Laurie and Child Support Registrar and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

LAURIE & CHILD SUPPORT REGISTRAR AND ANOR [2010] FamCAFC 38
FAMILY LAW – APPEAL - COSTS – Appeal against costs order made by Federal Magistrate – Where the orders concerned costs of proceedings relating to child support – Where the Father did not appear at the hearing and did not prosecute his application – Where the hearing proceeded notwithstanding the absence of the Father – Where the Father had every opportunity to participate in the hearing and prosecute his application and chose not do so – Where even if the Father had appeared, and subject to anything further which he might have adduced the application would have been dismissed – Where based on the material available the Father failed to address any of the matters relevant to the exercise of discretion in granting leave to appeal pursuant to Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) – Where the Father failed to address any possible errors by the Federal Magistrate in relation to her exercise of the discretion – In circumstances where the Father is seeking to essentially re-agitate in these costs proceedings the issues already dealt with in the substantive proceedings – Where the proceedings has been long and protracted – Application dismissed
CDJ v VAJ (No. 1) (1998) 197 CLR 172
Colgate-Palmolive Co and Another v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 118 ALR 248
Fitzgerald (as child representative for A (Legal Aid Commission of Tasmania)) v Fish and Another (2005) 33 Fam LR 123
Kohan and Kohan (1993) FLC 92-340
O'Rourke v P & B Corporation Pty Ltd [2008] WASC 36 (S) (unreported, Martin CJ, 14 March 2008)
Penfold v Penfold (1980) 144 CLR 311
Yunghanns v Yunghanns (2000) FLC 93-029

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)
Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)

Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth)
Federal Magistrates Court Rules 2001 (Cth)

APPELLANT: Mr LAURIE
FIRST RESPONDENT: CHILD SUPPORT REGISTRAR
SECOND RESPONDENT: Ms FILHO
FILE NUMBER: SYC 2252 of 2008
APPEAL NUMBER: EA 119 of 2009
DATE DELIVERED: 11 March 2010
PLACE DELIVERED: Sydney
PLACE HEARD: Sydney
JUDGMENT OF: O'Ryan J
HEARING DATE: 12 February 2010
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Federal Magistrates Court
LOWER COURT JUDGMENT DATE: 14 September 2009
LOWER COURT MNC: [2009] FMCAfam 971

REPRESENTATION

APPELLANT: No Appearance

SOLICITOR FOR THE FIRST 

RESPONDENT:

Nick Gouliaditis, Australian Government Solicitor

COUNSEL FOR THE SECOND

RESPONDENT:

Mentioned by consent of First Respondent

SOLICITOR FOR THE SECOND

RESPONDENT:

[Filho Lawyers]

Orders

  1. The application by Mr Laurie by way of Notice of Appeal filed on 12 October 2009 for leave to appeal against orders for costs made on 14 September 2009 by Federal Magistrate Sexton be dismissed.

  2. The Application in an Appeal filed on 3 February 2010 by the Child Support Registrar be granted.

  3. Mr Laurie pay the costs of the Child Support Registrar of and incidental to the applications in orders 1 and 2 hereof and the hearing on 12 February 2010.

  4. The costs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Laurie and Child Support Registrar and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FamCAFC 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Laurie and Child Support Registrar and Anor involved a dispute over child support obligations between the Father and the Mother. The Father had applied for leave to appeal against orders for costs made by Federal Magistrate Sexton on 14 September 2009, while the Child Support Registrar sought leave to adduce further evidence. The proceedings had a long and protracted history, involving multiple applications and appeals, and were ongoing due to a special leave application filed by the Father in the High Court of Australia.

The legal issues in the case centred on the Father's application for leave to appeal and the Child Support Registrar's application for leave to adduce further evidence. The court had to determine whether the Father's application for leave to appeal should be dismissed and whether the Child Support Registrar's application for leave to adduce further evidence should be granted. The court also had to consider the appropriate costs order in light of the Father's unsuccessful application and the Child Support Registrar's successful application.

The court dismissed the Father's application for leave to appeal, noting that he had not prosecuted his application and had not provided any valid reason for his absence. The court also granted the Child Support Registrar's application for leave to adduce further evidence, finding that the documents sought to be tendered were relevant to the proceedings and would assist in determining the appropriate costs order. The court ordered that the Father pay the costs of the Child Support Registrar for both the Father's unsuccessful application and the Child Support Registrar's successful application, as well as the costs of the hearing on 12 February 2010.

