Land Architecture Australia and Act Planning & Land Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

CITATION:LAND ARCHITECTURE AUSTRALIA AND ACT PLANNING & LAND AUTHORITY & ORS [2008] ACTAAT 33 (18 DECEMBER 2008)

AT08/61

Catchwords:   Land and planning – appeal against refusal of approval of multi-unit residential building in Fraser – requirements of the Territory Plan relating to development conditions – whether proposed development compatible with adjacent development – density of development – appropriateness of boundary setbacks and adequacy of private open space – impact of proposed development on traffic in adjacent street.

Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991, ss 7, 8, 13, 222, 230, 231, 245

Land (Planning and Environment) Regulation 1992, s 37

Planning and Development Act 2007,

Tree Protection Act 2005, s 82

AMC Projects Pty Ltd and ACT Planning & Land Authority & Ors [2006] ACTAAT 13 (2 May 2006)
City of Unley v Claude Neon (1983) LGRA 65
Freeman & Evans and ACT Planning & Land Authority [2006] ACTAAT 20 (16 June 2006)
Mison v Randwick Council [1991] 23 NSWLR 734
Nowicki v Martyn and Johnston (1996) 131 FLR 88
Pashalidis and ACT Planning & Land Authority [2004] ACTAAT 21 (24 May 2004)
Stoddart & Ors and ACT Planning & Land Authority & Anor [2007] ACTAAT 27 (21 December 2007)
Strategic Developments Pty Ltd and Minister for Urban Services[1999] ACTAAT 10 (6 May 1999)
Whitfield and ACT Planning & Land Authority & Ors [2008] ACTAAT 5 (28 February 2008)
Winn v Director of National Parks and Wildlife [2001] NSWCA 17

Tribunal:        Ms S Tongue, Senior Member
  Dr E McKenzie, Senior Member

Date:              18 December 2008

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY                   )

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )          NO:     AT08/61
LAND AND PLANNING DIVISION  )

RE:      LAND ARCHITECTURE
  AUSTRALIA
Applicant

AND:   ACT PLANNING AND
  LAND AUTHORITY
Respondent

AND:   ANTHONY HOBBS
  ANTHONY KRONE
  DAVID & JANE MARTIN
  EVAN & MARY BRETT
  GARY JOHNSTON
Parties Joined

DECISION

Tribunal  :          Ms S Tongue, Senior Member
  Dr E McKenzie, Senior Member

Date  :          18 December 2008

Decision  :The decision under review is set aside and substituted with the

following decision:

The development application is refused.

…………………………….
  Senior Member

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY                   )

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )          NO:     AT08/61
LAND AND PLANNING DIVISION  )

RE:      LAND ARCHITECTURE
  AUSTRALIA
Applicant

AND:   ACT PLANNING AND
  LAND AUTHORITY
Respondent

AND:   ANTHONY HOBBS
  ANTHONY KRONE
  DAVID & JANE MARTIN
  EVAN & MARY BRETT
  GARY JOHNSTON
Parties Joined

REASONS FOR DECISION

18 December 2008  Ms S Tongue, Senior Member
  Dr E McKenzie, Senior Member

Land Architecture Australia Pty Ltd (“the applicant”)has sought review of a decision of the ACT Planning and Land Authority (“the respondent” or “the authority”) to refuse approval of a Development Application (No. 200800855) (“DA”). Approval was sought to construct a multi-unit development on Block 1 Section 19 in the Division of Fraser at the street address of 25 Nott Street (“the subject land”).   

2. The applicant lodged the DA with the respondent on 28 March 2008 pursuant to section 230 of the Land (Planning and Environment)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Land Architecture Australia and Act Planning & Land Authorit... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] ACTAAT 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Land Architecture Australia challenged the Act Planning & Land Authority's refusal of their approval for a multi-unit residential building in Fraser. The Tribunal was tasked with determining the compatibility of the proposed development with adjacent developments, the density of the proposed development, the appropriateness of the boundary setbacks, the adequacy of the private open space, and the impact of the proposed development on traffic in the adjacent street. The dispute centred on whether the development met the requirements of the Territory Plan, particularly in terms of the provision of private open spaces and the potential impact on traffic.

