Leggett and Child Support Registrar (Child support)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Leggett and Child Support Registrar (Child support) [2019] AATA 230 (22 February 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2018/1929

Re:Sandy Leggett

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member C Edwardes

Date:22 February 2019

Place:Perth

The decision under review is affirmed.

.........[Sgd].....................................................

Member C Edwardes

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – child support debt – departure prohibition order (DPO) issued to Applicant – refusal by Respondent to allow Applicant to depart Australia to visit mother-in-law – decision under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) – ss 3(1), 72I, 72D, 72K, 72L, 72T, 116(2)

CASES

Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Naboush and Child Support Registrar [2014] AATA 930
O’Neill and Child Support Registrar [2010] AATA 545

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of Social Services – Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide (Version 4.38 – Released 4 February 2019)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member C Edwardes

22 February 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant seeks a review of a decision of the Child Support Registrar (CSR), made on 24 March 2018 to refuse an application made by him for the revocation of a Departure Prohibition Order (DPO), issued pursuant to s 72I of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (the Act) on 6 March 2017 (T8, 41).

  2. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) has jurisdiction to hear this matter as provided for in s 72T of the Act.

    72T  Applications for review of certain decisions

    (1)Applications may be made to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of a decision of the Registrar under section 72I, 72L or 72M.

    BACKGROUND

  3. A DPO was issued against the Applicant pursuant to s 72D of the Act on 6 March 2017 (T8, 41).

  4. The DPO was issued on the basis that the Applicant owed a child support debt. A certificate issued pursuant to s 116(2) of the Act states (T10, 68):

    I hereby certify that the following amounts totalling $28,646.70 are due and payable by Mr Sandy Leggett and remain unpaid as at the 24th Day of May 2018 in respect of registered maintenance liabilities:

    ·         Child Support debt $25,201.54

    ·         Penalties of $3,445.16

    This amount is payable to the Commonwealth in relation to registrable maintenance liability under section 30 (child support debt) and section 67 (penalties) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

  5. The Applicant’s request to revoke his DPO was refused on 24 March 2018 by the Department under s 72I of the Collection Act. The refusal notice stated (T11, 69):

    Your application has been refused because:

    ·         your child support debt has not been paid in full

    ·         you have not made satisfactory arrangements to pay your child support debt, and

    ·         the delegate considers that your child support debt can be recovered in part or in full.

  6. The DPO prevents the Applicant from travelling overseas.  It was duly issued by the Department, and on 7 March 2017…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Leggett and Child Support Registrar (Child support) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 230
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by the Applicant to revoke a departure prohibition order (DPO) issued by the Child Support Registrar. The Applicant sought to depart Australia to visit his mother-in-law, but the DPO prevented him from doing so. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine whether the DPO should be revoked.

The Tribunal considered whether the Applicant no longer had a child support liability, whether satisfactory arrangements had been made for the debt to be wholly discharged, and whether the child support liability was completely irrecoverable. The Tribunal also considered its discretionary power to revoke the DPO, taking into account the objects of the legislation, which include ensuring children receive financial support from their parents and that periodic maintenance payments are made regularly and on time.

