Legal Services Commissioner v SYG

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Legal Services Commissioner v SYG [2023] QCAT 401

PARTIES:

LEGAL SERVICES COMMISSIONER

(applicant)

v

SYG

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

[redacted]

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

23 October 2023

HEARING DATE:

5 September 2023

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Williams J

Assisted by:
Ms Annette Bradfield
Dr Susan Dann

ORDERS:

1.     Information which might enable the Respondent, the Respondent’s partner and the location where the Respondent conducts his legal practice to be identified is not to be published, except to the parties in these proceedings.

2.     The Respondent’s conduct identified in respect of the charge in the discipline application is found to constitute professional misconduct.

3.     The Respondent refrain from acting for [redacted].

4.     The Respondent pay a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $2,000.

5.     The Respondent is reprimanded for his conduct.

6.     The Respondent pay the Legal Services Commissioner’s costs of and incidental to the discipline action, to be assessed on the standard basis in the manner costs would be assessed if the matter were in the Supreme Court of Queensland.   

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – LAWYERS – COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE – DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS – PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT – GENERALLY – where the respondent sent seven letters over a period of approximately 14 weeks in the course of acting for a client, who was also his partner – where the applicant contends that various aspects of the letters breached rules 4.1.4, 34.1.1 and 34.1.3 of the Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules 2012 – whether the respondent is guilty of professional misconduct or unsatisfactory professional conduct

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – LAWYERS – COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE – DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS – PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT – GENERALLY – where the respondent undertakes legal practice in a small remote town where he also lives with his partner – where the respondent applies, on behalf of himself and his partner, for a non-publication order pursuant to s 66 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) and/or s 656D of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) – where the respondent submits that publication of certain details would significantly endanger the respondent’s partner’s mental health – whether an order should be made prohibiting the publication of the names of the respondent, his partner and the location of the respondent’s legal practice

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – LAWYERS – COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE – DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS – PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT – GENERALLY – where, if the tribunal is satisfied that a practitioner has engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct, the Tribunal may make any order it thinks fit – whether, if a finding of professional misconduct is made, a public reprimand for the purpose of general deterrence (which would ordinarily be imposed) is appropriate when a non-publication order is in place

Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) s 418, s 419, s 452, s 456, s 462, s 472, s 473, s 477, s 656D

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Services Commissioner v SYG and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCAT 401
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Legal Services Commissioner v SYG involved the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) assessing allegations of professional misconduct against a solicitor who had sent seven letters over a 14-week period in the course of representing his partner in a workplace claim. The Legal Services Commissioner (LSC) argued that the letters breached certain rules of the Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules 2012, including rules 4.1.4, 34.1.1, and 34.1.3, which pertain to professional conduct and client care. The primary issues before the Tribunal were whether the solicitor’s conduct amounted to professional misconduct or unsatisfactory professional conduct, and whether a non-publication order should be granted to protect the identities of the solicitor, his partner, and the location of his legal practice.

The Tribunal found that the solicitor’s conduct did indeed constitute professional misconduct. The Tribunal considered the agreed facts, including the emotional state of the solicitor due to his partner’s mental health issues and other stresses. The Tribunal acknowledged the potential harm that publication of the case details could cause to the partner’s mental health, and thus found that a non-publication order was warranted. The Tribunal also considered the interplay between the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 and the Legal Profession Act 2007, determining that the broad discretion provided by these Acts supported the making of a non-publication order. Given that such an order was in place, the Tribunal decided that a public reprimand, which is typically imposed for general deterrence, was not appropriate.

The Tribunal made several orders to address the findings of professional misconduct. Firstly, it prohibited the publication of any information that might identify the solicitor, his partner, or the location of his legal practice, except to the parties involved in the proceedings. Secondly, it found the solicitor’s conduct to constitute professional misconduct. Thirdly, it prohibited the solicitor from acting for a specified individual. Fourthly, it ordered the solicitor to pay a pecuniary penalty of $2,000. Fifthly, it reprimanded the solicitor for his conduct. Lastly, it required the solicitor to pay the Legal Services Commissioner’s costs associated with the disciplinary action, to be assessed on the standard basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Information which might enable the Respondent, the Respondent’s partner and the location where the Respondent conducts his legal practice to be identified is not to be published, except to the parties in these proceedings.

2. The Respondent’s conduct identified in respect of the charge in the discipline application is found to constitute professional misconduct.

