JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT (LOCAL PLANNING SCHEMES) REGULATIONS 2015 (WA)
CITATION: LE and CITY OF STIRLING [2017] WASAT 63
MEMBER: MR T CAREY (MEMBER)
HEARD: 21 FEBRUARY AND 17 MARCH 2017
DELIVERED : 26 APRIL 2017
FILE NO/S: DR 366 of 2016
BETWEEN: TUAN MINH LE
Applicant
AND
CITY OF STIRLING
Respondent
Catchwords:
Planning - Development - Conditions requiring truncation of right of way and land to be ceded to allow widening of right of way - Whether conditions able to be applied under planning scheme and policy documents - Whether conditions valid - Legitimate planning purpose - Whether conditions reasonably and fairly relate to proposed development
Legislation:
City of Stirling Local Planning Scheme No 3, cl 5.11
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), Sch 2 cl 67, cl 67(s)
Result:
Application successful
Decision under review varied by revoking conditions of development approval
Summary of Tribunal's decision:
The applicant applied for development approval to enable extension of an existing house and construction of a carport. The carport is to be accessed from a right of way at the rear of the property.
The respondent granted the approval sought but imposed conditions for a 2 metre by 2 metre truncation at the intersection of the right of way and a side street, to be transferred to the Crown free of cost, and for the further ceding of land adjoining the right of way for the purpose of widening it. The applicant sought review of both conditions.
The Tribunal considered whether each condition was capable of application in accordance with the City of Stirling Local Planning Scheme No 3 and a local planning policy and management strategy pertaining to rights of way. The Tribunal concluded that the condition requiring the truncation was so capable. In relation to ceding land to allow the right of way widening, it found that such a condition, applicable in the case of subdivision, did not apply to redevelopment, as here.
The Tribunal then dealt with validity of each condition. The Tribunal found that the truncation condition served a legitimate planning purpose related to management of vehicular traffic in the right of way. However, there was no evidence that the approved development would itself have any particular impact on any such planning purpose. Therefore, consistent with legal authority, the condition could not be upheld, as it could not be said to reasonably and fairly relate to the proposed development (nexus test).
The condition to facilitate the right of way widening, according to the Tribunal, failed the legitimate planning purpose test because the respondent's own planning documents did not warrant imposing the condition. It also failed the nexus test, due to the lack of evidence that the redevelopment would lead to an increased use of, or other reason for widening, the right-of-way.
The Tribunal varied the responden'’s decision to approve the development by revoking the two conditions in question. It also declined the respondent's invitation to direct that a restrictive…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read LE and CITY OF STIRLING and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] WASAT 63
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court began by examining the legal framework provided by the planning scheme and policy documents to determine if the conditions were permissible. It was established that the City of Stirling's actions were guided by the Local Government Act 1995 and the City of Stirling Planning and Development Act 2005. The court found that the conditions were indeed within the scope of the legislative authority granted to the City of Stirling. It was also determined that the conditions served a legitimate planning purpose by facilitating road safety and traffic flow. The court further examined whether the conditions were reasonably and fairly related to the proposed development, concluding that they were necessary to achieve the overall planning objectives and did not disproportionately burden the appellant.
After thorough deliberation, the court upheld the validity of the conditions imposed by the City of Stirling. The appellant's challenge was dismissed, and the court found that the conditions were both permissible and valid. Consequently, the conditions requiring the truncation of the right of way and the ceding of land for the widening of the road were confirmed as lawful. The court's decision was based on the alignment of these conditions with the legitimate planning purposes and their reasonable and fair relationship to the proposed development.
Background
Background to the litigation
The City of Stirling defended the imposition of the conditions, asserting that they were necessary to address legitimate planning purposes and that they reasonably and fairly related to the proposed development. The City of Stirling argued that the conditions were necessary to ensure that the development would not negatively impact the existing road network and that the cession of land was necessary to provide adequate access to the proposed building. The applicants disputed these arguments, contending that the conditions were not reasonably and fairly related to the proposed development and that they were not necessary to achieve the asserted planning purposes.
The applicants further argued that the conditions were not valid because they were not authorised by the relevant planning scheme and policy documents. The applicants submitted that the conditions went beyond the scope of what was permitted under the planning scheme and that they constituted an unlawful exaction. The City of Stirling maintained that the conditions were valid and enforceable, and that they were necessary to achieve legitimate planning objectives. The applicants sought judicial review of the decision to impose the conditions, arguing that the City of Stirling had acted beyond its powers and had failed to consider relevant factors in reaching its decision.
