Leonardis & Anor v Theta Developments P/L & Ors No. Scgrg-93-344

Link copied
Case Copied 88 min read

LEONARDIS & ANOR v THETA DEVELOPMENTS P/L & ORS

[2000] SASC 402

WILLIAMS J.

INDEX

Par No.

  1. Introduction   1

  2. The undisputed background   13

  3. The inventor’s explanation   21

  4. The principal patent claims and their integers   22

  5. The accused spacers described

    (a)     Introduction   26

    (b)    Podfix 2   27

    (c)    Podfix 1   36

    (d)    Bottom cover spacer

    (Aust Reg Design No105053)   37

6................ The engineering evidence

(a)     Introduction   43

(b)    Concrete flow   47

(c)    The meaning of “adjacent”   51

(d)    Other engineering evidence   53

  1. The issues   61

  2. Characterisation of Claim 1 - Product or process claim?                  62

  3. Identification (in pith and marrow) of the essential

    integers of the patent claims in the accused spacers   70

  4. The conduct of the corporate defendants   78

  5. Liability for contributory (or indirect) infringement   86

  6. Liability of personal defendants  102

  7. The dependent claims, their integers and infringement  108

  8. The significance of the Full Court decision in Sartas No. 1             114

  9. Agreed evidence (Exhibit P 14)  123
                      (a)     The Brochure  124
                      (b)    The correspondence of Reinforcement Bar Spacer Co.  127
                      (c)    The correspondence of the personal defendants             133

  10. Principles of construction of patents  145

  11. Summary  153

  12. Appendices:
    A      Extracts from Plaintiff’s patent
                      B      Extract from Registered Design No 105053
                      C      Extract from RBS Co Brochure  

  1. Introduction

  1. This is an action for infringement of patent.

  2. In accordance with a Master’s order the action came to trial upon the basis that the trial Judge determine the issue of liability on the claim and counterclaim and reserving any questions of damages.  A counterclaim raised questions under the Fair Trading Act 1987 (SA) and the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The defendants by way of defence assert that the male plaintiff’s patent is invalid and liable to be revoked. This allegation has not been particularised and there is no counter claim for revocation in accordance with s 121 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth). However the defendants have foreshadowed a late application to amend their pleadings in order to raise such a claim based upon s 138(3)(b) and (f) of the Patents Act 1990. At trial (and at the request of the parties) I ordered that certain limited questions arising upon the statement of claim should be determined before other issues. The defendants will not proceed with their application to amend until I have dealt with these questions (see pt 14 of these reasons). I have not yet been required to consider the difficulties which may be associated with such an application.

