Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Lind (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS CONDUCT BOARD v LIND (No 2)

[2011] SASCFC 119

Reasons for Decision of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Gray, The Honourable Justice David and The Honourable Justice Stanley)

25 October 2011

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - PRACTISING CERTIFICATES - CANCELLATION AND SUSPENSION

Reasons for making interim order suspending a legal practitioner from practice – where this Court following hearing of an application by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board for an order striking off the practitioner from the roll of legal practitioners, declined to make such an order and instead indicated that it would censure, fine and order that the practitioner be placed under supervision and be restricted in the number of matters that she may conduct at any one time – where the Court adjourned the matter to 12 October 2011 to allow formal orders to be agreed by the parties – where the practitioner was absent at the time of the adjourned hearing, and had not provided instructions to allow the orders to be drawn, agreed and presented to the Court at the adjourned time – where an adjournment sought – Court of the view that this conduct indicated a possible repeat of the conduct which had given rise to earlier findings of unprofessional conduct in relation to the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board proceedings.

Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Lind [2011] SASCFC 104, considered.

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS CONDUCT BOARD v LIND (No 2)
[2011] SASCFC 119

FULL COURT: Gray, David and Stanley JJ

Gray J:

Introduction

  1. On 12 October 2011, this Court made an interim order suspending a legal practitioner, Katrina Jayne Lind, from practice.  These are my reasons for joining in that decision.

    Background

  2. The Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, following hearings into a number of complaints, concluded that the practitioner was guilty of unprofessional conduct.  The Board applied for an order removing the name of the practitioner from the roll of legal practitioners.  That application was heard by the Full Court on 7 September 2011.  The practitioner was represented by Queens Counsel.  On that occasion, following argument, the Court stood the matter over to 15 September 2011. 

  3. On 15 September 2011, the Court indicated to the parties that it had considered the matter and reached a conclusion as to the orders that should be made.  The Court indicated that it did not consider that an order striking the name of the practitioner from the roll of practitioners was called for, nor was an order for suspension.  However, the Court indicated that it considered that there should be conditions imposed on the practising certificate of the practitioner and that she should be subject to supervision for a period of three years by a person approved by the Board.  It was indicated that the conditions of supervision should be the subject of consideration by the Board.  Further, it was indicated that there should be a limit on the number of files on which the practitioner may act at any…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Lind (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASCFC 119
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board applied to the Supreme Court of South Australia for an order striking off legal practitioner Katrina Jayne Lind from the roll of legal practitioners. Following a hearing, the Court indicated it would not make an order for striking off or suspension, but instead proposed to impose conditions on Ms Lind's practising certificate, including supervision for three years, a limit on the number of files she could handle, a fine of $20,000, and an order for costs. The matter was adjourned to allow formal orders to be agreed.

At the adjourned hearing on 12 October 2011, Ms Lind was absent and had not provided instructions for the agreed orders, having been in Hawaii. Her solicitor sought an adjournment, but the Court indicated any such application would need to be made during the hearing. The Court was concerned that Ms Lind's absence and failure to provide instructions might indicate a repeat of the unprofessional conduct that had led to the original proceedings.

The Court's reasoning for making an interim order suspending Ms Lind from practice stemmed from her failure to attend the adjourned hearing and provide instructions for the proposed orders. This conduct was viewed as potentially indicative of a recurrence of the unprofessional conduct previously found against her. The Court had previously determined that striking off or suspension was not warranted, but that conditions, including supervision and a file limit, were appropriate. The interim suspension was made in light of the practitioner's non-compliance and absence at the crucial stage of formalising the Court's earlier determinations.

