Leahy and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) [2020] AATA 2164 (9 July 2020)
Division:Taxation and Commercial Division
File Number: 2020/0236
Re:Jeffery Leahy
APPLICANT
Tax Practitioners Board And
RESPONDENT
Decision
Tribunal:Senior Member Keith James
Date:9 July 2020
Place:Melbourne
Pursuant to section 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, the decision of the Respondent of 19 December 2019 to terminate the Applicant’s registration as a tax agent is stayed until further order of the Tribunal.
......................[sgd].............................................
Senior Member Keith James
Catchwords
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – stay application – termination of registration as a tax agent - consideration of principles in Scott – whether it is in the public interest for stay to be granted – consideration of purpose of legislative scheme – stay granted
Legislation
A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
Tax Agent Services Act 2009Taxation Administration Act 1953
Cases
Evans and Tax Practitioners Board [2019] AATA 1408
Gould and Tax Practitioners Board [2019] AATA 1056
Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission, Re (2009) 51 AAR 114
Very Important Business Pty Ltd and Commissioner of Taxation [2019] AATA 1120
XTWK and Australian Securities and Investments Commission, Re (2007) 98 ALD 131Secondary Materials
Australian Taxation Office, Penalty relating to statements: meaning of reasonable care, recklessness and intentional disregard, MT 2008/1, 12 November 2008
G T Pagone, Tax Avoidance in Australia (The Federation Press, 2010)
Tax Practitioners Board, Code of Professional Conduct – Explanatory Paper, TPB 01/2010, 16 December 2010REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member Keith James
9 July 2020
On 19 of December 2019, the Respondent terminated the Applicant’s registration as a tax agent pursuant to paragraph 40-5(1)(b) of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (the TASA) with effect from 23 January 2020. The Respondent further held that he should be prohibited from applying for registration under the TASA for a period of five years from the date on which the termination of his registration takes effect.
The Applicant was notified of the decision in a letter dated 6 January 2020.
On 14 January 2020, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision. On the same day, the Applicant also applied, pursuant to section 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act), for a stay of the decision.
It is this request for a stay that is the subject of this decision.
I have concluded that the stay should be granted for the reasons which follow.
The Tribunal’s Stay Power
Section 41(2) of the AAT Act provides:
The Tribunal may, on request being made by a party to a proceeding before the Tribunal (in this section referred to as the relevant proceeding), if the Tribunal is of the opinion that it is desirable to do so after taking into account the interests of any persons who may be affected by the review, make such order or orders staying or otherwise affecting the operation or implementation…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Leahy and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] AATA 2164
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether it was in the public interest to grant a stay of the Tax Practitioners Board's decision to terminate Mr Leahy's registration as a tax agent. This required the court to consider the principles established in *Scott* and the overarching purpose of the *Tax Agent Services Act 2009* (TASA) in regulating tax agent services. The court also examined the procedural fairness afforded to Mr Leahy in the Board's deliberations and the communication of its decision.
The court reasoned that the TASA scheme, established to ensure tax agent services are provided to the public in accordance with appropriate standards of professional and ethical conduct, involves a mandatory Code of Professional Conduct and a range of sanctions for breaches. The court noted discrepancies between the Board Conduct Committee's minutes and the letter issued to Mr Leahy detailing the decision, which raised questions about procedural fairness. Ultimately, the court found that it was in the public interest to grant the stay.
Background
Background to the litigation
The TPB's decision to terminate the Applicant's registration arose from findings that he did not meet the registration requirement of being a fit and proper person to hold a tax agent registration. The TPB’s decision letter, dated 6 January 2020, provided specific reasons for the decision, which included findings from the Conduct Committee meeting. However, there were discrepancies between the meeting minutes and the letter, with certain findings recorded in the minutes but omitted in the letter and vice versa. The Tribunal noted that these discrepancies were critical to assessing whether procedural fairness had been observed. The Applicant argued that the differences in the documentation suggested a lack of clarity and fairness in the decision-making process.
In response to the Applicant's assertions, the Tribunal reviewed the TPB's legislative framework, particularly the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (TASA), which established the TPB and its regulatory functions. The TASA aimed to ensure that tax agent services were provided to the public with appropriate standards of professional and ethical conduct. The Act introduced a mandatory Code of Professional Conduct for tax agents, alongside a range of administrative sanctions for breaches of this Code, including termination of registration. The Tribunal also noted the TPB's power to impose sanctions commensurate with the severity of misconduct, as outlined in the explanatory memorandum to the Bill that became the TASA legislation. The Applicant's stay application thus centred on whether the TPB's decision-making process adhered to the principles of procedural fairness and the purpose of the legislative scheme.
