Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Power

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS CONDUCT BOARD v POWER

[2013] SASCFC 118

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Sulan, The Honourable Justice Anderson and The Honourable Justice Blue)

31 October 2013

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT - GENERALLY

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - ORDERS

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - QUALIFICATIONS AND ADMISSION - FIT AND PROPER PERSONS

The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board applies to the Supreme Court for an order that the name of the practitioner, Anthony Kurt Power, be struck off the Roll of Legal Practitioners. This follows a recommendation by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal that disciplinary proceedings be commenced against the practitioner in this Court.

The practitioner was charged by the Board with unprofessional conduct as he committed offences for which punishment by imprisonment is prescribed by law. These offences included indecent filming, indecent filming of a minor on a number of occasions and being in possession of child pornography. These facts are not in dispute and the practitioner pleaded guilty to all charges and was convicted in the District Court.

The practitioner opposes the order sought by the Board. He submits that he should be suspended with retrospective operation to 10 March 2010, the day he ceased to practise. He submits in the alternative that he should be suspended for a future period but taking into account the time he has been without a practising certificate.

Held (by the Court): The unprofessional conduct warrants the removal of the pracitioner's name from the Roll of Practitioners (at [39-[40]).

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA); Summary Offences Act 1935 (SA), referred to.
A Solicitor v The Council of the Law Society of New South Wales (2003) 216 CLR 253; In re a Practitioner (1984) 36 SASR 590, discussed.

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS CONDUCT BOARD v POWER
[2013] SASCFC 118

Full Court:  Sulan, Anderson and Blue JJ

  1. THE COURT: The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (“the Board”) seeks an order that the name of the practitioner, Anthony Kurt Power, be struck off the Roll of Legal Practitioners pursuant to s 89(2)(d) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) (“the Act”). This follows a recommendation by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) pursuant to s 82(6)(a)(v) and s 89(1) of the Act that disciplinary proceedings be commenced against the practitioner in this Court.

  2. The practitioner concedes that his conduct was unprofessional but opposes the order sought by the Board. He argues that a strike off order should not be made but that he should be suspended with retrospective operation to 10 March 2010, the day he ceased practice. In the alternative he argues that he should be suspended for a future period but taking into account the time he has been without a practising certificate.

    Background

  3. The practitioner was charged by the Board with unprofessional conduct on the basis that he committed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Power and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] SASCFC 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board brought disciplinary proceedings against a legal practitioner in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The practitioner was charged with unprofessional conduct due to convictions for offences of an infamous nature, specifically the indecent filming of a minor on multiple occasions and possession of child pornography. The practitioner conceded his conduct was unprofessional but argued against a strike-off order, proposing instead a period of suspension.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the practitioner's unprofessional conduct, arising from his criminal convictions, was of such a character as to warrant the removal of his name from the Roll of Practitioners. The Court was required to consider the public interest, the protection of the public, and the administration of justice, rather than solely the punishment of the practitioner.

The Court reasoned that while the practitioner's criminal conduct did not directly relate to his legal competence, it revealed significant character defects that impacted his fitness to remain a member of the legal profession. The Court applied principles established in cases concerning criminal convictions and professional misconduct, noting that such conduct can damage the essential relationships of trust and confidence within the profession and erode public confidence in the legal system. The Court emphasised that the legal profession holds a position of significant trust, and allowing a practitioner with such serious and recent convictions to remain a member would diminish the standing and reputation of the profession in the eyes of the public.

The Court ordered that the practitioner's name be removed from the Roll of Practitioners, finding that his unprofessional conduct warranted this severe disciplinary action to protect the public and uphold the integrity of the legal profession.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held (by the Court): The unprofessional conduct warrants the removal of the pracitioner's name from the Roll of Practitioners (at [39-[40]).