The Tribunal found that a certificate issued under s 116(2) of the Registration and Collection Act provided prima facie evidence of a child support debt of $25,201.54 plus penalties of $3,445.16 as at 24 May 2018. The Applicant had made no child support payments since 11 November 2015 and had not entered into any current payment arrangements. Despite the Applicant's claims of financial hardship due to business downturns and upcoming surgery, the Tribunal noted that the Applicant had previously stated his priority was to sustain his business and had not made regular payments even during successful periods. Furthermore, the Applicant had the capacity to address his debt, as indicated by a previous finding of approximately $23,400 in annual income. The Tribunal also observed that the existence of a DPO can act as an incentive to discharge the debt and that there was an alternative avenue for the Applicant to seek a departure authorisation certificate for specific travel.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, finding that the Applicant had a significant child support debt, had made no satisfactory arrangements for its discharge, and that his financial situation did not prevent him from doing so. Consequently, the DPO was not revoked.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 116(2) of the Act states:The mere production of a certificate in writing signed by the Registrar, certifying that an amount specified in the certificate was, on the date of the certificate, due and payable by a specified person to the Commonwealth in relation to a specified registrable maintenance liability or under a specified provision of Part IV, is prima facie evidence of the matters stated in the certificate.EVIDENCE The Application was heard in Perth on 18 February 2019. The Applicant appeared in person and the Respondent was represented by Ms Underhill from Mills Oakley.·Exhibit A1 – Applicant’s undated statement (Received 18 July 2018).·Exhibit A2 – Statutory declaration dated 17 July 2018.·Exhibit A3 – Medical Certificates dated 17 July 2017 and 9 May 2017.·Exhibit A4 – Default notice dated 27 March 2018.·Exhibit A5 – Tax Bill from Australian Tax Office dated 16 June 2018.·Exhibit A6 – Email from Applicant to Tribunal dated 18 July 2018.·Exhibit A7 – Email from Applicant to Tribunal regarding Departure Order dated 17 July 2018.·Exhibit R1 – T documents (T1-T13, pp1-88, ST1-ST2, pp89-116).·Exhibit R2 – Statement of Facts Issues and Contentions (SOFIC) dated 30 August 2018.·Exhibit R3 – Certificate of Debt dated 18 February 2019 issued pursuant to s 116(2) of the Act.·Exhibit R4 – Child Support Payer Transaction statements issued 18 February 2019. The Tribunal has reviewed all of the material before it and is satisfied all relevant evidence was before it and that both parties were provided with an opportunity to address the evidence in writing. Relevant aspects of the evidence and material before the Tribunal will be analysed and referred to below. The Respondent made the following contentions (R2):Does the applicant no longer have a child support liability?5.1Section 72E provides that a person has a child support liability if they have a registrable maintenance liability in an amount payable under the Act. A registrable maintenance liability is a “child support debt” where the liability remains wholly or partially unpaid.5.2It is not open to the Tribunal to look behind or draw conclusions inconsistent with previous child support assessments. A certificate under s 116(2) of the Registration and Collection Act is prima facie evidence of the debt.5.3The debt as evidenced by the s 116(2) certificate as at 24 May 2018 is comprised of overdue child support payments in the amount of $25,201.54 and late payment penalties of $3,445.16. (T10/68)5.4The applicant continues to have a child support liability and the condition precedent to revocation under s 72I(1)(a) does not exist.Have satisfactory arrangements been made for the debt to be wholly discharged?5.5The words “arrangements satisfactory … for the liability to be wholly discharged” are not further defined in the Collection Act. Per the Guide at instruction 5.2.11:A common sense approach is required to determine whether arrangements are satisfactory in each case.5.6A decision-maker is therefore to consider such factors as the size of the debt, the proposed period of any arrangement, the applicant’s compliance with previous arrangements and the extent to which the parent has the capacity to repay the debt in full.5.7The applicant has made no child support payments since 11 November 2015. (T12/71–83). The applicant entered into a payment arrangement with the Registrar on 10 September 2015 and made one payment under the arrangement (T9/47). The applicant has not entered into any further payment arrangements and does not have a current arrangement to discharge his child support debt.5.8The condition precedent to revocation under s 72I(1)(b) does not exist.Is the child support liability completely irrecoverable?5.9In Naboush and Child Support Registrar, Deputy President Tamberlin said: The word ‘irrecoverable’ is a word of wide import, and this width is expanded by the use of the word ‘completely’. Whilst ever there is some reasonable prospect of recovering money from the Applicant, the DPO should not be revoked.5.10This is consistent with the policy in the Guide at instruction 5.2.11.5.11There is no evidence that the applicant is completely incapable of paying any of his debt. On 18 May 2018, the SSCSD found that the applicant “currently has income of approximately $23,400.” (ST1/98 at [59])5.12The condition precedent to revocation under s 72I(2)(c) does not exist.Discretionary revocation5.13The Tribunal has said that the discretion in s 72I(3) “is to be exercised not entirely at large, but taking account of the purpose and objects of the legislation.”4 This is consistent with the policy in the Guide.5.14Subsection 3(1) of the Collection Act provides:The principal objects of this Act are to ensure:(a) that children receive from their parents the financial support that the parents are liable to provide; and(b) that the periodic amounts payable by parents towards the maintenance of their children are paid on a regular and timely basis; and(c) that Australia is in a position to give effect to its obligations under international agreements relating to maintenance obligations arising from family relationship parentage or marriage.5.15In O’Neill and Child Support Registrar, the Tribunal considered that:[T]he considerations which are most relevant in determining whether a DPO should be revoked relate to the current circumstances of the person the subject of the DPO. In particular, the current amount of their child support liability, the arrangements the person has made for payment of their child support liability, the extent to which the liability has become irrecoverable, the nature and purpose of the proposed travel and the likely impact of that travel on the capacity of the Registrar to recover the debt. I also consider that the statutory framework contemplates regard being had to the fact that a person subject to a DPO may apply for a DAC in respect of any particular instance of proposed travel.