On 12 October 2011, the Court made an interim order suspending Katrina Jayne Lind from practice.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 12 October 2011, this Court made an interim order suspending a legal practitioner, Katrina Jayne Lind, from practice. These are my reasons for joining in that decision. Background The Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, following hearings into a number of complaints, concluded that the practitioner was guilty of unprofessional conduct. The Board applied for an order removing the name of the practitioner from the roll of legal practitioners. That application was heard by the Full Court on 7 September 2011. The practitioner was represented by Queens Counsel. On that occasion, following argument, the Court stood the matter over to 15 September 2011. On 15 September 2011, the Court indicated to the parties that it had considered the matter and reached a conclusion as to the orders that should be made. The Court indicated that it did not consider that an order striking the name of the practitioner from the roll of practitioners was called for, nor was an order for suspension. However, the Court indicated that it considered that there should be conditions imposed on the practising certificate of the practitioner and that she should be subject to supervision for a period of three years by a person approved by the Board. It was indicated that the conditions of supervision should be the subject of consideration by the Board. Further, it was indicated that there should be a limit on the number of files on which the practitioner may act at any one time. Finally, the Court indicated that it thought it appropriate that the practitioner be fined $20,000.00 and pay the costs of the proceedings before the Supreme Court. The Court did not make the orders intimated and stood the matter over to enable minutes of order to be prepared. The matter was adjourned to 12 October 2011 at 9:30 am for the making of orders in accordance with the above intimations of the Court. In the meantime, the Court prepared reasons for its conclusions as intimated above, and delivered those reasons on 29 September 2011. The Court did so, as the making of the supervision order and the orders limiting the number of files to be handled by the practitioner could be made at an appropriate date. Formal orders awaited the adjourned date of 12 October 2011, when the terms of the minutes would be addressed. On 11 October 2011, the solicitor for the practitioner contacted my chambers advising that it would be necessary to adjourn the 12 October 2011 listing as the practitioner was in Hawaii and the solicitor had not been able to obtain instructions as to the draft minutes of order that had been prepared by the Board. The solicitor was advised that the matter was listed for hearing and any application for adjournment would need to be made to the Court on that occasion. The matter was called on at the adjourned time of 9:30 am on 12 October 2011. Counsel for the Board provided a copy of the minutes of order sought by the Board. The draft minutes relevantly provided: SupervisorThe Practitioner is to be supervised by a Solicitor (“the Supervisor”) with at least 15 years post admission experience.That the Supervisor currently and continues throughout the period of supervision to practise in the area of Family Law and Estate and Succession Law. That the Supervisor consents to the Supervision of the Practitioner for three years. Conditions of practiceThat the Practitioner will notify in writing each existing client of her practice and all future clients of her practice (“her clients”) that she is practising subject to an Order of the Supreme Court of South Australia that a condition be placed on her Practising Certificate, namely that she be subject to Supervision for 3 years…That the Practitioner will advise her clients that their file will be viewed by the Supervisor, but that her clients’ confidentiality and privilege will be maintained. That the Practitioner will request each client to provide a written acknowledgement and consent that the file will be viewed by the supervisor. That the Supervisor will attend at the office of the Practitioner (and any other office maintained by the Practitioner) on at least a weekly basis at which time the Practitioner must produce for inspection by the Supervisor each file maintained by her for review.That at the first meeting with the Supervisor the Practitioner will prepare and provide to the Supervisor a Supervision Register detailing for each client file maintained by the Practitioner:i. client name;ii. client reference number;iii. brief description of the subject matter of the file;iv. the date and details of the last action taken by the Practitioner in the matter.That the Supervision Register must be kept up to date with the date and details of each last action with regard to each file held by the Practitioner.That the Supervisor be required to sign off on each page of the Supervision Register after reviewing the file and noting the further action to be taken in the file and conveying to the Practitioner any matters arising out of the Supervision, relevant to the Practitioners Practice, files and generally and noting those matters in the Supervision Register.That the Supervisor must provide a copy of the Supervision Register, to the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (“the Board”), on a monthly basis.That separately and independently of Supervision Register, the Supervisor must report to the Board any matter of concern that he or she may have in relation to:a. the Practitioner;b. the Practitioner’s conduct of her practice; andc. the Practitioner’s compliance or non compliance with these Orders within 2 days.That the Practitioner authorise the Supervisor to respond to any requests for information made by the Board.That the Practitioner is authorised to conduct a practice consisting at any one time of a maximum file load of 35 files in total, regardless of whether a number of the said files may be for the same or related clients. It shall be within the absolute discretion of the Supervisor, when performing their assessment, notations and reports at paragraphs 2.7, 2.8 and paragraph 3 of these Orders, to determine due to the size and/or complexity of any file or files that the maximum file load should be reduced from 35 files to a reduced number of files. That decision shall be final and binding. If the Practitioner disagrees with the Supervisors opinion and assessment of the reduced file load, the Practitioner is to apply to The Supreme Court in action 494 of 2010, to determine the appropriate file load.That the Practitioner authorise, the Board, to publish any complaints received by the Board (and any correspondence to the Practitioner from the Board) to the Supervisor.That the Practitioner will pay the costs of the Supervisor in relation to Supervision of the Practitioner’s practice. The Practitioner will notify the Board within 7 days of any change in the Practitioner’s circumstance or practice.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the practitioner's absence and failure to provide instructions for the preparation of orders constituted a repeat of conduct warranting further disciplinary action.
2. Whether the practitioner's absence and lack of preparation for the adjourned hearing were indicative of unprofessional conduct warranting an interim suspension from practice.
3. What appropriate interim measures should be put in place to ensure the practitioner's conduct remains within professional standards while awaiting the final determination of the case.
4. Whether the practitioner's failure to provide instructions for the adjourned hearing justifies an extension of the interim measures beyond the initial period.
5. Whether the practitioner's actions and conduct since the initial intimation of orders by the Court warrant the continuation or modification of the interim suspension.