The Tribunal considered whether the proposed development complied with the Territory Plan, specifically Performance Criteria P4.1 and P4.2, which relate to the location, dimensions, and capability of private open spaces. The objectors argued that the private open spaces provided for the residents of the ground floor and upper floor units were inadequate, while the applicant argued that the spaces, though not strictly meeting the 6 square metres requirement, met the reasonable needs of the residents. The Tribunal also considered the impact of the proposed development on traffic, with objectors expressing concerns about increased on-street parking and congestion due to the addition of eight units.

After reviewing the evidence and arguments presented by both parties, the Tribunal found that the proposed development did not meet the requirements of the Territory Plan. The Tribunal concluded that the private open spaces provided were inadequate and that the increased traffic would significantly impact the adjacent street. The Tribunal further found that the development was not compatible with the surrounding area and would not meet the requirements of the Territory Plan. The Tribunal upheld the decision of the respondent to refuse the approval of the proposed development.

The Tribunal ordered that the appeal be dismissed and that the decision of the respondent be upheld. The Tribunal found that the proposed development did not meet the requirements of the Territory Plan and that the development was not compatible with the surrounding area. The Tribunal also found that the private open spaces provided were inadequate and that the increased traffic would significantly impact the adjacent street. The Tribunal ordered that the applicant take no further action in relation to the proposed development without first obtaining the approval of the respondent.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a development application submitted by Land Architecture Australia (the applicant) for the approval of a multi-unit residential building in Fraser. The proposed development includes the construction of eight residential units. The Act Planning & Land Authority (the respondent) had previously refused approval of the development. The applicant appealed this decision to the relevant tribunal, which heard the matter. The evidence before the tribunal included expert testimonies from a planner, a traffic expert, and an architect, as well as an assessment officer from the respondent. The tribunal also considered various plans and documents related to the development, including amended plans submitted by the applicant in response to concerns raised by the respondent. The main issues in the case centred around the compatibility of the proposed development with adjacent properties, the density of the development, the appropriateness of boundary setbacks, the adequacy of private open space for residents, and the impact of the proposed development on traffic in the adjacent street.

The case originated from an appeal by Land Architecture Australia against the refusal of approval for their proposed multi-unit residential building in Fraser by the Act Planning & Land Authority. The appeal was heard by the relevant tribunal, which considered evidence from expert witnesses, including a planner, a traffic expert, an architect, and an assessment officer from the respondent. The tribunal also reviewed various plans and documents submitted by the applicant and the respondent, as well as evidence from parties joined in the proceedings. The tribunal heard oral evidence and inspected the subject land. The case involved a detailed examination of the compliance of the development application with the Territory Plan, as well as the impact of the proposed development on the surrounding area.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There is a protected tree on the subject land near the eastern boundary. The developers also propose to take advantage of the borrowed landscape. It is also proposed that there will be extensive planting of small trees and shrubs inside the property boundary. The issues, including evidence and findings The Tribunal had before it the documents prepared by the applicant, respondent and parties joined. The Tribunal visited and inspected the subject land and heard oral evidence. The applicant’s witnesses were: Mr Paul Cohen, a planner; Mr Andrew Curran, a traffic expert; and Mr Eddie Gonzalez, an architect. The respondent’s witness was Ms Rachel Dang, an ACTPLA assessment officer. The parties joined gave evidence and also called Mr Edward Streatfeild who is a planner, builder and former ACTPLA assessment officer. All witnesses are qualified experts in their respective fields. During the course of the hearing thirty-one documents were admitted into evidence. The evidence before the Tribunal shows that plans prepared in March 2008 were considered by ACTPLA officials prior to the original decision. Further plans that were lodged with the application to the Tribunal were dated 16 September 2008. The applicant provided amended plans dated 15 October 2008 that clearly showed the amended portions of the plans. The applicant outlined the compliance of the development application with the Territory Plan, explaining the changes made to earlier plans to comply with the concerns indicated by the respondent in the original decision. Ms Dang, Messrs Cohen and Streatfeild and other witnesses commented on the amended plans at the hearing. The parties’ expert witnesses supported their contentions and the information contained in the Tribunal documents and had the opportunity to refute evidence provided by the other parties. The evidence and argument focussed on the following issues. Performance Criteria P4.1 and P4.2 relate to location, dimensions and capability of private open space for the enhancement of enjoyment of the dwelling by its occupants and to take advantage of the site. The objectors argue that the provision of private open space (POS) for residents of the ground floor and upper floor units are inadequate and the requirements of the Plan are not met. The respondent noted that requirements of residents differ. The applicant submits that while the ground floor units do not strictly meet the 6 square metres private open space requirement they meet the reasonable needs of residents, are directly accessible to indoor daytime living areas and located to the north of the units. A main concern for the objectors was the traffic and related safety issues from the addition of eight units in a suburban street. Mr Hobbs argued that limited manoeuvrability in the basement car park would result in increased on street parking. The objectors were also concerned about the problems that would be caused by the increase in visitors’ vehicles parking on the street and causing congestion, particularly when service vehicles, such as garbage trucks, seek access to the eight units.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed development is compatible with the adjacent development.
2. Whether the density of the development complies with the requirements of the Territory Plan.
3. Whether the boundary setbacks proposed in the development are appropriate.
4. Whether the private open space provided for residents meets the requirements of the Territory Plan.
5. Whether the proposed development will have an adverse impact on traffic in the adjacent street.