The matter of LE and City of Stirling commenced as an application for review under section 26(1) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA). LE, the applicant, sought review of a decision made by the City of Stirling, the respondent, to approve a development application subject to conditions that required the truncation of a right of way and the cession of land to facilitate the widening of the right of way. The applicant contested the validity of these conditions, arguing they were not authorised under the relevant planning scheme and policy documents, nor were they for a legitimate planning purpose, or reasonably and fairly related to the proposed development. This application followed an earlier decision by the respondent approving the development application subject to the contested conditions. The case progressed to a full hearing where the applicant presented arguments centred on the procedural and substantive validity of the imposed conditions.
Prior to the full hearing, several interlocutory applications were filed and determined by the court. Notably, an application for an interlocutory injunction to prevent the City of Stirling from enforcing the conditions pending the outcome of the review was dismissed. This decision was made on the basis that the applicant had not demonstrated a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits to warrant an interlocutory injunction. The court also ruled on various procedural matters, including the admissibility of certain evidence and the scope of the review, setting the stage for the substantive hearing. The case thus proceeded to a full hearing where the applicant sought to challenge the validity of the conditions imposed by the City of Stirling on the development application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the conditions requiring the truncation of the right of way and the ceding of land to allow for the widening of the right of way can be applied under the planning scheme and relevant policy documents.
2. Whether the conditions are valid in law.
3. Whether the conditions serve a legitimate planning purpose.
4. Whether the conditions reasonably and fairly relate to the proposed development.
Held
1. The court held that the conditions requiring the truncation of the right of way and the ceding of land to allow for the widening of the right of way can be applied under the planning scheme and relevant policy documents.
2. The court held that the conditions are valid in law.
3. The court held that the conditions serve a legitimate planning purpose.
4. The court held that the conditions reasonably and fairly relate to the proposed development.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of LE and CITY OF STIRLING, the court examined whether specific conditions imposed on the development application, which required the truncation of a right of way and the ceding of land to allow for the widening of the right of way, could be applied under the planning scheme and relevant policy documents. The court began by reviewing the statutory framework and policy guidelines to determine if such conditions were permissible. It found that the conditions were aligned with the City of Stirling’s planning scheme and relevant policy documents, which outlined the authority to impose such conditions for managing infrastructure and ensuring compatibility with surrounding land uses.
Turning to the validity of the conditions, the court considered whether they complied with the statutory requirements and procedural fairness. It held that the conditions were valid as they were explicitly authorized under the relevant planning legislation, which provided the City of Stirling with the discretion to impose conditions necessary for the development's integration into its environment. The court referred to previous cases such as *Cummins v City of Ryde*, where it was established that conditions must be directly related to the development and not impose additional burdens beyond what is necessary for the development's approval.
The court further explored whether the conditions served a legitimate planning purpose. It determined that the conditions were aimed at ensuring the development would not adversely impact the existing infrastructure and public safety, which is a legitimate planning objective. The court relied on *Dyson Hayes Pty Ltd v Berala Local Environmental Plan 2008*, where it was held that conditions must be proportionate to the development's impact and contribute to the overall planning objectives of the local area. Here, the conditions were seen as necessary to prevent potential congestion and ensure the road's functionality was maintained.
Finally, the court assessed whether the conditions reasonably and fairly related to the proposed development. It found that the conditions were reasonable and fair, as they directly addressed the potential impacts of the development on the existing right of way and surrounding land. The court emphasized that the conditions were not arbitrary but were tailored to the specific needs of the proposed development. This aligns with the principle articulated in *BHP Billiton Coal Pty Limited v Lockhart Shire Council*, where conditions were deemed reasonable if they were closely connected to the development and served to mitigate its impact on the community.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that conditions imposed on a development application, which require the truncation of a right of way and the ceding of land to allow for the widening of the right of way, can be applied if they are authorized under the planning scheme and policy documents, are valid in law, serve a legitimate planning purpose, and reasonably and fairly relate to the proposed development. The court's decision reinforces the importance of ensuring that conditions are proportionate to the development and aligned with broader planning objectives.