Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee v Edward

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   FULL BENCH

CITATION:   LEGAL PRACTITIONERS COMPLAINTS COMMITTEE -v- VERSCHUER EDWARD [2007] WASC 287

CORAM:   TEMPLEMAN J

LE MIERE J
SIMMONDS J

HEARD:   29 AUGUST 2007

DELIVERED          :   29 AUGUST 2007

PUBLISHED           :  27 NOVEMBER 2007

FILE NO/S:   LPD 2 of 2006

BETWEEN:   LEGAL PRACTITIONERS COMPLAINTS COMMITTEE

Applicant

AND

PATRICIA MAY VERSCHUER EDWARD
Respondent

Catchwords:

Practitioners - Tribunal finding unsatisfactory conduct - Withdrawals from testamentary fund - Withdrawals repaid - Benefit to fund - Complete records kept - Lack of dishonesty - Unusual circumstances - Practice under supervision since Tribunal findings

Legislation:

Legal Practice Act 2003 (WA), s 185, s 194

Result:

Continuation of supervision two years from date of Tribunal's order

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr M D Howard

Respondent:     Mr E M Corboy SC & Mr M D Cuerden

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Law Complaints Officer

Respondent:     Verschuer Edward

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Law Society of New South Wales v Moulton [1981] 2 NSWLR 736

Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee and Edward [2006] WASAT 113

New South Wales Bar Association v Evatt (1968) 117 CLR 177

Prothonotary of the Supreme Court of NSW v P [2003] NSWCA 320

Re a Practitioner (1982) 30 SASR 27

Re Nelson & Legal Practitioners Act 1970 (1991) 106 ACTR 1

  1. JUDGMENT OF THE COURT:  On 29 August 2007, the full bench heard an application by the Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee (the Committee) for an order that the name of the respondent, Patricia May Verschuer Edward (the practitioner), be struck off the roll of practitioners of this court: alternatively, that the practitioner be suspended from practice for a period of five years (or such further or other period as the court thought fit) and that the practitioner pay a fine of $10,000, and costs.

  2. The application was made by notice of originating motion, following a reference to the court by the State Administrative Tribunal pursuant to s 185(2) of the Legal Practice Act 2003 (WA). As will be seen, the Tribunal was constituted by the members of the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal which was seized of the matter before its jurisdiction was subsumed in that of the State Administrative Tribunal. For that reason, it will be convenient to refer to the tribunal members sitting in both capacities as 'the Tribunal'.

  3. The Tribunal's decision is Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee and Edward [2006] WASAT 113.

  4. At the conclusion of the hearing before the full bench, the court announced that it had decided not to make any order on the application, other than to continue an order made by the Tribunal for the supervision of the practitioner's trust account.  The court then gave a brief outline of its reasons for making that decision, on the basis that full reasons would be published in due course.  We now set out those reasons.

The legislative framework

  1. Division 5 of the Legal Practice Act 2003 deals with disciplinary proceedings in the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT). By s 185(1),…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee v Edward and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASC 287
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee applied for an order that Patricia May Verschuer Edward's name be struck off the roll of practitioners of this court, or that she be suspended from practice for five years and fined $10,000, and that she pay costs. The application was made following a reference to the court by the State Administrative Tribunal, which had found Edward guilty of unsatisfactory conduct. The Tribunal had found that Edward had made withdrawals from a testamentary fund for her own benefit, although the withdrawals had subsequently been repaid, and that she had failed to keep complete records. However, the Tribunal found that Edward had no intention of benefiting herself at the expense of others and that she had not acted dishonestly. The Tribunal also found that the circumstances were unusual, and that Edward had been practising under supervision since the Tribunal's findings.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Tribunal's findings of unsatisfactory conduct justified the striking off of Edward's name from the roll of practitioners, or a suspension for five years, a fine of $10,000, and an order that she pay costs. The court noted that the Tribunal's findings were conclusive as to all facts and findings mentioned or contained in the report. The court also noted that the powers of the full bench were set out in s 194 of the Legal Practice Act 2003, which enabled the court to make any order which the State Administrative Tribunal might make under s 185(2)(b). The court considered the nature and extent of Edward's unsatisfactory conduct, and the Tribunal's findings that she had not acted dishonestly and that the circumstances were unusual. The court also considered that Edward had been practising under supervision since the Tribunal's findings.

The court held that the Tribunal's findings of unsatisfactory conduct did not justify the striking off of Edward's name from the roll of practitioners, or a suspension for five years, a fine of $10,000, and an order that she pay costs. The court held that the Tribunal's findings were supported by the evidence and that there were no grounds for interfering with them. The court held that the unsatisfactory conduct was not of such a nature or extent as to warrant the striking off of Edward's name from the roll of practitioners, or a suspension for five years, a fine of $10,000, and an order that she pay costs. The court held that the circumstances were unusual and that Edward had been practising under supervision since the Tribunal's findings. The court held that an order for the supervision of Edward's trust account should continue for a period of two years from the date of the Tribunal's order.

