Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Romano

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v ROMANO

[2017] SASCFC 167

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Blue and The Honourable Justice Parker)

19 December 2017

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT - FALSIFICATION OF DOCUMENTS AND TRANSACTIONS

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEEDINGS IN TRIBUNALS

Appeal by the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner against a decision of the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (the Tribunal).

The practitioner was charged with unprofessional conduct in that on four occasions she made representations to the Legal Services Commission in relation to the grant of a legal aid assignment for her client when she knew or ought to have known that those representations were false. The four representations included two letters in which the practitioner represented that she was acting for a client on criminal charges when in fact the charges had long since been withdrawn and two commitment certificates signed by the practitioner claiming $929.50 for a psychology report which was not obtained and $144.10 for attending a pre-trial conference which did not occur in relation to that client.

The Tribunal found the practitioner not guilty of unprofessional conduct and declined to proceed with an inquiry into whether she was nonetheless guilty of unsatisfactory conduct on the basis that it was not charged in the alternative and that further written particulars were required from the Commissioner. The Commissioner appeals against the decision of the Tribunal and seeks an order that the practitioner be found guilty of unprofessional conduct. Alternatively, the Commissioner contends that the Tribunal wrongly failed to proceed to consider whether the practitioner was guilty of unsatisfactory conduct.

Held per Curiam:

1.       On the favourable findings of fact concerning the practitioner’s knowledge and belief made by the Tribunal, the practitioner was not guilty of unprofessional conduct (at [64]-[65]).

2. The Tribunal’s decision declining to conclude its inquiry into whether the practitioner was guilty of unsatisfactory conduct was vitiated by error. The Commissioner was not bound to provide any further particulars because the particulars of the conduct which was unsatisfactory were materially the same as the particulars for the alleged unprofessional conduct. The Tribunal proceeded on the erroneous view that the Commissioner could abrogate the Tribunal’s duty pursuant to s 82(8) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) to consider whether or not the practitioner was guilty of unsatisfactory conduct by declining to further prosecute the charges (at [76]-[79]).

3.       The practitioner was guilty of unsatisfactory conduct. The practitioner’s failure to properly examine and remind herself of the circumstances of the file on which the claim was made was a gross departure of the standard of professional work expected of a legal practitioner. The practitioner’s failure facilitated the making of a claim on the limited public resources of the Legal Services Commission for legal work she had not performed and for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Romano and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASCFC 167
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner appealed to the Supreme Court of South Australia against a decision of the Disciplinary Tribunal. The appeal concerned allegations of unsatisfactory professional conduct against Ms Romano, a solicitor, relating to her handling of two legal aid matters. The Tribunal had adjourned its inquiry into the allegations, prompting the Commissioner's appeal.

The central legal issues before the Supreme Court were whether the Tribunal had erred in adjourning its inquiry and whether Ms Romano's conduct, as evidenced by her own admissions and the documentary evidence, amounted to unsatisfactory professional conduct. The Court also considered the jurisdictional basis for the Tribunal's decisions and the scope of a solicitor's duty when submitting claims for legal aid.

The Court reasoned that the Tribunal had erred in adjourning its inquiry, as Ms Romano's own evidence demonstrated a level of carelessness that constituted unsatisfactory conduct, and there was no need for further particulars from the Commissioner. The Court held that while solicitors may delegate routine administrative tasks, signing correspondence that reports on a client's medical condition and the progress of criminal proceedings, and which seeks an extension of a legal aid assignment, requires more than a cursory review. Furthermore, the Court found that a solicitor has a duty to ensure that any claim for payment, including legal aid certificates, accurately reflects work actually done and is fair and reasonable. Ms Romano's failure to apply her mind to the claims she certified and submitted meant that her conduct was unsatisfactory in relation to all particulars.

