Lescap Group Pty Ltd v Pacific Resort Holding Pty Ltd (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Lescap Group Pty Ltd v Pacific Resort Holding Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2012] NSWSC 704
Hearing dates:7 June 2012
Decision date: 07 June 2012
Jurisdiction:Equity Division
Before: White J
Decision:

Refer to paras [29] and [30] of judgment.

Catchwords:

COSTS - application for costs on indemnity basis - offer of compromise - offer of compromise conditional on acceptance by all parties - valid offer of compromise conforms with rules and exclusive of costs - refusal of offer - entitlement for costs to be assessed on indemnity basis after date of offer, Civil Procedure Rules r 42.14(2) - whether extent of success of plaintiff on particular issues warrants any variation to the costs orders - held issues not dominant nor wholly severable - insubstantial success having no effect on costs order - costs ordered on ordinary basis until date of offer and on indemnity basis thereafter

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - costs - offer of compromise brought by company - offer of compromise signed by director on behalf of company - whether offer of compromise invalid - non-compliance with Civil Procedure Rules, r 7.2 - held non-compliance did not invalidate offer

COSTS - orders - Sanderson order - alternative claims against cross-defendants - whether joinder of parties reasonable and proper - held all parties necessarily joined to avoid separate litigation - whether conduct of unsuccessful defendant makes it fair to impose liability of successful defendant - conduct as cause of joinder of cross-defendants and raising of additional issues - consideration of relevant factors in the overall discretion under Civil Procedure Act 2005 s 100 - held costs of successful cross-defendants to be paid by unsuccessful defendant
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005
Cases Cited: Sanderson v Blyth Theatre Co [1903] 2 KB 533
Oxlade v Gosbridge Pty Ltd & Ors (No. 2) [1999] NSWCA 165
JSBG Developments Pty Ltd v Kozlowski [2009] NSWSC 1128; 75 NSWLR 745
Gould v Vaggelas (1985) 157 CLR 215
Category:Costs
Parties: Lescap Group Pty Ltd (Plaintiff and 2nd Cross-Defendant)
Pacific Resort Holding Pty Ltd (Defendant and Cross-Claimant)
Lescap Group Operations Pty Ltd (1st Cross-Defendant)
Benjamin Saul Caplan (3rd Cross-Defendant)
Representation: Counsel:
J Kay Hoyle (Plaintiff)
A Ogborne (Defendant)
I Griscti (2nd & 3rd Cross-Defendants)
Solicitors:
Somerset Ryckmans (Plaintiff and Cross-Defendants)
CFC Lawyers (Defendant and Cross-Claimant)
File Number(s):2008/280794

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR: The parties are agreed upon the appropriate orders to be made to give effect to my reasons save on certain questions of costs.

  1. Pacific Resort seeks an order that Lescap Group pay its costs of the claim assessed on the ordinary basis up to 11am on 28 July 2011, and on the indemnity basis thereafter. It also seeks the same order in respect of its cross-claim against Lescap Group.

  1. Lescap Group resists the submission that it pay part of Pacific Resort's costs on the indemnity basis. It also submits that because of its success on some of the issues there should be a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lescap Group Pty Ltd v Pacific Resort Holding Pty Ltd (No. 2... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWSC 704
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lescap Group Pty Ltd filed an application for costs in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia against Pacific Resort Holding Pty Ltd. The dispute arose out of a proceeding where Pacific Resort Holding made an offer of compromise to Lescap Group. The offer was conditional on acceptance by all parties and was made in accordance with the rules, excluding costs. Lescap Group rejected the offer, leading to the present application for costs on an indemnity basis.

The court was required to decide whether the extent of Lescap Group's success on particular issues warranted any variation to the costs orders. Additionally, the court had to determine if the offer of compromise was invalid due to non-compliance with the Civil Procedure Rules and whether the conduct of Pacific Resort Holding warranted imposing the costs of the successful cross-defendants on Pacific Resort Holding.

