Lease Collateral v Johnson

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Lease Collateral v Johnson [2018] NSWSC 452
Hearing dates: 23/03/2018
Date of orders: 23 March 2018
Decision date: 23 March 2018
Jurisdiction:Equity - Commercial List
Before: McDougall J
Decision:

Applicant released from “Harman” implied undertaking of confidentiality in respect of one category of documents. Applicant to pay costs of opponent.

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE – application for release from Harman undertaking – where release sought in relation to documents produced on subpoena – where it would be open to applicant to also subpoena those documents – application granted.

  COSTS – where costs tail wags substantive dog – where applicant originally sought unjustifiably broad order – where orders significantly narrowed day before hearing – where real dispute was as to costs – applicant ordered to pay costs of respondent.
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Lease Collateral Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Ian David Johnson (First Defendant)
ACN 093 752 893 Pty Limited (Second Defendant)
Christopher James Munday (Third Defendant)
David Andrew Marshall (Fourth Defendant)
Helmsman Funds Management Limited CAN 100 489 763 (Fifth Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
JAC Potts SC (Plaintiff)
JA Watson (First, Third and Fourth Defendants)
A Doumani (Second and Fifth Defendants)

  Solicitors:
Corrs Chambers Westgarth (Plaintiff)
Mills Oakley (First, Third and Fourth Defendants)
Ashurst (Second and Fifth Defendants)
File Number(s): 2016/293219

Judgment   (ex tempore – revised 12 APRIL 2018)

  1. HIS HONOUR:   This judgment deals with a notice of motion filed by a defendant seeking to be released from the usual undertaking as to confidentiality - the "Harman" undertaking - in respect of some four categories of documents. The first category comprises documents produced on subpoena. The second category comprises all the plaintiff's lay and expert evidence. The third and fourth categories between them comprise all the evidence of the defendants, both lay and expert.

  2. The suggested purpose for which the documents were required is for use in proceedings that are said to be related in various ways to, and to involve common issues of fact, with these proceedings.

  3. Release from the undertaking is of course a matter for the Court, and is not something that can be dealt with simply by the parties by consent between them. Nonetheless, where a party either consents to or does not oppose the order, the Court will be more inclined to give its consent, provided it is satisfied that there is some reasonable basis for the request and that making the order will not unduly infringe on the rights of third parties.

  4. In the present case, there could have been little basis to object to the order in respect of the first category - documents produced on subpoena. As I see the matter at present, it would have been open to the applicant on the motion to issue similar subpoenas in the related proceedings and obtain the documents that way.

  5. Different considerations apply to the evidence. The affidavits and reports are produced in effect under compulsion, pursuant to directions from time to time given by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lease Collateral v Johnson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWSC 452
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lease Collateral v Johnson involved an application by the defendant, Lease Collateral, to be released from a Harman undertaking in relation to certain documents produced on subpoena. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The primary focus of the dispute was whether the court should grant the defendant’s application to be released from the undertaking, given that it could also obtain the same documents through a subpoena. The respondent, Johnson, opposed the application and argued that the applicant’s conduct in seeking the release of the undertaking was unreasonable and wasteful.

The court was tasked with determining whether the applicant’s request for release from the Harman undertaking was reasonable and if the application was made in good faith. Additionally, the court needed to consider the conduct of the applicant in seeking the release, particularly in light of the respondent’s argument that the real issue was one of costs. The court had to weigh the applicant's entitlement to seek the release against the potential for the application to be seen as a waste of court resources.

In its judgment, the court found that it would be open to the applicant to also subpoena the documents in question, and as such, the application for release from the Harman undertaking was reasonable. However, the court was critical of the applicant's conduct, noting that the application originally sought an unjustifiably broad order, which was significantly narrowed just before the hearing. The court concluded that the real dispute was not about the documents themselves but about the costs incurred by the respondent. Consequently, the court ordered the applicant to pay the respondent’s costs, highlighting that the costs issue had dominated the proceedings, leading the court to characterise the situation as one where "costs tail wags substantive dog."

The court ordered Lease Collateral to pay the respondent's costs in relation to the application for release from the Harman undertaking. This decision underscored the importance of reasonable and proportionate litigation conduct, particularly in relation to applications that may be seen as wasteful of court resources. The court’s ruling emphasised that while the applicant was entitled to seek the release, the manner in which the application was conducted warranted a costs penalty.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case, Lease Collateral Pty Ltd sought to obtain certain documents from Johnson under a subpoena. Subsequently, Johnson applied to the court for an order to release him from his undertaking under the Harman doctrine in relation to those documents. The Harman undertaking is a legal principle in Australian civil procedure whereby a party who has obtained documents under a subpoena is not permitted to use those documents for any purpose other than the litigation in which the subpoena was issued, unless the court otherwise orders. Lease Collateral argued that it needed the documents to prepare its case, while Johnson contended that the documents were irrelevant and that the application for their release was an abuse of process. The central issue in this case revolves around the appropriateness of the court granting the application for release from the Harman undertaking.

This case came before the court as an application for the release of documents from the Harman undertaking. The matter was heard following a subpoena issued by Lease Collateral to Johnson. Prior to the hearing, Johnson applied to the court to be released from the Harman undertaking in relation to the documents. The application was made several days before the hearing, and the scope of the orders sought by Lease Collateral was significantly narrowed on the day before the hearing. The court had to determine whether to grant the application for release from the Harman undertaking and, if so, on what terms.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should grant the application for release from the Harman undertaking in relation to the subpoenaed documents.
2. If the application is granted, on what terms should the release from the Harman undertaking be granted.

Held
1. The court granted the application for release from the Harman undertaking in relation to the subpoenaed documents.
2. The court ordered the applicant to pay the costs of the respondent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application for release from the Harman undertaking in relation to the subpoenaed documents, noting that it would be open to the applicant to also subpoena those documents. The court examined the principle that the costs of litigation should not unduly influence the substantive merits of a case. The court found that the applicant's original application was unjustifiably broad and that the orders had been significantly narrowed the day before the hearing, with the real dispute being as to costs. The court held that it was appropriate to grant the application for release from the Harman undertaking, but ordered the applicant to pay the costs of the respondent to reflect the disproportionate focus on costs rather than the substantive issues. The court applied the principle that the costs of litigation should not be allowed to dominate the substantive issues and that orders should be proportionate to the real issues in dispute. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases where the focus of the application shifts significantly towards costs rather than the substantive issues, the court may still grant the application but should order the applicant to pay the costs of the respondent if appropriate.