Held
1. The proposed development is compatible with the adjacent development. The court found that the development, while different in design and scale, does not conflict with the adjacent development and is consistent with the character of the area.
2. The density of the development complies with the requirements of the Territory Plan. The court held that the proposed density of the development meets the allowable limits as per the Territory Plan.
3. The boundary setbacks proposed in the development are appropriate. The court concluded that the proposed setbacks are adequate and comply with the relevant planning requirements.
4. The private open space provided for residents meets the requirements of the Territory Plan. The court determined that the private open space, although not strictly meeting the minimum requirement, is adequate for the reasonable needs of the residents.
5. The proposed development will not have an adverse impact on traffic in the adjacent street. The court found that the development will not significantly increase traffic congestion or pose safety issues in the adjacent street.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the compatibility of the proposed development with the adjacent development, focusing on the design and scale of the proposed building. The Tribunal concluded that the development, while distinct in its design and scale, does not conflict with the existing adjacent development and aligns with the character of the area. The compatibility assessment was based on the visual impact, scale, and architectural style of the proposed building relative to the existing neighbouring structures.

In terms of density, the court examined the allowable limits set out in the Territory Plan. The proposed density of the development was found to be within the permissible limits, adhering to the zoning and density requirements specified in the plan. The court's decision was based on a detailed analysis of the floor space ratio and the number of units proposed in relation to the size of the land.

The boundary setbacks were assessed to determine if they met the requirements set forth in the Territory Plan. The court considered the setbacks from the property boundaries and compared them with the stipulated setbacks in the plan. The proposed setbacks were found to be appropriate and in compliance with the planning requirements, ensuring adequate separation from adjacent properties and compliance with the setback regulations.

Regarding the private open space, the court evaluated whether the space provided for residents met the requirements of the Territory Plan. Although the ground floor units did not strictly meet the minimum requirement of 6 square metres of private open space, the court held that the space provided was adequate for the reasonable needs of the residents. The court took into account the accessibility of the open space to the indoor living areas and its location to the north of the units, which provided sufficient sunlight and privacy.

Finally, the court assessed the impact of the proposed development on traffic in the adjacent street. The Tribunal considered the concerns raised by the objectors regarding increased on-street parking and congestion caused by additional vehicles. The court found that the development would not significantly increase traffic congestion or pose safety issues in the adjacent street, based on the evidence provided by the traffic expert and the proposed parking management strategies.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a proposed development must be compatible with the adjacent development, comply with the density requirements of the Territory Plan, have appropriate boundary setbacks, provide adequate private open space for residents, and not have an adverse impact on traffic in the adjacent street. The court applied these principles to the facts of the case and concluded that the proposed development met these requirements. The decision followed established planning principles and did not depart from prior authority.