LE and CITY OF WANNEROO

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   LE and CITY OF WANNEROO [2010] WASAT 154

MEMBER:   MR D R PARRY (SENIOR MEMBER)

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   19 OCTOBER 2010

FILE NO/S:   DR 163 of 2010

BETWEEN:   DAN LE

THANGS FAMILY CO PTY LTD
Applicants

AND

CITY OF WANNEROO
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Development - Preliminary issue - Classification - Caretaker's dwelling - Grouped dwellings - Whether dwelling is 'caretaker's dwelling' ­ Whether proposed development is capable of approval

Legislation:

City of Wanneroo District Planning Scheme No 2, cl 1.9.2, cl 1.9.3, cl 3.2.1, cl 3.2.2, cl 3.2.3, cl 3.7.3(a), cl 3.17, cl 3.17.3, cl 3.17.3(a), cl 4.1, cl 4.2.1, cl 6.7, Sch 1
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1)

Result:

The proper classification of the proposed development is grouped dwellings under the City of Wanneroo District Planning Scheme No 2
The proposed development is not capable of approval under the City of Wanneroo District Planning Scheme No 2
Development application refused

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicants:     Mr MJ Hardy

Respondent:     Mr CA Slarke

Solicitors:

Applicants:     Hardy Bowen

Respondent:     McLeods

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Pearce and City of Wanneroo [2010] WASAT 77

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. Members of an extended family operate a market garden located on three allotments in Carabooda.  Twelve members of the family working in the business also reside in five dwellings on the property.  A development application was made in order to enable the construction of two additional dwellings on one of the allotments to accommodate other family members who work in the business.  The allotment in question already contains a dwelling.

  2. The City of Wanneroo refused to grant development approval because a provision of the local planning scheme only permits the Council to approve the development of 'a maximum of two grouped dwellings on a lot' in the zone.  The applicants sought review of this decision by the Tribunal and the parties identified the following preliminary issues for determination:

    1)What is the proper land use classification of the proposed development under the scheme?

    2)Is the proposed development capable of approval under the scheme?

  3. The Tribunal determined that the proper land use classification of the development under the scheme is grouped dwellings and that the development is not capable of approval as it would result in three grouped dwellings on the lot.  The Tribunal rejected the applicants' contention that the existing dwelling would be classified as a caretaker's dwelling, because it would not be used as a dwelling by 'a person having the care' (emphasis added) of the facility, as required by the definition of 'caretaker's dwelling'.  The existing dwelling would not be a 'caretaker's dwelling', because there are a considerable number of family members who collectively care for the facility, the care is, in any case, an incidental aspect of their work, and two adjoining dwellings on the lot would…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LE and CITY OF WANNEROO and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] WASAT 154
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between LE and the City of Wanneroo involved a dispute concerning the classification and approval of a proposed development on a property. The applicant, LE, sought to build additional dwellings on a lot classified under the Rural Resource zone. The City of Wanneroo, the respondent, opposed the application on the basis that the proposed development did not meet the criteria for approval under the applicable planning schemes and codes. The matter was brought before the Planning and Environment Court of Western Australia, which was tasked with determining whether the proposed development was capable of approval.

The primary legal issues revolved around the classification of the proposed dwellings as either 'caretaker's dwellings' or 'grouped dwellings', and whether the proposed development was in compliance with the relevant planning schemes and codes. The court had to assess whether the dwellings would be used by persons having the care of the facility, as defined under the Scheme, or if they would be considered grouped dwellings under the codes. The court also had to determine whether the proposed development exceeded the allowable number of grouped dwellings on the lot in the Rural Resource zone.

The court examined the evidence presented by the applicant and the submissions made by both parties. It found that the proposed dwellings would not be used by a person having the care of the facility, as all family members would collectively care for the market garden operation. Instead, the dwellings would be used by family members working in and caring for the facility, which was their principal work. As a result, the dwellings would be classified as grouped dwellings. The court concluded that the proposed development involved the construction of two grouped dwellings in addition to the existing dwelling, which would constitute a third grouped dwelling on Lot 106. This exceeded the allowable number of grouped dwellings under the planning schemes and codes, and therefore, the proposed development was not capable of approval.

In light of the court's findings, the City of Wanneroo was successful in its opposition to the development application. The court dismissed the application, and no development permit was granted for the proposed additional dwellings on Lot 106. The existing dwelling, however, was not subject to the court's decision and remained unaffected by the outcome of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As noted earlier, the letter from Drescher and Associates dated 10 July 2007 states that:All members of the family … participate in the market garden, sorting and distribution activity and all are required to be on call at all times to manage the growing, harvesting and distribution of the produce throughout Australia. …The very nature of the size of the land area involved and the extent of the scale and number of horticultural machinery required to run the operation as well as the number of production bores required to service the garden together with the extensive reticulation which require constant checking and maintenance warrants the demand for extra housing for the family who are all[,] in fact, caretakers of this intensive market garden operation. This therefore requires a considerable number of caretakers to maintain the plant and equipment as well as constant tending to establish crops.In fact, the supervision of the entire market garden operation requires every member of the family to be available on site. (Emphasis in bold added) In the circumstances of this case, the existing dwelling would not be used as a dwelling by 'a person having the care' of the facility (emphasis in bold added), as required by the definition of 'caretaker's dwelling' under the Scheme. Rather than a single person, there are a considerable number of family members who collectively care for the facility. As Drescher and Associates said, 'the family … are all[,] in fact, caretakers of this intensive market garden operation'. Furthermore, while the family members collectively care for the facility, it appears that this is merely an incidental aspect of their work. The principal element of their work is the operation of the market garden. Finally, the existing dwelling would adjoin the two proposed dwellings which would each be occupied by family members working in (and collectively caring for) the facility. There is not, therefore, to quote Thangs' and Mr Dan Le's submission, 'a legitimate and demonstrable need for a person to reside on the property [in the existing dwelling] to care for any building, plant, equipment or grounds', because members of the family who work in (and collectively care for) the market garden would also reside in two other dwellings on Lot 106 which would be in a similar location to the existing dwelling. As the existing dwelling and two proposed dwellings on Lot 106 would be 'a group of two or more dwellings on the same lot such that no dwelling is placed wholly or partly vertically above another', they each fall within the terms of the definition of 'grouped dwelling' under the Codes and, hence, for the purposes of DPS 2. The proper land use classification of the proposed development under DPS 2 is, therefore, grouped dwellings. Clause 3.17.3(a) of the Scheme allows the Council to approve a maximum of two grouped dwellings on a lot in the Rural Resource zone. The proposed dwelling is not capable of approval, because it involves the construction of two grouped dwellings in addition to the existing dwelling that would be a third grouped dwelling on Lot 106.