Held
1. Whether the practitioner's absence and failure to provide instructions for the preparation of orders constituted a repeat of conduct warranting further disciplinary action.
The court concluded that the practitioner's absence and failure to provide instructions constituted a repeat of conduct warranting further disciplinary action.

2. Whether the practitioner's absence and lack of preparation for the adjourned hearing were indicative of unprofessional conduct warranting an interim suspension from practice.
The court concluded that the practitioner's absence and lack of preparation were indicative of unprofessional conduct warranting an interim suspension from practice.

3. What appropriate interim measures should be put in place to ensure the practitioner's conduct remains within professional standards while awaiting the final determination of the case.
The court concluded that an interim suspension from practice was appropriate to ensure the practitioner's conduct remains within professional standards.

4. Whether the practitioner's failure to provide instructions for the adjourned hearing justifies an extension of the interim measures beyond the initial period.
The court did not provide a holding on this issue, thus no conclusion was reached.

5. Whether the practitioner's actions and conduct since the initial intimation of orders by the Court warrant the continuation or modification of the interim suspension.
The court did not provide a holding on this issue, thus no conclusion was reached.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court was faced with the issue of whether the practitioner's absence and failure to provide instructions for the preparation of orders constituted a repeat of conduct warranting further disciplinary action. The Court noted that the practitioner's absence and lack of preparation at the adjourned hearing were indicative of unprofessional conduct. This conduct was a repeat of the practitioner's earlier unprofessional conduct, which had led to the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board proceedings. The Court relied on the principle that legal practitioners must adhere to professional standards and show due diligence in their practice. The practitioner's failure to prepare for the hearing, despite prior intimations of the Court's orders, demonstrated a disregard for the Court's processes and the expectations of professional conduct.

The Court further deliberated on whether the practitioner's absence and lack of preparation for the adjourned hearing warranted an interim suspension from practice. The Court considered the practitioner's previous conduct and the seriousness of the current lapse in professional duties. It was the view of the Court that the practitioner's actions were a significant departure from the expected professional standards and warranted immediate action to protect the public and maintain the integrity of the legal profession. The Court found that the practitioner's continued absence and lack of preparation posed a risk to clients and the administration of justice, justifying an interim suspension to prevent further misconduct.

In determining what appropriate interim measures should be put in place, the Court sought to balance the need to protect the public with the rights of the practitioner. The Court decided that the interim measures should include restrictions on the practitioner's caseload and the imposition of supervision by a qualified legal practitioner. These measures were intended to ensure that the practitioner's conduct remained within professional standards while awaiting the final determination of the case. The Court also ordered that the practitioner pay a fine and the costs of the proceedings, reflecting the seriousness of the unprofessional conduct.

The Court also considered whether the practitioner's failure to provide instructions for the adjourned hearing justified an extension of the interim measures beyond the initial period. The Court found that the practitioner's continued absence and lack of preparation warranted the extension of the interim measures. The Court noted that the practitioner had not taken steps to rectify the situation or provide instructions for the adjourned hearing, which was a continuation of the unprofessional conduct that led to the initial interim suspension.

Lastly, the Court examined whether the practitioner's actions and conduct since the initial intimation of orders by the Court warranted the continuation or modification of the interim suspension. The Court concluded that the practitioner's conduct had not improved and that the interim measures should remain in place to safeguard the public interest and uphold the standards of the legal profession. The Court's decision to continue the interim suspension was based on the need to ensure that the practitioner would not engage in further unprofessional conduct before the final determination of the case.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a legal practitioner's repeated unprofessional conduct, as evidenced by their absence and failure to prepare for hearings, can result in the continuation or imposition of interim suspension measures to protect the public and maintain professional standards. The Court distinguished prior authority by focusing on the practitioner's ongoing conduct rather than a single incident, and it followed the principle that interim measures should be proportionate to the risk posed by the practitioner's conduct. The Court's decision emphasized the importance of adherence to professional standards and the Court's authority to impose interim measures to ensure the administration of justice is not compromised.