Le Cornu v Hammill & Qual-Chem No. Scgrg-97-1025 Judgment No. S6655

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

LE CORNU FURNITURE & CARPET CENTRE PTY LTD

v  HAMMILL & QUAL-CHEM BUILDING SERVICES PTY LTD

Full Court
Coram: Matheson, Prior and Debelle JJ

Matheson J

On 1 August 1990 the first respondent, ("the plaintiff"), was employed by the second respondent,  ("Qual-Chem").   He was working on an asbestos roof on premises of the appellant,  ("Le Cornu"), at Scotland Road, Mile End, when portion of the roof collapsed.   The plaintiff fell a distance of approximately six metres through the aperture and his injuries included a fractured skull, and a fracture of his right wrist.  He sued Le Cornu and Qual-Chem in the District Court.  The learned trial judge found that Le Cornu was negligent and in breach of its statutory duty.  He rejected a plea that the plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence.  Le Cornu has appealed against that decision. 

His Honour assessed the plaintiff’s damages as follows:-

Non economic loss             
pastfuture  $40,000$45,000        $85,000.00
Past loss of earning capacity       $50,000.00
Future  economic loss       $250,000.00
Future medical expenses     $5,000.00
"Beck v Farrelly" award       $1,250.00
Special damages agreed (paid by Workcover)        $18,350.33
Interest     $3,100.00
Management fee         $50,000.00
         $462,700.33

Le Cornu has also appealed against his Honour’s assessment of damages for past and future loss of earning capacity, and against the award of a management fee. 

His Honour also found that Qual-Chem was negligent and in breach of its statutory duty.  Qual-Chem has not appealed.

The plaintiff has cross appealed.  He alleges that the amounts awarded for non-economic loss, for interest thereon, for past and future loss of earning capacity and the award for gratuitous assistance, both past and future, were manifestly inadequate. 

Qual-Chem issued a contribution notice against Le Cornu.   Relevant  to the issue of contribution was s.54 of the Workers’ Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 ("the Act") which at the relevant time, and so far as is material, provided:

  1. (1)    Subject to subsection (2), no liability attaches to an employer in respect of a compensable disability arising from employment by that employer except -

(a)     a liability under this Act;

or

(b)     a liability at common law for non-economic loss ...

(2) and (3) ...

(4a)   ...

(4b)  Where -

(a)     a worker suffers a compensable disability (not being a disability that arises out of the use of a motor vehicle and gives rise to a liability of a kind referred to in subsection (2));

and
(b)     action is taken against a person other than the employer for damages in respect of the disability,

the other person has no right to recover contribution from the employer;

... "

On the topic of contribution, the learned judge said:

"A contribution notice was issued by the second defendant against the first. By operation of s54(4b) of The Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act, Le Cornu is precluded from any similar recovery against Qual-Chem.

The exercise is to a large extent academic but I am obliged to make a finding upon the contribution notice as to the extent to which it is just and equitable that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Le Cornu v Hammill & Qual-Chem No. Scgrg-97-1025 Judgment No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6655
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Le Cornu Furniture and Carpet Centre Pty Ltd (appellant) has appealed against the decision of the trial judge that it was negligent in breach of a duty of care and statutory obligations. The Full Court considered the appeal and cross-appeal by the plaintiff, Hammill, and the cross-appeal by the second defendant, Qual-Chem Building Services Pty Ltd. The Full Court found that Le Cornu was in breach of a duty of care owed to the plaintiff, and that this duty was identifiable as a special duty imposed upon Le Cornu in all the circumstances of the case. The Full Court also found that the awards for economic loss should be varied and that the management fee fixed was plainly erroneous. The Full Court upheld the trial judge's findings that the appellant was in breach of a duty of care owed by it to the plaintiff, and that this duty was identifiable as a special duty imposed upon Le Cornu in all the circumstances of the case. The Full Court agreed with the trial judge's assessment of damages, with the exception of the award for past loss of earning capacity, future loss of earning capacity, and the management fee. The Full Court increased the award for past loss of earning capacity to $90,000, and for future loss of earning capacity to $325,000. The Full Court found that the award for management fee was plainly erroneous and would hear counsel further as to what sum, if any, should be awarded having regard to this court’s judgment.

The Full Court dismissed the appeal by Le Cornu, and allowed the cross-appeal by the plaintiff to the extent of increasing the awards for past loss of earning capacity, future loss of earning capacity, and to the extent of reducing the award for management fee. The Full Court agreed with the trial judge's findings in relation to the cross-appeal by the plaintiff and the cross-appeal by Qual-Chem Building Services Pty Ltd. The Full Court dismissed the cross-appeal by Qual-Chem Building Services Pty Ltd.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established