Land Operations Pty Ltd v M & W Equipment Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Civil: Application)

LAND OPERATIONS PTY LTD v M & W EQUIPMENT PTY LTD

[2016] SASC 2

Reasons for Ruling of The Honourable Justice Blue (ex tempore)

18 December 2015

PROCEDURE - COURTS AND JUDGES GENERALLY - COURTS - CONCURRENT JURISDICTION OF DIFFERENT COURTS - TRANSFER OF PROCEEDINGS UNDER CROSS-VESTING LEGISLATION - WHERE APPROPRIATE AND IN INTERESTS OF JUSTICE

Application by the defendants for transfer of proceedings under section 5(2)(b)(iii) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (SA) to the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The plaintiffs sue the defendants for breach of contract, misleading conduct and negligence in relation to the sale and delivery of a crusher and screening plant.

The plaintiffs are based in Port Victoria, South Australia and the defendants in Wagga Wagga, New South Wales.  The applicant defendants submit that the alleged contracts were formed in New South Wales; their performance and breach (which is denied) occurred in New South Wales; the contracts incorporated their standard terms and conditions that contained a jurisdiction clause providing for proceedings to be brought in New South Wales; and they would suffer prejudice in their business if the action proceeded in South Australia.

The respondent plaintiffs submit that the alleged misleading conduct occurred and the contracts were made during communications between the two jurisdictions; there is no relevant difference between the substantive and procedural law to be applied in South Australia or New South Wales; and the jurisdiction clause if incorporated into the contracts is non-exclusive. The respondents submit that the proceedings bear greater connection to South Australia in that the goods were supplied and broke down and are stored in South Australia and the preponderance of witnesses are in South Australia.

Held:

1.  It cannot be determined at this point whether the defendants’ standard terms and conditions formed part of the contract. The jurisdiction clause at clause 13 on its proper construction is non-exclusive (at [15]-[24]).

2.  In the circumstances, the jurisdiction clause should be given very little weight (at [27]-[30]).

3.  The proceedings have a greater connection to South Australia than New South Wales (at [34]-[35]).

4.  The incremental detriment that would be suffered by the applicants if the application were denied would be marginal and is outweighed by the overall greater connection to South Australia (at [39]-[41]).

5.  Application dismissed (at [42]).

Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (SA); Sale of Goods Act 1895 (SA); Sale of Goods Act 1923 (NSW), referred to.
Air Attention WA Pty Ltd v Seeley International Pty Ltd (1996) (unreported, Supreme Court of Western Australia, Walsh J, 3 September 1996); Australian Rail Track Corporation Ltd v Mineral Commodities Ltd [2006] SASC 27; River Gum Homes Pty Ltd v Meridian Pty Ltd [2010] QCA 293; Ross Mollison Group Pty Ltd v Really Useful Co (Australia) Pty Ltd [2000] VSC 256, discussed.

LAND OPERATIONS PTY LTD v M & W EQUIPMENT PTY LTD
[2016] SASC 2

Civil:
BLUE J:

  1. This is an application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Land Operations Pty Ltd v M & W Equipment Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Land Operations Pty Ltd (plaintiff) brought an action against M & W Equipment Pty Ltd (defendant) in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, seeking a declaration of rights and remedies in relation to a supply of goods. The defendant sought to transfer the proceedings to the Supreme Court of South Australia, claiming that it was the more appropriate court. The plaintiff opposed the transfer on the basis that the Federal Circuit Court had jurisdiction and that it was the more appropriate forum. The court was required to determine whether it was appropriate to transfer the proceedings to another court under cross-vesting legislation, and whether it was in the interests of justice for the proceedings to remain in the Federal Circuit Court. The court considered a range of factors, including the bargain made by the parties, the application of substantive and procedural law, and the balance of convenience to the parties and witnesses. The court found that the parties had made a bargain as to the jurisdiction in which disputes between them should proceed, but that this factor could not be given weight as it was not possible to determine whether the terms on the back of the invoices were terms of the contracts. The court also found that there were no relevant differences in substantive or procedural law between the Federal Circuit Court and the Supreme Court of South Australia. The court held that the balance of convenience favoured transferring the proceedings to the Supreme Court of South Australia, as it was the more appropriate court and it was in the interests of justice for the proceedings to remain there. The court dismissed the application to transfer the proceedings.

The court ordered that the proceedings remain in the Supreme Court of South Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As I observed when I ruled that these paragraphs were admissible, they are of limited weight because there are few primary facts in the affidavit about the extent of detriment. I am called on to make my own assessment of that detriment. The vast majority of that detriment will be suffered whether the trial proceeds in Sydney or Adelaide. Either way, they will both need to be away from Wagga for the period of the trial and I will assume that that will take a week. They will be devoted during the day to the events of the trial and they will not be able to work on either sales or project management or running the workshop. They will both be physically absent from the operations in Wagga. There may be some marginal advantage in being in Sydney but I consider that to be very small.Conclusion I do not think that overall this outweighs the greater connection with South Australia. Ultimately it is an evaluative exercise of weighing all of the factors in the scales and giving appropriate weight to all of them and seeing where the interests of justice lie overall or which is most the appropriate court. In doing that, I conclude that South Australia is the more appropriate court and it is in the interests of justice that the action stay in South Australia. For those reasons, I dismiss the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I proceed on the basis that at this point it is finely balanced which party’s submissions will prevail as to whether the terms and conditions on the back of the invoices are in fact terms and conditions of the contracts.Relevant considerations The parties agree that the approach that should be taken to the transfer application was that laid down by the High Court in BHP Billiton Ltd v Schulz.[1] The common law forum non conveniens test is inapplicable and it is a question of in which direction the interests of justice point. That will almost always involve a weighing process because different considerations will point in different directions, and the ultimate test as formulated by the High Court is whether it is more appropriate that the action proceed in one court as against the other. The factors are not constrained in that there is not a discrete list of relevant considerations. What are relevant considerations will vary from case to case but commonly certain types of considerations will arise and they were identified by Debelle J in Australian Rail Track Corp Ltd v Mineral Commodities Ltd.[2] [1] [2004] HCA 61, (2004) 221 CLR 400.[2] [2006] SASC 27 at [21]. The first two considerations identified were application of substantive law and procedural law in that either the substantive law or the procedural law might favour one party or the other if there are differences. Here there are no relevant differences. The substantive law is the same, namely contract law. It is true that the Sale of Goods legislation technically is different but that legislation codifies the pre-existing common law and is in substance largely uniform between the different States. There is no relevant distinction drawn by the parties between the South Australian Sale of Goods Act and the New South Wales Sale of Goods Act. I conclude that there are no differences in substantive law and that factor can be ignored. The other causes of action are for misleading conduct, which again is uniform, and negligence. Likewise it is not suggested that there are any procedural law differences that would give rise to a forensic advantage or detriment. I can put those factors aside. The next factors identified by Debelle J were substantial connections with the forum, balance of convenience to parties and witnesses, and convenience to the court system. I will come back to those and address them together. An additional factor should be added, as suggested by the defendants, which is the bargain made by the parties. I turn to that and the argument that here the parties have made a bargain as to the jurisdiction in which disputes between them should proceed. Bargain by the parties My analysis has to be constrained by the fact that I cannot make a definitive finding whether the terms on the back of the invoices are terms of the contracts. If they are not, then those terms are to be ignored and there is no weight to be given to the factor of the bargain of the parties. All I can do is proceed on the basis that they may or may not form part of the terms of the contract.