Le Breton v Pacific Mirage Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Le Breton v Pacific Mirage Limited (No 2) [2013] FCA 691

Citation: Le Breton v Pacific Mirage Limited (No 2) [2013] FCA 691
Parties: JUDITH ANNE LE BRETON v PACIFIC MIRAGE LIMITED ACN 010 585 967
File number(s): NSD 681 of 2012
Judge(s): EDMONDS J
Date of judgment: 16 July 2013
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – Crown lease of land in perpetuity to company limited by shares – sub-leases by company of self-contained suites in building erected on land to shareholders in company

CONTRACTS – construction of sub-lease – responsibility for repair and upkeep of roof top and roof areas – whether boundaries of premises sub-leased are the same as the perimeter of “the Suite” – sub-lessee responsible for repair and upkeep of areas extending to internal faces of all walls, ceilings and floors erected on or within the boundaries – sub-lessor responsible for repair and upkeep of roof top and roof areas  

Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 232, 233
Building Units and Group Titles Act 1980 (Qld) s 9
Date of hearing: 7 May 2013
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 29
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr MK Condon SC
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Price & Company
Counsel for the Defendant: Mr RD Marshall
Solicitor for the Defendant: Short Punch & Greatorix

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 681 of 2012

BETWEEN:

JUDITH ANNE LE BRETON
Plaintiff

AND:

PACIFIC MIRAGE LIMITED ACN 010 585 967
Defendant

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 JULY 2013

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The parties agree draft short minutes of order consistent with these reasons.

2.If the parties are unable to reach agreement so as to comply with order 1 by 23 July 2013, each party shall bring in draft short minutes of order consistent with these reasons and the Court will hear the parties at a mutually convenient time, with a view to making final orders.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 681 of 2012

BETWEEN:

JUDITH ANNE LE BRETON
Plaintiff

AND:

PACIFIC MIRAGE LIMITED ACN 010 585 967
Defendant

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE:

16 JULY 2013

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BACKGROUND

  1. The defendant (“Pacific Mirage”) is the lessee of certain land at Main Beach on the Gold Coast, Queensland, by virtue of a lease in perpetuity granted by the Crown commencing on 1 April 1988.  Upon that land is erected a building called “Pacific Mirage” (“Building”).  The Building comprises some 54 self-contained suites (“villas”) which Pacific Mirage sub-leases to its shareholders.

  2. In order to sub-lease a villa, a person must purchase a specific shareholding in Pacific Mirage, which shareholding confers an automatic right of exclusive sub-leasing of that villa, for the exclusive use and benefit of that particular shareholder.

  3. The applicant (“Ms Le Breton”) is the sub-lessee of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Le Breton v Pacific Mirage Limited (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 691
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Le Breton v Pacific Mirage Limited (No 2), the dispute centered around the interpretation of a sub-lease agreement regarding the maintenance responsibilities for a building known as the "Building" located in Queensland. The plaintiff, Ms Le Breton, sub-leased a suite known as Villa 43 from the defendant, Pacific Mirage Limited, which owned the underlying land and the Building. The crux of the matter was the interpretation of the sub-lease agreement, specifically concerning who was responsible for the maintenance of various parts of the Building, including the roof top and roof areas.

The legal issues before the court involved determining the boundaries of the premises sub-leased to Ms Le Breton and the extent of her maintenance obligations under the sub-lease agreement. The court had to ascertain whether the term "Suite" in the sub-lease included the roof top and roof areas, and if Ms Le Breton was responsible for the upkeep of these areas or if Pacific Mirage Limited, as the sub-lessor, retained this responsibility. The court also needed to interpret the obligations under clauses 3(t) and 5(c) of the sub-lease, particularly regarding the maintenance of the "Roof Garden" and the roof top.

The court determined that the boundaries of the sub-leased premises extended to the centre lines of the constructed walls, floors, and ceilings, in line with the Building Units and Group Titles Act 1980 (Qld). However, the court found that the term "Suite" in the sub-lease did not encompass the roof top and roof areas. Instead, the "Suite" was defined to include only the internal faces of the walls, floors, and ceilings. Consequently, the court held that Pacific Mirage Limited was responsible for the maintenance of the roof top and roof areas, while Ms Le Breton's obligations were limited to the interior of the Suite as defined in the sub-lease.

In conclusion, the court ruled that Pacific Mirage Limited was liable for the ongoing maintenance, repair, and upkeep of all planter boxes, garden areas, roof top and roof level areas, external balustrades, tiles, windows, and doors on or part of the external balcony and roof top garden areas for the suite known as Villa 43. The court directed the parties to draft short minutes of order consistent with its reasons and scheduled a hearing to make final orders if the parties could not agree on the terms of the order by a specified date.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties agree draft short minutes of order consistent with these reasons.

