Law v Beaudesert Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT
COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Law v Beaudesert Shire Council [2000] QPEC 090
PARTIES: MICHAEL GRAHAM LAW
(Appellant)
v.
BEAUDESERT SHIRE COUNCIL
(Respondent)
and
FRIENDS OF TAMBORINE MOUNTAIN ASSOCIATION INC. & ORS
(Respondents by Election)
FILE NO/S: Appeal No. 4077 of 1999
DIVISION: Planning and Environment Court
PROCEEDING: Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:
DELIVERED ON: 24 May 2000
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARING DATE: 10-12 May 2000
JUDGE: Robin Q.C. D.C.J.
ORDER: Appeal Dismissed
CATCHWORDS:

Appeal by developer against condition attached by Council to rezoning approval – condition limited tourist cabins to 18, appellant sought 35 – appellant contended impacts should be assessed by reference to addition of 17 cabins, Council’s approval being the starting point – contention rejected – proper comparison was between land as is and as proposed to be developed by appellant – unusually large community input did not  entitle relevant Development Control Plan to special weight – feelings of local residents could be important in assessing amenity impacts, which are not limited to physical impacts, (which the secluded nature of site served to reduce) – applicability of the precautionary principle considered – although Court had jurisdiction to reduce the cabin numbers permitted by varying the condition, it would be unjust to do so in the absence of any cross-appeal by the respondents by election

(Local Government  (Planning and Environment) Act 1990 s. 4.3(1), s. 4.4(5A), s. 7.1(1), s.7.1()(3)
Integrated Planning Act 1997 s.1.2.3(2), s.6.1.2(1), s.6.1.3, s.6.1.23(1)(d), s.6.1.25

Arksmead Pty Ltd v Council of the City of Gold Coast & Ors, Appeal No. 4436 of 1999, 10 March 2000
Broad v Brisbane City Council (1986) 2 Qd.R. 317
Leatch v. National Parks and Wildlife Service (1993) 81 LGERA 270, 282
Yamauchi v. Jondaryan Shire Council (1998) QPELR 452, 459.

COUNSEL:

Mr M. Hinson SC for the appellant
Mr C. Hughes for the respondent
Mr Giffard for the first respondent by election
Ms Langslow for Tamborine Mountain Natural History Association, Friends of Tamborine Mountains and 21 respondents by election

SOLICITORS: Connor O’Meara solicitors for the appellant

Corrs Chambers Westgarth for the respondent

  1. In this appeal, Mr Law seeks relaxation of conditions imposed by the respondent Council in its approval of a requested rezoning of land at 135-139 Eagle Heights Road, Eagle Heights to Special Facilities (18 Accommodation Units, Caretaker’s Residence, Refreshment Services, Caterer’s Rooms and Tourist Facilities) Zone.  Although a number of conditions were originally in issue, by the time of the hearing, as between Mr Law and the Council, the sole live issue was whether the accommodation units should continue to be limited to 18, as allowed by the Council, or increased to 35, as sought in the rezoning application. 

  1. The rezoning application was lodged on 18 September 1997.  Given that the land abuts the Palm Grove National Park, an environmental impact statement was required, which was lodged on 27 March 1998, leading to the view being taken at some stages that this was the effective date of the application.  It was common ground on the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Law v Beaudesert Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] QPEC 90
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Law v Beaudesert Shire Council, the developer, Law, sought to appeal against a condition imposed by the Beaudesert Shire Council on the approval of a rezoning application. The condition limited the number of tourist cabins to 18, while Law sought permission for 35 cabins. The dispute was heard by the Queensland Land Court, which was required to determine whether the comparison for assessing the impacts of the proposed development should be made by reference to the approved 18 cabins or if the additional 17 cabins proposed by the appellant should be considered. Additionally, the court had to determine if the large community input warranted giving special weight to the Development Control Plan and if the precautionary principle was applicable in this case.

The court considered the proper comparison to be between the land in its existing state and the proposed development as intended by the appellant. It was held that the comparison should not be made by reference to the approved 18 cabins. The court also ruled that the unusually large community input did not entitle the Development Control Plan to special weight. Although feelings of local residents could be important in assessing amenity impacts, which are not limited to physical impacts, the secluded nature of the site served to reduce these concerns. The precautionary principle was not applicable in this instance, as the court found no evidence of a risk of serious or irreversible environmental damage.

The court had the jurisdiction to reduce the cabin numbers permitted by varying the condition, but it was deemed unjust to do so in the absence of any cross-appeal by the respondents. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed.

ORDERS:
Appeal Dismissed

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal Dismissed