Law Society Northern Territory v Petersen

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

CITATION:Law Society Northern Territory v Petersen [2025] NTSC 34      

PARTIES:LAW SOCIETY NORTHERN TERRITORY

v

PETERSEN, Patricia May

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:2020-01748-SC

DELIVERED:  6 June 2025

HEARING DATES:  24 & 25 March 2025

JUDGMENT OF:  Brownhill J

CATCHWORDS:

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS – Suitability matters – Applicant for admission – Duty of disclosure –Failure to disclose prior application for admission in another jurisdiction – Failure to disclose prior criminal matters and civil proceeding – Deliberate misrepresentation to admission authority – Deliberate dishonesty - Finding that legal practitioner lacks the capacity to discharge a lawyer’s responsibilities – Revocation of admission order – Removal of legal practitioner’s name from roll

Supreme Court Act 1979 (NT), s 22.

Supreme Court Rules 1987 (NT) -, Rule 95.01.

Legal Profession Act 2006 (NT), s 25, s 28, s 32, s 34, s 554.

Legal Profession Admission Rules 2007 (NT)

Connop v Law Society Northern Territory [2016] NTSC 38;Frugtniet v Board of Examiners [2002] VSC 140; Frugtniet v Board of Examiners [2005] VSC 332; In re Lee [2015] NTSC 22; Heffernan v Law Society Northern Territory [2023] NTCA 10 at [174]; Legal Services Commissioner v Scott [2014] QCA 266; O’Donnell v Reichard [1975] VR 916 at 929; Re Del Castillo (1998) 136 ACTR 1; Re Deo (2005) 16 NTLR 102; Re Gadd [2013] NTSC 13; Re OG (A Lawyer) (2007) 18 VR 164; Re OG [2007] VSC 197; Re Petrolias [2005] 1 Qd R 643; Re Warren [1976] VR 406; Re OG [2007] VSC 197, referred to.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Applicant:TJ Scotter                 

Respondent:  Self-represented              

Solicitors:

Applicant:Law Society Northern Territory            

Respondent:  Self-represented  

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:  Bro2505                  

Number of pages:  113        

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Law Society Northern Territory v Petersen [2025] NTSC 34

No. 2020-01748-SC

BETWEEN:

LAW SOCIETY NORTHERN TERRITORY

Applicant

AND:

PATRICIA MAY PETERSEN      Respondent

CORAM:    BROWNHILL J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 6 June 2025)

  1. The Supreme Court admitted the respondent (‘Petersen’) to the legal profession under s 25 of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (NT) (‘Act’) on 11 May 2020.

  2. Some years after her admission, the applicant (‘Society’) became aware of various matters which it said Petersen had failed to disclose in her application for admission in breach of the duty of candour. Those things included that Petersen had been charged with various criminal offences, that Petersen had, as a party, pursued unmeritorious litigation and been ordered to pay indemnity costs, and that Petersen had applied to be admitted to the legal profession in Queensland before making her application in the Northern Territory (‘Territory’).

  3. The Society argued that in the affidavit in support of her Territory application, Petersen had denied having applied for admission in another jurisdiction, which was deliberately dishonest and motivated by a desire to hide the other matters she had not disclosed.