  3. By my order I am now required to decide whether the activities of the defendants respectively with respect to three products have infringed the patent of Leonardis undermentioned.  These products (sometimes referred to by counsel as the accused spacers) are building formwork spacers called respectively Podfix 1, Podfix 2 and “the Bottom Cover Spacer” (Australian Registered Design No.AU-S-105053).  It is alleged that the corporate defendants manufacture and sell these products with instructions for use in some cases.  The defendant Mr St Alban is a director of the defendant Reinforcement Bar Spacer Co…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Leonardis & Anor v Theta Developments P/L & Ors No. Scgrg-93... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SASC 402
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nicola Leonardis and Ezyline Pty Ltd brought an action against Theta Developments P/L and others for patent infringement. The patent in question, Australian Letters Patent No. 591816, relates to improvements in building foundation form work. The patent was amended by the Federal Court, and the validity of the patent was upheld subject to the excision of eight claims. The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants infringed the patent by using a similar method and device for positioning cardboard box formwork for concrete pours. The defendants argued that the patent was invalid and that the construction of the patent claims by the Full Court in a previous case, Sartas No.1, was decisive. The court had to determine whether the defendants' construction of the patent claims was correct and whether the defendants had infringed the patent. The court found that the defendants' construction of the patent claims was not correct and that the Full Court's construction of the patent claims in Sartas No.1 was not decisive in this case. The court also found that the defendants had infringed the patent by using a similar method and device for positioning cardboard box formwork for concrete pours. The court granted an interlocutory injunction restraining the defendants from continuing to infringe the patent. The plaintiffs were also awarded damages for the infringement.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The undisputed background The plaintiff Mr Nicola Leonardis is the proprietor of Australian Letters Patent No.591816 sealed by the Commissioner of Patents on 14 September 1991. It is entitled “Improvements relating to Building Foundation Form Work”. In accordance with s 105 of the Patents Act 1990 the patent was amended by the order of Gummow J (sitting in the Federal Court of Australia) on 24 January 1997 in proceedings known as Sartas No1 Pty Ltd v Koukourou & Partners Pty Ltd and Anor. In that action Sartas No.1 alleged that Koukourou and Leonardis were making unjustified threats with respect to patent infringement. The decision of Gummow J (2 December 1994) at first instance in that case is reported (1994) 30 IPR 479. (Mr Leonardis was a respondent to those proceedings). An appeal by Mr Leonardis to the Full Federal Court (decided by Burchett, Hill and Tamberlin JJ on 13 June 1996) is reported under the title Leonardis v Sartas No.1 Pty Ltd and Anor (1996) 35 IPR 23. In the result the validity of the patent was upheld subject to the excision of eight claims. For present purposes I have referred to the amended claim numbers (1-13) as they appear upon the face of the patent after bringing to account the abovementioned order. Subject to some modification, the content of Claim 7 as recited by Gummow J became Claim 1 and the content of Claim 12 became Claim 6 after amendment. The passages which I have quoted from this earlier decision (see pt 14 below) must be read in this light. The statement of claim alleges that in 1987 Mr Leonardis granted a licence to Ezyline to use the patent. Ezyline is the trading name adopted by Mr Leonardis and his co-plaintiff whose interest as a party does not require further mention with respect to the immediate issues. In Martin Engineering Co & Anor v Nicaro Holdings Pty Ltd & Ors (1991) AIPC 90-799 at page 37583 Burchett J notes the different position of the patent holder and the exclusive licensee in terms of loss resulting from patent infringement and explains their separate interests in an action for infringement. The present trial was conducted against the background of the earlier Federal Court litigation involving Sartas No.1. In his reasons Gummow J (at p 488 of the report) notes the existence of the present proceedings. On all trials much is taken by all parties as assumed and only those facts really in dispute strictly proved. In such cases what is assumed is in proof: in Re Robson [1952] SASR 101 at 105 per Napier CJ citing R v Higham 119 ER 1352 at 1355. In the present case this reference is apt to describe the efficient way in which counsel have approached and identified the issues and then confined the evidence to essentials; they have taken me to the recitation of fact by Gummow J as a useful starting point for my own deliberations but based upon the evidence led before me from the two same principal engineering witnesses who also gave evidence before Gummow J in the Federal Court. The Leonardis invention relates to building foundation form work and provides for a method and a device called a “spacer” to position cardboard box formwork for the purposes of a concrete pour. The unstable soil conditions which are common on Adelaide building sites has led to the development of a concrete footing design in which on a levelled site a grid system of beams with a covering horizontal slab (known as a “waffle raft”) is integrally cast in concrete on and above the ground surface. The form work for this system is laid on the ground and avoids the need for labour intensive trenching. The form work for such a system may be provided by laying cardboard boxes in an appropriate pattern on the ground so that the boxes form and define the sides of channels into which the concrete is poured so as to mould the structural beams of the waffle raft. The upper surface of the boxes also fill the voids as the slab is poured over the underlying beams and cardboard form work. This latter material is sacrificed in the sense that it becomes lost when permanently incorporated into the concrete structure. This system of constructing cardboard box formwork is itself the subject of patent rights obtained by engineers Koukourou and partners (for example: Patent No 584769).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The engineering evidence Although the construction of the patent is a matter for me there are two contentious matters in particular where I have looked to the views of the engineers in order to test my own tentative conclusions. Views expressed by the defendants’ engineer (Mr John) reinforce the approach which I would otherwise have reached upon two issues. There has been debate between counsel as to the extent of the ground clearance or beam elevation envisaged in the Leonardis invention which is expressed in qualitative rather than quantitative terms - “lowermost edge which is substantially above the supporting level surface” (see Claim 1 (integer (vii)) or “lowermost surface which is substantially above a lowermost edge of each of the engaging surfaces” (Claim 6 integer (xix)). There was also debate as to which of the four sets of “jaws” at the corners of the (square) frame are “adjacent”. The patent (both in the body and in its claims) refer to the respective “adjacent” boxes and the planar surfaces (ie jaws) which engage against the sides of “respective adjacent boxes” (see for example Claim 1 integers (iv) and (v) and Claim 6 integer (xvii)). Upon each of these topics I will treat the undermentioned as statements which I am prepared to adopt as the basis for conclusions on each issue as mentioned below.(b) Concrete flow In his report dated 1 October 1998 Mr Trevor John, a Consulting Engineer engaged on behalf of the defendants described some background facts which as applied to the plaintiff’s invention do not constitute any advancement over the common knowledge as at December 1985. Mr John says (pp 19-20):“7.9 SPACERS INTERRUPTING CONCRETE FLOWSpacers in reinforced concrete construction, and which are intended to remain permanently in place have typically fallen into 2 types-those which interrupt the flow of concrete between the reinforcement and the adjacent concrete face, and those which effectively allow the concrete to be continuous save for a small interruption where the actual spacer material exists.It is preferable to allow the concrete to flow around the reinforcement with the minimum of interruption to minimise any potential crack propagation and reduce the risk of ingress of air and/or water. The thickness of concrete between any spacer element and the concrete surface is not critical provided it is sufficient to allow the sand/cement matrix to flow continuously. There is no requirement for the maximum size coarse aggregate in the concrete to flow under the “frame members” of the spacer, provided that the material under the “frame members” is of a similar strength to the general concrete.If the sand/cement matrix, together with the smaller particles of coarse aggregate, is prevented from flowing under the spacer then there is a greater risk of moisture penetrating the concrete section along the spacer/concrete interface. This has not been found to be a significant problem where concrete spacers have been used as bonding between the concrete spacer and the cast in-situ concrete will occur. When other materials are used which will not bond to the poured concrete then it is preferable that the exposure of the spacer to the concrete face is minimised. In the particular case of isolated bar chairs which do not extend across the width of a section to any significant extent then the risk of concrete shrinkage cracking and tensile cracking is reduced to a negligible level.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