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, made a finding of unsatisfactory conduct against Ms Romano in relation to all charged particulars, and remitted the matter to the Tribunal for the determination of penalty.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is an implicit condition of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction pursuant to s 82 of the LP Act that it accord the parties procedural fairness. It is also necessarily implicit in s 82(4) of the LP Act that the Tribunal will not decline to exercise its jurisdiction for an extraneous reason. The Tribunal’s decisions on those questions are jurisdictional. Whether or not the Tribunal is authorised to determine those questions finally for itself need not be decided. It is sufficient to hold, consistently with the judgment of this Court in O’Dea, that decisions of that kind are decisions for the purposes of s 86 of the LP Act. Accordingly, a decision to continue an inquiry in a way which necessarily and finally denies procedural fairness is a decision for the purposes of s 86 of the LP Act. So too is a failure to continue an inquiry when there is no proper reason to do so. The Commissioner’s appeal is therefore competent.The evidence On 24 April 2008 Andersons opened a file for a client Ms G on six charges of obtaining Centrelink payments knowing or believing that she was not eligible to receive them contrary to s 135.2(1) of the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth). The cover sheet of the file records that it was a criminal legal aid matter and that Ms Romano was the solicitor charged with its conduct. A letter under Ms Romano’s name, but apparently signed by another person, probably Ms Boyne, was forwarded to the LSC on 24 April 2008 seeking a grant of aid for Ms G. On 8 May 2008 a grant of aid in the sum of $450, equally divided between solicitor and counsel work, was granted for guilty pleas in the Magistrates Court. By letter dated 3 March 2009, apparently signed by Ms Romano, Andersons sought a psychological from Dr White. Ms G was seen by Dr White on the same day. He provided the report and sent an invoice, dated 10 March 2009, charging a GST inclusive fee of $929.50. The invoice was numbered 80162 and bore the reference number 2522. Ms G’s matter was heard and she received a suspended sentence. Ms Romano completed an LSC commitment certificate on 11 April 2012 claiming the sum of $450 and certifying that the claim ‘is correct and accurately reflects services undertaken’. Andersons opened a ‘criminal legal aid’ file for Ms M on 7 July 2011 (the Andersons File or the File). The Andersons File was admitted into evidence but Ms Romano testified that it did not appear to be complete. The File was assigned to Ms Romano. The administrative assistant responsible for the File is recorded as Ms Boyne. Ms M was charged on complaint with offences of:·disorderly behaviour;·assaulting a member of the police force;·resisting a member of the police force. On the same day, Andersons wrote to the LSC seeking a grant of aid with respect to Ms M. The letter informed the LSC that Ms M was of Filipino nationality and would require an interpreter. On 13 July 2011, the LSC granted aid to Ms M on the charges of assaulting police and resisting arrest and made a legal aid assignment to Andersons for a Magistrates Court guilty plea in the sum of $240 for solicitor work and $240 for counsel work.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This was not a case in which in the exercise of the Tribunal’s discretion it might require the provision of further particulars. The question was whether on Ms Romano’s own evidence she had admitted to a level of carelessness which amounted to unsatisfactory conduct. There was no ground whatsoever on which to require the Commission to furnish further particulars. For this reason too, the Tribunal erred in adjourning its inquiry.Conclusion A solicitor may properly delegate responsibility for preparing simple correspondence on routine administrative matters to an assistant. Signing correspondence of that kind after only briefly perusing it is not unsatisfactory conduct. The letter of 13 March 2012 was not correspondence of that kind. The letter reported on Ms M’s medical conditions and the progress of her criminal proceedings. It sought an extension of a legal aid assignment. Even though the assignment itself cannot result in a payment unless and until the commitment certificates are completed, it creates an imposition on the commitment budget of the LSC. We therefore find Ms Romano guilty of unsatisfactory conduct in relation to the first particular because she signed the 13 March 2012 letter. The question of whether Ms Romano had engaged in unsatisfactory conduct in relation to the other charged particulars and the representations there made to the LSC could only be answered in one way. The rendering of an account or claim for payment by a solicitor cannot, as is sometimes the case in the commercial world, be an ambit claim submitted with only the financial interests of the legal practitioner in mind. A legal practitioner is duty bound, whether a client requires a formal certificate of the kind used by the LSC or not, to pay close attention to his or her account to ensure that only a fair and reasonable claim for work actually done is submitted. Ms Romano should not have completed the certificate and drafted the letter making the claim on the assignment without actively turning her mind to the matter on which the claim was made. If Ms Romano had taken the time to do so, on an occasion when she was not, as the Tribunal appears to have found, hopelessly distracted, and had turned her attention mindfully to the file, she would have inevitably realised that the claim was a false one. Ms Romano’s conduct was unsatisfactory. We:1allow the appeal;2make a finding of unsatisfactory conduct in relation to all particulars;3remit the matter to the Tribunal to determine penalty.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.