Lee Rumble v Liverpool Plains Shire Council [No. 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

District Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Lee Rumble & Anor v Liverpool Plains Shire Council & Ors [No. 2] [2012] NSWDC 99
Hearing dates:22 May 2012, 23 May 2012, 24 May 2012, 25 May 2012, 28 Mary 2012 and 13 July 2012
Decision date: 20 July 2012
Before: Mahony SC DCJ
Decision:

See paragraph 14 of Judgment

Catchwords: Costs following Calderbank Offer
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005
Cases Cited: Calderbank v Calderbank ]1975] 3 All ER 333
Vieira v O'Shea (No. 2) [2012] NSWCA 121
Miwa Pty Ltd v Siantan Properties Pty Ltd (No. 2) ]2011] NSWCA 344
Category:Costs
Parties: Lee Rumble - First Plaintiff
Robert Rumble - Second Plaintiff
Liverpool Plains Shire Council - First Defendant
Mervyn John Prendergast - Second Defendant
Matthew Sproul - Third Defendant
Christine Anderson - Fourth Defendant
Simon Carroll - Fifth Defendant
Paul Fahey - Seventh Defendant
Chris Byers - Eighth Defendant
Darren Clark - Ninth Defendant
Representation: S Galitsky - Plaintiff
J Guihot - First to Fifth and Seventh to Ninth Defendants
Websters Solicitors - Plaintiffs
Moray & Agnew - First to Fifth and Seventh to Ninth Defendants
File Number(s):11/58125
Publication restriction:Nil

Judgment ON COSTS

  1. The defendants, by notice of motion filed with leave on 13 July 2012, seek the following orders:

(1)   An order that the costs orders made on 5 July 2012 in favour of the plaintiffs against the first defendant be revoked.

(2)   That in lieu thereof the Court order that:

(a)   The plaintiffs pay the First Defendant's costs of the proceedings;

(b)   Alternatively, that there be no order as to costs up to 16 May 2012; or

(c)   Alternatively,

(i)   The First Defendant pay the costs of the plaintiffs on an ordinary basis up to 16 May 2012

(ii)   Each plaintiff to pay the costs of the First Defendant on and from 17 May 2012,

(iii)   That such costs be paid by the plaintiffs on an indemnity basis.

(d)   Each plaintiff to pay the First Defendant's costs of this motion.

(e)   That the First Defendant's costs of the motion be paid by the plaintiffs on an indemnity basis.

(3)   An order that enforcement of the judgment in favour of each plaintiff against the First Defendant be stayed pending an assessment of the First Defendant's costs payable under Order 2 and that any such costs be set off against the said judgments in favour of the plaintiffs.

(4)   Such further or other orders so as to give effect to the orders sought herein.

  1. The defendants relied on an affidavit of Mark James Brothers sworn 11 July 2012 which annexed correspondence between the parties. Relevantly, it included a letter from the defendants' solicitors to the plaintiffs' solicitors dated 30 April 2012, which contained the following:

"We are instructed to make one final offer to settle these proceedings The offer is our clients' highest position and no further offers will be made. The offer is as follows:
1.  In full settlement of:
1.1   all claims…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lee Rumble v Liverpool Plains Shire Council [No. 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWDC 99
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Lee Rumble brought an action against Liverpool Plains Shire Council in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The dispute revolves around an offer made under the Calderbank principle, which provides that an offer to settle can be taken into account when determining costs, even if the offer is not ultimately accepted. The offer was made by the council in a case involving a personal injury claim and the adequacy of signage at a public park. The council made the offer shortly before the case was due to be heard. The court had to determine whether the offer was made in genuine contemplation of settlement, and whether the offer was reasonable and should be taken into account in the event the plaintiff was unsuccessful.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Calderbank offer made by the council should be taken into account when assessing costs. The court had to consider whether the offer was made in good faith and whether it was reasonable in the circumstances. The plaintiff argued that the offer was not made in good faith, as it was made late and without any explanation. The council argued that the offer was genuine and should be taken into account, even though it was not accepted. The court had to weigh these arguments and decide whether the offer should be taken into account in determining costs.

The court found that the offer was made in good faith and was reasonable in the circumstances. The court held that the offer was made at a time when the parties were preparing for trial, and the council had a genuine belief that the claim had merit. The court also found that the offer was reasonable, as it was not an exorbitant sum and represented a significant proportion of the claim. The court held that the offer should be taken into account when assessing costs, even though it was not ultimately accepted. The court ordered that the costs of the proceeding be assessed on the basis that the plaintiff was entitled to recover 75% of the costs incurred up to the date of the offer, and 50% of the costs incurred thereafter.

The court also made orders regarding the assessment of costs. The court ordered that the plaintiff was entitled to recover 75% of the costs incurred up to the date of the offer, and 50% of the costs incurred thereafter. The court ordered that the defendant was to pay the plaintiff's costs up to the date of the offer, and that the plaintiff was to pay the defendant's costs from that date onwards. The court held that the orders were just and equitable in all the circumstances, and reflected the court's finding that the offer was made in good faith and was reasonable.

Orders

Orders of the court

See paragraph 14 of Judgment

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established