SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: Le Grand v CJC (No 2) [2001] QCA 432 PARTIES: PIERRE MARK LE GRAND
(applicant/appellant/respondent)
v
CRIMINAL JUSTICE COMMISSION
(respondent/respondent/applicant)FILE NO/S: Appeal No 7658 of 2001
No number allocated belowDIVISION: Court of Appeal PROCEEDING: Miscellaneous Application – Civil ORIGINATING COURT: Supreme Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON: 12 October 2001 DELIVERED AT: Brisbane HEARING DATE: 25 September 2001 JUDGES: Davies and Williams JJA, White J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders madeORDER: The order made 14 September 2001 be vacated.1.
The following documents in the Appeal Record and in the court file relating to proceedings CA 7658 of 2001 and the antecedent proceedings in the Trial Division commenced by Originating Application filed on 16 August 2001 be placed in a sealed envelope or envelopes marked with the relevant court file number or numbers and marked “Not To Be Opened Without An Order Of The Court” and that such envelope be opened only if the Court orders it to be opened:-2.
Exhibits “B6”,“B7”,“B8”,“B9”,“B10”,“B11” and “B12” to the affidavit of Andrew Boe affirmed on 15 August 2001; (a)
Exhibits “A”,“B1”,“B2”,“C1”,“C2”,“D” and “G” to the affidavit of Pierre Mark Le Grand; (b)
The pages containing paragraphs 4(a),4(b) and 4(c) of the Originating Application (pages 2 and 3); (c)
The pages containing paragraphs 18 and 20 to 22 of the affidavit of Andrew Boe affirmed 15 August 2001 (pages 6 and 7);(d)
The pages containing the following parts of the Boe & Callaghan memorandum dated 10 August 2001 (Exhibit “A” to the affidavit of Andrew Boe):(e)
paragraphs 32.2 and 32.3 on page 7;(i)
the heading immediately above paragraph 39 on page 9;(ii)
paragraph 39 on page 9 to paragraph 45 on page 10, including footnotes contained therein;(iii)
paragraph 47 on page 11 to paragraph 64 on page 14, including footnotes contained therein(iv)
the second and third lines in paragraph 65 on page 14;(v)
paragraphs 67 and 70 and footnote 48 on page 15;(vi)
the third line of paragraph 72.6 on page 16;(vii)
paragraph 73 on page 16;(viii)
paragraphs 77.2.1 and 77.2.2 on page 17; and(ix)
footnote 54 on page 17;(x)
the pages containing the following parts of exhibit “H” to the affidavit of Andrew Boe, which also comprises exhibit “BJB1” to the affidavit of Brendan Butler sworn 16 August 2001:(f)
the third line in paragraph 6 on page 2; and(i)
the first line of the paragraph numbered “2” on page 2;(ii)
the pages containingthe following parts of the affidavit of Pierre Mark Le Grand sworn 15 August 2001: (g)
paragraphs 8.1 and 8.2 on page 3;(i)
paragraphs 8.3 on page 4;(ii)
the third line of paragraph 28.6 on page 13;(iii)
the last four lines of paragraph 28.6 on page 14;(iv)
the last line on page 14 in paragraph 28.8; and(v)
the first four lines on…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Le Grand v Criminal Justice Commission (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] QCA 432
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the privilege attached to certain documents was lost due to their disclosure in court proceedings. It also considered the appropriateness of issuing non-disclosure orders concerning documents that pertain to third-party interests in potential criminal proceedings and documents not subject to legal professional privilege. Furthermore, the court explored the applicability of parliamentary privilege and whether it could override legal professional privilege. The court's reasoning centred on the need to balance the public interest in transparency and accountability with the protection of sensitive information that could prejudice ongoing or potential criminal proceedings.
