Le'Sam Accounting Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

Le'Sam Accounting Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board [2021] AATA 1593 (21 May 2021)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL              )
  )         No: 2020/0223 - 24
TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION            )

Re: Le'Sam Accounting Pty Ltd
Applicant

Re: Sam Rizkallah
Applicant

And: Tax Practitioners Board
Respondent

DIRECTION

TRIBUNAL:  Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

DATE OF CORRIGENDUM:            31 May 2021

PLACE:           Sydney

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the text of the decision in these applications as follows:

  1. Delete paragraph one of the orders, found on the first page of the decision, and replace with “The decisions made under ss 40-5(1)(b) and 40-15(1)(b) of the TAS Act, to terminate the registration of both Mr Rizkallah and Le’Sam Accounting Pty Ltd as tax practitioners, are affirmed.”

1        

  1. Delete the first sentence of paragraph sixty four and replace with “The Tribunal affirms the decisions made under ss 40-5(1)(b) and 40-15(1)(b) of the TAS Act to terminate the registration of both Mr Rizkallah and Le’Sam Accounting Pty Ltd as tax practitioners”.

.............................SGD........................
Bernard J McCabe, Deputy President

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):       2020/0223 - 24

Re: Le’Sam Accounting Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndSam Rizkallah

APPLICANT

Tax Practitioners BoardAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

Date:21 May 2021

Place:Sydney

1.The decisions made under s 20-5 of the TAS Act, to terminate the registration of both Mr Rizkallah and Le’Sam Pty Ltd as tax practitioners, are affirmed.

2.The decision of the Board to impose a non-registration period on Mr Rizkallah, pursuant to s 40-25 of the TAS Act, is varied to prevent him from applying for registration for a period of three and a half years.

3.The decision of the Board to impose a non-registration period on Le’Sam Accounting Pty Ltd, pursuant to s 40-25 of the TAS Act, is set-aside. The Tribunal decides in substitution that a non-registration period should not be imposed.

...........................SGD........................

Bernard J McCabe, Deputy President

Catchwords

REGISTRATION AS A TAX AGENT – where the records of a former client were improperly accessed – where the former client was engaged in litigation against the applicant – where the applicant was evasive, dishonest and non-compliant in his dealings with the respondent – where the applicant was late in filing a personal income tax return - where the applicant was evasive in his evidence provided to the Tribunal – applicant no longer satisfies the fit and proper person requirement for registration – decisions under review affirmed – periods precluding application for re-registration varied

Legislation

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)
Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth)

Cases

Hill and the Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 678

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Pochi [1980] FCA 85

Stasos v Tax Agents Board [1990] FCA 379

Sullivan v Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2014] FCAFC 93

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Bernard J McCabe

  1. Sam Rizkallah has been a registered tax agent for the better part…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Le'Sam Accounting Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1593
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Le'Sam Accounting Pty Ltd and its director, Mr. Rizkallah, against decisions made by the Tax Practitioners Board. The dispute arose from Mr. Rizkallah's improper access to the tax portal of a former client, Mrs. Bardetta, who was engaged in litigation against him. The Board found that Mr. Rizkallah had been evasive, dishonest, and non-compliant in his dealings with them, and had also failed to file his personal income tax return on time. These actions led the Board to conclude that Mr. Rizkallah no longer satisfied the requirement of being a fit and proper person for registration as a tax agent.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr. Rizkallah and Le'Sam Accounting Pty Ltd continued to meet the fit and proper person requirements for registration as tax practitioners, and if not, what period should preclude them from re-registration. The Tribunal was required to consider the gravity of Mr. Rizkallah's conduct, including his evasiveness and misrepresentations to the Board, and to balance the interests of the applicants against the public interest in maintaining the integrity of the tax profession.

Deputy President McCabe P found that Mr. Rizkallah's behaviour demonstrated fundamental character flaws rather than mere ignorance. The Tribunal affirmed the decisions to terminate the registration of both Mr. Rizkallah and Le'Sam Accounting Pty Ltd as tax practitioners, concluding that deregistration was the only appropriate course given the demonstrated character flaws. The Tribunal varied the period of non-registration for Mr. Rizkallah, imposing a period of three and a half years, finding that this longer period would serve as both specific deterrence to him and general deterrence to other tax agents.

