Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Mancini

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v MANCINI

[2018] SASCFC 29

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Kelly, The Honourable Justice Blue and The Honourable Justice Parker)

2 May 2018

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEEDINGS IN TRIBUNALS

Appeal by Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner against findings by Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal that practitioner not guilty of professional misconduct but guilty of unsatisfactory professional conduct.

In February 2015 the practitioner sent certified commitment certificates to the Legal Services Commission claiming payment for a pretrial conference and guilty pleas and counsel fees in respect of his client KC.  He had not in fact attended at any hearing of the matter and had not attended a pretrial conference or the hearing at which KC pleaded guilty and was sentenced. The practitioner was charged with one count of making false representations (count 1) and one count of claiming fees to which he knew or should reasonably have known he was not entitled (count 6).  His defence was that he had done the work necessary for each court appearance including providing advice to KC and communicating with the court including making written submissions on sentence.

On 22 January 2015 the practitioner attended at the Magistrates Court in relation to charges against his clients SG and BJ. The practitioner had been told two days earlier that the prosecution would withdraw the charges.  The charges were dismissed upon the prosecution tendering no evidence.  The practitioner caused to be sent emails to the Legal Services Commission requesting funding for each matter.  He did not disclose that the charges were about to be dismissed. 

The Commissioner alleged that by each email the practitioner made a false representation that the matter was still pending (counts 2 and 4) and in respect of BJ that the practitioner claimed fees to which he was not entitled (count 7). The practitioner’s defence was that that he believed that the Commission from time to time exercised a discretion to grant retrospective funding.

On 23 January 2015 the Commission wrote to the practitioner authorising him to represent SG in the District Court on a plea of guilty.  On 29 January the practitioner wrote to the Commission enclosing a certified commitment certificate and case finalisation form.  The commitment certificate did not state that the matter had been finalised in the Magistrates’ Court or by way of withdrawal as opposed to a guilty plea.  The case finalisation form showed in handwriting the Court in which finalised as “AMC” and finalisation as “withdrawn or nolle to all charges”.  It showed the date of finalisation as 24 January.  The Commissioner alleged that the practitioner made false representations by the commitment certificate that he had attended at the District Court to finalise the matter and by the case finalisation form that the matter had been finalised on 24 January 2015 (count 3) and claimed fees to which he was not entitled (count…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Mancini and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASCFC 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia against a decision of the Legal Practitioners Conduct Tribunal. The Commissioner contended that the Tribunal's reasoning in accepting the practitioner's evidence as honest was generic and did not adequately disclose the factual basis for its conclusion that the practitioner's conduct amounted only to "unsatisfactory professional conduct". The practitioner had previously been found guilty of unprofessional conduct for making false and misleading statements to a psychologist, which resulted in a suspension of his practising certificate that was later varied by this Court to a three-year supervision requirement. The conduct under review occurred while the practitioner was subject to this supervision and also involved conditions imposed by the Legal Services Commission relating to his eligibility to work under legal aid grants.

The legal issues before the Full Court concerned the adequacy of the Tribunal's reasons for its findings, particularly in relation to charges of professional misconduct. The Court was required to determine whether the Tribunal had properly considered the evidence and articulated the factual findings upon which its conclusions were based, especially concerning allegations of dishonesty and the classification of the practitioner's conduct. The Court also had to consider the appropriate course of action for charges where the Tribunal's reasoning was found to be deficient.

The Full Court allowed the appeal, finding that the Tribunal's reasoning in accepting the practitioner's evidence was vitiated by a lack of specificity, mirroring issues identified in previous findings. Consequently, the Court set aside the Tribunal's findings on certain counts. In lieu of those findings, the Court substituted findings that the practitioner was guilty of professional misconduct in relation to counts 1, 2, and 4. The remaining counts were remitted to a differently constituted Tribunal for a fresh hearing and determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Commissioner contends that the reasoning of the Tribunal in accepting the practitioner’s evidence as honest took only a generic approach to the charges with the consequence that its reasons do not adequately disclose on which facts it ultimately based its conclusion that the conduct of the practitioner was only “unsatisfactory professional conduct”. Background Disciplinary proceedings have previously been brought against the practitioner. Those proceedings are summarised in the reasons for judgment of this Court in Mancini v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board.[2] [2] [2014] SASCFC 31. In April 2013 the Tribunal found the practitioner guilty of unprofessional conduct by making false and misleading statements to an expert psychologist retained by him and which the practitioner admitted. The Tribunal suspended his entitlement to hold a practising certificate for two months. In April 2014 this Court allowed the practitioner’s appeal against the suspension of his practising certificate. This Court ordered that it be a condition of the practitioner’s entitlement to practise the profession of the law that he be under supervision for three years by a legal practitioner approved by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board. Mr Ward was appointed as the practitioner’s supervisor for this purpose. The practitioner was under supervision at the time of the conduct which was the subject of the charges relevant to this appeal. In July 2014 the Commission introduced a new regime under which a practitioner was required to be a member of the relevant panel to be eligible to work under a grant of legal aid. The Criminal Law Panels comprised a General Panel and a Complex Panel. The practitioner’s original application for inclusion on these panels was unsuccessful. His appeal within the Commission against that rejection was successful in December 2014. On 31 December 2014 the Commission and the practitioner entered into a General Panel Agreement in standard terms. In addition, ten specific conditions were imposed that applied only to the practitioner. Those conditions included that the practitioner would observe his obligations under section 22(1)(a) of the Legal Services Commission of South Australia Act 1977 (SA) to disclose to the Commission any information relating to the provision of legal assistance to assisted persons that the Commission may require (condition 2.6 and 7) and that the practitioner would provide sufficient information relating to the merits of an application for a grant of legal aid, or extension of a grant, to support certification of merit (condition 10). The charges Each charge contained detailed factual particulars of the conduct alleged to constitute the charge. The nine counts particularised on the charge sheet can conveniently be grouped as follows.KC’s matter Counts 1 and 6 related to a client of the practitioner with the initials KC. KC was charged in the Murray Bridge Magistrates Court on complaint with driving under disqualification and two more minor traffic offences committed in December 2012, and on information with aggravated assault, criminal damage and a more minor offence committed in August 2013.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In relation to the question whether the practitioner claimed fees to which he knew he was not entitled, on the one hand the Tribunal’s finding of lack of dishonesty is vitiated for the same reasons as in respect of counts 3 and 5. On the other hand, this Court not having heard or seen the practitioner give evidence is not in a position to make findings concerning these questions. Counts 6 to 9 must be remitted to the Tribunal for fresh hearing and determination.Conclusion We allow the appeal. We set aside the findings of the Tribunal. In lieu of the findings on counts 1, 2 and 4, we substitute findings that the practitioner was guilty of professional misconduct. We remit the remaining counts to a differently constituted Tribunal for fresh hearing and determination.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.