Laurie Lindner Constructions Pty Ltd v Western Cape Communities Trust Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Laurie Lindner Constructions Pty Ltd v Western Cape Communities Trust Pty Ltd [2024] QSC 123

PARTIES:

LAURIE LINDNER CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD

(Respondent Plaintiff)

v

WESTERN CAPE COMMUNITIES TRUST PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE WESTERN CAPE COMMUNITIES TRUST

(Applicant Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

417 of 2023

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

7 June 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Cairns

HEARING DATES:

2 February 2024, 15 March 2024

JUDGE:

Henry J

ORDER:

1.   The plaintiff will give security for the defendant’s costs up to mediation in the sum of $90,000 to be either paid into court or secured by provision of a bank guarantee evidenced in a form satisfactory to the Registrar within 28 days of this order.

2.   The proceeding is stayed until such security is provided.

3.   Liberty to the defendant to apply for further security on the giving of five business days notice in writing.

4.   The plaintiff will pay the defendant’s costs thrown away by the adjournment of the application on 2 February 2024, to be assessed, if not agreed, on the standard basis.

5.   The balance of the costs of the application are reserved.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – SECURITY FOR COSTS – FACTORS RELEVANT TO EXERCISE OF DISCRETION – PLAINTIFF’S OR APPLICANT’S IMPECUNIOSITY – CAUSE OF PLAINTIFF’S OR APPLICANT’S IMPECUNIOSITY – where the impecunious plaintiff claims its impecuniosity is attributable to the defendant’s conduct –where the plaintiff claims that the defendant has been unjustly enriched through breach of contract, monies wrongly withheld as liquidated damages and monies wrongly retained from progress payments – where the defendant applies for security for its costs – where the discretion is enlivened – whether a security for costs order would stultify the proceedings – whether and to what extent the defendant should be granted security for their costs

Base 1 Projects Pty Ltd v Islamic college of Brisbane Ltd [2012] QCA 114, cited

Blatch v Archer [1774] 98 ER 969, cited

Equititrust Limited v Tucker [2020] QSC 269, cited

Jazabas Pty Ltd v Haddad [2007] NSWCA 291, cited

Ollerenshaw v The Uniting Church in Australia Property (NSW) [2017] NSWSC 1637, cited

Rossi v Westbrook [2013] QCA 102, cited

Suncare Constructions Australia Pty Ltd & Anor v Gainspace (Mackay) Pty Ltd [2016] QSC 67, followed

Treadstone Developments Pty Ptd Wever Family Trust v The Salisbury Group Pty Ltd [2014] QSC 109, cited

Zenith Corporation Australia Pty Ltd v Optus Mobile Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 1110, cited

Corporation Act 2001 (Cth) r 1335

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) r 670, 671, 672

COUNSEL:

C Ryall for respondent plaintiff

P Nevard for applicant defendant

SOLICITORS:

Miller Harris Lawyers for respondent plaintiff
Clayton Utz for applicant defendant

  1. Lindner Constructions contracted with Western Cape Communities Trust Pty Ltd to build a new administration centre at Weipa, having tendered a price of about $9.4 million.  It complains its works cost…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Laurie Lindner Constructions Pty Ltd v Western Cape Communit... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Laurie Lindner Constructions Pty Ltd (Lindner) filed a claim against Western Cape Communities Trust Pty Ltd (WCCT) for breach of contract, alleging that WCCT wrongfully withheld liquidated damages, wrongly retained progress payments, and unjustly enriched itself. WCCT sought security for its costs, contending that Lindner's impecunious state would otherwise impede the fair conduct of the proceedings. The case was heard by the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which had to determine whether the court should exercise its discretion to order security for costs.

The court identified several discretionary factors to consider, including the means of those standing behind the proceedings, the prospects of success or merits of the proceedings, and whether Lindner's impecuniosity was attributable to WCCT's conduct. The court concluded that no informed assessment of the merits could be made on the materials filed, but the potential costs of the proceeding were substantial. The court noted that Lindner's impecuniosity and the means of those standing behind the proceeding were central to the decision. The court also considered whether Lindner's impecuniosity was due to WCCT's conduct, such as delays in providing architectural plans that allegedly caused construction problems and increased costs.

After weighing these factors, the court decided that Lindner must provide security for WCCT's costs up to mediation, in the amount of $90,000. The proceedings were stayed until such security was provided. The court also granted WCCT liberty to apply for further security and ordered Lindner to pay WCCT's costs of the application. The balance of the costs of the application were reserved.

The court's decision underscores the importance of considering the impecuniosity of a plaintiff and the potential for oppressive or stifling effects of a security for costs order. The court carefully balanced the need to ensure fair proceedings with the potential impact on the plaintiff.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiff will give security for the defendant’s costs up to mediation in the sum of $90,000 to be either paid into court or secured by provision of a bank guarantee evidenced in a form satisfactory to the Registrar within 28 days of this order.

2. The proceeding is stayed until such security is provided.

3. Liberty to the defendant to apply for further security on the giving of five business days notice in writing.

4. The plaintiff will pay the defendant’s costs thrown away by the adjournment of the application on 2 February 2024, to be assessed, if not agreed, on the standard basis.

5. The balance of the costs of the application are reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Laurie Lindner Constructions Pty Ltd (Lindner Constructions) and Western Cape Communities Trust Pty Ltd (WCCT) entered into a contract for the construction of an administration building at Weipa. The contract stipulated that the building would be a steel framed blockwork structure; however, it was later agreed that Lindner Constructions would construct it with a concrete framed structure. The terms of the contract, particularly the process for amending the architectural plans, are in dispute. Lindner Constructions alleges that delays in WCCT providing its architectural plans resulted in various problems during construction, causing delays and additional costs beyond those allowed for in Lindner Constructions' tender. Lindner Constructions further claims that it is impecunious and that this impecuniosity is attributable to WCCT's conduct. WCCT has applied for security for its costs, arguing that Lindner Constructions' impecuniosity and the potential for substantial costs make it necessary to safeguard its costs in the proceedings.

The matter before the court is an application by WCCT for security for its costs in the proceedings against Lindner Constructions. This application arises from a broader dispute between the parties concerning the construction contract and the alleged breach by WCCT. The court has previously dealt with interlocutory matters in the case, including an adjournment and the assessment of certain costs. The current application is focused on whether the court should order Lindner Constructions to provide security for WCCT's costs in light of Lindner Constructions' claimed impecuniosity and the potential financial implications of the proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Lindner Constructions' impecuniosity is attributable to WCCT's conduct.
2. Whether, in light of Lindner Constructions' impecuniosity and the means of those standing behind the proceedings, a security for costs order would stultify the proceeding.

Held
1. The court concluded that Lindner Constructions' impecuniosity is attributable to Western Cape Communities Trust's (WCCT) conduct.
2. The court concluded that, given Lindner Constructions' impecuniosity and the means of those standing behind the proceedings, a security for costs order would stultify the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The question is whether the court should order security for costs in the exercise of that discretion. What are the main discretionary considerations here? Rule 672 lists an array of matters the court may have regard to in deciding whether to make such an order. Section 1335 Corporations Act does not do likewise, but it is not suggested in the circumstances of a case like the present that the discretion would be exercised any differently under s 1335 than it would be under the UCPR. Rule 672 relevantly provides:“672 Discretionary factors for security for costsIn deciding whether to make an order, the court may have regard to any of the following matters – (a) the means of those standing behind the proceedings;(b) the prospects of success or merits on the proceedings;(c) the genuineness of the proceedings;(d) for rule 671(a) – the impecuniosity of a corporation;(e) whether the plaintiff’s impecuniosity is attributable to the defendant’s conduct; …(g) whether an order for securfity for costs would be oppressive;(h) whether an order for security for costs would stifle the proceedings; …(k) whether delay by the plaintiff in starting the proceedings has prejudiced the defendant; …(m) the costs of the proceedings.” Some of the above listed matters are of minor or neutral relevance here. It is not suggested the claim is not genuine (matter (c)), for instance that it is trivial or vexatious. However no informed assessment can be made of prospects or merits (matter (b)) on the materials filed. There was some delay in starting the proceeding (matter (k)) but it is not suggested that has occasioned significant prejudice. The costs of the proceeding (matter (m)) will be potentially substantial but that does not loom as a determinative consideration. Rather it informs consideration of whether a costs order would stultify the proceeding, that is, be oppressive (matter (g)) or stifle the proceeding (matter (h)). The discretionary considerations of more material relevance here are:· whether Lindner Constructions’ impecuniosity is attributable to WCCT’s conduct (matter (e)); and· whether, in light of the company’s impecuniosity (matter (d)) and the means of those standing behind the proceeding (matter (a)), a costs order would stultify the proceeding.Is Lindner Constructions’ impecuniosity attributable to WCCT’s conduct? Consideration of whether Lindner Constructions’ impecuniosity is attributable to WCCT’s conduct requires an appreciation of the nature of the alleged conduct and of the source of impecuniosity.Nature of the alleged conduct Lindner Constructions tendered for and was contracted to perform the construction of an administration building at Weipa for WCCT. WCCT’s plans for the construction involved a steel framed blockwork structure but it was agreed Lindner Constructions should build with a concrete framed structure. The terms of the contract, particularly the process by which the architectural plans would be amended, are in dispute. Lindner Constructions complains delay in WCCT’s provision of its architectural plans led to a miscellany of problems during the ensuing construction. This is said to have caused delays and an excess, in the costs allowed for in Lindner Constructions’ tender, of on and off-site overheads, structural elements and barging and freight costs.