2. If the parties are unable to reach agreement so as to comply with order 1 by 23 July 2013, each party shall bring in draft short minutes of order consistent with these reasons and the Court will hear the parties at a mutually convenient time, with a view to making final orders.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Because Villa 43 includes an area on the roof level of the Building, the provisions of sub-cl 3(t) are relevant. Under para (b) the obligation of the sub-lessee is limited to keeping the Roof Garden in a clean and tidy condition at all times. There is no definition of the term “Roof Garden” but having regard to the context in which the term is used in the following paragraphs of sub-cl 3(t), it clearly encompasses the whole of the floor area delineated within A443 on the plan that is Annexure “B” and all structures, such as planter boxes and pergolas, built thereon. The obligation to keep the Roof Garden, and such structures, in good repair is, by virtue of the provisions of sub-cl 5(c), the obligation of Pacific Mirage, the Roof Garden not being within the “interior” of the Suite within the parenthetical exception to sub-cl 5(c), nor within the sub-lessee’s obligations under sub-cl 3(1). The floor, walls and such structures as there are, are the roof of the Building.CONCLUSION For these reasons, I am of the view that Pacific Mirage is liable for the ongoing maintenance, repair and upkeep of all planter boxes, garden areas, roof top and roof level areas, external balustrades, tiles, windows and doors on or part of the external balcony and roof top garden areas for the suite known as Villa 43. At this stage, I do not propose to make any orders or provide any other relief of the kind sought in the Originating Process. I propose to direct the parties to bring in draft short minutes of order consistent with these reasons but, if these cannot be agreed, for each party to bring in such short minutes of order. I will then hear the parties at a mutually convenient time, with a view to making final orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

All the submissions that follow are predicated on the correctness of this fundamental submission. The difficulty for Pacific Mirage’s case is that its fundamental submission is flawed, and its consequential submissions infected with error.ANALYSIS AND CONSIDERATION It may be accepted that the boundaries of the premises sub-leased to Ms Le Breton under the Sub-lease extend to the centre lines of the constructed walls, floors and ceilings. So much follows from the words of the preamble extracted in [9] above and the Notes, in particular para 2, on the plans that are Annexures “A” and “B” and para 1 on Annexure “C” (see [10] to [12] above). Moreover, so much is consistent with the position under the Building Units and Group Titles Act 1980 (Qld), s 9(5) of which provides:In a building units plan, the common boundary of any lot with another lot or with common property shall be the centre of the wall, floor or ceiling, as the case may be.While the Building is not registered under that Act, cl 7 of the Sub-lease reproduced in [17] above contemplates that if Pacific Mirage acquires the estate in fee simple in the land, the parties will endeavour to procure the subdivision of the land and the Building into lots pursuant to that Act. Having the boundaries of the sub-leases extend to the centre lines of the constructed walls, floors and ceilings would, no doubt, facilitate that process, and it is comprehensible that those responsible for the establishment of the Pacific Mirage scheme would have been so mindful. But it does not follow that the perimeter of “the Suite” extends to the boundaries of the sub-leased premises notwithstanding the parenthetical words “herein collectively called ‘the Suite’”, which immediately follow the references to plans “A”, “B” and “C” in the preamble. Those parenthetical words are not definitional, but for convenient articulation; they are subsumed in the definition of “the Suite” in cl 14, first by reference to the premises so described and second, by the “carve out”, albeit by implication, of anything but the internal faces of the walls, floors and ceilings. The consequence of such a construction giving rise to a difference between the boundaries of the premises, the subject of the Sub-lease, on the one hand, and the perimeter of “the Suite”, on the other, is to be preferred to consequential conflict, amounting to alleged repugnance, in the interaction contended for by Pacific Mirage. The definition of “suite” later in cl 14 further supports the view that the perimeter of “the Suite” is not coterminous with the boundaries of the leased premises but is confined, so that while it includes “the internal faces of all walls erected on the boundary of the premises and the internal faces of the ceilings and floors contained within those boundaries”, it does not include anything beyond those faces. Such a construction of what is and what is not “the Suite” for the purposes of the Sub-lease, creates a more harmonious context in which the operative provisions of the Sub-lease are to work and interact. That harmony provides for greater certainty of demarcation between what are the obligations of Pacific Mirage, on the one hand, and what are the obligations of the sub-lessee, in this case Ms Le Breton, on the other.