…[I]n the context of an application of this kind, it is neither necessary or [sic] appropriate in my view for the Tribunal to embark on a detailed consideration “on the merits” of whether the DPO should have been imposed at the time at which it was. The decision under review is the decision not to revoke the DPO, not the decision to impose it. Indeed this Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to review the imposition of DPOs.5.16It has been judicially observed that a DPO is a form of security that prevents the recovery of a child support debt from being frustrated. It may be issued as a general preventative measure as well as in response to a specific, threatened departure. It follows that, in an application for revocation, it is relevant to consider whether the DPO acts as an incentive in the particular case to discharge the child support debt.5.17The existence of the applicant’s mounting child support debt and failure to make any payments for more than two and a half years demonstrates that he is not providing financial support to his children on a regular and timely basis as Parliament intended. The Registrar contends that this is a factor which strongly weighs against the exercise of the discretion in s72I(3).5.18The history of the matter demonstrates that the imposition of the DPO has resulted in the applicant engaging with his assessment. After the DPO was issued, the applicant applied for a change of assessment and the decision has been reviewed internally and externally by the SS&CSD.5.19The applicant says that he wishes to travel overseas to visit his infirm mother-in- law.5.20A person who is prevented from leaving Australia by reason of a DPO may apply for a departure authorisation certificate (DAC), authorising departure from Australia for a foreign country pursuant to s 72K of the Collection Act. Considerations relevant to issuing a DAC are found in s 72L and include humanitarian grounds. There is therefore an avenue other than revocation of the DPO which may facilitate travel.5.21There are no circumstances advanced (or evidence in support of same) which weigh in favour of the exercise of the discretion to revoke the DPO under s 72I(3). In all the circumstances, the Tribunal should not exercise the discretion to revoke the DPO.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal finds on the evidence available the Applicant (R3):·has a child support debt in the amount of $25,296.63 and late payment penalties of $4,853.85;·has made no satisfactory arrangements to discharge this child support debt; and·his financial situation is not an impediment to him discharging this debt.DECISION For the reasons outlined above the decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Under cross-examination the Applicant said:·He had 3 children.·He accepted he had a liability, although the quantum was in dispute.·He had made an offer to pay child support prior to the DPO being registered however the quantum was not agreed to.·He thought the amount was $100/week, however because no agreement was finalised with the CSR, he made only spasmodic payments (R4).·He accepted his priority was to sustain his business and he would maintain his business payments at the expense of his child support obligations.·He had not worked for 12 months and is going in for shoulder surgery shortly which will put him out of work for 12 months.·He had been in a relationship for the past 5 years with a Mauritian lady.·He sponsored her through a fiancée visa and agreed to fund her medical expenses.·His travel to visit his mother-in-law in Mauritius will be funded by his parents.·He said with the business downturn in late 2016 and property decline he could not afford to pay his child support debt.·He did not have an answer when the Tribunal asked why during the successful period of operation of the business he did not make regular payments. He did acknowledge that he had not made an effort to continue payments.CONSIDERATION A Certificate issued under s 116(2) of the Registration and Collection Act states that the Applicant had child support debt of $25,201.54 and penalties of $3,445.16 as at 24 May 2018. This amount is payable to the Commonwealth as a child support debt (T10, 68). The Tribunal is satisfied the Applicant has a child support liability and is the subject of a DPO issued on 6 March 2017 (T9, 53). The Tribunal notes the last payment made by the Applicant for child support occurred on 11 November 2015 (T7, 32). The Tribunal notes the report dated 3 March 2017 (T7, 30-38) which states:Since 27 June 2016 when these cases were referred for DPO enforcement, DHS CS has:· Made two successful telephone contacts with Mr Leggett, no arrangement to pay was made in either conversation.· Issued two specific Please Contact DHS CS letters, the last being returned to DHS CS.· Issued six child support account statements to Mr Leggett’s postal address, of which three account statements have been returned to DHS CS.…….The last successful contact with Mr Leggett occurred on 20 January 2017.……..Every effort has been made to discuss his child support debt, however Mr Leggett has failed to make a suitable arrangement to pay his child support debt. The Report also outlines the number of unsuccessful telephone contacts with the Applicant, noting in reference to the last successful contact with the Applicant that “Mr Leggett refused to complete the Proof of Identity (POI) check with DHS CS or discuss his child support debt… Mr Leggett terminated the call before his child support debt could be discussed” (T7, 33). The report concludes that the Applicant “has the available financial resources to address his child support debt in full.”