Lee v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Lee v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2024] NSWPIC 182
CLAIMANT: Hong Chul Lee
INSURER: Allianz
MEMBER: Terrence Broomfield
DATE OF DECISION: 5 April 2024
CATCHWORDS: MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; application for discretionary exemption pursuant to section 7.34(1)(b); general complexity; claimant entrepreneurial in various businesses involving various entities within which he traded; both parties retained forensic accountants to analyse various businesses and entities; Insurance Australia Ltd t/a NRMA Insurance v Banos, IAG Ltd t/a NRMA Insurance v Abiad, and IAG Limited t/a NRMA Insurance v Khaled applied; allegations of false and misleading statements, and complex economic loss issues that would involve the cross examination of the claimant, lay witnesses and forensic accountants some of whom may not be compellable to give evidence without the force of a subpoena; parties estimate if heard in the Commission the matter is likely to take two to three days; whether a court hearing is likely to result in the just, quick and cost effective resolution of the real issues in dispute and compel the calling of witnesses that may otherwise not be compellable to give evidence; Held – claim not suitable for assessment; recommendation that the claim be exempt from assessment; recommendation subsequently approved by the Division Head, as the President’s delegate.

RECOMMENDATIONS – CLAIM NOT SUITABLE FOR ASSESSMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. The claimant was involved in a motor accident on 19 February 2020.

  2. On 26 February 2020 the claimant made a claim against Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (the insurer).

  3. The insurer has now filed a reply to the claimant’s application in the Personal Injury Commission (the Commission) seeking that I recommend to the President that the matter be exempt from assessment as a matter that is not suitable for assessment in the Commission.

  4. I conducted an initial Preliminary Conference on 6 November 2023. The insurer some days prior to the Preliminary Conference had filed its reply which incorporated an application for a discretionary exemption.

  5. I conducted a 2nd Preliminary Conference on 27 March 2024 at which time some additional oral submissions were made by the solicitors for the parties.

STATUTORY FRAMEWORK

  1. The insurer’s application for exemption is made pursuant to s 7.34(1)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (‘MAI Act’) that provision is in the following terms:

    “7.34 Claims exempt from assessment

    (1)   A claim is exempt from assessment under this Division if:

    (a) the claim is of a kind specified in the regulations is a claim that is exempt from assessment under this Division, or

    (b)  the Commission has made a preliminary assessment of the claim and has  determined (with the approval of the President) that the claim is not        suitable for assessment under this Division.

    (2)    If a claim is exempt from assessment under this Division, the President must,   as soon as practicable, arrange for the issue to the insurer and the claimant a  certificate to that effect (enabling court proceedings to be commenced in respect of the claim…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lee v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPIC 182
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lee v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, the claimant sought a discretionary exemption from assessment of his claim for motor accident injuries under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The dispute centred on the complexity of the claimant's business interests and the potential for significant economic loss. Both parties engaged forensic accountants to analyse the various entities through which the claimant conducted business, leading to intricate financial and economic loss issues. The case required the court to determine whether the matter was suitable for assessment by the Commission or if a court hearing would be more just, quick and cost-effective, particularly in light of the potential difficulty in compelling certain witnesses to give evidence.

The legal issues before the court included the assessment of the general complexity of the claim and the implications of the claimant's entrepreneurial activities across multiple entities. The court needed to consider the extensive nature of the economic loss claims and the potential for disputes over false and misleading statements. Reference was made to previous cases such as Insurance Australia Ltd t/a NRMA Insurance v Banos, IAG Ltd t/a NRMA Insurance v Abiad, and IAG Limited t/a NRMA Insurance v Khaled to guide the decision. The court also had to weigh the estimated duration of the hearing in the Commission against the likelihood of a court hearing resolving the issues more efficiently.

The court determined that the complexity of the case, including the need for cross-examination of the claimant, lay witnesses, and forensic accountants, some of whom might not be compellable without a subpoena, made the claim unsuitable for assessment. It was concluded that a court hearing was more likely to achieve a just, quick, and cost-effective resolution. The court recommended that the claim be exempt from assessment, a recommendation that was subsequently approved by the Division Head, as the President’s delegate. This decision highlighted the importance of considering the practicalities of evidence gathering and the potential for a more streamlined resolution through a court hearing.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a claim for motor accident injuries pursuant to the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 by a claimant against Allianz Australia Insurance Limited. The claimant was involved in a motor accident and has multiple businesses and entities in which he trades. The complexity of the claim arises from the various business interests and entities involved. Both parties engaged forensic accountants to examine the claimant’s businesses and entities. The case involves allegations of false and misleading statements and intricate economic loss issues. The cross-examination of the claimant, lay witnesses, and forensic accountants is anticipated, some of whom might not be compellable without the force of a subpoena. The parties estimate that if the matter were heard in the Commission, it would likely take two to three days. The primary concern is whether a court hearing would result in a just, quick, and cost-effective resolution of the issues and ensure the calling of witnesses who may not otherwise be compellable.

This matter came before the court as an application for a discretionary exemption from assessment under section 7.34(1)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The application was made by the insurer, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited. The claimant’s application for exemption was supported by affidavits and submissions from both parties. The court considered the relevant precedents including Insurance Australia Ltd t/a NRMA Insurance v Banos, IAG Ltd t/a NRMA Insurance v Abiad, and IAG Limited t/a NRMA Insurance v Khaled. The court was asked to decide whether the claim was suitable for assessment under the Act and whether exemption would lead to a more efficient resolution of the issues.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the claimant’s motor accident claim suitable for assessment under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017?
2. Would granting a discretionary exemption from assessment pursuant to section 7.34(1)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 result in a just, quick, and cost-effective resolution of the real issues in dispute?
3. Would a court hearing compel the calling of witnesses that may otherwise not be compellable to give evidence?

Held
1. The claimant’s motor accident claim was not suitable for assessment under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.
2. Granting a discretionary exemption from assessment pursuant to section 7.34(1)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 would result in a just, quick, and cost-effective resolution of the real issues in dispute.
3. A court hearing would compel the calling of witnesses that may otherwise not be compellable to give evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the general complexity of the claimant’s entrepreneurial ventures and the multiple entities involved. Both parties had retained forensic accountants to analyse these complex business structures and transactions. The court referred to previous cases such as Insurance Australia Ltd t/a NRMA Insurance v Banos, IAG Ltd t/a NRMA Insurance v Abiad, and IAG Limited t/a NRMA Insurance v Khaled to assess the suitability of the claim for assessment under the Act. These cases highlighted the importance of ensuring that the resolution process is just, quick, and cost-effective.

Given the allegations of false and misleading statements and the complex economic loss issues, the court determined that the matter would require extensive cross-examination of the claimant, lay witnesses, and forensic accountants. Some of these potential witnesses might not be compellable to give evidence without the force of a subpoena, making their participation in a court hearing crucial. Both parties estimated that if heard in the Commission, the matter would likely take two to three days. The court concluded that a court hearing would compel the calling of these witnesses, thereby ensuring a comprehensive examination of the issues.

The court found that granting a discretionary exemption from assessment would serve the interests of justice by facilitating a more efficient and effective resolution of the complex matters at hand. The recommendation for exemption was subsequently approved by the Division Head, acting as the President’s delegate. The binding legal principle, or ratio decidendi, established by this decision is that in cases of significant complexity and where the calling of non-compellable witnesses is necessary, a discretionary exemption from assessment under section 7.34(1)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 may be appropriate to achieve a just, quick, and cost-effective resolution.