered the circumstances of the case and the wife's mental health condition, and determined that the orders made were just and equitable. The court also ordered that the parties retain their respective personal property and interests in superannuation funds.

In summary, the court ordered the sale of the Suburb G property, with the net proceeds to be divided 60 per cent to the wife and 40 per cent to the husband after payment of the mortgage, credit card debts, and other expenses. The parties were to retain their personal property and interests in superannuation funds. The court's decision was based on the evidence presented, the parties' respective contributions, and the wife's lack of earning capacity.

Orders

Orders of the court

SYC 585 of 2016

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 1)

BETWEEN:

MR LESTARI

Applicant

AND:

MS HIDAYAT

First Respondent

MS LIPARI

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

ALDRIDGE J

DATE OF ORDER:

9 OCTOBER 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1. Within sixty (60) days from the date of these orders, the parties are to do all acts and things and sign all documents necessary to forthwith place the property situated at F Street, Suburb G (“the Suburb G property”) (Folio Identifier: …) for sale and sold by public auction on the following terms:

(a) A real estate agent is to be appointed by the agreement of the parties to market the property and failing such agreement the real estate agent shall be as nominated by the President of the Real Estate Institute of New South Wales or the President’s nominee at the shared expense of the parties;

(b) The reserve sale price of the property shall be as agreed between the parties and failing such agreement, the sale price shall be nominated by the President of the New South Wales Division of the Australian Property Institute or the President’s nominee at the shared expense of the parties;

(c) A solicitor is to be appointed to act on the sale of the property by the agreement of the parties and failing such agreement by a solicitor nominated by the President of the Law Society of NSW at the shared expense of the parties;

(d) The parties shall co-operate with all reasonable requests by the real estate agent in relation to the sale including to facilitate inspections of the property by prospective purchasers; and

(e) Until such time as the Suburb G property is sold, the wife is to do all acts and things necessary to ensure that she maintains the Suburb G property in good order and pays all outgoings in respect of the Suburb G property including:

(i) Repayments on any mortgage secured over the property;

(ii) Insurance for all reasonable insurable risks, including building and contents insurance;

(iii) Strata, council and water rates; and

(iv) Any land tax due on the property.

2. On completion of the sale of the Suburb G property, proceeds of sale shall be applied in the following order of priority:

(a) In discharge of any mortgage(s) and loans secured over the property;

(b) In payment of any outstanding council rates, water rates or land tax due in respect of the property;

(c) In payment of any real estate agent’s commission, marketing expenses, auctioneer’s fees;

(d) In payment of any solicitor’s costs and disbursements for acting on the sale;

(e) In payment of the wife’s credit card liability of $55,000;

(f) In payment of the husband’s credit card liability of $93,000; and

(g) With the surplus to be divided so that the wife receives 60 per cent and the husband 40 per cent.

3. As between the husband and wife, and subject to the above orders, the husband and wife shall each respectively retain all interest in and entitlement to:

(a) All personal property now in his/her respective name, possession or control and

(b) All interests in superannuation funds standing in his/her sole name respectively.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: This copy of the Court’s Reasons for judgment may be subject to review to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 10.14(b) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Family Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 10.13 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Family Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

Section 121 of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) makes it an offence, except in very limited circumstances, to publish proceedings that identify persons, associated persons, or witnesses involved in family law proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

By 1 May 2023, the parties were in a position to confirm they would be ready to proceed to final hearing. The matter was relisted to commence on 10 July 2023.BACKGROUND The husband was born in 1977 and was 45 years old at the time of the final hearing. The wife was born in 1978 in Country C and was 45 years old at the time of the hearing. The parties met in 2008. In 2009, they commenced their relationship and cohabitation in Australia living with the husband’s parents at Suburb J. The wife frequently travelled to Country C and spent the majority of her time there until the parties married. The parties were married in Country C in 2011. The wife suffers from a mental health disorder and throughout the relationship has been hospitalised frequently due to her mental health issues. She was placed on a disability support pension in 2013, on which she remains. In 2012, the wife purchased a vacant block of land in Country C known as “[H Property]”. Later that year, the wife also purchased an off the plan apartment in Country C known as the “[K Property] apartment” for approximately AUD 47,000. The wife’s evidence was that the husband initially contributed AUD 13,050 towards the purchase of the apartment but made no further payments towards it after that. Later in 2012, with a loan from L Bank, the wife purchased land at F Street, Suburb G in her sole name for $230,000. The parties could not agree about the source of funds for the deposit. In 2013, the wife refinanced the Suburb G mortgage for the sum of $443,200 in order to construct the residence that now stands on the property. M Builders commenced construction mid-2013. The parties moved into the Suburb G property in about late 2013 to early 2014. Soon after this, rooms in the property were leased out to tenants to assist with the mortgage payments. In mid-2014, the husband lodged a development application with N Council for the subdivision of the land at Suburb G. That application was approved in late 2014. In late 2014, the wife obtained a mortgage from a Country C bank, P Bank, in order to purchase the K Property apartment. The land known as H Property was also sold around this time so that the proceeds could be applied to the P Bank mortgage. The parties separated on a final basis after an incident in late 2015. The wife says that apprehended domestic violence orders were issued for the protection of both parties from each other. The parties were divorced in 2017. In late 2017, the husband entered into a contract with Q Company, a surveying firm, for the subdivision of the land at Suburb G. By early 2018, Q Company put the husband on notice that he was in breach of their contract as a result of non-payment of their fees. By mid-2018, Q Company had filed a claim against the husband in the Local Court for breach of contract. On 9 July 2018, Henderson J made orders permitting the wife to sell the K Property apartment with the net proceeds to be held in an interest-bearing account until further order of the Court, or as agreed by the parties.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