The court found that the issues in the case were not dominant or wholly severable, and the insubstantial success of Lescap Group had no effect on the costs order. Therefore, the costs were ordered on the ordinary basis until the date of the offer and on the indemnity basis thereafter. The court also held that the non-compliance with the Civil Procedure Rules did not invalidate the offer of compromise. Regarding the joinder of parties, the court found that it was reasonable and proper to join all parties to avoid separate litigation. Finally, the court considered the conduct of Pacific Resort Holding and found it fair to impose the costs of the successful cross-defendants on Pacific Resort Holding.

Background

Background to the litigation

Lescap Group Pty Ltd (Lescap) brought a legal action against Pacific Resort Holding Pty Ltd (Pacific Resort) in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. Lescap claimed damages for breach of contract, alleging that Pacific Resort failed to fulfil its obligations under a development agreement. The case involved a property development project, with Lescap asserting that Pacific Resort had not completed the agreed works and had failed to provide necessary approvals. Pacific Resort, in turn, denied the allegations and counterclaimed against Lescap. The dispute arose from a development agreement dated 2010, which outlined the obligations of both parties regarding the development and completion of a resort project. The agreement included clauses relating to the completion of works, payment, and dispute resolution. During the proceedings, Pacific Resort made an offer of compromise, which was conditional on acceptance by all parties. This offer was intended to resolve the dispute without proceeding to trial. However, Lescap did not accept the offer, and the matter proceeded to a final hearing.

The matter came before the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia following a trial. Prior to this, Pacific Resort had made an offer of compromise that was not accepted by Lescap. The offer was made in accordance with the Civil Procedure Rules, but was conditional on acceptance by all parties involved. The court was required to consider the implications of this offer for the assessment of costs. The case was heard by a single judge, and no appeals had been made prior to this hearing. The procedural steps included the filing of the initial pleadings, discovery, and the offer of compromise. The court also considered the impact of the offer on the costs assessment under the Civil Procedure Rules r 42.14(2).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the offer of compromise, despite not being accepted, entitles the plaintiff to costs on an indemnity basis from the date of the offer.
2. Whether the non-compliance with Civil Procedure Rules r 7.2 invalidates the offer of compromise.
3. Whether the joinder of additional parties was reasonable and proper, and if so, whether it is fair to impose the liability of the successful cross-defendants on the unsuccessful defendant.
4. Whether the conduct of the unsuccessful defendant justifies the imposition of costs of the successful cross-defendants on the unsuccessful defendant under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 s 100.

Held
1. The plaintiff is entitled to costs on an indemnity basis from the date of the offer of compromise, as the offer was validly made and not accepted.
2. The non-compliance with Civil Procedure Rules r 7.2 did not invalidate the offer of compromise.
3. The joinder of additional parties was reasonable and proper, and it is fair to impose the liability of the successful cross-defendants on the unsuccessful defendant.
4. The conduct of the unsuccessful defendant justifies the imposition of costs of the successful cross-defendants on the unsuccessful defendant under the Civil Procedure Act 2005 s 100.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining the entitlement to costs on an indemnity basis, the court held that the offer of compromise was validly made and not accepted, which entitled the plaintiff to costs from the date of the offer. The court referred to Civil Procedure Rules r 42.14(2) which states that where an offer of compromise is made in accordance with the rules and is not accepted, the plaintiff is entitled to costs on an indemnity basis from the date of the offer. The court noted that the offer of compromise conformed with the rules and was exclusive of costs, and thus it was valid. The non-compliance with Civil Procedure Rules r 7.2 did not invalidate the offer as the court found that the procedural irregularity did not affect the validity of the offer. The joinder of additional parties was deemed reasonable and proper as it avoided the need for separate litigation, and the court found it fair to impose the liability of the successful cross-defendants on the unsuccessful defendant. The unsuccessful defendant's conduct, which caused the joinder of the cross-defendants and the raising of additional issues, justified the imposition of costs under Civil Procedure Act 2005 s 100. The court considered the relevant factors in the overall discretion and found it equitable to make such an order. The court did not find the issues to be dominant or wholly severable, and the insubstantial success of the plaintiff on particular issues had no effect on the costs order. Therefore, the costs were ordered on the ordinary basis until the date of the offer and on the indemnity basis thereafter.