Landmark Operations Limited v J Tiver Nominees Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

LANDMARK OPERATIONS LIMITED v J TIVER NOMINEES PTY LTD & ORS (No 3)

[2009] SASC 329

Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court

22 October 2009

PROCEDURE

Post judgment interest under s 114(1) Supreme Court Act 1935 and 87R 84.19 - Order under s 8 of the Enforcement of Judgments Act 1991 for chattels to be delivered up to the plaintiff and for it to be able to sell them to satisfy a judgment debt - held judgment for the purpose of s 8 of that Act did not include any post judgment interest.

PROCEDURE

Stay of execution - s 17 of Enforcement of Judgments Act 1991 - stay refused on sale of chattels under s 8 of that Act where proceeds of sale may exceed the amount of the judgment - whether post judgment interest could be brought into account when plaintiff accounted for any surplus.

LANDMARK OPERATIONS LIMITED v J TIVER NOMINEES PTY LTD & ORS (No 3)
[2009] SASC 329

Reasons on a further application by the third defendant to stay the order for sale.

  1. JUDGE LUNN:

    Background.

  2. On 26 November 2008 this Court gave judgment against all six defendants, inter alia, for $10,857,200 (“the judgment”).  The first defendant is now in liquidation and the five personal defendants, apart from the third defendant, Phyllis Tiver, are bankrupt.  There are bankruptcy proceedings by the plaintiff pending against the third defendant in the Federal Magistrates Court, but as far as I am aware they remain undecided. 

  3. The second to sixth defendants had previously carried on a partnership of “Flagstaff Proprietors” which owned various plant and equipment. On 14 February and 16 June 2009 this Court made charging orders under s 8 of the Enforcement of Judgments Act 1991 over this plant and equipment.  On 12 August 2009 I made the following order for the delivery up and sale of much of this plant and equipment in the following terms:

    1The items in the Schedule to this Order save for items A-6, A-11, A-14, A-15, A-16, A-19, A-26, A-27, A-32, A-33, A-34, A-39, A2-16, A2-28, A2-33, A2-37, A2-40, A2-41, A2-42 and A2-46 be delivered up to the plaintiff.

    2The plaintiff be at liberty to sell the items in the Schedule to this Order.

    3That the proceeds of sale received by the plaintiff pursuant to paragraph 2 of this Order be applied by the plaintiff to the judgment herein entered against the defendants in favour of the plaintiff on 26 November 2008.

    (The Schedule contained a detailed description of the numerous items of plant and equipment of the partnership, but their precise identities are not relevant for this application).

  4. By an application dated 9 September 2009, FDN 414, the third defendant sought an order “That a stay of execution of the orders made ….. on 12 August 2009 be granted”.  On 9 September 2009 another Master made an Order partly staying the Order of 12 August 2009 until further order as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Landmark Operations Limited v J Tiver Nominees Pty Ltd (No 3... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 329
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Landmark Operations Limited v J Tiver Nominees Pty Ltd (No 3), the plaintiff, Landmark Operations Limited, sought to enforce a judgment debt of $10,857,200 against various defendants through the sale of plant and equipment owned by a partnership known as Flagstaff Proprietors. The third defendant, Phyllis Tiver, contested the sale, arguing that the plaintiff would be able to satisfy the entire judgment debt without needing to sell the partnership’s assets. The Federal Magistrates Court was tasked with determining whether the sale of the plant and equipment should be stayed and if the plaintiff was entitled to post-judgment interest on the debt.

The key legal issues before the court included whether the plaintiff could recover post-judgment interest and if such interest could be enforced through the sale of the partnership’s assets. The court examined historical legal precedents and statutory provisions concerning interest on judgment debts, including the English Judicature Act Rules 1876 and the South Australian Supreme Court Act 1935. The court also considered the Supreme Court Rules 1987, which prescribed the rate of interest and the circumstances under which it could be levied.

The court concluded that post-judgment interest was indeed payable under the Supreme Court Act 1935, but it was not automatically levied as part of the sale of assets unless explicitly stated. The court further found that the plaintiff could recover the post-judgment interest through other means, such as direct payments or settlements, and did not need to rely on the sale of the partnership's assets. Consequently, the court determined that it was not unjust to proceed with the sale of the plant and equipment as ordered. The court dismissed the application for a stay of execution, allowing the sale to proceed as previously ordered.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

