Lee v Bus and Coach International Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[2005] QDC 269

DISTRICT COURT

CIVIL JURISDICTION

JUDGE ROBIN QC

No 5082 of 2000

WOO NAM LEE AND CHIN OK LEE Plaintiffs

and

BUS AND COACH INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD (ACN 073 935 341)

and

RONALD JAMES NAZZARI

and

JEFF WALKER

First Defendant

Second Defendant

Sixth Defendant

BRISBANE

..DATE 24/08/2005

ORDER

CATCHWORDS: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 470 - leave refused for defendants to apply for an order that plaintiffs file an affidavit deposing to what reports or draft reports of an expert exist - trial before another judge stood adjourned part heard after the plaintiffs' opening (in the course of which a report and supplementary report of the expert were tendered, subject to her being called - confusing correspondence from plaintiffs' solicitor induced concern that additional reports of the expert (not disclosed) might exist - unimpressive efforts by legal representatives to sort out confusion - by the hearing date, the defendants accepted there were no further reports or drafts.

HIS HONOUR: It is almost a quarter to 1 and most of the participants in this matter have been here at Court since about 9.30. The hearing began at 5 past 11. I am sorry to say that the exercise does not reveal the legal system operating at its best or living up to the philosophy set out in rule 5 of the UCPR.

The application before the Court was filed on 15th of August on behalf of the first and second defendants.  It seeks the Court's leave under rule 470 for the bringing of the application.  Beyond that, what the applicants ask for is orders that:

(1)The plaintiffs file and serve within seven days affidavits deposing to:

(a)the number and description of the reports including draft reports prepared on their behalf by HLB Mann Judd (formerly Moore Stephens HL) for the purpose of this proceeding;

(b)whether any expert reports as to damages other than those deposed to have ever been within their possession or control; and

(2)  Costs on an indemnity basis."

Leave was necessary because not only has a request for trial date been signed but the trial has commenced before his Honour Judge McLauchlan QC on the 18th of July 2005.  Some oral evidence has been taken to accommodate a witness who was ill.  The plaintiff's opening was presented by Mr Amerena of counsel and, in the course of it, subject to the calling of the author, there was tendered and received a report and supplementary report of Ms Manders.  She is an accountant giving expert evidence which may assist the Court in quantifying the plaintiffs' loss which they assert contains large consequential losses attributable to deficiencies in a bus acquired from the principal defendant which led to its not being available for service; opportunities for other employment of capital tied up were lost, etc.

Ordinarily, one would expect the present application to have been brought before the trial Judge who happens to be in Cairns this week, as is Mr Amerena.  Word is that his Honour has…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lee v Bus and Coach International Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] QDC 269
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Lee v Bus and Coach International Pty Ltd, the plaintiffs, Woo Nam Lee and Chin Ok Lee, sought to recover damages from the defendants, Bus and Coach International Pty Ltd, Ronald James Nazzari, and Jeff Walker, for the purchase of a bus which was allegedly defective. The defendants applied for leave to apply for an order that the plaintiffs file an affidavit deposing to what reports or draft reports of an expert exist. The application was brought before the Court despite the commencement of the trial before another judge. The plaintiffs tendered a report and supplementary report of Ms Manders, an expert accountant, subject to her being called. The defendants, concerned about the existence of additional reports not disclosed, sought leave to apply for an affidavit deposing to the existence of such reports.

The court was required to decide whether leave should be granted under Rule 470 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules for the defendants to apply for an order that the plaintiffs file an affidavit deposing to the existence of any further reports or draft reports of Ms Manders. The court also had to consider whether the defendants had demonstrated compliance with Rule 444 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and whether the costs of the application should be reserved to the trial judge.

The court found that the defendants' concerns about the existence of additional reports were unfounded, as the plaintiffs' solicitors had clarified that there were no further reports. The court noted that the plaintiffs' solicitors had contributed to the defendants' concerns by sending a confusing letter. The court held that there was no justification for granting the leave required under Rule 470, as the defendants now had the clarification they needed. The court also considered that the costs of and incidental to the application ought to be reserved to the trial judge who would be in a better position to assess the merits of the application. The application was dismissed and costs were reserved to the trial judge.

The court ordered that the application be dismissed and costs reserved to the trial judge. The court also noted that the defendants' application had been brought without the knowledge of the trial judge, who had anticipated that an argument about particulars could go before him.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.