Ultimately, the court found that certain documents needed to be sealed and protected from public disclosure to safeguard the integrity of potential criminal proceedings and the legal professional privilege involved. It ordered specific parts of the documents to be placed in sealed envelopes, with access restricted unless further ordered by the court. The court also prohibited the respondent from disclosing the contents of these documents to any person without the appellant's consent. The decision underscored the importance of maintaining confidentiality in legal matters while ensuring that the public interest is adequately considered.
Orders
Orders of the court
The order made 14 September 2001 be vacated.1.
The following documents in the Appeal Record and in the court file relating to proceedings CA 7658 of 2001 and the antecedent proceedings in the Trial Division commenced by Originating Application filed on 16 August 2001 be placed in a sealed envelope or envelopes marked with the relevant court file number or numbers and marked “Not To Be Opened Without An Order Of The Court” and that such envelope be opened only if the Court orders it to be opened:-2.
Exhibits “B6”,“B7”,“B8”,“B9”,“B10”,“B11” and “B12” to the affidavit of Andrew Boe affirmed on 15 August 2001; (a)
Exhibits “A”,“B1”,“B2”,“C1”,“C2”,“D” and “G” to the affidavit of Pierre Mark Le Grand; (b)
The pages containing paragraphs 4(a),4(b) and 4(c) of the Originating Application (pages 2 and 3); (c)
The pages containing paragraphs 18 and 20 to 22 of the affidavit of Andrew Boe affirmed 15 August 2001 (pages 6 and 7);(d)
The pages containing the following parts of the Boe & Callaghan memorandum dated 10 August 2001 (Exhibit “A” to the affidavit of Andrew Boe):(e)
paragraphs 32.2 and 32.3 on page 7;(i)
the heading immediately above paragraph 39 on page 9;(ii)
paragraph 39 on page 9 to paragraph 45 on page 10, including footnotes contained therein;(iii)
paragraph 47 on page 11 to paragraph 64 on page 14, including footnotes contained therein(iv)
the second and third lines in paragraph 65 on page 14;(v)
paragraphs 67 and 70 and footnote 48 on page 15;(vi)
the third line of paragraph 72.6 on page 16;(vii)
paragraph 73 on page 16;(viii)
paragraphs 77.2.1 and 77.2.2 on page 17; and(ix)
footnote 54 on page 17;(x)
the pages containing the following parts of exhibit “H” to the affidavit of Andrew Boe, which also comprises exhibit “BJB1” to the affidavit of Brendan Butler sworn 16 August 2001:(f)
the third line in paragraph 6 on page 2; and(i)
the first line of the paragraph numbered “2” on page 2;(ii)
the pages containingthe following parts of the affidavit of Pierre Mark Le Grand sworn 15 August 2001: (g)
paragraphs 8.1 and 8.2 on page 3;(i)
paragraphs 8.3 on page 4;(ii)
the third line of paragraph 28.6 on page 13;(iii)
the last four lines of paragraph 28.6 on page 14;(iv)
the last line on page 14 in paragraph 28.8; and(v)
the first four lines on page 15 in paragraph 28.8;(vi)
the pages containing the following passages in the appellant’s outline below:(h)
paragraphs 19.1,19.2 and 19.3 on page 6; (i)
the third and fourth lines in paragraph 38 on page 9;(ii)
footnotes 29,30 and 31 on page 9; (iii)
the fourth line in paragraph 44 on page 11; and(iv)
footnote 38 on page 11;(v)
(i) page 2 of the judgment of de Jersey CJ in respect of the last five lines of paragraph 4;
the page containing line 3 of paragraph 21 of the respondent’s outline before this court (page 7);(j)
the pages containing the following passages in the appellant’s outline before this court:(k)
paragraph 33.2.4 (page 10); and(i)
footnote 29 (page 11);(ii)
the page containing the first line of paragraph 19.1 of the affidavit of Pierre Mark Le Grand;(l)
pages 45 to 47 of exhibit B to the affidavit of Terence Douglas Martin containing the text in the section headed “The Grenning Allegations”’ and(m)
the documents tendered as exhibit 1 in the Court of Appeal on 29 August 2001.(n)
3. The appellant lodge in the Registry forthwith an amended copy of the pages of the documents listed at 2(c) to 2(m) above duly amended by deleting the paragraphs, lines and footnotes set out in 2(c) to 2(m) to replace the pages subject to this order.