JUDGE LUNN:Background. On 26 November 2008 this Court gave judgment against all six defendants, inter alia, for $10,857,200 (“the judgment”). The first defendant is now in liquidation and the five personal defendants, apart from the third defendant, Phyllis Tiver, are bankrupt. There are bankruptcy proceedings by the plaintiff pending against the third defendant in the Federal Magistrates Court, but as far as I am aware they remain undecided. The second to sixth defendants had previously carried on a partnership of “Flagstaff Proprietors” which owned various plant and equipment. On 14 February and 16 June 2009 this Court made charging orders under s 8 of the Enforcement of Judgments Act 1991 over this plant and equipment. On 12 August 2009 I made the following order for the delivery up and sale of much of this plant and equipment in the following terms:1The items in the Schedule to this Order save for items A-6, A-11, A-14, A-15, A-16, A-19, A-26, A-27, A-32, A-33, A-34, A-39, A2-16, A2-28, A2-33, A2-37, A2-40, A2-41, A2-42 and A2-46 be delivered up to the plaintiff.2The plaintiff be at liberty to sell the items in the Schedule to this Order.3That the proceeds of sale received by the plaintiff pursuant to paragraph 2 of this Order be applied by the plaintiff to the judgment herein entered against the defendants in favour of the plaintiff on 26 November 2008.(The Schedule contained a detailed description of the numerous items of plant and equipment of the partnership, but their precise identities are not relevant for this application). By an application dated 9 September 2009, FDN 414, the third defendant sought an order “That a stay of execution of the orders made ….. on 12 August 2009 be granted”. On 9 September 2009 another Master made an Order partly staying the Order of 12 August 2009 until further order as a holding measure to enable this application to be determined. On 20 August 2009 the plaintiff exercised its power as mortgagee to sell various real estate of the first defendant for a gross amount of $8,155,750 (“the land sales”). Settlement on these sales is not scheduled to occur until 20 February 2010. The plaintiff has also exercised various other rights as a secured and judgment creditor to obtain payments of various amounts on account of the judgment debt. I do not intend to say anything about the amounts recovered and how they have been applied by the plaintiff as that may be the subject of subsequent disputes. The essence of the third defendant’s submission on the present application is that the plaintiff will be able to recover all of its judgment debt without resort to any sale of the plant and equipment of the partnership. Hence it argues that it would be unjust for that plant and equipment now to be delivered up and sold. Whether the third defendant’s contention about the satisfaction of the judgment is correct depends largely upon whether the plaintiff is also able to recover through the Order of 12 August 2009 post judgment interest on its judgment. Hence it is necessary for me to consider some novel and interesting submissions about the entitlement of a judgment creditor to post-judgment interest and how such interest can be recovered.Post-Judgment Interest.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The plaintiff has also exercised various other rights as a secured and judgment creditor to obtain payments of various amounts on account of the judgment debt. I do not intend to say anything about the amounts recovered and how they have been applied by the plaintiff as that may be the subject of subsequent disputes. The essence of the third defendant’s submission on the present application is that the plaintiff will be able to recover all of its judgment debt without resort to any sale of the plant and equipment of the partnership. Hence it argues that it would be unjust for that plant and equipment now to be delivered up and sold. Whether the third defendant’s contention about the satisfaction of the judgment is correct depends largely upon whether the plaintiff is also able to recover through the Order of 12 August 2009 post judgment interest on its judgment. Hence it is necessary for me to consider some novel and interesting submissions about the entitlement of a judgment creditor to post-judgment interest and how such interest can be recovered.Post-Judgment Interest. At Common Law a judgment did not carry interest. The right was first given by an English statute of 1837, which provided:Every judgment debt shall carry interest at the rate of 4 Pounds per centum per annum from the time of entering up the judgment ….. until the same shall be satisfied, and such interest may be levied under a writ of execution on such judgment.Order 41 Rule 14 of the English Judicature Act Rules 1876 provided:Every writ of execution for the recovery of money shall be indorsed with a direction to the sheriff ….. to levy the money really due and payable and sought to be recovered under the judgment, stating the amount, and also to levy interest thereon, if sought to be recovered, at the rate of ….. (This history is taken from the judgment of Griffiths CJ in Reis v Carling (1908) 5 CLR 673 at 676-678). In South Australia s 33 of the Supreme Court Act 1867 provided:Every judgment debt shall carry interest at the rate of Ten Pounds per centum per annum, from the time of entering up the judgment until the same shall be satisfied, in lieu and instead of Five Pounds per centum per annum, as provided by the Ordinance No 9 of 1846.This partly followed the English 1837 Act, but left out the latter part about interest being levied under a writ of execution. This section was replaced by the present s 114(1) of the Supreme Court Act 1935 which provides:(1)All money, including costs, payable under any judgment or order shall bear interest at the rate from time to time prescribed by the Rules of Court. This action is still governed by the Supreme Court Rules 1987. Rule 84.19, now prescribes that the rate shall be that specified in Rule 261 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006. The former Supreme Court Rules in this State also largely re-enacted the English Judicature Act Order 41 Rule 14. It appeared in the Supreme Court Rules 1947 as Order 42 Rule 17:17Every writ of execution for the recovery of money shall be indorsed with a direction to the Sheriff, or other officer or person to whom the writ is directed, to levy the money really due and payable and sought to be recovered under the judgment or order, stating the amount, and also to levy interest thereon, if sought to be recovered, at the rate of ten per cent per annum from the date of the judgment or order: Provided that in cases where there is an agreement between the parties that more than ten per cent interest shall be secured by the judgment, then the indorsement may be accordingly to levy the amount of interest so agreed.There was no direct equivalent of that Rule in the Supreme Court Rules 1987, but there was a partial equivalent in Rule 88A.06(2) which provided:(2)Recovery of interest accrued after issue of warrant.The Sheriff may deduct from the proceeds of any warrant and pay to the judgment creditor interest accrued on the judgment debt under rule 84.19 from the time of the issue of the warrant to when he makes payment to the judgment creditor provided that if he receives payment of the judgment debt in lieu of effecting a sale he need not account to the judgment creditor for interest accrued after the date on which he receives payment of the debt.That Rule does not apply here because, under the terms of the Order of 12 August 2009, the sale of the items is to be conducted by the plaintiff and not by the Sheriff.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established