The significance of the Full Court decision in Sartas No 1 The defendants base an argument upon the manner in which the patent was construed by the Full Court of the Federal Court in Sartas No 1. If a different construction is to be given to the patent, then the defendants assert that this may affect the validity of the patent. As the defendants have foreshadowed a possible attack upon validity, the basis of my decision on infringement (in the light of Sartas No.1) is important to the defendants in deciding whether to pursue an application to amend the pleadings. I noted in the introduction to these reasons the manner in which I had proceeded to determine limited questions at this stage. The Court in Sartas No.1 upheld the appeal of Mr Leonardis as to the validity of his patent upon the basis that a disputed essential integer was sufficiently disclosed in and fairly based upon the provisional patent application when reference was made to the accompanying drawings. The defendants’ submissions directed to the meaning to be given to the words “substantially above” in claims 1 and 6, may be summarised as follows:(a).... “The patent claims have already been construed by a Court. That must be decisive of the construction. The construction of a patent claim is constant and the claim is not construed with an eye to the infringer. The claims that define the monopoly confer rights in rem or, as it was put by Gummow J; the specification operates to confer rights in rem (at 488 line 34). The Court has defined those rights by construing the claims, where appropriate in the light of the specification and the provisional specifications and the invention disclosed in the provisionals and described in the body of the specification. That construction does not logically alter depending on the circumstances of an infringement action. This goes further than the question of stare decisis.”(b)“The reference to once again and significantly make it clear that the frame members must be raised sufficiently to allow for concrete to pass fully. Clearly the fully refers to all of the aggregate. This applies to all of the frame members and the object is to resist localised fracturing and capillary water.” The question at issue is what as a matter of construction was “disclosed” by the drawing which was before the Full Court and now included in the amended patent. The drawing does not stand alone but will be studied in light of the text of the specification. How high must the frame members be raised? The Full Court commented in Leonardis at 32:“Another matter to which reference should be made at the outset is the use of the word “substantially” in claims 7 and 12. In claim 12, the added words “such that concrete can extend continuously beneath each of said frame members” make it clear, in functional terms, how large the gap must be to meet the requirement conveyed by this word. It is not inadmissible to use in a claim an imprecise word, in an appropriate context, where it conveys the necessary meaning: cf Populin v HB Nominees Pty Ltd (1982) 41 ALR 471 at 473 (“relatively small”); Re Imperial Chemical Industries Ltd (Clark’s) Application [1969] RPC 574 at 583, 584 (“a minor amount of water...small in comparison with the total amount of other liquid constituents”); Vax Appliances Ltd v Hoover Plc [1991] FSR 307 at 309, 318 (“substantially dropwise” flow); Monsanto Co v Commissioner of Patents (1974) 48 ALJR 59 (“substantial effect”). The purpose of the integer conveyed by the words “substantially above” being plain, the dictum of Taylor J in Martin v Scribal Pty Ltd (1954) 92 CLR 17 at 97 applies:........... ...it is right to construe a claim with an eye benevolent to the inventor and with a view to making the invention work-this is an application of the old doctrine ut res magis valeat quam pereat.The difficulty which proved fatal for the appellant, in the view of the learned trial judge, was the absence of language in the two provisional specifications corresponding with such expressions in the complete specification as that appearing at the end of claim 12, revealing a raising of the frame members of the spacer so that concrete can flow beneath them. The first question involved in the appeal is whether this facet of the invention as claimed finds a fair basis in the first and second provisional specifications. One aspect of that problem is whether fair basis may be found in the drawings forming part of a provisional specification although the words, if taken alone, would not provide it. For here there are general references to the “pouring” of concrete and to an aim (conveyed by the expression “[i]n order to achieve” of “minimal interference with the total strength of any cement or concrete cast”, but there is no specific statement of the purpose dictating the raising of frame members, or of the fact that this permits concrete, when poured, to flow beneath them. There is a statement, in the second provisional specification, from which these things might be inferred by the attentive reader: “The concrete is then poured as appropriate and all of the spacing units are left in position to be integrated in the final cast foundation.” Integration in the foundation could only actually be achieved if concrete did flow beneath the raised members. Of course, the flat surfaces bearing against the cardboard form work would, like the form work itself, remain outside the body of concrete, but this is so obvious that no reader could be mistaken about it; the reference to the integration of the spacing unit in the final cast foundation must be taken as a reference to the frame of the unit to which those surfaces are attached, one embodiment of which includes also means for holding reinforcing rods.But the second provisional specification does expressly take its reader to the drawings in the passage commencing:For a better understanding of this invention it [ie the invention itself, not just the preferred embodiment to which reference is then made] will now be referred to with reference to a preferred embodiment in which...By this language, which is similar to language used in the first provisional specification, the drawings are introduced, and they are made central to an understanding of the invention. The words themselves of the document do also make it plain that the drawings introduce new and significant ideas, not presented in the first provisional specification...”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.