This matter before the tribunal concerns a stay application filed by the Applicant, Leahy, against the Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) regarding the termination of his registration as a tax agent. Leahy, who is self-represented, argues that the decision to terminate his registration was not made in accordance with the principles set out in Scott v ASIC, which pertain to procedural fairness. The tribunal notes that the decision to terminate Leahy's registration was made by the Board Conduct Committee of the Tax Practitioners Board on 19 December 2019, following an investigation into Leahy's conduct as a tax agent. The tribunal examines the Board's filings, including the minutes of the Conduct Committee meeting and the letter from the Respondent's Secretary and CEO to Leahy, which outlines the reasons for the decision. The tribunal's task is to determine whether it is in the public interest for a stay to be granted, considering the principles in Scott and the purpose of the legislative scheme.
In determining whether to grant the stay, the tribunal considers whether Leahy was afforded the appropriate level of procedural fairness during the Board's deliberations and in the reporting and communication of its decision. The tribunal examines the differences between the Board's minuted findings and the reasons provided in the letter to Leahy, which include additional matters not recorded in the minutes and omissions from the letter. The tribunal also considers the object of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (TASA), which is to ensure that tax agent services are provided to the public in accordance with appropriate standards of professional and ethical conduct, as well as the key reforms introduced by the TASA, including the establishment of the Tax Practitioners Board and the enactment of a mandatory Code of Professional Conduct for tax agents. The tribunal's decision to grant a stay will be based on the principles in Scott and the purpose of the legislative scheme, with a focus on whether the Board's decision-making process and communication of its decision to Leahy met the required standards of procedural fairness.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
These differences are further discussed later in these reasons.acts scheme and registration and regulating power Section 2-5 of the TASA provides that the object of the TASA ‘is to ensure that tax agent services are provided to the public in accordance with appropriate standards of professional and ethical conduct.’ In his second reading speech, the then Minister advised that the bill ’will replace the existing law regulating tax agents in part VIIA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936. This part was introduced in 1943 and is now out of date and out of step with current tax and commercial environment.’[3][3] Commonwealth, Parliamentary Debates, House of Representatives, 13 November 2008, 10844 (Chris Bowen, Minister for Competition policy and Consumer Affairs, and Assistant Treasurer). The TASA scheme involves the establishment of the Board, endowing the Board with registration, conduct investigation and discipline functions, and the enactment of a mandatory Code of Professional Conduct (the Code). When the TASA was enacted in 2009 the introduction of the Code was seen as a ‘key’ element of the reforms. In the second reading speech the then Minister when introducing the Bill stated: The code will define the professional and ethical standards required of agents, and their roles and responsibilities. It will therefore provide clarity and certainty around the standards required and expected of agents. It will also provide a benchmark against which the board and taxpayers can evaluate the tax agent services being provided.[4]Another ‘key’ reform was the establishment of:a wider and more flexible range of administrative sanctions than those existing under the present arrangement. In cases of noncompliance with the code, the board will be able to impose a sanction that is commensurate with the severity of the misconduct, ranging from a written caution or an order to undergo training or work under supervision, through to termination of registration. The introduction of a range of constructive and educative sanctions for noncompliance will improve the standard of services provided to the public.[5][4] Ibid at 10845.[5] Ibid. This theme is continued in the Explanatory memorandum to the Bill that became the TASA legislation under the heading ‘Key elements of the new legislative Scheme’:The introduction of a Code of Professional Conduct1.19 A Code of Professional Conduct (Code) governs the ethical and professional standards of tax agents and BAS agents. The Code is set out as a statement of principles and the Board may issue binding written guidelines for the interpretation and application of the Code.1.20 A formal legislative code has been a key aspect of the new legislative regime since it was first recommended in 1994 by the Report of the National Review of Standards for the Tax Profession, Tax Services for the Public. This report recommended that any such code should be made binding through legislation to enable the Board to impose sanctions for breaches and thereby to enforce compliance with the code.A Range of sanctions for breaches of the Code of Professional Conduct1.21 Under the new arrangements, if a tax agent or BAS agent has breached the Code, the Board has a range of options. The Board may caution the agent, require the agent to complete a course of training, subject the agent to practising restrictions, require the agent to practice under supervision, or suspend or terminate the agent’s registration. (Currently, the state Boards are only able to suspend or terminate registration.)[6][6] Explanatory Memorandum, Tax Agent Services Bill 2008, 10.