Legal Services Commissioner v Puryer

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read
CITATION: Legal Services Commissioner v Puryer [2012] QCAT 48
PARTIES: Legal Services Commissioner
(Applicant/Appellant)
v
Terence Robert Puryer
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: LPD011-09
MATTER TYPE: Occupational regulation matters
HEARING DATE: 4 May 2011; and,
on the papers 13 September 2011
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Justice Alan Wilson, President
Assisted by:
Mr G Sinclair (Practitioner Panel Member)
Dr S Dann (Lay Panel Member)
DELIVERED ON: 2 February 2012
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    Charge 1 is dismissed;

2.    Charges 2 and 3 are upheld;

3.    The respondent’s name is to be removed from the roll; and,

4.    It is further ordered that the respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the second and third charges; and that, for the purpose of determining those costs:

a.    The applicant will, within 28 days, file and serve written submissions concerning the amount of its costs, and an affidavit showing their method of calculation; and,

b.    The respondent will file and serve any submissions and affidavits in reply within 28 days thereafter.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – LAWYERS – COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE – DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS – PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT – where the Commissioner filed a disciplinary application relating to three charges contending that the respondent misled the Supreme Court of Queensland and failed to meet his obligation of frankness and candour to the Supreme Court – where respondent contested the charges – where Tribunal dismissed charge one – where Tribunal found the respondent deliberately misled the Supreme Court of Queensland in relation to charge two – where the Tribunal found respondent failed to meet his obligation of frankness and candour in relation to charge three – appropriate penalty

Legal Profession Act 2007, ss 5, 417, 452, 462

Council of the Queensland Law Society Inc v Wakeling [2004] QCA 42 applied
Council of the Queensland Law Society v Wright [2001] QCA 58 applied
Legal Services Commissioner v Mullins [2006] LPT 012 cited
Legal Services Commissioner v Voll [2008] LPT 001 cited
Puryer v Webb & Ors [2008] QCA 246 discussed

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):

APPLICANT: Ms T Thomson of Counsel representing the Legal Services Commissioner
RESPONDENT: Mr Puryer in person

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Three charges are brought against Mr Puryer in a discipline application[1] originally commenced in the Supreme Court on 6 October 2009: that on two occasions on 13 December 2007 he misled the Supreme Court of Queensland (in the person of Daubney J); and, that on that day he failed to meet his obligation of frankness and candour to the Supreme Court.

    [1]        Legal Profession Act 2007, s 452.

  2. Although Mr Puryer does not hold a current practicing certificate from the Queensland Law Society and was not in practice as a solicitor in December 2007 (and, in the proceedings before Daubney J, appeared for himself as a party in those proceedings), he is amenable to the discipline application because he was still at that time an Australian Lawyer[2] and Chapter 4 of the Legal Profession Act 2007

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Services Commissioner v Puryer and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QCAT 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Services Commissioner filed a disciplinary application against Mr Puryer, alleging professional misconduct in relation to three charges arising from proceedings before the Supreme Court of Queensland. Mr Puryer contested the charges, leading to a hearing before the Tribunal. The Tribunal dismissed the first charge but upheld the second and third charges, finding that Mr Puryer deliberately misled the Supreme Court and failed to meet his obligation of frankness and candour. The Tribunal ordered that Mr Puryer's name be removed from the roll of legal practitioners and that he pay the Commissioner's costs associated with the second and third charges. The Commissioner was directed to file written submissions concerning the amount of costs, accompanied by an affidavit detailing the method of calculation, within 28 days. Mr Puryer was then required to file any submissions and affidavits in reply within 28 days after the Commissioner's filing.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether Mr Puryer's conduct amounted to professional misconduct under the Legal Profession Act 2007. The Commissioner argued that the three charges constituted professional misconduct, while Mr Puryer contested this, asserting that his actions were not misconduct. The Tribunal found that while the first charge was not substantiated, the second and third charges were valid, leading to the penalties imposed. The Tribunal's decision hinged on whether Mr Puryer's conduct was dishonest and whether it breached his duty of frankness and candour to the court.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal considered the evidence and submissions presented by both parties. It found that Mr Puryer's conduct in relation to the second charge demonstrated deliberate misleading of the Supreme Court, which constituted professional misconduct. Regarding the third charge, the Tribunal determined that Mr Puryer had failed to meet his obligation of frankness and candour, again amounting to professional misconduct. The Tribunal concluded that the appropriate penalty for these findings was the removal of Mr Puryer's name from the roll of legal practitioners. Furthermore, the Tribunal ordered that Mr Puryer pay the Commissioner's costs related to the second and third charges, establishing a timeline for the submission and response of cost details.

