Legal Services Commissioner v De Fraine

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Legal Services Commissioner v De Fraine [2024] QCAT 105

PARTIES:

LEGAL SERVICES COMMISSIONER

(applicant)

v

ANTHONY DE FRAINE

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR 175-23

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

22 March 2024

HEARING DATE:

7 March 2024

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Justice Williams

Assisted by:
Mr Ross Perrett, Practitioner Panel Member
Ms Patrice Lorraine McKay, Lay Panel Member

ORDERS:

1.     The Respondent is publicly reprimanded.

2.     The Respondent pay a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $2,000 to be paid within six (6) months.

3.     The Respondent pay the LSC’s costs of and incidental to the discipline application, to be assessed on the standard basis as if this were a proceeding before the Supreme Court of Queensland.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – LAWYERS – COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE – PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT – GENERALLY – where the applicant filed a disciplinary application made under s 452 Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) for the Tribunal to make disciplinary orders pursuant to s 456 Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) – where the subject of the disciplinary proceedings is the improper use of social media by legal practitioners – where the disciplinary conduct alleged is posting entries on the social media platform Facebook which are likely to bring the profession into disrepute – where the respondent accepts his conduct is appropriately characterised as unsatisfactory professional conduct – whether the relevant conduct is properly characterised as unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct – agreed proposed sanction – whether the agreed sanction is appropriate

Australian Solicitor Conduct Rules 2012 (Qld), rr 3, 5, 9, 28

Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld), ss 5(1), 6(1), 418, 419, 420, 423(2)(a)(i), 452, 456, 462

Adamson v Queensland Law Society Incorporated (1990) 1 Qd R 498
Legal Services Commission v De Fraine [2015] QCAT 292
Legal Services Commissioner v Bradshaw [2009] QCA 126
Legal Services Commissioner v Challen [2019] QCAT 273
Legal Services Commissioner v Laylee and Anor [2016] QCAT 237
Legal Services Commissioner v PRF [2023] QCAT 291

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

A Angeli, Legal Services Commission

Respondent:

The Respondent appeared in person.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This is a discipline application by the Legal Services Commissioner (LSC) under s 452 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) (LP Act) for disciplinary orders pursuant to s 456 of the LP Act. The discipline application raises a single charge against the respondent, Mr Anthony De Fraine (Respondent) of engaging in conduct which is likely to a material degree to bring the legal profession into disrepute. 

  2. The LSC and the Respondent have agreed the relevant facts in respect of the discipline application and the hearing proceeded on the basis of a statement of agreed facts dated 6 December 2023 (SOAF),[1] together with a Joint Submission on Sanction.[2]

    [1]Hearing Book (HB) pp. 62-64.

    [2]HB pp. 65-66.

  3. The Joint Submission on Sanction is on the basis that the Respondent’s conduct should be characterised as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Services Commissioner v De Fraine and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCAT 105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Services Commissioner (LSC) brought a disciplinary application against the respondent, De Fraine, alleging that he had engaged in improper use of social media in breach of professional standards. The Queensland Legal Services Tribunal (the Tribunal) was tasked with determining whether De Fraine's conduct amounted to unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct under the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) and, if so, to decide on an appropriate sanction. The respondent conceded that his conduct was appropriately characterised as unsatisfactory professional conduct.

The Tribunal considered the respondent's improper use of social media and its impact on the legal profession. The central legal issues were whether the respondent's conduct was properly classified as unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct and if the agreed sanction was suitable. The Tribunal reviewed the Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules (ASCR) and the Queensland Law Society's Guidance Statement No. 24 on ethical considerations in social media use, which although postdating the respondent's conduct, provided relevant insights.

The Tribunal concluded that the respondent's conduct was appropriately characterised as unsatisfactory professional conduct, not rising to the level of professional misconduct. The agreed sanction included a public reprimand and a pecuniary penalty of $2,000, along with an order for the respondent to pay the LSC’s costs. The Tribunal found the agreed sanction to be appropriate, considering the respondent's acceptance of responsibility and the need to uphold professional standards in the use of social media.

The Tribunal issued orders for the respondent to be publicly reprimanded, to pay a pecuniary penalty of $2,000 within six months, and to cover the LSC’s costs as if the proceeding had been before the Supreme Court of Queensland.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Respondent is publicly reprimanded.

