JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: EQUAL OPPORTUNITY ACT 1984 (WA)
CITATION: LEE and CITY OF SWAN [2019] WASAT 120
MEMBER: MS L EDDY, SENIOR MEMBER
HEARD: DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS
DELIVERED : 25 NOVEMBER 2019
FILE NO/S: EOA 13 of 2019
BETWEEN: AMELIA LEE
Applicant
AND
CITY OF SWAN
Respondent
Catchwords:
Equal opportunity - Allegation of discrimination on ground of race in area of services - Service of providing opportunity to potential owners of deceased cat to identify cat - Application to strike out complaint referred to Tribunal after being dismissed by Equal Opportunity Commissioner - Lacking in substance - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (WA), s 4, s 36, s 46, s 90(2), Pt III
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 47, s 60(2)
Result:
Application to strike out proceeding allowed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Applicant | : | N/A |
| Respondent | : | N/A |
Solicitors:
| Applicant | : | N/A |
| Respondent | : | N/A |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
IW v City of Perth [1997] HCA 30; 191 CLR 1
Laurent and Commissioner of Police [2009] WASAT 254
Rainsford v Victoria (2007) 167 FCR 1
Robinson v Commissioner of Police, NSW Police Force [2012] FCA 770
Waters v Public Transport Corporation [1991] HCA 49; 173 CLR 349
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Introduction
In April 2019 Ms Amelia Lee (applicant) made a complaint to the Equal Opportunity Commission alleging racial discrimination by the City of Swan (City or respondent) in relation to actions taken by one of the City's rangers in respect of a deceased cat. The Commissioner for Equal Opportunity (Commissioner) described the Ms Lee's complaint as an allegation of race discrimination in the area of the provision of a good or service. After asking Ms Lee several times for further information and documentation, by letter dated 5 June 2019, the Commissioner dismissed Ms Lee's complaint as lacking in substance. On 6 June 2019 the applicant advised the Commissioner that she did not agree with the Commissioner's decision and requested that her complaint be referred to the Tribunal.
On 19 June 2019, the Tribunal received the Commissioner's referral, pursuant to s 90(2) of the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (WA) (EO Act), of Ms Lee's complaint. The matter was listed for a directions hearing on 3 July 2019. Ms Lee requested adjournment of that directions hearing on the basis that she was unwell. The Tribunal advised Ms Lee of the limited nature of the directions hearing and offered Ms Lee the ability to attend the directions hearing by telephone link. Ms Lee did not accept this offer and maintained her request for an adjournment. The directions hearing was vacated as requested. Prior to re-listing the directions hearing, the Tribunal attempted to liaise with Ms Lee as to a suitable date for the directions hearing. When she did not initially respond, Ms Lee was given three options and asked to advise her preference. When the Tribunal received no response from Ms Lee, the matter was listed…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read LEE and CITY OF SWAN and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] WASAT 120
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was whether the service provided by the City of Swan, or the lack thereof, could be considered discriminatory on the basis of race. The Tribunal had to determine if the service of providing an opportunity to potential owners of a deceased cat to identify the cat was a service customarily provided by the City of Swan, and if it was offered on different terms or not offered at all to Ms Lee based on her race. The Tribunal also had to consider whether there was sufficient evidence to establish that the failure to enquire at Ms Lee's residence was due to her race.
The Tribunal found that the service in question was a helpful or beneficial activity that could potentially allow the owner of a deceased cat to be informed of the cat's death and take charge of its burial. The Tribunal was satisfied that this task, if undertaken, could be considered a service. However, the Tribunal noted that there was no evidence that the enquiries were part of the employees' role or expected by the City of Swan. Additionally, there was no evidence that the failure to enquire at Ms Lee's residence was due to her race. The Tribunal concluded that the complaint was lacking in substance and did not raise a plausible case of discrimination. Therefore, the application to strike out the complaint was successful.
The Tribunal ordered that the complaint made by Ms Lee be struck out as lacking in substance.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
It is not necessary for the conduct to be required to be carried out by a person's terms of employment; it may be sufficient if it is a service that is customarily provided: Waters Waters v Public Transport Corporation [1991] HCA 49; 173 CLR 349 at 373 (Waters) In the circumstances of this case, the fundamental question is what is the good, service or facility which is available which was either refused or offered on different terms or in a different manner to Ms Lee on the grounds of her race? In this case, I think it can only be a 'service' that is in question, as the allegations do not raise any question of goods or facilities. There can be no question that the respondent provides services to residents within its local government area. However, it is necessary to identify the alleged service that is the subject of the complaint with some precision: Waters at 404-405. Ms Lee complains that the respondent's employees did not enquire at her residence on the day the deceased cat was found as to whether it belonged to anyone in the household, but did enquire at some other residences on Wheatstone Drive. It is not clear why the employees made these enquiries. There is no evidence on which the Tribunal would be able to conclude that such enquiries were part of the employees' role or were expected of them by the respondent. There is no evidence as to whether the enquiries conducted in relation to the deceased cat is something that is generally done when a deceased animal that appears to have been a pet is found by the respondent's employees. For the purpose of the strike out application, I consider it appropriate to assume that either this service is ordinarily provided, or if not, then offering the service to other people in Wheatstone Drive on this occasion is sufficient to establish that the respondent offered some people, but not others in Wheatstone Drive this service. For the purposes of this application, the Tribunal is satisfied that this task, if in fact undertaken, as it seemingly was, could be considered to be a helpful or beneficial activity. It might allow the deceased's cat's owner to be advised of the cat's death and take charge of burial of the cat if he or she wished. At least for the purposes of the strike out application, I am prepared to assume that Ms Lee could establish that the respondent's employees were carrying out a 'service' when they made enquiries in Wheatstone Road in order to attempt to identify the owner of a deceased cat. There is no allegation of any overt statement made orally or in writing to support the allegation that the failure to enquire at Ms Lee's residence was because of Ms Lee's race. There is no allegation that the respondent's employees who attended the area knew Ms Lee or had any knowledge of her race or racial background. The evidence, taken at is highest indicates that the respondent's employees made enquiries at some residences in Wheatstone Drive and not at others. The racial background is provided for only some residences that were visited, and for only some of the residences that were not visited. Again, whether the respondent's employees knew the racial background of the occupants of the residences that were not attended is not known.