Background

Background to the litigation

The practitioner concedes that his conduct was unprofessional but opposes the order sought by the Board. He argues that a strike off order should not be made but that he should be suspended with retrospective operation to 10 March 2010, the day he ceased practice. In the alternative he argues that he should be suspended for a future period but taking into account the time he has been without a practising certificate.Background The practitioner was charged by the Board with unprofessional conduct on the basis that he committed offences of an infamous nature in respect of which punishment by imprisonment is prescribed by law. The offences with which the practitioner was charged were as follows:·Between 31 December 2007 and 11 January 2008 at Stockport the practitioner engaged in indecent filming of a minor contrary to s 23AA(1)(a) of the Summary Offences Act 1935 (count 3);·Between 5 August 2008 and 18 July 2009 at Wynn Vale the practitioner engaged in indecent filming of a minor contrary to section 23AA(1) of the Summary Offences Act 1935 (count 2);·On 27 March 2010 at Wynne Vale the practitioner engaged in indecent filming contrary to s 23AA(1) of the Summary Offences Act 1935 (count 1);·On 28 March 2010 at Wynn Vale the practitioner was in possession of child pornography knowing of its pornographic nature and knowing that the victim of the offence was at the time of the offence under the age of 14 years, contrary to section 63A(1)(a) Summary Offences Act 1935 (count 4); and·On 28 March 2010 at Wynn Vale the practitioner was in possession of child pornography knowing of its pornographic nature, contrary to s 61A(1)(a) Summary Offences Act 1935 (count 5). The facts surrounding the offending are not in dispute. The practitioner pleaded guilty to all charges and was convicted in the District Court on 31 March 2011. At the relevant time the practitioner was a member of the congregation of a Church at Golden Grove. He assisted the Church as a youth group leader. This involved running youth group meetings and accompanying youths on trips and Church camps. The first count involved an act of indecent filming. The practitioner was living in Port Pire where he was working as a solicitor. He also kept a room in a house that he shared with two female house mates at Wynn Vale. He would stay at the Wynn Vale house most weekends. On 27 March 2010, the practitioner and his housemates hosted a party at the house. A number of their mutual friends who were members of the Church congregation attended the party, including a number of youths. At one point during the evening, a guest at the party discovered a hidden camera in the toilet cubicle. It was positioned so that the lens of the camera faced the toilet. Two males suspected the practitioner’s involvement and confronted him in private. He admitted to installing the camera and using a wireless device to transmit the images to a laptop in his bedroom. The police were called to the house and the practitioner readily made admissions to them. He was arrested and taken to the Holden Hill Police Station. A number of adult persons who attended the party had been filmed without their consent.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Although the approach and observations of the sentencing Judge are relevant matters to which this Court may have regard, the issues arising on an application to strike off a practitioner are substantially different from those which a sentencing judge is required to consider. The mere fact that the sentence imposed by the District Court has expired is of little relevance to the issue to be determined by this Court.Consideration The practitioner conceded before the Tribunal that his conduct was unprofessional. The Tribunal found the offences committed by the practitioner to be infamous and that his conduct was unprofessional. The issue before this Court is whether that unprofessional conduct was of such a character as to require the practitioner’s name to be struck from the Roll. When exercising disciplinary powers, the Court acts in the public interest to protect the public and the administration of justice. It is primarily concerned with protecting the public, not punishing the practitioner.[4] Section 89(2) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) confers a range of powers on the Court, from reprimand to striking off. The Court will prevent a person from acting as a legal practitioner by striking him or her off the Roll to protect the public, when it is demonstrated that the person is, by reason of his or her conduct, not fit to remain a member of a profession that plays an important part in the administration of justice, and in which the public is entitled to place great trust.[5][4] Wentworth v NSW Bar Association (1982) 176 CLR 239, 250-251; Law Society of South Australia v Murphy (1999) 201 LSJS 456, 460-461; NSW Bar Association v Evatt (1968) 117 CLR 177, 183-184.[5] Law Society of South Australia v Murphy (1999) 201 LSJS 456, 460-461. In Law Society (SA) v Rodda, this Court considered offences of an infamous nature in relation to unprofessional conduct. The Court observed:[6]In a case like this, where the court's concern is with criminal conduct unconnected with the practitioner's profession, and with the defects of character or personality that are revealed by that conduct, issues of professional competence in the narrow sense do not arise. Nevertheless, the court must still consider whether the conduct and the convictions affect Mr Rodda's capacity to act as a practitioner, and how that conduct and those convictions would reflect on the legal profession were Mr Rodda permitted to remain a member of it. Two points were made in Ziems that are worth bearing in mind. First, as Fullagar J said (at 290), professional misconduct will usually have "a much more direct bearing on the question of a man's fitness to practise" than personal misconduct. And Kitto J said (at 298), while a conviction may "carry such a stigma that judges and members of the profession may be expected to find it too much for their self-respect to share with the person convicted the kind and degree of association which membership of the Bar entails", nevertheless, there will be many kinds of convictions "which do not spell unfitness for the Bar".The offences in question do not reflect directly on Mr Rodda's capacity to act as a practitioner. They do not reveal any lack of competence, or any lack of understanding of the law.But the offences are of a kind that damage the ability of Mr Rodda to maintain the relationship with other members of the profession that is an essential aspect of being a practitioner. Other practitioners would not readily place trust and confidence in a practitioner who has committed such a serious offence. Another practitioner could not assume that Mr Rodda accepts the high standard of conduct which membership of the legal profession requires. In the words of Dixon CJ in his dissenting judgment in Ziems (at 285-286), Mr Rodda could not "command the confidence and respect" of the court or of his fellow practitioners.More significantly, the offences indicate that Mr Rodda lacks qualities that are essential for the conduct of legal practice. The offences involve a serious breach of the law, even though they might be regarded as impulsive and isolated. Mr Rodda took advantage of a vulnerable and immature young woman. That being so, Mr Rodda cannot be regarded as a person in whom clients, especially vulnerable persons, could place their complete trust. Nor could he command the respect of clients.There is another factor. The reputation and standing of the legal profession in the public eye are important. Public confidence and trust in the legal profession is important to the effective functioning of the profession. That confidence and trust rest in part on the reputation and standing of the profession. The public could not view with respect, and have complete confidence in, a person with such serious and recent convictions. Were the court to continue to hold Mr Rodda out as a fit and proper person to remain a member of the profession, the standing of the profession as a whole would suffer. The public would rightly doubt the standards of a profession which permitted a person who has recently committed such serious offences to remain one of its members.In summary, Mr Rodda's offences damage his ability to maintain professional relationships with other members of the profession. They disclose character defects that affect his capacity and fitness to be a practitioner. The public could not be expected to put complete trust in him. The offences are of a nature and seriousness such that the public would rightly consider that a profession that occupies the position of the legal profession, and maintains the high standards that it does, could not properly continue to regard Mr Rodda as a member of the profession.[6] Law Society (SA) v Rodda (2002) 83 SASR 541, [25]-[30].