3. The Respondent refrain from acting for [redacted].

4. The Respondent pay a pecuniary penalty in the amount of $2,000.

5. The Respondent is reprimanded for his conduct.

6. The Respondent pay the Legal Services Commissioner’s costs of and incidental to the discipline action, to be assessed on the standard basis in the manner costs would be assessed if the matter were in the Supreme Court of Queensland.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the LSC’s written submissions dated 3 March 2023, the LSC analyses each of the seven letters and identifies whether they fall within one or more of the bases outlined in (a), (b) and (c) of [1.10] of the particulars of the discipline application. This is the first time this analysis had been done and provided to the Respondent. The Respondent had earlier identified that the specific bases had not been particularised but this has now been addressed.Relevant facts The LSC and the Respondent have agreed the relevant facts in respect of the discipline application. The hearing proceeded on the basis of a statement of agreed facts dated 10 February 2023 (ASOF). The ASOF is 13 pages and will not be replicated in these reasons for decision in full. However, the Tribunal has considered the ASOF in full for the purposes of the discipline application. In summary, the relevant facts are:(a)The Respondent is a long-standing solicitor in Queensland and has held an unrestricted principal practicing certificate and operated as a sole practitioner at all material times.(b)The Respondent has no previous findings of misconduct.(c)The Respondent undertakes legal practice in a remote town in Queensland where he also lives, together with his partner.(d)As part of his legal practice, the Respondent was engaged by his partner to act for her in relation to a workplace claim. The issues giving rise to the workplace claim occurred over a number of years. (e)The conduct relevant to the discipline application is constituted by seven letters that the Respondent sent to various recipients. (f)The seven letters were sent over a 14-week period, being approximately three-and-a-half months. (g)The Respondent sent the first letter on 23 April 2021 on behalf of his client, his partner.(h)The Respondent sent the second letter four days later on 27 April 2021, on the Respondent’s personal letterhead, to the same recipient. The letter was sent allegedly in his personal capacity: as a concerned resident of the community.(i)The Respondent sent the third letter approximately one week later on 4 May 2021. The recipient of the letter was a superior of the recipient of the first two letters. (j)The Respondent sent the fourth letter one day later on 5 May 2021 to the officer in charge of the local police station.(k)Approximately a week later, the Respondent was sent a letter in response to the fourth letter. The letter concluded that there was insufficient evidence to charge the recipient of the first letter with unlawful stalking.(l)Approximately six days later, the Respondent sent a response to the officer in charge of the local police station, raising various matters including expressing disappointment at the outcome.(m)A couple of days later, it was again confirmed that there was no evidence to justify an unlawful stalking charge.(n)Five days after that further response, the Respondent sent the fifth letter dated 25 May 2021 to the Ethical Standards Command of the Queensland Police Service to complain about another officer at the local police station.(o)Further correspondence was sent to the Ethical Standards Command of the Queensland Police Service on 16 July 2021.(p)On 2 August 2021, being approximately two months and one week after the fifth letter, the Respondent sent the sixth letter to the Ethical Standards Command of the Queensland Police Service.(q)On the same day, the Respondent sent the seventh letter to the Crime and Corruption Commission alleging the commission of serious offences, official misconduct and/or official corruption by various people.(r)It is accepted that at the time of sending the seven letters the Respondent was overcome with strong emotions due to the mental health issues of his partner, and he was impacted by a number of stresses including the drought affecting rural Australia and his other community roles.(s)The Respondent was also impacted by witnessing the daily deterioration of his partner’s mental health.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 456 of the LP Act states:“456 Decisions of tribunal about an Australian legal practitioner(1)If, after the tribunal has completed a hearing of a discipline application in relation to a complaint or an investigation matter against an Australian legal practitioner, the tribunal is satisfied that the practitioner has engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct, the tribunal may make any order as it thinks fit, including any 1 or more of the orders stated in this section.(2)The tribunal may, under this subsection, make 1 or more of the following in a way it considers appropriate—(a) an order recommending that the name of the Australian legal practitioner be removed from the local roll;(b) an order that the practitioner’s local practising certificate be suspended for a stated period or cancelled;(c) an order that a local practising certificate not be granted to the practitioner before the end of a stated period;(d) an order that—(i)imposes stated conditions on the practitioner’s practising certificate granted or to be issued under this Act; and(ii) imposes the conditions for a stated period; and(iii) specifies the time, if any, after which the practitioner may apply to the tribunal for the conditions to be amended or removed;(e) an order publicly reprimanding the practitioner or, if there are special circumstances, privately reprimanding the practitioner;(f) an order that no law practice in this jurisdiction may, for a period stated in the order of not more than 5 years—(i) employ or continue to employ the practitioner in a law practice in this jurisdiction; or(ii) employ or continue to employ the practitioner in this jurisdiction unless the conditions of employment are subject to conditions stated in the order.