However, on or about 10 September 2018, the wife cancelled the sale. She consented to the husband taking control of the sale of the K Property apartment conditional upon the husband meeting the mortgage payments until its sale, and if not, would result in P Bank taking possession of the property. In early 2019, the developer of the K Property apartment wrote to the wife informing her that no mortgage payments had been made for three months, that P Bank would now be taking possession of the property and the deposit and repayments to the developer were not refundable. THE EVIDENCE RELIED UPON It is important to note the limited evidence relied upon by the parties. The wife relied on the following affidavits and Financial Statements:·Affidavit of the wife filed on 24 September 2021 (although it is to be noted that filed copy of this affidavit is not complete in that it does not include any annexures after Annexure “MH-10”. A complete copy is to be found in the Court Book prepared by the parties); ·Affidavit of the second respondent filed on 24 September 2021;·Financial Statement of the wife filed on 24 September 2021;·Financial Statement of the second respondent filed on 24 September 2021; and·Affidavit of Dr E filed on 7 June 2022. As is obvious, there was no up to date evidence at the hearing. Dr E diagnosed the wife with a serious psychiatric disorder with a parallel disorder. He expressed the view that whilst there were periods where the wife could function in a reduced capacity “under pressure she becomes completely overwhelmed, […] and decompensates potentially into self-harm” (Affidavit of Dr E filed on 7 June 2023, p.6). Given these observations, Dr E formed the view that the wife did not have the capacity to give proper instructions or to attend a court hearing. It is thus understandable that no further evidence was obtained from the wife. She was not in a position to be cross-examined. There was, however, no evidence from another source as to her present circumstances or needs. The second respondent’s death prevented her from being cross-examined on her affidavit. Those unfortunate events have the effect that the evidence of the wife and the second respondent has not been tested by cross-examination. Thus, their evidence, especially on contested matters, must be looked at with care, with very much reduced weight given to such evidence which is not supported by other evidence or strong probabilities. The husband relied on the following:·Affidavit of the husband filed on 24 September 2021 and·Financial Statement of the husband filed on 24 September 2021. He did not seek to rely on any more recent evidence and did not attempt to explain why that was so. The Financial Statement must be approached with some care as the husband has not lodged an income tax return since 2014 and agreed that, at least at times, he has worked for cash. He was an unsatisfactory witness – evasive, argumentative, and determined to argue his case rather than answer questions. He agreed that he altered a bank statement attached to an affidavit of his of 26 April 2018 by removing the word “payroll” next to a transfer to the wife. The husband was unconcerned by this dishonest behaviour, seemingly on the basis that the affidavit was not now relied upon.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I have rejected each of the other contentions. CONCLUSION That leaves me to return to the earlier finding that the wife directly or with the assistance of her mother, made the greater financial contribution to the acquisition of the Suburb G property, including its maintenance. The parties’ marriage was short and they had no children. I proceed on the basis that their non‑financial contributions during that time were equal. I infer that since separation the wife has made greater non-financial contributions to the upkeep and maintenance of the Suburb G property, simply because she was in occupation. She has the benefit too of residing there and there were tenants. In the absence of much evidence on this consideration, I afford it little weight. Overall, I consider that the parties’ respective contributions favour the wife as to 55 per cent and the husband 45 per cent. Neither party adduced any evidence as to their current circumstances. I was informed by counsel for the wife that her medical needs are being met but she submitted that as the wife has no earning capacity and will not regain any (which submission is supported by the evidence of Dr E) and as the husband is a trained professional, albeit he has been working in transport for much of the time since 2015, he has a greater working capacity. I accept that to be so. It is appropriate that an adjustment of five per cent be made to take into account that differential. The wife will therefore receive 60 per cent of the proceeds of sale after payment of the mortgage of the Suburb G property and the various credit card debts. On the above figures, leaving aside the costs of sale, the wife will receive $625,500. The husband will receive $417,000. This is a differential of $208,500. There will be an order for the sale of the Suburb G property with the parties’ credit card debts to be paid off before division of the proceeds, which will then be divided 60 per cent to the wife and 40 per cent to the husband. They will otherwise retain the assets and entitlements they have. This will slightly favour the wife, but the difference is not of great significance. In the circumstances of this case, I consider these orders to be just and equitable.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.