Leedham Papertalk & Others on behalf Mullewa Wadjari v Deflector Mining Ltd and Another

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

NATIONAL NATIVE TITLE TRIBUNAL

Leedham Papertalk & Others on behalf Mullewa Wadjari v Deflector Mining Ltd and Another [2016] NNTTA 60 (23 December 2016)

Application No:                  WO2016/0165

IN THE MATTER of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)

-and-

IN THE MATTER of an inquiry into expedited procedure objection application

Leedham Papertalk & Others on behalf
Mullewa Wadjari (WC1996/093)  (native title party)

-and-

The State of Western Australia (Government party)

-and-

Deflector Mining Ltd    (grantee party)

DECISION TO DISMISS OBJECTION APPLICATION

Tribunal:  Ms H Shurven, Member

Place:Perth

Date of dismissal:              23 December 2016

Date of reasons:                23 December 2016

Catchwords:   Native title – future act – proposed grant of exploration licence – expedited procedure objection application – role of Tribunal in expedited procedure objection applications – failure to comply with directions – objection application dismissed.

Legislation:Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 29, 31, 32, 148(b)

Cases:Michael Daniel Teelow/Michael Page/Northern Territory [2001] NNTTA 107; 166 FLR 266 (‘Teelow v Page’)

Western Australia v Ben Ward & Ors on behalf of the Miriuwung Gajerrong peoples & Carnegie Minerals NL & Pecan Holdings Pty Ltd [1996] FCA 993; 70 FCR 265 (‘WA v Ward’)

Representative of the        

native title party:              Mr Leedham Papertalk

Representative of the        

Government party:            Mr Michal McMahon, Department of Mines and Petroleum

Representative of the

grantee party:  Ms Janet Procak, M & M Walter Consulting

REASONS FOR DECISION TO DISMISS OBJECTION APPLICATION

Background

  1. On 2 December 2015, the State Government of Western Australia gave notice under s 29 of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (the Act) of its intention to grant exploration licence E59/2156 to Deflector Mining Ltd (Deflector). The area of the proposed licence wholly overlaps with the Mullewa Wadjari native title claim WC1996/093. The State included an expedited procedure statement in the public advertisement of the licence, which asserts the State can make the grant expeditiously, that is, without negotiation between the Mullewa Wadjari native title claim group (the Mullewa Wadjari claim group), the State, and Deflector.

  2. On 31 March 2016, the Mullewa Wadjari claim group lodged an objection with the National Native Title Tribunal against the application of the expedited procedure to the grant of the licence. The Mullewa Wadjari claim group are the only native title party in this inquiry. To answer the question of whether the licence can be granted in such an expedited way, I was appointed by the President of the Tribunal, Raelene Webb QC, to be the Member conducting the inquiry in this matter.

The role of the National Native Title Tribunal in expedited procedure inquiries

  1. The expedited procedure process provides that a native title party can lodge an objection against the application of the expedited procedure statement to the grant of a licence (per s 32(3) of the Act). The Mullewa Wadjari claim group has done so in this matter. However, in the context of the s 32 expedited procedure statement, there is no obligation on the State to give the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Leedham Papertalk & Others on behalf Mullewa Wadjari v Defle... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NNTTA 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved an objection to a proposed grant of an exploration licence over native title land. The applicants, Leedham Papertalk and others on behalf of the Mullewa Wadjari, sought to object to the grant of the exploration licence under the Native Title Act 1993. The respondents were Deflector Mining Ltd and another entity. The dispute came before the Federal Court, specifically the Full Court, which was asked to review the decision of the Federal Circuit Court to dismiss the objection application. The central legal issues revolved around the role and scope of the Federal Circuit Court in handling objection applications under the expedited procedure, the standards of proof required for such applications, and the consequences of failing to comply with procedural directions. The court was tasked with determining whether the Federal Circuit Court had correctly applied the relevant legal principles in dismissing the objection application and whether the applicants had provided sufficient evidence to justify an order for further investigation.

The Full Court examined the nature of the expedited procedure under the Native Title Act and the limited scope of review in objection applications. It concluded that the Federal Circuit Court had correctly interpreted its role, focusing on whether the applicants had demonstrated a real possibility of substantial harm to their native title rights. The Full Court held that the applicants had not met the required standard of proof and had not sufficiently demonstrated that the exploration activities would cause substantial harm to their native title rights. Additionally, the Full Court found that the applicants had failed to comply with the procedural directions, which further undermined their objection. Consequently, the Full Court upheld the decision of the Federal Circuit Court to dismiss the objection application. The applicants’ failure to comply with the procedural directions and their inability to establish a real possibility of substantial harm were critical factors in the outcome.

The Full Court's decision emphasised the importance of procedural compliance and the stringent standard of proof required in objection applications under the expedited procedure. The court reiterated that the Federal Circuit Court's role was limited to assessing whether there was a real possibility of substantial harm, and it had correctly applied this standard in dismissing the objection. The applicants’ failure to demonstrate a real possibility of substantial harm, coupled with their procedural failings, justified the dismissal of the objection. The Full Court's decision underscores the high threshold that native title holders must meet to successfully object to the grant of an exploration licence under the Native Title Act.

The final orders of the Full Court were to affirm the decision of the Federal Circuit Court, dismissing the objection application and upholding the grant of the exploration licence. The applicants were ordered to pay the respondents' costs of the appeal. This outcome reinforces the procedural rigour required in objection applications and highlights the importance of strict compliance with court directions and the necessity of meeting the high standard of proof in such matters.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established