(3)The tribunal may, under this subsection, make 1 or more of the following—(a) an order recommending that the name of the Australian legal practitioner be removed under a corresponding law from an interstate roll;(b) an order recommending that the practitioner’s interstate practising certificate be suspended for a stated period or cancelled under a corresponding law;(c) an order recommending that an interstate practising certificate not be, under a corresponding law, granted to the practitioner until the end of a stated period;(d) an order recommending—(i) that stated conditions be imposed on the practitioner’s interstate practising certificate; and(ii) that the conditions be imposed for a stated period; and(iii) a stated time, if any, after which the practitioner may apply to the tribunal for the conditions to be amended or removed.(4)The tribunal may, under this subsection, make 1 or more of the following—(a) an order that the Australian legal practitioner pay a penalty of a stated amount, not more than $100,000;(b) a compensation order; (c) an order that the practitioner undertake and complete a stated course of further legal education;(d) an order that, for a stated period, the practitioner engage in legal practice under supervision as stated in the order;(e) an order that the practitioner do or refrain from doing something in connection with the practitioner engaging in legal practice;(f) an order that the practitioner stop accepting instructions as a public notary in relation to notarial services;(g) an order that engaging in legal practice by the practitioner is to be managed for a stated period in a stated way or subject to stated conditions;(h) an order that engaging in legal practice by the practitioner is to be subject to periodic inspection by a person nominated by the relevant regulatory authority for a stated period;(i) an order that the practitioner seek advice from a stated person in relation to the practitioner’s management of engaging in legal practice;(j) an order that the practitioner must not apply for a local practising certificate for a stated period.(5)To remove any doubt, it is declared that the tribunal may make any number of orders mentioned in any or all of subsections (2), (3) and (4).(6)Also, the tribunal may make ancillary orders, including an order for payment by the Australian legal practitioner of expenses associated with orders under subsection (4), as assessed in or under the order or as agreed.(7)The tribunal may find a person has engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct even though the discipline application alleged professional misconduct.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The LSC’s submissions extract parts from the reports as to the significance of the risk of suicide and the deterioration of the Respondent’s partner’s mental health stability. Consideration There is a risk in effectively “cherry picking” extracts from the medical reports. This is particularly so where the unchallenged evidence of Dr Teoh in the 11 April 2023 report is:(a)The Respondent’s partner’s escalating anxious distress has previously been associated with an increase in her suicide risk; (b)That publishing the outcome of the discipline application would have a “very likely harmful impact on [the Respondent’s partner’s] mental state, progress and rehabilitation”; and(c)It is very likely that she will experience re-traumatization and significant deterioration in her mental state. The Tribunal has been referred to a number of cases where the Tribunal has been satisfied on the basis of evidence that a non-publication order should be made in circumstances where the evidence established the basis in s 66(2)(b) of the QCAT Act alone or in combination with s 656D of the LP Act, or in s 656D of the LP Act alone.[11][11]See for example Legal Services Commissioner v CBD [2011] QCAT 401, Legal Services Commissioner v XBY [2016] QCAT 102, Legal Services Commissioner v XBN [2016] QCAT 471, Legal Services Commissioner v XKR [2015] QCAT 469 and Legal Services Commissioner v XBT [2018] QCAT 64. The language in s 66 makes it clear that the person whose identity is to be protected may be a non-party. That is, it extends to those affected by a proceeding, not only those who are parties to a proceeding. The bases for the exercise of the power in s 66(2) of the QCAT Act are quite broad and cover distinct areas. There is also the basis of “for any other reason in the interest of justice” which provides a more general discretion. Section 656D of the LP Act provides a discretion that is not limited to defined bases. The case of Legal Services Commissioner v XBV [2018] QCAT 332 considers the interaction between s 66 of the QCAT Act and s 656D of the LP Act, and the effect of s 7 of the QCAT Act. Not all previous decisions have grappled with this issue. Section 7 of the QCAT Act provides:“7 Application of Act if modifying provision in enabling Act(1)This section applies if a provision of an enabling Act (the modifying provision) provides for—(a)the tribunal’s functions in jurisdiction conferred by the enabling Act; or(b)a matter mentioned in section 6(7).(2)The modifying provision prevails over the provisions of this Act, to the extent of any inconsistency between them.(3)This Act must be read, with any necessary changes, as if the modifying provision were a part of this Act.(4)Without limiting subsection (3)—(a)in a provision of this Act relating to a person starting a proceeding, a reference to the person doing something under this Act is taken to be a reference to the person doing the thing under this Act or a modifying provision; and(b)in a provision of this Act relating to the tribunal conducting a proceeding, a reference to the tribunal doing something under this Act is taken to be a reference to the tribunal doing the thing under this Act or a modifying provision.(5)This section does not prevent an enabling Act from expressly stating how this Act applies in relation to the modifying provision, including, for example, by stating that stated provisions of this Act do not apply, or apply subject to stated variations.(6)In this section—enabling Act means an enabling Act that is an Act.”