  4. This deliberate dishonesty was argued…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Law Society Northern Territory v Petersen and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NTSC 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, the Law Society Northern Territory, sought orders that Patricia Petersen’s admission to the legal profession be revoked and her name struck from the roll of lawyers. The basis for the application was that Petersen had failed to disclose various criminal charges, a civil proceeding, and a prior application for admission in Queensland in her application for admission to the legal profession in the Northern Territory. Petersen was admitted as a local lawyer by the Supreme Court on 11 May 2020. The Society became aware of the matters not disclosed by Petersen in 2024. The Society argued that Petersen’s failure to disclose the matters in her application for admission amounted to a failure to comply with the duty of candour, which required her to disclose any matter which may reasonably be taken to bear on an assessment of fitness for legal practice. The Society further argued that Petersen had deliberately misled the Court and the NT Board by denying in her affidavit that she had previously applied for admission in Queensland, and that her failure to disclose the admitted suitability matters and deliberate dishonesty demonstrated that she was not a fit and proper person to be admitted to the legal profession. Petersen argued that the matters she failed to disclose in her application for admission were not suitability matters, that she had not deliberately misled the Court or the NT Board, and that she was a fit and proper person to be admitted to the legal profession. Brownhill J found that Petersen had failed to disclose various criminal charges, a civil proceeding, and a prior application for admission in Queensland. The evidence established that Petersen had been charged with various criminal offences, including offences in relation to election signs, obstructing Police, unlawful possession of a motor vehicle, making threats, imposing on the Commonwealth, and being in suspicion of stolen goods. She had also been a party to a civil proceeding in which she was ordered to pay indemnity costs. She had also applied for admission in Queensland. Petersen had failed to disclose those matters in her application for admission in the Territory, and had deliberately misled the Court and the NT Board by denying that she had applied for admission in Queensland. Brownhill J found that, by failing to disclose those matters, Petersen had failed to comply with the duty of candour, and had deliberately misled the Court and the NT Board. Those matters were relevant to an assessment of her fitness to practise as a lawyer. They bore on her good fame and character, and on her ability to meet professional standards, including her honesty, candour and respect for the law. The deliberate misrepresentation to the Court and the NT Board was a serious matter which demonstrated that Petersen was not a fit and proper person to be admitted to the legal profession. The order admitting Petersen as a lawyer was revoked and her name was struck from the roll of persons admitted to the legal profession. Petersen’s affidavits, and the affidavits of others, and certain notices to admit were subject to a non-publication order. The reasons for decision were not anonymised.

Background

Background to the litigation

Patricia May Petersen applied for admission to the legal profession in the Northern Territory in April 2020. The Law Society Northern Territory (‘the Society’) later became aware of various matters Petersen had failed to disclose in her application, including a prior application for admission in Queensland, criminal charges, and her involvement in unmeritorious litigation. The Society sought to have Petersen's admission revoked and her name removed from the roll of lawyers.

Petersen had applied for admission to the legal profession in Queensland in December 2019. She disclosed various criminal charges and mental health issues in that application. However, she did not disclose these matters in her Northern Territory application, and falsely stated that she had not previously applied for admission in another jurisdiction.

After her admission in the Northern Territory, Petersen pursued unmeritorious litigation against a political opponent, resulting in a judgment against her and an order to pay costs on an indemnity basis. She also filed documents in the Northern Territory proceedings which identified parties, children, and the subject matter of family law disputes, demonstrating a lack of capacity to discharge the responsibilities of a lawyer.

The Supreme Court found that Petersen had deliberately misled the Court and the Board in her application for admission, and revoked her admission and removed her name from the roll of lawyers. The Court also made non-publication orders in relation to certain evidence filed in the proceedings.

The Supreme Court of the Northern Territory received an application from the Law Society Northern Territory to revoke the admission of Patricia May Petersen as a legal practitioner and remove her name from the roll of persons admitted to the legal profession. The matter was heard by Brownhill J over two days in March 2025, with the judgment delivered in June 2025. The Society argued that Petersen had failed to disclose prior applications for admission, criminal matters, and civil proceedings in her original application for admission, which constituted deliberate dishonesty. These failures were said to demonstrate that Petersen lacked the capacity to discharge a lawyer's responsibilities, warranting the revocation of her admission and the removal of her name from the roll. The matter came before the Court as an application under the inherent jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to review a decision to admit a person to the legal profession. The Supreme Court Act 1979 (NT) and the Supreme Court Rules 1987 (NT) provide for the Full Court to exercise jurisdiction over matters relating to the discipline of a lawyer, but the Court may refer such matters to a single Judge if appropriate. This application was referred to a single Judge due to the large volume of evidentiary material and the need for findings of fact. The Society sought and was granted leave to make the application and be heard, consistent with its entitlements under the Legal Profession Act 2006 (NT). The onus of proof was held to rest with the Society, as the moving party seeking the revocation of an order of admission.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the applicant for admission have a duty to disclose her prior application for admission in Queensland and, if so, did she fulfil that duty?
2. Was the statement in the applicant's affidavit that she had not previously applied for admission to the legal profession in another jurisdiction deliberately false and dishonest?
3. Did the applicant for admission have a duty to disclose her prior criminal matters and civil proceeding, and did she fulfil that duty?
4. Did the applicant for admission have a duty to disclose her involvement in civil litigation and, if so, did she fulfil that duty?
5. Did the applicant for admission have a capacity to diligently discharge the responsibilities of the office of a lawyer, and did she demonstrate such capacity through her conduct during these proceedings?
6. Should the admission order be revoked and the applicant's name be struck from the roll of lawyers?
7. Should certain evidence and submissions be subject to a non-publication order?
8. Should the reasons for decision be anonymised to protect the applicant's privacy and mental health?