The final orders of the court were that the Father's application for leave to appeal be dismissed, the Child Support Registrar's application for leave to adduce further evidence be granted, and the Father pay the costs of the Child Support Registrar in the amount of $3,638.20. The court's reasoning was based on the principles of finality, the need to discourage elaborate and detailed submissions on costs, and the provisions of the relevant legislation.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The application by Mr Laurie by way of Notice of Appeal filed on 12 October 2009 for leave to appeal against orders for costs made on 14 September 2009 by Federal Magistrate Sexton be dismissed.

2.

The Application in an Appeal filed on 3 February 2010 by the Child Support Registrar be granted.

3.

Mr Laurie pay the costs of the Child Support Registrar of and incidental to the applications in orders 1 and 2 hereof and the hearing on 12 February 2010.

4.

The costs in order 3 hereof be assessed in the amount of $3,638.20.

Background

Background to the litigation

For reasons I will give shortly, this application can be very briefly disposed of. The Father did not appear at the hearing before me and thus he did not prosecute his application. The Father had sought that the hearing be vacated. However, I resolved that the hearing would proceed notwithstanding the absence of the Father. In the circumstances, I feel constrained to set out some of the unfortunate history of the proceedings.BACKGROUND In reasons for judgment delivered on 10 July 2009 Federal Magistrate Sexton from [4] to [23] provided a detailed history of the proceedings which were repeated and elaborated upon by me in reasons for judgment I delivered on 12 October 2009 after hearing an application in an appeal by the Father by which he sought to reinstate an abandoned appeal. Correspondence between the parties and the Family Court, marked as Exhibit A, also provides a history of the proceedings before me on 12 February 2010. In addition, the Child Support Registrar put in evidence the affidavit affirmed by Ms Fusitu’a of 3 February 2010, which annexes various correspondence between the parties and the Family Court and various documents filed by the Father in the High Court of Australia, including his application for special leave to appeal a decision made by me on 12 October 2009. Close assessment of this affidavit illustrates that there has been long and protracted litigation between the Father and the Mother, and, due to the filing of a special leave application, that such litigation is not to be concluded anytime soon. The Father and Mother have two children, born in 1994 and 1997 the subject of a child support assessment registered with the Child Support Agency on 27 January 1997. On 5 October 2000, the Mother lodged a change of assessment application with the Child Support Registrar under Part 6A of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (“the Assessment Act”) seeking an increase in the child support payable by the Father on the basis of the costs of childcare being greater than five per cent of the payee’s child support income, and on the basis of the Father’s financial position. On 18 December 2000 the Child Support Registrar made a departure determination under Part 6A of the Assessment Act increasing the Father’s child support liability. The reasons contended for by the Mother were established and the annual rate of child support payable by the Father was increased to $10,534.20. It is this decision which the Father sought to impugn. On 26 July 2006 the Mother was informed by a solicitor from the AGS that the Father had declared himself bankrupt. The Mother deposed in her affidavit of 23 March 2009 that as a result, proceedings for enforcement of child support obligations of the Father, which were against the Father and a company that was described as the alter ego of the Father, were withdrawn by the Child Support Registrar. On 15 August 2007 the Father requested an extension of time within which to lodge an objection to the decision made on 18 December 2000. The application was made almost seven years after the decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At [31] the Federal Magistrate considered the order sought by the Child Support Registrar and the Mother that any costs be paid by the Father within one month. However, her Honour concluded by allowing the Father two calendar months to pay the costs from the date of the orders. APPLICATION TO ADDUCE FURTHER EVIDENCEGeneral On 3 February 2010 the Child Support Registrar filed an application to adduce further evidence. An affidavit was affirmed in support by Ms Fusitu’a. The affidavit of Ms Fusitu’a gives an account of emails sent on 2 December 2008 between the Child Support Registrar; Mr Maurice, counsel for the Mother in proceedings before Federal Magistrate Sexton; and the Associate to Federal Magistrate Sexton, regarding the addition of the Mother as a second respondent to proceedings before Federal Magistrate Sexton. The Child Support Registrar seeks leave to tender copies of such emails for the sake of “completeness”. Ms Fusitu’a also includes in her affidavit a copy of the Father’s High Court special leave application; his Notice of a Constitutional Matter; and draft and amended summary’s of argument before the High Court and amended reply to the Child Support Registrar’s summary of argument. As noted before, the Child Support Registrar seeks leave to tender these documents to demonstrate that the proceedings brought in the High Court seek to re-agitate issues which are currently before the Court in these proceedings. In my reasons for judgment of 12 October 2009, I dealt with an issue raised by the solicitor for the Father that there had been a “conspiracy” between the Mother and Sexton FM regarding email communications: see [24] to [35] and [112]. In the Father’s third ground of appeal for this appeal he seeks to re-agitate this issue of a “conspiracy” between the Mother and Sexton FM that I have already dealt with in my reasons for judgment dated 12 October 2009. Conclusion In the circumstances, so far as they are relevant given that it is an application for leave to appeal, I am not going to set out the settled relevant principles to be applied in determining the application. However, I will have regard to s 93A(2) of the Act, r 22.39 of the Rules and the reasons of McHugh, Gummow and Callinan JJ in CDJ v VAJ (No. 1) (1998) 197 CLR 172 particularly at [104] to [116]. I am going to admit the further evidence. Section 107A(1) of the Collection Act relevantly states that leave to appeal is required in appeals which relate to child support matters. Section 107A(1) provides:(1) An appeal lies, with the leave of the Family Court, to the Family Court from: (a) a decree of the Federal Magistrates Court exercising original jurisdiction under this Act; or ….(5) On an appeal under subsection (1) or (1A), the Family Court may affirm, reverse or vary the decree or decision the subject of the appeal and may make such decree or decision as, in the opinion of the court, ought to have been made in the first instance, or may, if it considers appropriate, order a re‑hearing, on such terms and conditions (if any) as it considers appropriate.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my reasons for judgment of 12 October 2009, I dealt with an issue raised by the solicitor for the Father that there had been a “conspiracy” between the Mother and Sexton FM regarding email communications: see [24] to [35] and [112]. In the Father’s third ground of appeal for this appeal he seeks to re-agitate this issue of a “conspiracy” between the Mother and Sexton FM that I have already dealt with in my reasons for judgment dated 12 October 2009. Conclusion In the circumstances, so far as they are relevant given that it is an application for leave to appeal, I am not going to set out the settled relevant principles to be applied in determining the application. However, I will have regard to s 93A(2) of the Act, r 22.39 of the Rules and the reasons of McHugh, Gummow and Callinan JJ in CDJ v VAJ (No. 1) (1998) 197 CLR 172 particularly at [104] to [116]. I am going to admit the further evidence. Section 107A(1) of the Collection Act relevantly states that leave to appeal is required in appeals which relate to child support matters. Section 107A(1) provides:(1) An appeal lies, with the leave of the Family Court, to the Family Court from: (a) a decree of the Federal Magistrates Court exercising original jurisdiction under this Act; or ….(5) On an appeal under subsection (1) or (1A), the Family Court may affirm, reverse or vary the decree or decision the subject of the appeal and may make such decree or decision as, in the opinion of the court, ought to have been made in the first instance, or may, if it considers appropriate, order a re‑hearing, on such terms and conditions (if any) as it considers appropriate. Section 117(1) of the Act provides that “[s]ubject to subsection (2), subsection 70NFB(1) and sections 117AA, 117AB, 117AC and 118, each party to proceedings under this Act shall bear his or her own costs.” Section 117(2) of the Act provides that if, in proceedings under the Act the court is of opinion that there are circumstances that justify it in doing so, it may, subject to sub secs (2A), (4) and (5) and the applicable rules, make such order as to costs whether by way of interlocutory order or otherwise, as it considers just. Section 117(2A) of the Act provides that in considering what order (if any) should be made under s 117(2), the court shall have regard to the matters set out in paragraphs (a) to (g). I also have regard to what was said by the Full Court Fitzgerald (as child representative for A (Legal Aid Commission of Tasmania)) v Fish and Another (2005) 33 Fam LR 123 per Kay, Warnick and Boland JJ at 130 and Penfold v Penfold (1980) 144 CLR 311 per Stephen, Mason, Aicken and Wilson JJ at 315-16. Notwithstanding the very detailed background I have given above, I have regard to what was said by Martin CJ in O'Rourke v P & B Corporation Pty Ltd [2008] WASC 36 (S) (unreported, Martin CJ, 14 March 2008). [6] I think it is important that a robust approach be taken to the resolution of costs issues of this kind and that the practice of making elaborate and detailed submissions with respect to costs, supported by elaborate and detailed evidence and oral argument, should be actively discouraged by the court. With that in mind, the reasons that I will give in relation to these applications will be brief.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established