2. The Respondent pay a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $2,000 to be paid within six (6) months.

3. The Respondent pay the LSC’s costs of and incidental to the discipline application, to be assessed on the standard basis as if this were a proceeding before the Supreme Court of Queensland.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 456 of the LP Act states:“456 Decisions of tribunal about an Australian legal practitioner(1)If, after the tribunal has completed a hearing of a discipline application in relation to a complaint or an investigation matter against an Australian legal practitioner, the tribunal is satisfied that the practitioner has engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct, the tribunal may make any order as it thinks fit, including any 1 or more of the orders stated in this section.(2)The tribunal may, under this subsection, make 1 or more of the following in a way it considers appropriate—(a) an order recommending that the name of the Australian legal practitioner be removed from the local roll;(b) an order that the practitioner’s local practising certificate be suspended for a stated period or cancelled;(c) an order that a local practising certificate not be granted to the practitioner before the end of a stated period;(d) an order that—(i)imposes stated conditions on the practitioner’s practising certificate granted or to be issued under this Act; and(ii) imposes the conditions for a stated period; and(iii) specifies the time, if any, after which the practitioner may apply to the tribunal for the conditions to be amended or removed;(e) an order publicly reprimanding the practitioner or, if there are special circumstances, privately reprimanding the practitioner;(f) an order that no law practice in this jurisdiction may, for a period stated in the order of not more than 5 years—(i) employ or continue to employ the practitioner in a law practice in this jurisdiction; or(ii) employ or continue to employ the practitioner in this jurisdiction unless the conditions of employment are subject to conditions stated in the order.(3)The tribunal may, under this subsection, make 1 or more of the following—(a) an order recommending that the name of the Australian legal practitioner be removed under a corresponding law from an interstate roll;(b) an order recommending that the practitioner’s interstate practising certificate be suspended for a stated period or cancelled under a corresponding law;(c) an order recommending that an interstate practising certificate not be, under a corresponding law, granted to the practitioner until the end of a stated period;(d) an order recommending—(i) that stated conditions be imposed on the practitioner’s interstate practising certificate; and(ii) that the conditions be imposed for a stated period; and(iii) a stated time, if any, after which the practitioner may apply to the tribunal for the conditions to be amended or removed.(4)The tribunal may, under this subsection, make 1 or more of the following—(a) an order that the Australian legal practitioner pay a penalty of a stated amount, not more than $100,000;(b) a compensation order; (c) an order that the practitioner undertake and complete a stated course of further legal education;(d) an order that, for a stated period, the practitioner engage in legal practice under supervision as stated in the order;(e) an order that the practitioner do or refrain from doing something in connection with the practitioner engaging in legal practice;(f) an order that the practitioner stop accepting instructions as a public notary in relation to notarial services;(g) an order that engaging in legal practice by the practitioner is to be managed for a stated period in a stated way or subject to stated conditions;(h) an order that engaging in legal practice by the practitioner is to be subject to periodic inspection by a person nominated by the relevant regulatory authority for a stated period;(i) an order that the practitioner seek advice from a stated person in relation to the practitioner’s management of engaging in legal practice;(j) an order that the practitioner must not apply for a local practising certificate for a stated period.(5)To remove any doubt, it is declared that the tribunal may make any number of orders mentioned in any or all of subsections (2), (3) and (4).(6)Also, the tribunal may make ancillary orders, including an order for payment by the Australian legal practitioner of expenses associated with orders under subsection (4), as assessed in or under the order or as agreed.(7)The tribunal may find a person has engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct even though the discipline application alleged professional misconduct.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There are other rules in the ASCR which may be relevant to the conduct being currently considered. These include Rules 3, 9 and 28 which state as follows:“3. Paramount duty to the court and the administration of justice3.1A solicitor’s duty to the court and the administration of justice is paramount and prevails to the extent of inconsistency with any other duty.…9. Confidentiality9.1A solicitor must not disclose any information which is confidential to a client and acquired by the solicitor during the client’s engagement to any person who is not:9.1.1a solicitor who is a partner, principal, director, or employee of a solicitor’s law practice; or9.1.2a barrister or an employee of, or a person otherwise engaged by, the solicitors law practice or by an associated entity for the purposes of delivering or administering legal services in relation to the client, EXCEPT as permitted in Rule 9.2.9.2A solicitor may disclose confidential client information if:9.2.1the client expressly or impliedly authorises disclosure;9.2.2the solicitor is permitted or is compelled by law to disclose;9.2.3the solicitor discloses the information in a confidential setting, for the sole purpose of obtaining advice in connection with the solicitor’s legal or ethical obligations;9.2.4the solicitor discloses the information for the sole purpose of avoiding the probable commission of a serious criminal offence; 9.2.5the solicitor discloses the information for the purpose of preventing imminent serious physical harm to the client or to other persons; or9.2.6the information is disclosed to the insurer of the solicitor, law practice or associated entity.