Lenzo v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lenzo v Commissioner of Taxation [2007] FCA 1402

INCOME TAX – deductions – outgoings incurred in plantation investment - scheme comprising prospectus, management and lease agreements, loan agreement, indemnity agreement and round-robin arrangement between manager and lender – whether tax benefit derived in connection with scheme – dominant purpose for entry into scheme – objective criteria – matters to be considered – investment structure – approach to consideration of relevant factors – alternative finance available to like effect as scheme finance – whether tax benefit unique to scheme – scheme not entered into for dominant purpose of tax benefit – commercial benefit of scheme – expert evidence as to financial returns and benefits on a pre-tax basis

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) s 177F(1), s 177A, s 177C, s 177D
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)

Puzey v Commissioner of Taxation (2002) 51 ATR 616 cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Sleight (2004) 136 FCR 211 cited
Calder v Commissioner of Taxation (2005) 59 ATR 655 cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Hart (2004) 217 CLR 216 cited

GINO LENZO v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
WAD 95 OF 2005

FRENCH J
7 SEPTEMBER 2007
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 95 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

GINO LENZO
Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Respondent

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 SEPTEMBER 2007

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant’s appeal against the decisions of the Commissioner disallowing his objections to the amended assessments issued on 7 September 2001 in respect of the years of income ended 30 June 1998, 30 June 1999 and 30 June 2000 is allowed.

2.Each of the respondent’s decisions disallowing the applicant’s objection for the years of income ended 1998, 1999 and 2000 are set aside.

3.It is declared that the applicant is entitled to the deductions disallowed in each of the relevant years of income.

4.The respondent is directed to further amend the amended assessments to give effect to these orders. 

5.The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs of the proceedings.

6.Liberty to apply for such further or other orders as may be necessary to give effect to the preceding orders.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 95 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

GINO LENZO
Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Respondent

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE:

7 SEPTEMBER 2007

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. Gino Lenzo, an accountant, appeals against the disallowance by the Commissioner of Taxation (the Commissioner) of his objection to amended assessments disallowing deductions which he claimed in relation to his investment in a sandalwood plantation project near Kununurra.  The years of income for which the deductions were claimed were 1998, 1999 and 2000.  The Commissioner concedes some of the deductions but maintains that other deductions including certain…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lenzo v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1402
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lenzo v Commissioner of Taxation, the taxpayer, Mr. Lenzo, appealed against the Commissioner's disallowance of certain deductions related to his investment in a sandalwood plantation. The primary legal issue before the court was whether Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 applied to the claimed deductions, effectively rendering them non-deductible. The court needed to determine whether the investment scheme had a dominant purpose of obtaining a tax benefit, which would trigger the anti-avoidance provisions of Part IVA.

The court examined various factors, including the commercial viability of the investment, the structure of the investment, and the availability of alternative financing. It noted that while the investment structure did provide tax benefits, the scheme was primarily driven by the potential for significant commercial returns. The court found that the investment was suitable for Mr. Lenzo based on his financial position and risk tolerance, and that the project was a genuine commercial venture. Consequently, the court concluded that the dominant purpose of the investment was not to obtain a tax benefit, and thus Part IVA did not apply.

As a result, the court allowed Mr. Lenzo's appeal, set aside the Commissioner's decisions disallowing his objections, and declared that Mr. Lenzo was entitled to the disallowed deductions. The Commissioner was directed to amend the assessments accordingly, and Mr. Lenzo was awarded costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s appeal against the decisions of the Commissioner disallowing his objections to the amended assessments issued on 7 September 2001 in respect of the years of income ended 30 June 1998, 30 June 1999 and 30 June 2000 is allowed.

2. Each of the respondent’s decisions disallowing the applicant’s objection for the years of income ended 1998, 1999 and 2000 are set aside.