Held
1. The court found that the applicant for admission had a duty to disclose her prior application for admission in Queensland and that she did not fulfill that duty.
2. The court found that the statement in the applicant's affidavit that she had not previously applied for admission to the legal profession in another jurisdiction was deliberately false and dishonest.
3. The court found that the applicant for admission had a duty to disclose her prior criminal matters and civil proceeding, and that she did not fulfill that duty.
4. The court found that the applicant for admission had a duty to disclose her involvement in civil litigation, and that she did not fulfill that duty.
5. The court found that the applicant for admission did not demonstrate the capacity to diligently discharge the responsibilities of the office of a lawyer through her conduct during these proceedings.
6. The court ordered that the admission order be revoked and the applicant's name be struck from the roll of lawyers.
7. The court made non-publication orders for certain evidence and submissions in the case.
8. The court denied the applicant's request for anonymisation of the reasons for decision to protect her privacy and mental health.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the applicant's duty to disclose prior applications for admission in another jurisdiction and found that the applicant, Petersen, had a duty to disclose her prior application in Queensland. Petersen's denial of having applied for admission in Queensland was deliberately false and dishonest, as she had filed an originating motion and affidavit in support of her application for admission in Queensland. The court found that Petersen's failure to disclose this prior application was a breach of the duty of candour and a material matter that should have been disclosed in her application for admission in the Northern Territory.

The court also found that Petersen's statement in her affidavit denying that she had previously applied for admission in another jurisdiction was deliberately false and dishonest. The court considered Petersen's conduct during the proceedings, including her filing of material identifying parties, children, and the subject matter of family law disputes, and found that she lacked the capacity to diligently discharge the responsibilities of the office of a lawyer.

Regarding the duty to disclose prior criminal matters and civil proceedings, the court found that Petersen had a duty to disclose her prior criminal matters and civil proceedings, but she failed to do so. The court considered the admitted suitability matters, including Petersen's criminal history and involvement in civil litigation, and found that they were relevant to her fitness to practise as a lawyer.

The court also considered Petersen's involvement in civil litigation and found that she had a duty to disclose it. However, she failed to disclose her involvement in civil litigation, which was a breach of the duty of candour.

The court found that Petersen lacked the capacity to diligently discharge the responsibilities of the office of a lawyer, based on her conduct during these proceedings and her failure to disclose relevant information.

The court revoked the admission order and removed Petersen's name from the roll of lawyers, as her admission was obtained by fraud and non-compliance with the rules for admission.

The court also made non-publication orders in respect of certain evidence and submissions, and considered the applicant's request for anonymisation of the reasons for decision. The court found that the reasons for decision should not be anonymised to protect Petersen's privacy and mental health, as her deliberately dishonest conduct in her application and during the proceedings should not be hidden from public scrutiny.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an applicant for admission to the legal profession has a duty to disclose prior applications for admission in another jurisdiction, prior criminal matters, and involvement in civil litigation. Failure to disclose such matters, particularly if done deliberately and dishonestly, can result in the revocation of the admission order and removal of the applicant's name from the roll of lawyers. The court's power to revoke an admission order and remove an applicant's name from the roll of lawyers is an aspect of its inherent jurisdiction in relation to the control and discipline of lawyers.