| CITATION: | Legal Services Commissioner v Scheiwe [2016] QCAT 414 |
| PARTIES: | Legal Services Commissioner (Applicant) | |
| v | ||
| Paula Elizabeth Scheiwe | ||
| APPLICATION NUMBER: | OCR017-14 | |
| MATTER TYPE: | Occupational Regulation Matter |
| HEARING DATE: | On the papers |
| HEARD AT: | Brisbane |
| DECISION OF: | Justice Carmody Assisted by: Ms Megan Mahon, Legal panel member Dr Margaret Steinberg, Lay panel member |
| DELIVERED ON: | 31 October 2016 |
| DELIVERED AT: | Brisbane |
| ORDERS MADE: | IT IS THE DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL THAT: 1. The publication of the psychiatric reports and/or any information in relation to the discipline application which would disclose details of Ms Scheiwe’s mental health condition is prohibited. 2. Ms Scheiwe is to be publicly reprimanded. 3. Ms Scheiwe is to pay the Legal Services Commissioner a pecuniary penalty of $2,000.00 within 6 months of the date of this order. 4. The following conditions are placed on any future practising certificate issued to Ms Scheiwe: (i) Ms Scheiwe may only be granted an employee-level practising certificate; (ii) Ms Scheiwe must obtain and provide to the Queensland Law Society a report from her employer detailing established supervision arrangements within four weeks of recommencing employment as a legal practitioner; (iii) Ms Scheiwe is subject to the following conditions for as long as she continues practising: (a) Ms Scheiwe must consult with her psychiatrist monthly for the first 12 months, and then at a frequency to be determined by the treating psychiatrist. (b) Ms Scheiwe must cooperate with the taking, or administering, of medication as prescribed by the treating psychiatrist. (c) Ms Scheiwe’s medication blood levels should be monitored by the treating psychiatrist whenever this is possible and meaningful at an interval of at least every 3-6 months or more frequently if clinically indicated. (d) Ms Scheiwe must provide consent for the Queensland Law Society to write to her treating psychiatrist and general practitioner to enquire into her treatment responsiveness and the progress of any treatment and for such medical practitioners to provide a written response to the enquiries. (e) Ms Scheiwe must consent to her treating psychiatrist and to her treating general practitioner providing the Queensland Law Society with short reports advising of any significant change in her mental state or treatment and details of her alcohol intake, monthly for the first 12 months and then as appropriate. (f) Ms Scheiwe must provide to the Queensland Law Society copies of any reports provided to the Mental Health Review Tribunal and/or Mental Health Court about her condition. (g) Ms Scheiwe must inform the Queensland Law Society of any admissions to any mental health facility as soon as possible after admission. (h) Ms Scheiwe must inform the Queensland Law Society if she should come to the attention of the police, even if such attention does not result in criminal charges. (i) Ms Scheiwe must inform the Queensland Law Society if she becomes subject to any legal action. (j) The Queensland Law Society determine the appropriate sanction should Ms Scheiwe fail to adhere to any conditions placed upon the maintenance of her practising certificate,… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Services Commissioner v Scheiwe and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] QCAT 414
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The tribunal examined the evidence and submissions presented, focusing on the nature and seriousness of the breaches, Ms Scheiwe’s conduct, and the impact on the legal profession and the public. It was noted that Ms Scheiwe had a mental health condition and had taken steps to address it, which influenced the tribunal's considerations. The tribunal concluded that the conduct did amount to unsatisfactory professional conduct and professional misconduct, warranting disciplinary action.
In light of the findings, the tribunal imposed several conditions on Ms Scheiwe’s practising certificate, including a public reprimand, a pecuniary penalty, and restrictions on the type of practising certificate she could hold. Further conditions included mandatory monthly consultations with her psychiatrist for the first year, ongoing supervision by an approved solicitor, and various reporting requirements to her treating psychiatrist and general practitioner. These measures aimed to ensure Ms Scheiwe's fitness to practise law and protect the public interest.
The tribunal issued orders prohibiting the publication of Ms Scheiwe’s mental health information, mandated a public reprimand, and imposed a pecuniary penalty. It also imposed detailed conditions on her practising certificate, including restrictions on the type of practising certificate, supervision by an approved solicitor, and ongoing reporting and consultation requirements. The tribunal empowered the Queensland Law Society to determine further sanctions if Ms Scheiwe failed to comply with the imposed conditions.
Orders
Orders of the court
IT IS THE DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL THAT:
1. The publication of the psychiatric reports and/or any information in relation to the discipline application which would disclose details of Ms Scheiwe’s mental health condition is prohibited.
2. Ms Scheiwe is to be publicly reprimanded.
3. Ms Scheiwe is to pay the Legal Services Commissioner a pecuniary penalty of $2,000.00 within 6 months of the date of this order.
4. The following conditions are placed on any future practising certificate issued to Ms Scheiwe:
(i) Ms Scheiwe may only be granted an employee-level practising certificate;
(ii) Ms Scheiwe must obtain and provide to the Queensland Law Society a report from her employer detailing established supervision arrangements within four weeks of recommencing employment as a legal practitioner;
(iii) Ms Scheiwe is subject to the following conditions for as long as she continues practising:
(a) Ms Scheiwe must consult with her psychiatrist monthly for the first 12 months, and then at a frequency to be determined by the treating psychiatrist.
(b) Ms Scheiwe must cooperate with the taking, or administering, of medication as prescribed by the treating psychiatrist.
(c) Ms Scheiwe’s medication blood levels should be monitored by the treating psychiatrist whenever this is possible and meaningful at an interval of at least every 3-6 months or more frequently if clinically indicated.
(d) Ms Scheiwe must provide consent for the Queensland Law Society to write to her treating psychiatrist and general practitioner to enquire into her treatment responsiveness and the progress of any treatment and for such medical practitioners to provide a written response to the enquiries.
(e) Ms Scheiwe must consent to her treating psychiatrist and to her treating general practitioner providing the Queensland Law Society with short reports advising of any significant change in her mental state or treatment and details of her alcohol intake, monthly for the first 12 months and then as appropriate.
(f) Ms Scheiwe must provide to the Queensland Law Society copies of any reports provided to the Mental Health Review Tribunal and/or Mental Health Court about her condition.
(g) Ms Scheiwe must inform the Queensland Law Society of any admissions to any mental health facility as soon as possible after admission.
(h) Ms Scheiwe must inform the Queensland Law Society if she should come to the attention of the police, even if such attention does not result in criminal charges.
(i) Ms Scheiwe must inform the Queensland Law Society if she becomes subject to any legal action.
(j) The Queensland Law Society determine the appropriate sanction should Ms Scheiwe fail to adhere to any conditions placed upon the maintenance of her practising certificate, which may include the cancelling or suspension of the practising certificate.
(iv) For the first 12 months of any return to legal practice, Ms Scheiwe be supervised by a solicitor approved by the Tribunal or by the Queensland Law Society.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi