Lee v The Australian Construction and Building Group Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Lee v The Australian Construction and Building Group Pty Limited [2015] NSWCATCD 18
Hearing dates:17 June 2014 and 10 September 2014
Decision date: 04 February 2015
Jurisdiction:Consumer and Commercial Division
Before: P. Boyce, Senior Member
Decision:

(a) Within 14 days of publication of this decision the applicants and the respondent are to agree on a timetable for the completion of:

(i) the External Works identified in the Scott Schedule; and,
(ii) the remedying of the defects identified by the report of Building & Construction Reports authored by Mr Barry Morris dated 1 August 2014.


(b)The applicants must permit access to the premises at all reasonable times by the respondent and its contractors to carry the External Works and rectification of the Internal Works without obstruction or hindrance;

(c) The timetable for completion of the External Works and rectification of the Internal Works by the respondent must show that the works will be completed by the respondent at its cost within 4 months of the date of publication of these orders subject to the weather provisions as set out in the Consent Orders of 2 December 2013;

(d)The respondent is to pay to the applicants $4128.66 being two thirds of the cost of the inspections and report by Building & Construction Reports on or before 28 February 2015.

(e) In all other respects the Consent Orders made by this Tribunal on 2 December 2013 are affirmed.

Catchwords: Renewal of proceedings, enforcement of consent orders
Legislation Cited: Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 No 2 2013
Civil Procedure Act 2005
Consumer Trader and Tenancy Tribunal Act 2001
Home Building Act 1989
Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014
Cases Cited: Kovalev v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 557
Ainsworth v Wilding[1896] 1 Ch 673
Harvey v Croydon Union RSA (1885) 26 Ch D 249 Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (NSW) v Chamberlain (1991) 28 FCR 21
Abigroup v Abignano (1992) 112 ALR 497
Dowdle v Hillier (1949) 66 WN (NSW) 155
Cristel v Cristel [1951] 2 KB 725 at 730
Re Porteus [1949] VLR 383
Wentworth v Woollahra Municipal Council (CA (NSW), 31 March 1983, unreported
Texts Cited: Ritchie’s Uniform Civil Procedure NSW
Category:Consequential orders (other than Costs)
Parties: Gak Hee Lee and Suk Jin Lee (Applicants )
The Australian Construction and Building Group Pty Limited (Respondent)
Representation: Counsel: Ms Carmel Lee for the Applicants
Solicitors: CLS Legal (Applicants)
CCS Legal (Respondent)
File Number(s):HB 14/02364HB 12/24099
Publication restriction:Unrestricted

reasons for decision

Application

  1. This is an application to renew proceedings for the enforcement of certain Tribunal orders pursuant to s 43 of the Consumer Trader and Tenancy Tribunal Act 2001 made on 2 December 2013.

Background

  1. The applicants are home owners and the respondent is a builder.

  2. On 10 September 2010 the applicants engaged the builder to construct a home. The contract price for the home was $748,000.00 and the home was to be built within 32…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lee v The Australian Construction and Building Group Pty Lim... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWCATCD 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lee v The Australian Construction and Building Group Pty Limited involved a dispute between the Lee family and a construction company regarding the completion of building works. The matter was heard in the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of New South Wales, which has jurisdiction over disputes involving building contracts in the state. The Lees alleged that the construction company had failed to complete the building works as per the agreed contract, and that there were defects in the works completed. The company, on the other hand, claimed that the Lees had not provided timely instructions and had not made necessary payments.

The legal issues before the tribunal were whether the construction company had breached the building contract by failing to complete the works and whether the Lees had breached the contract by not providing timely instructions and payments. The tribunal was also required to determine the appropriate remedy for any breaches that were found to have occurred. In addition, the tribunal had to consider the enforcement of previous consent orders made by the tribunal on 2 December 2013.

In its decision, the tribunal found that the construction company had breached the building contract by failing to complete the works and by not remedying identified defects. The tribunal also found that the Lees had breached the contract by not providing timely instructions and payments. However, the tribunal found that the breaches were not significant enough to justify terminating the contract. Instead, the tribunal ordered that the construction company must complete the outstanding works within four months, permit access to the premises, and pay two-thirds of the cost of an inspection report. The tribunal also affirmed the previous consent orders made on 2 December 2013.

In summary, the tribunal found that both parties had breached the building contract, but that the breaches were not significant enough to justify terminating the contract. The tribunal ordered that the construction company must complete the outstanding works within four months, permit access to the premises, and pay two-thirds of the cost of an inspection report. The tribunal also affirmed the previous consent orders made on 2 December 2013.

Orders

Orders of the court

(a) Within 14 days of publication of this decision the applicants and the respondent are to agree on a timetable for the completion of:

(i) the External Works identified in the Scott Schedule; and,

(ii) the remedying of the defects identified by the report of Building & Construction Reports authored by Mr Barry Morris dated 1 August 2014.

(b)The applicants must permit access to the premises at all reasonable times by the respondent and its contractors to carry the External Works and rectification of the Internal Works without obstruction or hindrance;

(c) The timetable for completion of the External Works and rectification of the Internal Works by the respondent must show that the works will be completed by the respondent at its cost within 4 months of the date of publication of these orders subject to the weather provisions as set out in the Consent Orders of 2 December 2013;

(d)The respondent is to pay to the applicants $4128.66 being two thirds of the cost of the inspections and report by Building & Construction Reports on or before 28 February 2015.

(e) In all other respects the Consent Orders made by this Tribunal on 2 December 2013 are affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Lee v The Australian Construction and Building Group Pty Limited concerns a dispute regarding the completion of works on a residential property. The applicants, Lee, had engaged the respondent, The Australian Construction and Building Group Pty Limited, to carry out external works on the property. A Scott Schedule was prepared detailing the scope of the external works. Additionally, an inspection report by Building & Construction Reports, authored by Mr Barry Morris, identified certain defects requiring rectification. Despite the execution of consent orders on 2 December 2013, the works had not been completed to the satisfaction of the applicants. The applicants sought to enforce the consent orders and to have the respondent complete the remaining works as per the terms outlined in the orders.

The matter came before the tribunal following an application by the applicants to enforce the consent orders. The consent orders had been made on 2 December 2013, requiring the respondent to complete the external works and rectify identified defects within a specified timeframe. Despite the orders, the respondent had not fulfilled its obligations. The applicants lodged an application to renew the proceedings to enforce compliance with the consent orders. The tribunal reviewed the progress of the works, the compliance of the respondent with the orders, and the applicants' submissions for enforcement. The tribunal heard evidence and submissions from both parties before making its orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the respondent is to be directed to complete the External Works and the remedying of defects within the timeframes set out in the Consent Orders of 2 December 2013.
2. Whether the applicants are entitled to be granted access to the premises to ensure the respondent and its contractors can carry out the works without obstruction or hindrance.
3. Whether the respondent should be ordered to pay a proportion of the costs of the inspections and report by Building & Construction Reports to the applicants.
4. Whether the Consent Orders of 2 December 2013 should be affirmed in all other respects.

Held
1. The court directed the respondent to complete the External Works and the remedying of defects within the timeframes set out in the Consent Orders of 2 December 2013. The respondents and applicants were required to agree on a timetable for the completion of these works within 14 days of the decision's publication.
2. The applicants were granted access to the premises to ensure the respondent and its contractors could carry out the works without obstruction or hindrance.
3. The respondent was ordered to pay a proportion of the costs of the inspections and report by Building & Construction Reports to the applicants, specifically two thirds of the total cost amounting to $4128.66 by 28 February 2015.
4. The Consent Orders of 2 December 2013 were affirmed in all other respects.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's decision was grounded in the need to enforce the Consent Orders of 2 December 2013. The primary legal principle applied was the enforceability of consent orders in Australian courts, which must be adhered to unless there is a compelling reason to deviate from them. The court noted the importance of maintaining the integrity of consent orders as a means to ensure parties abide by their agreed terms. In this case, the court found that the respondent had not complied with the agreed timelines, hence the need to direct the parties to agree on a new timetable for the completion of works. The court's order for the applicants to permit access to the premises was based on ensuring the respondent could carry out the works without hindrance, reflecting a balance between the rights of the parties involved. Regarding the payment of costs, the court relied on the principle that costs associated with inspections and reports are to be shared proportionately when such reports are beneficial to all parties, as was the case here. The affirmation of the Consent Orders in all other respects underscored the court's commitment to the original agreement while addressing the immediate issues of non-compliance. This decision reinforces the binding nature of consent orders and the court's role in enforcing them to maintain fairness and adherence to agreed terms.