In relation to Le'Sam Accounting Pty Ltd, the Tribunal set aside the Board's decision to impose a three-year non-registration period. Instead, the Tribunal decided that no such period should be imposed on the company, reasoning that the message of general deterrence was adequately communicated by the action taken against Mr. Rizkallah personally.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The non-responsiveness of the responses was not merely unhelpful. It was actively evasive – which brings me to my second observation about the correspondence: it misrepresented facts that were known to Mr Rizkallah at the time. That much is clear from Mr Rizkallah’s statement dated 20 September 2020 which was provided shortly before the hearing. In that statement (at [24]), Mr Rizkallah recalls the following exchange with Ms Nashed:At this time in late August 2019, I recollected that it was Marilise Nashed whomI had asked to assist in the inquiry as to whether Mrs Bardetta was still a client. I hadher come into my office and we had a conversation to the following effect:SR: “I have received a complaint from the Tax Board about accessing [Mrs B’s] tax portal information. They say it happened on 4 and 7 March 2019.I asked you to check if she was still a client. What did you do?”MN: “You asked me to check is she was still a client and gave me her tax filenumber. I couldn’t see [Mrs B] on our portal so I added her on”.SR: Why did you appoint me as her tax agent? I only asked you to see if shewas still a client”.MN: “She wasn’t on our system”.SR: (angrily) “I am now under investigation for misconduct. They are saying Idid it to help with a family law case I am involved in”.MN: (crying) “She wasn’t on our system. That is the only way I could havefound out”.SR: (softening) “Don’t worry. I will handle it. I will talk to you later”. The date of the conversation with Ms Nashed is important. The statement confirms it took place in August 2019 – that is, at the time the Board first asked about unauthorised access. Indeed, the statement makes clear on its face that the conversation with Ms Nashed was prompted by the Board’s preliminary enquiry. It follows Mr Rizkallah was, on his own evidence, aware from the time the Board first approached him that an employee had accessed the portal in problematic circumstances. Mr Rizkallah was asked about this in cross-examination. The exchange began with Mr O’Mahoney, counsel for the Board, quoting from the letter dated 9 September 2019 sent on behalf of the applicant to the Board which asserted (transcript at pp 127 - 128): “There is no valid complaint we call upon you to immediately terminate your investigation.” The exchange continued:Mr O’Mahoney: Do you see that?Witness: Yes, I do.Mr O’Mahoney: That was you attacking the integrity of the complaint. Correct?Witness: Yes, I was.Mr O’Mahoney: That was you saying there was nothing to it. Correct?Witness: Yes.Mr O’Mahoney: That was you inviting the very body charged with investigating you to terminate immediately that investigation. Correct?Witness: Yes.Mr O’Mahoney: You did that knowing that there was substance to this complaint because you had a conversation with your colleague about the inappropriate access in late August. Correct? Witness: Yes.Mr O’Mahoney: So really this was you inviting the board to stop an investigation that you knew would unearth unauthorised conduct in terms of access of [Mrs B’s] tax agent portal. Correct?Witness: Yes.Mr O’Mahoney: If I then ask you to look at the next paragraph, sir. You take issue with the end with the fact that the complaint is not even signed and the words “anyone could have made that complaint.” Do you see that?Witness: Yes.Mr O’Mahoney: This is you once again not meaningfully responding and honestly responding to the questions asked of you. Correct?Witness: Yes.Mr O’Mahoney: But actually attacking the complaint and attacking the process. Correct?Witness: Yes.Mr O’Mahoney: You’d accept, would you not, as an accountant of 36, 37 years standing, that is an entirely inappropriate way to respond to a statutory notice from the Board?Witness: Yes.Mr O’Mahoney: It’s a disgraceful way to respond to a statutory notice from the Board, you’d accept that?Witness: Yes.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While I considered whether it was appropriate to impose a period of non-registration on the company to send a message of general deterrence, I am satisfied that message is adequately communicated by the action taken against Mr Rizkallah. Conclusion The Tribunal affirms the decisions made under s 20-5 of the TAS Act to terminate the registration of both Mr Rizkallah and Le’Sam Pty Ltd as tax practitioners. The Tribunal varies the decision of the Board to impose a non-registration period on Mr Rizkallah pursuant to s 40-25 so that he is prevented from applying for registration for a period of three and a half years. The Tribunal sets aside the decision of the Board under s 40-25 which imposed a three-year non-registration period on Le’Sam Pty Ltd and decides in substitution that the non-registration period should not be imposed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I am not satisfied that conditions of that kind are appropriate in the circumstances. Mr Rizkallah’s difficulties are not the product of ignorance. The problems with his behaviour are more fundamental than that. Given the gravity of the factual findings I have made, deregistration is the only appropriate course for Mr Rizkallah. He cannot safely remain in practice given the character flaws he has demonstrated. In circumstances where Mr Rizkallah is the only director of Le’Sam, there is no good reason why the company should not be deregistered as well. For what period should the applicants be prevented from seeking (re)registration? The more difficult question is the length of time during which the applicants should be prevented from seeking (re)registration. The power to impose a period during which a deregistered agent may not apply for registration is contained in s 40-25. The discretion to impose such a period is discretionary. I will deal with Mr Rizkallah first. The Board decided Mr Rizkallah should be prevented from applying for registration for three years. In final submissions, Mr O’Mahoney on behalf of the Board submitted there were good reasons for the Tribunal to consider extending the duration of the exclusion period from three years to four years. Mr O’Mahoney pointed out the Tribunal’s proceedings are conducted de novo, and there was no reason in principle why the exclusion period could not be extended if the Tribunal formed the view that was the correct or preferable decision. The Board says the additional details disclosed at the hearing were more damning, which meant a four-year exclusion period might be more appropriate. Mr O’Mahoney also pointed out the applicants had been warned about the possibility the Tribunal might consider imposing a longer period of exclusion. The applicants had the opportunity to withdraw their application in light of the Board’s submissions, and to make their own submissions in reply. It is appropriate to have regard to a range of considerations when determining the length of any exclusion period. The interests of the applicants are obviously relevant. Mr Rizkallah will experience significant economic loss if he is unable to continue as a registered tax practitioner. That will impact on his family. The nature and extent of that hardship was described in his statements provided in support of the stay application. He has already incurred significant expense in conducting these proceedings, although he has also had the benefit of a stay of the reviewable decision. The employees of Le’Sam might also lose their jobs if the practice were to close. Mr Rizkallah’s clients may also experience disruption if he is unable to play a central role in the business, and they will be forced to engage a new firm if Le’Sam is unable to continue. Having said that, the clients will be protected from lax data security and the risk of other shortcomings associated with Mr Rizkallah’s practice. The public interest is decisive in a case like this. The length of the exclusion period sends a signal which helps promote the objectives in the TAS Act. A longer period of exclusion provides specific deterrence to Mr Rizkallah who has not yet demonstrated appropriate insight into the gravity of his behaviour. A significant exclusion period would help him in this regard. Importantly, a significant exclusion period also sends a signal of general deterrence: it reminds other tax agents of the importance of data security, of the need to avoid conflicts of interest when handling information about former clients, and – in particular – the need to respond appropriately and honestly to the Board as it carries out its functions.