Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Scragg

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v SCRAGG

[2023] SASC 179

Decision of Judge Dart a Master of the Supreme Court  

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COSTS - GENERAL MATTERS - NATURE OF COSTS: INDEMNITY DOCTRINE - APPLICATION TO PARTICULAR PERSON OR PARTY - SALARIED OFFICER OF CROWN OR STATUTORY AUTHORITY

Respondent instituted an appeal in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal - appeal dismissed - Tribunal awarded costs to the applicant - applicant has made a claim for costs on the Higher Courts costs scale - costs are an indemnity - applicant was represented in the appeal by employed solicitors - respondent says a true indemnity would occur if costs allowed on the hourly salary of the employed solicitors - in the circumstances appropriate to tax on the Higher Courts costs scale.

Held:

1. Taxation to proceed on the Higher Courts costs scale.

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA); Crown Proceedings Act 1992 (SA), referred to.
Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) 193 CLR 72; Bell Lawyers Pty Ltd v Pentelow [2019] HCA 29; London Scottish Benefit Society v Chorley (1884) 13 QBD 872; Guneser v Aitken Partners Pty Ltd [2020] VSC 329; Far West Coast Native Title Claim v State of South Australia (No 8) [2014] FCA 635; Mancorp Pty Ltd v Baulderstone Hornibrook (1993) 169 LSJS 165, considered.

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v SCRAGG
[2023] SASC 179

  1. This matter involves an issue that has arisen in a taxation of costs. Central to the awarding of costs in a civil dispute is the concept that such costs are awarded to indemnify a party against the legal costs incurred in a proceeding. The respondent here has put in issue what the appropriate amount of costs required to satisfy the indemnity is. The applicant used legal practitioners employed in his office and did not incur external legal costs.

    Background

  2. The applicant is a statutory officer.[1] He is not, unlike many other commissioners appointed by the government, an agency of the Crown.[2] He runs an office and employs a number of legal practitioners.

    [1] The office is created by s 71 of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981.

  3. The applicant undertook an investigation into the conduct of the respondent and made findings adverse to him. A sanction was imposed on the respondent.

  4. A practitioner who is dissatisfied with a determination of the Commissioner has a right of appeal. The appeal lies to the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. The respondent pursued an appeal. The right of appeal arises from the following section of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981:

    77K—Appeal against determination of Commissioner

    (1) Subject to subsection (3), an appeal to the Tribunal against a determination of the Commissioner under section 77J(1)(a) or (3)(a)(i) may be instituted by—

    (a)     the legal practitioner or former legal practitioner in relation to whom the determination was made; or

    (b)     the complainant.

    (2) Subject to subsection (3),…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Scragg and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 179
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved an application by the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner for taxation of costs following a disciplinary investigation and appeal. The Commissioner, who is a statutory officer, conducted an investigation into the conduct of the respondent and imposed a sanction. The respondent appealed the Commissioner's determination to the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. The central issue was whether the Commissioner was entitled to claim costs on the Higher Courts costs scale, or whether this would result in overcompensation under the indemnity principle. The Commissioner did not incur external legal costs as he employs in-house legal practitioners.

The court considered whether the Commissioner could claim costs on the Higher Courts scale or whether this would result in overcompensation. The court noted that if the Commissioner was not entitled to claim on the Higher Courts scale, then a forensic accountant would need to be retained to determine the true costs incurred. However, the costs of obtaining such a report would likely exceed the total amount of costs claimed. The court held that in the circumstances of this matter, the interests of justice were satisfied by allowing the Commissioner to claim costs on the Higher Courts scale. The court found that the big picture issue of how the costs of a government body calculated on the court scale can be squared against the indemnity principle could await a more suitable case.

The court ordered that the taxation of costs was to proceed on the basis that the Commissioner could claim costs on the Higher Courts scale. The Commissioner was thus entitled to recover the costs claimed on that basis. The respondent's contention that this would result in overcompensation was rejected given the modest amount claimed and the impracticality of obtaining a forensic report to determine true costs. The interests of justice were held to be satisfied by allowing the Commissioner to proceed with its costs claim on the court scale.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This matter involves an issue that has arisen in a taxation of costs. Central to the awarding of costs in a civil dispute is the concept that such costs are awarded to indemnify a party against the legal costs incurred in a proceeding. The respondent here has put in issue what the appropriate amount of costs required to satisfy the indemnity is. The applicant used legal practitioners employed in his office and did not incur external legal costs. Background The applicant is a statutory officer.[1] He is not, unlike many other commissioners appointed by the government, an agency of the Crown.[2] He runs an office and employs a number of legal practitioners. [1] The office is created by s 71 of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981.[2] Crown Proceedings Regulations 2023. The applicant undertook an investigation into the conduct of the respondent and made findings adverse to him. A sanction was imposed on the respondent. A practitioner who is dissatisfied with a determination of the Commissioner has a right of appeal. The appeal lies to the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. The respondent pursued an appeal. The right of appeal arises from the following section of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981:77K—Appeal against determination of Commissioner (1) Subject to subsection (3), an appeal to the Tribunal against a determination of the Commissioner under section 77J(1)(a) or (3)(a)(i) may be instituted by— (a) the legal practitioner or former legal practitioner in relation to whom the determination was made; or (b) the complainant. (2) Subject to subsection (3), an appeal to the Tribunal against a determination of the Commissioner under section 77J(1)(b), (2) or (3)(a)(ii) or (b) after conducting an investigation into the conduct of a legal practitioner or former legal practitioner following receipt of a complaint may be instituted by the person who made the complaint. (3) An appeal must be instituted within 1 month of the date on which the appellant is notified of the determination unless the Tribunal is satisfied that there is good reason to dispense with the requirement that the appeal should be so instituted. (3a) Subject to subsections (3b) and (3c), the Tribunal will, in exercising its review jurisdiction, examine the determination of the Commissioner by way of rehearing. (3b) On a rehearing, the Tribunal must reach the correct or preferable decision but in doing so must have regard to, and give appropriate weight to, the determination of the Commissioner. (3c) A procedure on a rehearing will include— (a) an examination of the evidence or material before the Commissioner (unless any such evidence or material is to be excluded under another provision of this Act or under any other law); and (b) a consideration of any further evidence or material that the Tribunal decides, in the circumstances of the particular case, to admit for the purposes of rehearing the matter. (4) The Tribunal may, on the hearing of the appeal— (a) affirm, vary, quash or reverse the determination subject to the appeal and administer any reprimand, or make any order, that should have been administered or made in the first instance; and (b) make such orders as to costs as it considers appropriate. (5) Section 85(2) to (4) (inclusive) apply in relation to an order as to costs made under subsection (4).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

All that is required in the present case is to determine if the costs can appropriately be taxed on the scale. For the reasons that follow, they can be. The big picture issue of how the costs of a government body calculated on the court scale can be squared against the indemnity principle can await a more suitable case.Consideration The respondent says that the applicant is not entitled to claim on the Higher Courts costs scale because that would result in overcompensation. There is a difficulty in this case because the amount claimed is very modest. The applicant, assuming the respondent’s contention to be correct or at least arguably correct, would have to retain a forensic accountant to establish the true costs incurred in the matter. The costs of that exercise would form part of the costs of the taxation. The costs of obtaining such a report is likely to exceed the total amount of costs claimed in this matter. In the circumstances of this matter, the interests of justice are satisfied by allowing the applicant to make its claim for costs on the Higher Courts costs scale. The taxation is to proceed on that basis.