The orders of the court were that the application be dismissed, and that the order made by the Tribunal for the supervision of Edward's trust account be continued for a period of two years from the date of the Tribunal's order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Continuation of supervision two years from date of Tribunal's order

Background

Background to the litigation

Patricia May Verschuer Edward is a legal practitioner who has been subject to disciplinary proceedings. The proceedings were initiated by the Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee following a complaint that Edward had made withdrawals from a testamentary fund held in her trust account. The withdrawals were subsequently repaid, and no benefit was derived by Edward. Edward has kept complete records of the transactions, and there was no evidence of dishonesty or intent to deceive. The circumstances surrounding the withdrawals were unusual, and it was found that Edward's practice has been under supervision since the Tribunal's findings were made.

The matter began with a complaint to the Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee, which referred the matter to the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT). The Tribunal found Edward guilty of unsatisfactory conduct and made a report to the full bench of the Supreme Court of Western Australia pursuant to s 185(2) of the Legal Practice Act 2003 (WA). The full bench heard an application by the Committee for an order to strike off Edward's name from the roll of practitioners or, alternatively, to suspend her from practice for a period of five years and impose a fine. The full bench decided not to make any order on the application, other than to continue the order for the supervision of Edward's trust account.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: On 29 August 2007, the full bench heard an application by the Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee (the Committee) for an order that the name of the respondent, Patricia May Verschuer Edward (the practitioner), be struck off the roll of practitioners of this court: alternatively, that the practitioner be suspended from practice for a period of five years (or such further or other period as the court thought fit) and that the practitioner pay a fine of $10,000, and costs. The application was made by notice of originating motion, following a reference to the court by the State Administrative Tribunal pursuant to s 185(2) of the Legal Practice Act 2003 (WA). As will be seen, the Tribunal was constituted by the members of the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal which was seized of the matter before its jurisdiction was subsumed in that of the State Administrative Tribunal. For that reason, it will be convenient to refer to the tribunal members sitting in both capacities as 'the Tribunal'. The Tribunal's decision is Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee and Edward [2006] WASAT 113. At the conclusion of the hearing before the full bench, the court announced that it had decided not to make any order on the application, other than to continue an order made by the Tribunal for the supervision of the practitioner's trust account. The court then gave a brief outline of its reasons for making that decision, on the basis that full reasons would be published in due course. We now set out those reasons. Division 5 of the Legal Practice Act 2003 deals with disciplinary proceedings in the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT). By s 185(1), SAT has jurisdiction to make a finding that a legal practitioner is guilty of 'unsatisfactory conduct'. By s 185(2), if SAT makes a finding of unsatisfactory conduct, it may make and transmit a report on the finding to the full bench of the Supreme Court or deal with the practitioner as specified in s 187. However, under s 185(3), if SAT transmits a report to the full bench under s 185(2)(a), it may, pending the determination of the full bench, either suspend the legal practitioner from practice or restrict his or her entitlement to practise. Section 187 provides SAT with a range of options, including suspension for a period not exceeding two years, the imposition of conditions or restrictions on the right of the practitioner to practise, for a period not exceeding two years, the payment of a fine not exceeding $25,000 and a reprimand. There are also provisions which enable SAT to order the practitioner to pay money for the benefit of the complainant or compensation where appropriate. The powers of the full bench are set out in s 194 of the Act, which is in the following terms:(1)If the State Administrative Tribunal under section 185(2)(a) or 190(4)(b) makes and transmits a report in respect of a legal practitioner to the Supreme Court (full bench), the report is to be taken to be conclusive as to all facts and findings mentioned or contained in the report.(2)The Supreme Court (full bench) may, upon motion and upon reading the report, and without any further evidence, fine, suspend from practice, or strike off the Roll of Practitioners the legal practitioner or make any order which the State Administrative Tribunal might make under section 185(2)(b).(3)The Supreme Court (full bench) may make such order as to the payment of costs by the legal practitioner as the Court thinks fit.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application by the Legal Practitioners Complaints Committee (the Committee) seeking to strike off the practitioner's name from the roll of practitioners, suspend her from practice for five years, impose a fine of $10,000, and order her to pay costs. The application was made by notice of originating motion, following a reference to the court by the State Administrative Tribunal pursuant to s 185(2) of the Legal Practice Act 2003 (WA). The Tribunal had found the practitioner guilty of unsatisfactory conduct. The court reviewed the Tribunal's findings and the circumstances surrounding the practitioner's conduct. The Tribunal had found that the practitioner had made withdrawals from a testamentary fund and repaid the amounts withdrawn. The Tribunal also found that the withdrawals had benefited the fund, that complete records had been kept, and that there was no evidence of dishonesty. The circumstances were described as unusual. The Tribunal noted that the practitioner had been under supervision since the Tribunal's findings. In light of these findings and circumstances, the court decided not to make any order to strike off the practitioner's name or to suspend her from practice. The court also decided not to impose a fine or to order the practitioner to pay costs. The court continued an order made by the Tribunal for the supervision of the practitioner's trust account. The court did not find it necessary to make any further orders given the circumstances and the Tribunal's findings. The court's decision not to strike off the practitioner's name or to suspend her from practice, despite the Tribunal's findings of unsatisfactory conduct, highlights the court's consideration of the specific circumstances and the Tribunal's findings. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where a practitioner has been found guilty of unsatisfactory conduct but the circumstances are unusual, the court may choose not to strike off the practitioner's name or suspend her from practice, and may instead continue supervision of the practitioner's trust account.