The final orders of the Tribunal were that the first charge was dismissed, while the second and third charges were upheld. Mr Puryer's name was to be removed from the roll of legal practitioners, and he was required to pay the Commissioner's costs associated with the second and third charges. The Commissioner was mandated to file written submissions and an affidavit detailing the method of cost calculation within 28 days, with Mr Puryer then required to respond within another 28 days. This comprehensive ruling addressed the misconduct allegations and set clear penalties and procedural requirements for the enforcement of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Charge 1 is dismissed;

2. Charges 2 and 3 are upheld;

3. The respondent’s name is to be removed from the roll; and,

4. It is further ordered that the respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the second and third charges; and that, for the purpose of determining those costs:

a. The applicant will, within 28 days, file and serve written submissions concerning the amount of its costs, and an affidavit showing their method of calculation; and,

b. The respondent will file and serve any submissions and affidavits in reply within 28 days thereafter.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is also to be noted, in connection with Chapter 4, that it has two key concepts[4], called unsatisfactory professional conduct and professional misconduct. The Commissioner accepts that because Mr Puryer was acting in a private capacity in the proceedings before Daubney J, this is not a case in which there could be a finding of the first kind – but contends that all three charges amount to professional misconduct.[4] Legal Profession Act 2007, ch 4 pt 4.2.The background to the charges The proceedings before Daubney J had a rather complex history. They arose out of Mr Puryer’s relationship with another person, and their shared obligations as tenants in residential premises under a 12 month lease beginning on 2 February 2006. The lease contained a term that each of them could, by notice in writing, exercise an option to renew the lease for a further 12 months. As explained in a decision of the Court of Appeal which was the genesis of the disciplinary action against Mr Puryer (Puryer v Webb & Ors [2008] QCA 246), the relationship ended in acrimonious circumstances in mid 2006, and on 12 July the co-tenant offered to pay to the letting agent of the lessor an amount representing 40% of the rental payable for the unexpired balance of the lease – an offer which reflected, the Court of Appeal said, the circumstance that up to that time she had contributed 40% to the outgoings for the house. On the same day, however, Mr Puryer purported to exercise the option to renew the lease from 3 February 2007 to 2 February 2008. His co-tenant notified Mr Puryer that she would not consent to any renewal of the lease. He remained in occupation of the house. The co-tenant then commenced proceedings in the Small Claims Tribunal seeking to be released from her obligations under the lease on the basis of excessive hardship: she alleged that she was adversely affected by a medical condition which was being exacerbated, she also alleged, by the stress of living with Mr Puryer. That was Small Claims Tribunal claim No 4011 of 2006. On 28 July 2006 the Small Claims Tribunal made an order ‘removing’ the co-tenant from the lease. The order was made without notice to Mr Puryer. On the same day, the co-tenant paid 40% of the rent payable until 2 February 2007 to the lessor’s leasing agent. Subsequently, in February 2007, the lease was terminated on the grounds of rental arrears in different Small Claims Tribunal proceedings (No 0450 of 2007) between the letting agent, and Mr Puryer. Some time earlier (on 26 August 2006) Mr Puryer had commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court for judicial review of the first decision of the Small Claims Tribunal ‘removing’ his former co-tenant from the lease. He sought to have that order quashed, or reconsidered. A directions hearing took place before Muir J on 22 December 2006, by which time Mr Puryer had obtained the co-tenant’s consent to abide the orders of the Court and, with one qualification, take no further part in the proceedings. Muir J ordered that the co-tenant produce some documents to Mr Puryer but, otherwise, she was granted leave to withdraw – with the reservation that her right to be heard on the question of costs was preserved.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.