3. It is declared that the applicant is entitled to the deductions disallowed in each of the relevant years of income.

4. The respondent is directed to further amend the amended assessments to give effect to these orders.

5. The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs of the proceedings.

6. Liberty to apply for such further or other orders as may be necessary to give effect to the preceding orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow I do not consider that Pt IVA applies to the claimed deductions and will allow Mr Lenzo’s appeal. The relevant amended assessments will be set aside and the Commissioner directed to further amend the assessments to give effect to these reasons. Factual background – the taxpayer considers investing in a sandalwood plantation Gino Lenzo has been a certified practising accountant for about 24 years and a sole practitioner for the last ten years. Prior to that he was employed as an accountant at Ernst & Young for a period of 14 years. He commenced his employment with that firm, then known as Ernst & Whinney, as a new graduate from the University of Western Australia. Early in 1997 Mr Lenzo became aware of trials, being conducted by the Department of Conservation and Land Management (CALM), of the growing of commercial quantities of Indian sandalwood for export. The trials were conducted in the Ord River irrigation area near Kununurra (the Ord). Mr Lenzo was told of the trials by Mr Arthur Baker. Mr Baker was promoting a managed investment scheme under which investors would become growers in a commercial Indian sandalwood operation at Kununurra. The proposed scheme was called the “Kununurra Tropical Forestry Project” also known as the “AllRange Project”. In 1997 Mr Lenzo travelled to Kununurra with Mr Baker, at Mr Baker’s expense, to inspect the proposed plantation. He was impressed with the commercial potential for Indian sandalwood in Kununurra, the infrastructure, the nursery setup to cater for future plantations and the research which had been undertaken by CALM. Nevertheless, he said he did not “feel comfortable” with the management team behind the AllRange Project. His family has a long history in farming and agriculture and he was aware of the importance of having experienced and knowledgeable people undertaking farming operations. He decided not to invest in Mr Baker’s project but was still “enthused” about the potential of Indian sandalwood. In 1998 Mr Lenzo was provided with a brochure by an organisation called Australian Tropical Forestry. The brochure offered a number of services for potential investors in commercial sandalwood plantations. He considered the merits of commencing his own operation. While of the view that it would have made a good return, he regarded the initial outlay required as prohibitive. He decided to do some more research into the Indian sandalwood industry and to read some books from his local library discussing the general nature of the product. Early in 1998 Mr Lenzo heard of another managed investment scheme involving the growing of Indian sandalwood in Kununurra. It was called the Ord River Sandalwood Project. Mr Baker was involved. Mr Lenzo received and considered an assessment report conducted by AssetWare Pty Ltd. Again he was not comfortable with the management team behind the project and declined to invest in it. Later that year Mr Lenzo became aware that a friend and former work associate, Mr Frank Wilson of the law firm Wilson & Atkinson, was becoming involved in the commercial cultivation of Indian sandalwood in Kununurra by way of a managed investment scheme. Mr Lenzo was provided with a prospectus for the project which was dated 31 March 1998. He received the prospectus at the end of May 1998. He read it and considered the commercial returns shown in it. It contained tables setting out forecasts and annual internal rates of return depending upon whether the investor chose to prepay annual lease and management fees and borrowed for the investment. Mr Lenzo considered the assumptions underpinning the forecast returns and based on his knowledge of Indian Sandalwood, and discussions with people experienced in the relevant market, formed the view that they were reasonable. As appears from the evidence of expert witnesses called in these proceedings this was a well based view. The project was being promoted by East Kimberley Sandalwood Company Ltd (EKS). Messrs Wilson and Atkinson were both directors of EKS. By way of follow-up he received a letter from EKS dated 22 June 1998 stating that many other managed investment schemes preferred to disclose an annual rate of return on investment rather than an internal rate of return. In order to allow a proper basis for comparison with other projects EKS provided a projected annual rate of return on investment from its project.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I accept Mr Sammon’s evidence. In one respect it goes to the proposition, which is not in dispute, that the project was a genuine commercial project. However the significant issue which he and the other expert witnesses canvassed was whether the “upfront” payments were higher than reasonable for commercial purposes. The answer to that question would be relevant to whether the way in which the payments were structured could be said to have a dominant purpose of obtaining a tax benefit. Expert evidence in relation to suitability of the investment Mr Lenzo called evidence from Paul Begley, Director, Alliance Investment and Retirement Services Pty Ltd (AIRS). AIRS is the holder of an Australian Financial Services licence. Mr Begley said he is authorised, by that licence, to give advice in relation to listed securities, managed investments, master trusts, superannuation investments, property syndicates and income investments. AIRS specialises in servicing customers with $1 million or more in investment capital. He has himself been a grower of Indian sandalwood with TFS since June 2000 and a shareholder since that time. Mr Lenzo’s solicitors had asked him to give evidence on the suitability of the investment in the EKS project number 1 based on the content of its prospectus focussing in particular on projected returns and taking into account the financial circumstances and goals of Mr Lenzo. His evidence was objected to by counsel for the Commissioner. The objection was on the basis that his opinion about the suitability of the investment was not a matter to which the provisions of Pt IVA were directed. The evidence was again received subject to relevance. Mr Begley had been provided with an AIRS financial information questionnaire completed by Mr Lenzo and a worksheet detailing Mr Lenzo’s financial position. He also had a copy of the prospectus. He set out his academic and other qualifications and experience in his affidavit. These were not in dispute. He stated his familiarity with pooled managed investment schemes which he described as providing an opportunity to invest in assets and industries that would otherwise be out of the reach of most investors. The pooling of funds provided economies of scale to investors enabling them to acquire interests in assets otherwise beyond their means, access management expertise and reduced management costs. Mr Begley said he had reviewed Mr Lenzo’s financial position as it was in June 1998. This was based on information provided in the AIRS financial information questionnaire which Mr Lenzo had completed. His opinion was shortly stated: The applicant’s investment in the Project was a higher risk investment, however projections indicated attractive financial returns on a pretax basis. Depending on the option chosen by the investor the projected returns ranged on a pretax and prefinance basis from 11.81% per annum for the annual fee option and 13.82% per annum for the prepaid option calculated on an internal rate of return basis. Given the applicant’s high after tax income giving rise to excess cash flow at the time, his strong asset position which consisted mainly of property, equities and alternative investments, his age, his relatively high tolerance for risk in investing and his relatively low exposure to forestry as an asset class, in my opinion, the Project was a suitable (although relatively small) investment for the applicant to make at the time.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
Taking all these factors together and the transaction overall, I accept that there were tax benefits to be derived from the way in which the investment structure was set up. Aspects of the investment structure were indicative of a purpose of deriving a tax benefit from the scheme. I do not accept however, having regard to the factors already mentioned, the significant returns which could reasonably be expected from a moderately successful outcome to the project, independent of any tax benefits, and the ready availability of alternative financing arrangements to Mr Lenzo that it would be concluded that he or the manager or promoter entered into or carried out the scheme for the dominant purpose of enabling him to obtain a tax benefit in connection with the scheme. Conclusion In my opinion, for the preceding reasons, the scheme was not one to which Pt IVA applied. The applicant’s appeal against the decision disallowing his objections succeeds.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J