4. The respondent is prohibited from publishing or disclosing the contents of the documents and parts of the documents listed at 2(a) to 2(n) above to any person other than with the express written consent of the appellant.
The respondent is to take steps to ensure that all copies of the documents and parts of documents listed at 2(a) to 2(n) above that are held by the respondent and its lawyers, including those provided to counsel, are placed in sealed envelopes on their own files with a copy of this order attached to each envelope, and held in a place that will reasonably protect confidentiality in the documents.5.
6.There be no order as to costs.
7. Liberty to apply.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter originated as an originating application filed by Pierre Mark Le Grand on 16 August 2001. The application was subsequently heard by the Trial Division of the Supreme Court of Queensland. An appeal was then brought before the Court of Appeal on 14 September 2001. The Director of Public Prosecutions applied for leave to intervene and to access certain documents produced in the proceedings. The Court of Appeal vacated the order made on 14 September 2001 and directed that specific documents be placed in sealed envelopes and opened only if the Court orders it. The Court also prohibited the respondent from disclosing the contents of these documents to any person without the express written consent of the appellant and ordered the respondent to take steps to ensure the confidentiality of the documents held by them.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Director of Public Prosecutions is granted leave to intervene in the proceedings brought by Pierre Mark Le Grand against the Criminal Justice Commission.
2. Whether legal professional privilege has been lost through the disclosure of documents in court.
3. What is the extent of the Criminal Justice Commission's duty to report to the Parliamentary Criminal Justice Committee, subject to legal professional privilege.
4. Whether it is appropriate to make non-disclosure orders with respect to documents concerning third party interests in potential criminal proceedings and other miscellaneous documents not subject to legal professional privilege.
5. How the application of parliamentary privilege under the Parliamentary Papers Act 1992 (Qld) interacts with the legal professional privilege in this context.
Held
1. The Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld) was not granted leave to intervene in the proceedings brought by Pierre Mark Le Grand against the Criminal Justice Commission.
2. The court held that legal professional privilege had not been lost through the disclosure of documents in court.
3. The extent of the Criminal Justice Commission's duty to report to the Parliamentary Criminal Justice Committee, subject to legal professional privilege, was considered but not conclusively decided.
4. The court found it appropriate to make non-disclosure orders with respect to documents concerning third party interests in potential criminal proceedings and other miscellaneous documents not subject to legal professional privilege.
5. The court determined that the application of parliamentary privilege under the Parliamentary Papers Act 1992 (Qld) did not override legal professional privilege in this context.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court addressed the application for leave to intervene by the Director of Public Prosecutions, emphasizing the importance of maintaining confidentiality and the privilege of communications between a client and their legal advisor. It was noted that the intervention could potentially prejudice the client's position, hence the leave was not granted. Regarding the issue of legal professional privilege, the court found that the privilege was not lost by virtue of the documents being served upon another party in court, as the disclosure in court was necessary for the determination of the case. The court also considered the extent to which the Criminal Justice Commission is required to report to the Parliamentary Criminal Justice Committee, suggesting that such reporting should be done with due regard to legal professional privilege. Furthermore, the court issued non-disclosure orders to protect the interests of third parties and documents that did not fall under legal professional privilege, indicating that such measures were necessary to balance the public interest with the protection of privileged information. Finally, the court examined the interaction between parliamentary privilege and legal professional privilege, concluding that the former does not automatically supersede the latter in this case. The decision highlights the delicate balance between the public's right to know and the protection of confidential communications essential for the proper functioning of the legal system.