…28 . Public comment during current proceedings28.1A solicitor must not publish or take steps towards the publication of any material concerning the current proceedings which may prejudice a fair trial or the administration of justice.” The ASCR are sufficiently broad to cover conduct involving statements on social media, as well as traditional media. The LSC confirmed in oral submissions that possible contraventions of Rules 3, 9 and 28 were considered and may in certain circumstances be relevant to the proper characterisation of conduct involving publishing information and comments on social media. However, the charge was framed as a breach of Rule 5.1.2 taking into account all of the facts and circumstances, including the response provided by the respondent. The Queensland Law Society (QLS) has released Guidance Statement No. 24 in relation to ‘Ethical considerations on the use of social media and law practice websites’ (Guidance Statement). This was released on 23 August 2021, which post-dates the subject conduct. However, the Guidance Statement does provide some assistance. The Guidance Statement discusses the practical ethical issues which arise and also provides some suggested “good practice” in respect of these issues and avoiding potential “pitfalls”. The Guidance Statement includes the following:“The unique characteristics of social media have transformed the way in which solicitors interact with clients, colleagues, courts and the community … Practitioners need to be aware of the risks involved in the use of social media, and the higher standard expected of officers of the court when engaging on social media platforms (whether that engagement is in connection with their practice or is done in a personal capacity, and regardless of whether or not a pseudonym/avatar is used).[11][11]Richard Miles Esq, PC 2018/0372/D5 (The Bar Tribunals & Adjudication Service, HH Michael Topolski QC, 18 November 2019).3. Issues3.1 Ethical duties applyDue to the potential of anonymity, social media users sometimes act as if they are unregulated in their use and may feel the usual rules do not apply.Regardless of the platform used, the jurisdiction in which it is hosted or the ability to anonymise a user’s identity, solicitors remain beholden to their ethical duties in the same way that they are in any other forum. A solicitor must not use social networking sites at any time (whether during or outside work hours) to discriminate, harass, bully or victimise employees, clients or contractors of the solicitor. Breaches of duties which occur on social media platforms or cyber-space are punishable in the same way as breaches which occur in the physical world.[12]3.2 Officer of the CourtAs officers of the court, solicitors have less leeway than laypeople when utilising social media. While social media generally involves a less formal and more robust level of engagement, solicitors remain officers of the court even when engaging on such platforms and should refrain from adopting a lower standard of conduct.3.3 Reputational riskPractitioners should bear in mind that messages and comments posted on social media platforms may remain accessible for the life of the platform, and often longer. They can be shared or screen-shotted; once posted, such comments are difficult if not impossible to control.Colleagues, clients, potential clients and even members of the bench may become aware of comments and posts made by practitioners. The possibility for reputational damage, to a firm, individual practitioner, or indeed the profession as a whole is real and not remote.3.4 Contempt/disreputeSocial media activity has no exemption from the laws of contempt or the duty to avoid bringing the profession into disrepute. Practitioners should refrain from providing any running commentary or comment on social media in relation to active files, whether before the court or otherwise.[12]Richard Miles Esq, PC 2018/0372/D5 (The Bar Tribunals & Adjudication Service, HH Michael Topolski QC, 18 November 2019).3.5 ConfidentialityThe duty to maintain client confidentiality extends to activity on social media, and practitioners should be aware of the fact that confidentiality can be breached more easily when using social media. For lawyers, the very act of updating their status or tweeting their own or their clients’ whereabouts can result in a breach of this duty.Prior to any social media activity, lawyers should consider whether or not they are divulging sufficient information to breach client confidentiality. For example there are seemingly innocent posts such as:·tweeting a photo of a solicitor and client outside a magistrate’s court, on the day of the criminal court sittings, with the comment ‘great result today!’;·a solicitor posting their joy at securing a particular client; ·a post about an important meeting, with a photo of the building in which the meeting is taking place;·a photo of a client with a solicitor at a social event, whether or not that event is hosted by the solicitor.Each of these scenarios could result in a breach of confidentiality, by revealing the client, the nature of the work being done or through telegraphing a client’s likely intent. While a client can authorise such disclosures by providing their informed consent beforehand, great caution is advised, especially when acting for clients who may not be able to fully comprehend or appreciate the consequences of giving consent. Photos of clients should never be posted without their express consent.”